Symmetry-Resolved Entanglement Entropy in Higher Dimensions

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2503.09070
• Title: Symmetry-Resolved Entanglement Entropy in Higher Dimensions
• Authors: Yuanzhu Huang, Yang Zhou (Department of Physics, Fudan University)
• Classification: hep-th (High Energy Physics - Theory), cond-mat.stat-mech (Statistical Mechanics), cond-mat.str-el (Strongly Correlated Electron Systems)
• Publication Date: March 2025 (Prepared for submission to JHEP)
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2503.09070

Abstract

This paper proposes a method for computing symmetry-resolved entanglement entropy (SREE) of spherical regions in higher-dimensional conformal field theories. By employing the Casini-Huerta-Myers mapping, the entanglement problem is transformed into a thermodynamic calculation in hyperbolic space. The method is verified through calculations in free field theory and holographic field theory. For large hyperbolic space volumes, the results reveal a universal expansion structure of SREE, where the equipartition property holds at the constant order. Using asymptotic analysis techniques, the universality of this expansion structure and equipartition property in arbitrary dimensions is established.

Research Background and Motivation

Problem Definition

Symmetry-resolved entanglement entropy (SREE) is an important branch of quantum entanglement research. It decomposes entanglement entropy into different charge sectors by considering the global symmetries of the system. While traditional entanglement entropy measures the entanglement degree of an entire subsystem, SREE further reveals how symmetry affects the entanglement structure.

Research Motivation

1. Need for dimensional generalization: Existing SREE research is primarily concentrated on (1+1)-dimensional systems; universal properties in higher dimensions remain unclear
2. Lack of computational methods: Systematic computational methods applicable to general higher-dimensional cases are lacking
3. Exploration of universal structures: Understanding whether SREE exhibits universal expansion structures across different dimensions and theories

Limitations of Existing Methods

• Most research is confined to specific calculations in particular dimensions
• Lack of unified theoretical framework for handling arbitrary dimensions
• Systematic proof of the universality of the equipartition property is absent

Core Contributions

1. Proposed a universal computational method for higher-dimensional SREE: Based on the Casini-Huerta-Myers conformal mapping, transforming entanglement calculations in spherical regions into thermodynamic problems in hyperbolic space
2. Revealed the universal expansion structure of SREE: Established the universal form $S(q) = S - \# \log V + O(V^0) + q\text{-dependent terms}$
3. Proved the universality of the equipartition property: Through asymptotic analysis, rigorously proved that the equipartition property holds at the constant order, with charge $q$ dependence appearing only in higher-order terms
4. Verified method validity: Detailed calculations in free field theory and holographic field theory confirm theoretical predictions

Methodology Details

Task Definition

Calculate the symmetry-resolved entanglement entropy $S(q)$ of a spherical region $A$ (radius $R$) in the vacuum state of a $d$-dimensional conformal field theory, where $q$ is the eigenvalue of the conserved charge.

Core Methodological Framework

1. Conformal Mapping Technique

Employing the Casini-Huerta-Myers mapping to transform the spherical region $A$ into a hyperbolic cylinder $\mathbb{R} \times H^{d-1}$:

• The reduced density matrix $\rho_A$ of the spherical region maps to a thermal density matrix in hyperbolic space at temperature $T_0 = \frac{1}{2\pi R}$
• The conserved charge operator $Q_A$ correspondingly maps to the charge operator $Q$ in hyperbolic space

2. Charged Moment Calculation

Define the charged moments: $Z_n(\mu) = \text{tr}[\rho_A^n e^{i\mu Q_A}]$

Through conformal mapping, transform into the grand canonical partition function in hyperbolic space: $Z_n(\mu) = \frac{Z(n\beta_0, \frac{i\mu}{n\beta_0})}{Z(\beta_0, 0)^n}$

3. Fourier Inverse Transform

Obtain the symmetry-resolved partition function from charged moments via Fourier inverse transform: $Z_n(q) = \int_{-\pi}^{\pi} \frac{d\mu}{2\pi} Z_n(\mu) e^{-i\mu q}$

4. SREE Calculation

Symmetry-resolved Rényi entropy: $S_n(q) = \frac{1}{1-n} \log \frac{Z_n(q)}{Z_1^n(q)}$

Symmetry-resolved entanglement entropy is obtained through the $n \to 1$ limit: $S(q) = \lim_{n \to 1} S_n(q)$

Technical Innovations

1. Imaginary chemical potential technique: Introducing imaginary chemical potential $i\mu$ to handle charged moments through boundary condition modifications
2. Asymptotic expansion analysis: Systematic asymptotic analysis in the large hyperbolic space volume $V$ limit
3. Universality proof: Mathematical analysis proving the universality of expansion structure, independent of specific theoretical details

Experimental Setup

Theoretical Models

1. Free field theory:
   • Four-dimensional conformally coupled complex scalar field
   • Two-dimensional conformally coupled complex scalar field
2. Holographic field theory:
   • Dual field theory of Einstein-Maxwell gravity
   • Topological black hole solutions in arbitrary dimensions

Computational Tools

• Heat kernel technique: For partition function calculations in free field theory
• Holographic duality: Utilizing AdS/CFT correspondence for holographic theory calculations
• Laplace method: For large parameter asymptotic expansion

