On The Black Hole Weak Gravity Conjecture and Extremality in the Strong-Field Regime

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2503.20910
• Title: On The Black Hole Weak Gravity Conjecture and Extremality in the Strong-Field Regime
• Authors: Sergio Barbosa, Sylvain Fichet, Lucas de Souza (Federal University of ABC, Brazil)
• Classification: hep-th (High Energy Physics - Theory)
• Publication Date: October 16, 2025 (v2)
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2503.20910v2

Abstract

This paper demonstrates that the Weak Gravity Conjecture (WGC) implies that sufficiently small extremal black holes necessarily reside in the strong-field regime of electrodynamics, thereby probing the ultraviolet (UV) completeness of the Maxwell sector. To investigate the WGC boundaries generated by these small extremal black holes, the authors revisit black hole decay in general field theories in asymptotically flat spacetime. The paper derives necessary and sufficient conditions for any black hole decay, which are equivalent to boundaries on charge growth relative to mass. Applying these conditions to extremal black holes in the Maxwell sector with various UV completions, the authors find that Euler-Heisenberg and DBI effective actions satisfy the sufficient decay conditions, while the ModMax model fails the necessary conditions, rendering it incompatible with the WGC. Using the decay conditions, the paper proves that black hole WGC implies positivity of the U(1) gauge coupling beta function, providing an independent argument for the non-existence of classically stable (embedded abelian) colored black holes.

Research Background and Motivation

Core Problem

This research addresses the fundamental issue of the interplay between extremal black holes and the Weak Gravity Conjecture in the strong-field regime. Specifically, it encompasses:

1. How extremal black holes probe UV completeness of the Maxwell sector
2. What conditions govern black hole decay in strong-field regions beyond the effective field theory (EFT) range
3. Whether different nonlinear electrodynamics models are compatible with the WGC

Significance

The importance of this problem is manifested in:

1. Theoretical Physics Foundations: The WGC is a crucial conjecture in quantum gravity theory, asserting that gravity is the weakest force
2. UV Completeness: Extremal black holes serve as semi-classical probes of high-energy physics
3. Swampland Program: Identifying which low-energy gravitational theories belong to the "swampland" (incompatible with quantum gravity)

Limitations of Existing Approaches

Current research is primarily limited by:

1. Studying WGC only within the EFT regime using perturbative expansions of the form Z̄ = 1 + a/M^n
2. Lack of general conditions beyond the weak-field regime
3. Insufficient systematic analysis of different UV completion models in the strong-field region

Core Contributions

1. Established the existence of strong-field regions: Proved that applying WGC to large extremal black holes implies small extremal black holes necessarily reside in strong-field regions
2. Derived decay conditions transcending EFT:
   • Sufficient condition: ∂Z̄/∂M < 0 (charge growth boundary)
   • Necessary condition: Existence of discrete mass subsets such that Z̄ strictly decreases
3. Analyzed specific physical models:
   • Euler-Heisenberg and DBI models satisfy WGC
   • ModMax model is incompatible with WGC
4. Established beta function positivity: Proved that black hole WGC implies the U(1) gauge coupling beta function must be positive
5. Applications to colored black holes and holography: Provides new arguments for colored black hole instability and verifies AdS/CFT compatibility

Methodology Details

Task Definition

Investigation of decay conditions for charged black holes in asymptotically flat spacetime under various UV completions of the Maxwell sector, with particular focus on the behavior of the charge-to-mass ratio Z = √2Q/(κM) for extremal black holes.

Theoretical Framework

EFT Scale Analysis

The authors introduce three expansion parameters to describe physics near the horizon of extremal black holes:

ε = 1/(Λ²r₊²)     (derivative expansion)
εᵣ = 1/(Λᵣ²r₊²)   (curvature expansion) 
εF = e²Q²/(Λ₄Fr₊⁴) (field strength expansion)

where the critical field strength scale is:

Λᶜ_F = √(eQ/r₊)

Strong-Field Region Criterion

When ΛF < Λᶜ_F, the black hole enters the strong-field region. For extremal black holes, the critical radius is:

rch = e/(κΛ²F)

Decay Condition Derivation

Sufficient Condition Proof

By proving strict subadditivity of the extremal charge function Q̄(M):

Q̄(M₁ + M₂) < Q̄(M₁) + Q̄(M₂)

This is equivalent to monotonic decrease of Z̄: ∂Z̄/∂M < 0.

Necessary Condition Proof

Utilizing kinematic constraints on black hole decay:

Z₀ = Σᵢ σᵢZᵢ, Σᵢ σᵢ < 1

Through iterative construction, the authors prove that there must exist discrete mass subsets such that Z̄ strictly decreases.

Specific Model Analysis

Euler-Heisenberg Model

In the strong-field limit:

Z̄_EH ≈ 1 + (q²e²)/(24π²)(-2 + log(√2eq/(m²rhκ)))

Satisfies ∂Z̄/∂M < 0, thus compatible with WGC.

DBI Model

Extremal charge-to-mass relation:

Z̄_DBI = √2/κ × (3√π/(2ΛDBIΓ(1/4)Γ(5/4)))^(2/3) × M^(-1/3)

Similarly satisfies the decay condition.

