Nonperturbative Formulation of Resonances in Quantum Mechanics Based on Exact WKB Method

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2503.18741
• Title: Nonperturbative Formulation of Resonances in Quantum Mechanics Based on Exact WKB Method
• Authors: Okuto Morikawa (RIKEN iTHEMS), Shoya Ogawa (Kyushu University)
• Classification: hep-th, nucl-th, quant-ph
• Publication Date: September 27, 2025 (arXiv v3)
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2503.18741

Abstract

This paper employs exact Wentzel-Kramers-Brillouin (WKB) analysis as a nonperturbative framework to investigate quasi-stationary states in quantum mechanics. Unlike previous work primarily focused on stable systems, we explore unstable states such as resonances. As a concrete example, we analyze the inverted Rosen-Morse potential, which exhibits barrier resonances. This model admits exact solutions, enabling direct comparison with exact WKB predictions. We provide a simple analytical picture of resonances and demonstrate consistency between exact solutions and results based on WKB analysis, extending the applicability of exact WKB analysis to non-polynomial potentials.

Research Background and Motivation

Research Problem

The core problem addressed in this paper is how to systematically understand quasi-stationary states in quantum mechanics using nonperturbative methods, particularly resonant states. Traditional WKB methods have limitations when dealing with unstable systems, and resonant states are difficult to handle due to wave function divergence in asymptotic regions.

Problem Significance

1. Universality: Resonance phenomena are ubiquitous in quantum many-body systems, including scattering theory, nuclear physics, open quantum systems, and non-Hermitian quantum mechanics
2. Theoretical Challenge: Resonant states are non-normalizable with complex probabilities, requiring sophisticated techniques such as analytic continuation or complex scaling methods
3. Methodological Unification: Existing methods such as complex scaling method (CSM), Zel'dovich regularization, and assembled Hilbert space approaches lack a unified theoretical framework

Limitations of Existing Methods

• Complex scaling method, while effective, involves complex mathematical techniques with opaque relationships to other methods
• Traditional WKB methods are primarily applied to stable systems
• Lack of intuitive physical pictures for resonant states

Research Motivation

Leveraging recent developments in exact WKB analysis, particularly resurgence theory, to provide a mathematically rigorous and physically meaningful nonperturbative formulation for quasi-stationary states, and to verify the method's validity through the exactly solvable inverted Rosen-Morse potential model.

Core Contributions

1. Method Extension: First systematic application of exact WKB analysis to unstable quantum systems, particularly resonant states
2. Physical Picture: Provides a simple universal explanation of resonances (including barrier resonances) from an analytic perspective
3. Exact Verification: Direct verification of complex energies predicted by exact WKB through exact solutions of the inverted Rosen-Morse potential
4. Extended Applicability: Extends the applicability of exact WKB methods to non-polynomial potentials
5. Theoretical Unification: Provides a potential bridge between understanding resonant states and other techniques such as complex scaling methods

Detailed Methodology

Problem Definition

Study quasi-stationary states in one-dimensional Schrödinger equation, particularly resonant states with complex energies: $\left[-\frac{\hbar^2}{2}\frac{d^2}{dx^2} + V(x)\right]\psi(x) = E\psi(x)$

where $E$ can be complex, with real part representing resonance energy and imaginary part related to decay width.

Exact WKB Analysis Framework

Basic Setup

Rewrite the Schrödinger equation as: $\left[-\frac{d^2}{dx^2} + \hbar^{-2}Q(x)\right]\psi(x) = 0, \quad Q(x) = 2[V(x) - E]$

WKB solutions adopt the form of formal power series: $\psi(x,\hbar) = e^{\int^x dx' S(x',\hbar)}, \quad S(x,\hbar) = \sum_{i=-1}^{\infty}\hbar^i S_i(x)$

Recursion Relations

Leading order yields: $S_{-1}(x) = S_{\pm}^{-1}(x) \equiv \pm\sqrt{Q(x)}$

Exact solutions and WKB approximations are: $\psi(x,\hbar)^{\pm} = \frac{1}{\sqrt{S_{odd}}}e^{\pm\int_{x_0}^x dx' S_{odd}} \sim \frac{1}{Q^{1/4}}e^{\pm\hbar^{-1}\int_{x_0}^x dx'\sqrt{Q}} + \cdots$

Stokes Phenomenon

The critical condition is the Stokes curve: $\text{Im}\hbar^{-1}\int^x dx'\sqrt{Q} = 0$

When the path crosses a Stokes curve, the wave function undergoes a discontinuity (Stokes phenomenon), described by monodromy matrices: $M_+ = \begin{pmatrix} 1 & i \\ 0 & 1 \end{pmatrix}, \quad M_- = \begin{pmatrix} 1 & 0 \\ i & 1 \end{pmatrix}$

Analytical Picture of Resonant States

Potential Structure in Complex Plane

In complex coordinates $z \in \mathbb{C}$, if the potential $\text{Re}V(z)$ possesses unstable local minima, the system contains resonant states. This is because the Stokes curve structure in exact WKB analysis is sensitive to sign changes of $V(z) - E$.

Resonance Mechanism in Inverted Rosen-Morse Potential

For the potential $V(x) = 1/\cosh^2(x)$, $\text{Re}V(z)$ has local minima at $\text{Im}z \neq 0$ in the complex plane, explaining the existence of barrier resonances.

Experimental Setup

Model System

The inverted Rosen-Morse potential is chosen as the research subject: $\left[-\frac{\hbar^2}{2m}\frac{d^2}{dx^2} + \frac{U_0}{\cosh^2\beta x}\right]\psi(x) = E\psi(x), \quad U_0 > 0$

Parameter Settings

Introduce dimensionless variables:

• $\xi = \tanh\beta x$
• $k = \sqrt{2mE}/\hbar$
• $s = \frac{1}{2}\left(-1 + \sqrt{1 - 8mU_0/(\beta^2\hbar^2)}\right)$

Boundary Conditions

Employ Siegert boundary conditions (purely outgoing wave boundary conditions) to determine resonant states.