Parameter Settings

• Hyperbolic space volume as large parameter: $V \gg 1$
• Charge sectors: Primarily considering $q = O(1)$ cases
• Regularization: Using cutoff regularization for divergence handling

Experimental Results

Main Results

1. Four-Dimensional Free Scalar Field

$S(q) = \frac{V}{90\pi} - \frac{1}{2}\log V + \log(2\sqrt{3}\pi) - \frac{3}{2} + \frac{24\pi(\pi^2 q^2 - 3)}{V} + O(V^{-2})$

2. Two-Dimensional Free Scalar Field

$S(q) = \frac{V}{3} - \log V + \log 2 - 1 + \frac{2(2\pi^2 q^2 - 5)}{V^2} + O(V^{-3})$

3. Holographic Theory (Arbitrary Dimension)

$S(q) = 2\pi \left(\frac{L}{l_P}\right)^{d-1} V - \frac{1}{2}\log V + h_0 + h_{-1} + \cdots$

where $h_{-1}$ contains dependence on $q^2$.

Universal Expansion Structure

All computational results exhibit the same structure: $S(q) = S - \# \log V + O(V^0) + q\text{-dependent terms}$

where:

• The leading term is the unresolved entanglement entropy $S$
• The subleading term is the logarithmic correction $-\frac{1}{2}\log V$ or $-\log V$
• The constant term is independent of charge $q$, manifesting the equipartition property
• $q$ dependence appears only in $O(V^{-1})$ or higher-order terms

Equipartition Property Verification

In all computational cases, the equipartition property is verified at the constant order:

• Four-dimensional case: Equipartition holds to $O(V^0)$, with $q^2$ dependence appearing in $O(V^{-1})$ terms
• Two-dimensional case: Equipartition holds to $O(V^0)$, with $q^2$ dependence appearing in $O(V^{-2})$ terms
• Holographic case: Equipartition holds to $O(V^0)$, with $q^2$ dependence appearing in $O(V^{-1})$ terms

Related Work

Historical Development

1. SREE concept: Systematically introduced by Goldstein and Sela in 2018
2. Two-dimensional research: Primarily concentrated on conformal field theory, such as compact bosons, WZW models, etc.
3. Higher-dimensional exploration: Limited research involving specific dimensions of Fermi gases and free field theories

Comparison with This Work's Contributions

• Method universality: Provides a unified method applicable to arbitrary dimensions
• Theoretical rigor: Offers rigorous mathematical proofs through asymptotic analysis
• Result completeness: Simultaneously addresses both free field theory and holographic field theory

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Universal expansion structure: SREE exhibits a universal expansion form in the large subsystem size limit
2. Equipartition property: The equipartition property universally holds at the constant order, independent of specific theoretical details
3. Method validity: The conformal mapping method successfully generalizes to higher dimensions

Limitations

1. Scope of applicability: Primarily applicable to spherical regions in conformal field theories
2. Asymptotic conditions: Requires large hyperbolic space volume condition, i.e., $R \gg \delta$
3. Charge restrictions: Analysis is most reliable for small charge sectors ($q^2 \ll V$)

Future Directions

1. Non-abelian symmetries: Generalization to non-abelian global symmetries
2. Alternative expansion parameters: Exploration of other expansion parameters (e.g., large charge expansion) and their physical properties
3. Non-conformal theories: Extension of methods to non-conformal field theories

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Theoretical innovation: Successfully generalizes 2D SREE computational methods to arbitrary higher dimensions, filling an important theoretical gap
2. Mathematical rigor: Provides rigorous mathematical proofs of the equipartition property through asymptotic analysis, rather than mere numerical observations
3. Strong universality: Methods applicable to both free field theory and holographic field theory frameworks
4. Deep results: Not only provides specific computational results but also reveals underlying universal physical mechanisms

Weaknesses

1. Geometric limitations: Methods primarily applicable to spherical regions; generalizability to other geometric shapes requires verification
2. Large parameter dependence: Result validity heavily depends on large volume approximation; behavior in small systems remains unclear
3. Experimental verification: As purely theoretical work, lacks direct comparison with numerical simulations or experiments

Impact

1. Academic value: Provides important theoretical tools and universal insights for SREE research
2. Application prospects: Methods applicable to quantum phase transitions and critical phenomena in condensed matter physics
3. Foundation for future research: Establishes foundation for subsequent research on non-abelian symmetries, non-conformal theories, etc.

Applicable Scenarios

1. Theoretical physics research: Conformal field theory, holographic duality, quantum information theory
2. Condensed matter physics: Critical systems, quantum phase transitions, strongly correlated electron systems
3. Mathematical physics: Mathematical structures of entanglement entropy, asymptotic analysis methods

References

This paper cites 32 important references, primarily including:

• Original work on Shannon entropy 1
• Foundational work on SREE 2
• Development of conformal mapping techniques 37-39
• Related research on holographic entanglement entropy 8-10, 38
• Mathematical foundations of heat kernel methods 42, 43

Overall Assessment: This is a high-quality theoretical physics paper that successfully addresses important problems in SREE research, providing universal computational methods and profound theoretical insights. The work demonstrates high technical content, rigorous mathematical derivations, and significant academic value with promising applications.