ModMax Model

This model yields a constant charge-to-mass ratio Z̄ = e^γ, satisfying no decay conditions and thus incompatible with WGC.

Experimental Setup

Theoretical Verification Methods

1. Dimensional Analysis: Estimating physical quantities such as field strength and curvature near the horizon
2. Exact Analytical Solutions: Solving black hole metrics in nonlinear electrodynamics
3. Perturbative Expansions: Separate expansions in weak-field and strong-field regimes

Model Parameters

• Euler-Heisenberg: Fermion mass m, fractional charge q
• DBI: D-brane tension parameter ΛDBI
• ModMax: Conformal parameter γ

Computational Methods

Employing magnetic black hole configurations to simplify calculations, utilizing spherical symmetry to solve Einstein and Maxwell field equations.

Experimental Results

Main Results

EFT Scale Hierarchy

Application of WGC in the weak-field regime leads to scale hierarchy:

ΛR/κ > Λ²F/e

This ensures the existence of strong-field regions.

Model Compatibility

Beta Function Constraints

Black hole WGC requires:

β^(1) > 0

This imposes strong constraints on U(1) gauge theories.

Physical Insights

Renormalization Flow

In the strong-field region, the running of effective coupling constants can be viewed as renormalization flow in the black hole solution space:

Z̄ ≈ 1 + (β^(1)g₀²)/2 × log(2g₀/(rhκμ₀²))

Colored Black Hole Instability

The negative beta function of Yang-Mills theory contradicts the positive beta function required by WGC, providing new arguments for the classical instability of colored black holes.

Related Work

Historical Development of WGC

1. Original Conjecture: Arkani-Hamed et al. proposed the concept that gravity is the weakest force
2. Infrared Arguments: Physical arguments based on extremal black hole decay
3. Ultraviolet Motivation: Abundant evidence from string theory

Applications in Black Hole Physics

1. EFT Corrections: Effects of higher-order operators on extremality
2. Love Numbers: Relationship between tidal deformations and WGC
3. Causality Constraints: Restrictions on black hole thermodynamics from unitarity and causality

Nonlinear Electrodynamics

1. Born-Infeld Theory: Effective action from string theory
2. Euler-Heisenberg Action: One-loop effective action of QED
3. Conformally Invariant Models: Novel extensions such as ModMax

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Universality of Strong-Field Regions: WGC guarantees the existence of strong-field regions for extremal black holes
2. Generalization of Decay Conditions: Necessary and sufficient conditions transcending EFT
3. Model Selection Principle: WGC as a tool for distinguishing "swampland" theories
4. Beta Function Constraints: New restrictions on renormalization flow of gauge theories

Limitations

1. Classical Approximation: Does not account for quantum corrections and Hawking radiation
2. Asymptotically Flat Assumption: Not extended to AdS or dS backgrounds
3. Perturbative Level: Beta function analysis only at perturbative order
4. Numerical Factors: Some estimates neglect numerical coefficients

Future Directions

1. Non-Perturbative Effects: Investigation of non-perturbative beta functions in strong coupling regimes
2. Quantum Corrections: Inclusion of Hawking radiation and quantum geometric effects
3. Higher-Dimensional Generalizations: Extension to arbitrary spacetime dimensions
4. Experimental Verification: Verification of theoretical predictions through gravitational wave observations

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Theoretical Innovation: First systematic study of WGC in strong-field regimes
2. Mathematical Rigor: Clear and complete logical structure in decay condition proofs
3. Physical Intuition: Connects abstract WGC to concrete physical models
4. Broad Applicability: Encompasses multiple fields from effective field theory to holographic duality

Weaknesses

1. Experimental Verifiability: Theoretical predictions are difficult to directly observe
2. Model Dependence: Some conclusions depend on specific theoretical assumptions
3. Numerical Precision: Some calculations employ approximate treatments

Impact

1. Theoretical Physics: Provides new tools for the swampland program
2. Black Hole Physics: Deepens understanding of extremal black hole properties
3. Quantum Gravity: Provides insights into consistency conditions of quantum gravity
4. Phenomenology: Imposes constraints on new physics beyond the Standard Model

Applicable Scenarios

1. String Theory Compactifications: Verification of low-energy effective theory consistency
2. Dark Matter Models: Constraints on hidden sector coupling constants
3. Modified Gravity Theories: Testing viability of modified gravitational theories
4. Black Hole Thermodynamics: Investigation of extremal black hole stability

References

This paper cites over 90 relevant references spanning multiple fields including WGC, black hole physics, nonlinear electrodynamics, and effective field theory. Key references include:

1. Original WGC papers by Arkani-Hamed et al. 7
2. Work by Cheung-Remmen on infrared consistency 11
3. Classical literature on Euler-Heisenberg effective action 36
4. Foundational papers on AdS/CFT correspondence 69

This paper holds significant importance in theoretical physics, advancing our understanding of the Weak Gravity Conjecture and providing new criteria for identifying low-energy theories compatible with quantum gravity. Its methods and results have profound implications for understanding black hole physics, quantum gravity, and new physics beyond the Standard Model.