Experimental Results

Exact Analytical Solutions

Exact solutions obtained through hypergeometric functions: $\psi(x) = (1-\xi^2)^{-\frac{ik}{2\beta}}F\left(-\frac{ik}{\beta}-s, -\frac{ik}{\beta}+s+1, -\frac{ik}{\beta}+1, \frac{1-\xi}{2}\right)$

Resonance Conditions and Complex Energies

Two classes of solutions from Siegert boundary conditions:

1. Resonant States ($\Gamma(-\frac{ik}{\beta} + s + 1)$ diverges): $k_n^R = \frac{\beta}{2}\left[\sqrt{\frac{8mU_0}{\beta^2\hbar^2}} - 1 - i(2n+1)\right]$
2. Anti-Resonant States ($\Gamma(-\frac{ik}{\beta} - s)$ diverges): $k_n^{AR} = \frac{\beta}{2}\left[-\sqrt{\frac{8mU_0}{\beta^2\hbar^2}} - 1 - i(2n+1)\right]$

Exact WKB Predictions

Leading Order Results

At leading order in WKB, the quantization condition is: $2\sqrt{2}\pi(1 + \sqrt{E}) = 2\pi in$

yielding complex energies: $E = \left(1 - \frac{in}{\sqrt{2}}\right)^2$

This already exhibits resonance characteristics in the fourth quadrant at leading order.

Exact WKB Analysis

Through Stokes diagram analysis and A-cycle integration, the quantization condition is: $1 - A = 0 \quad \text{or} \quad 1 + A = 0$

where the A-cycle can be precisely calculated through analytic properties of hypergeometric functions, ultimately yielding complex energy results in complete agreement with traditional methods.

Consistency Verification

Complex energies predicted by exact WKB method are in perfect agreement with results obtained through traditional scattering theory methods, verifying the correctness and validity of the approach.

Related Work

Development of Exact WKB Analysis

• Applications of resurgence theory in thermodynamic Bethe ansatz equations, Painlevé equations, supersymmetric theories, etc.
• Successful applications in double-well potentials, periodic potentials, supersymmetric quantum mechanics, and PT-symmetric quantum mechanics

Resonant State Research Methods

• Complex scaling method (CSM) and its applications in many-body systems
• Zel'dovich regularization and Berggren completeness
• Assembled Hilbert space methods
• Gamow shell model and complementary methods

Relationship to Related Work

This paper is the first to systematically apply exact WKB analysis to unstable systems, providing a unified nonperturbative theoretical framework for existing various methods.

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Exact WKB analysis provides a rigorous nonperturbative formulation for resonant states
2. The analytic structure of the potential in the complex plane determines the existence of resonant states
3. Exact solutions of the inverted Rosen-Morse potential are in complete agreement with exact WKB predictions
4. The method successfully extends to non-polynomial potentials

Limitations

1. Currently verified primarily in one-dimensional systems; extension to higher dimensions requires further research
2. For more complex many-body systems, computational complexity may increase significantly
3. Precise relationships with other methods (such as complex scaling methods) still require deeper investigation

Future Directions

1. Extension to more general systems and more complex potentials
2. Establish explicit connections with complex scaling methods, assembled Hilbert space methods, etc.
3. Application to practical physical systems, such as resonance phenomena in nuclear and atomic-molecular physics

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Theoretical Innovation: First systematic application of exact WKB analysis to resonant state research, providing new theoretical perspective
2. Methodological Rigor: Based on mathematically rigorous framework of resurgence theory, avoiding limitations of traditional approximate methods
3. Physical Intuitiveness: Provides clear physical picture of resonance phenomena from analytic perspective
4. Sufficient Verification: Completely validates method correctness through exactly solvable models
5. Writing Clarity: Clear paper structure, detailed mathematical derivations, intuitive physical pictures

Shortcomings

1. Application Scope: Currently verified only on one specific model; more examples needed to demonstrate method universality
2. Computational Complexity: For more complex systems, Stokes diagram analysis and A-cycle calculations may become extremely complex
3. Practical Utility Assessment: Advantages compared to existing mature methods require further evaluation in practical applications
4. Higher-Order Corrections: While importance of higher-order terms is mentioned, detailed analysis is insufficient

Impact

1. Theoretical Contribution: Provides new tools for studying nonperturbative phenomena in quantum mechanics
2. Interdisciplinary Value: Method may have applications in nuclear physics, atomic-molecular physics, condensed matter physics, etc.
3. Methodological Significance: Demonstrates application potential of exact WKB analysis in new domains
4. Reproducibility: Detailed mathematical derivations and verifiable results

Applicable Scenarios

1. Theoretical Physics Research: Suitable for studying resonance phenomena in various quantum systems
2. Nuclear Physics: Theoretical analysis of nuclear resonant states
3. Atomic-Molecular Physics: Resonances in molecular dissociation and atomic ionization processes
4. Open Quantum Systems: Quasi-stationary state analysis of systems coupled to environment

References

The paper includes abundant references covering important works in exact WKB analysis, resurgence theory, resonant state research and related fields, providing readers with comprehensive background knowledge and directions for further research.

Overall Assessment: This is a high-quality theoretical physics paper that innovatively applies exact WKB analysis to resonant state research, providing a rigorous mathematical framework and clear physical picture. While the current application scope is limited, it opens new avenues for studying nonperturbative phenomena in quantum mechanics, possessing significant theoretical value and application prospects.