Neuro-Symbolic Imitation Learning: Discovering Symbolic Abstractions for Skill Learning

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2503.21406
• Title: Neuro-Symbolic Imitation Learning: Discovering Symbolic Abstractions for Skill Learning
• Authors: Leon Keller, Daniel Tanneberg, Jan Peters
• Classification: cs.AI cs.LG cs.RO
• Publication Time/Conference: IEEE International Conference on Robotics and Automation (ICRA) 2025
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2503.21406
• DOI: 10.1109/ICRA55743.2025.11127692

Abstract

Imitation learning is a popular method for teaching robots new behaviors. However, most existing approaches focus on teaching short-term, isolated skills rather than long-term, multi-step tasks. To bridge this gap, imitation learning algorithms need not only to learn individual skills but also to develop abstract understanding of how to sequence these skills for effective execution of extended tasks. This paper addresses this challenge by proposing a neuro-symbolic imitation learning framework. The system first learns symbolic representations that abstract low-level state-action spaces using task demonstrations. The learned representations decompose tasks into simpler subtasks and enable the system to leverage symbolic planning to generate abstract plans. Subsequently, the system utilizes this task decomposition to learn a set of neural skills capable of refining abstract plans into actionable robot commands. Experimental results in three simulated robotic environments demonstrate that our neuro-symbolic approach improves data efficiency, enhances generalization capabilities, and promotes interpretability compared to baseline methods.

Research Background and Motivation

Core Problem

This research addresses fundamental limitations of existing imitation learning methods when handling long-term, multi-step robotic tasks. Specifically:

1. Skill Isolation: Most existing methods can only learn short-term, isolated skills and cannot handle complex tasks requiring sequences of multiple skills
2. Lack of Abstract Understanding: Existing methods lack abstract understanding of how to sequence skills to complete extended tasks
3. Limited Generalization: Traditional methods show insufficient generalization when facing unseen task configurations

Problem Significance

This problem has important implications for practical applications:

• Real-World Applications: Real-world robotic tasks (such as kitchen assistants) require executing complex multi-step operation sequences
• Cognitive Ability Simulation: Humans handle complex tasks through abstraction; robots similarly need such cognitive tools
• Engineering Practice Requirements: While current Task and Motion Planning (TAMP) methods are effective, they require manual design of symbolic representations and motion planning models by human experts

Limitations of Existing Methods

1. Manual Design Dependency: Traditional TAMP methods require extensive manual design of symbolic representations
2. Separation of Skills and Symbols: Existing research either learns symbols given skills or learns skills given symbols, lacking a unified framework
3. Low Data Efficiency: Pure neural network methods suffer from low data efficiency when handling long sequence tasks

Core Contributions

1. Unified Neuro-Symbolic Framework: First to propose a unified framework that simultaneously learns relational symbolic abstractions and neural skills from raw task demonstrations
2. Novel Predicate Learning Method: Proposes a predicate selection method based on optimizing objective functions, balancing fine-grained segmentation and operator complexity
3. Two-Stage Learning Strategy: Designs a two-stage approach that first learns symbolic components (predicates and operators), then leverages symbolic representations to learn neural skills
4. Significant Performance Improvements: Demonstrates substantial improvements in data efficiency, generalization capability, and interpretability compared to baseline methods across three simulated robotic environments

Methodology Details

Task Definition

This paper studies imitation learning in fully observable robotic environments:

• Environment Composition: Robot and multiple manipulable objects
• Object Representation: Each object o ∈ O has type t(o) ∈ T and feature vector ξᵢ(o) ∈ Ξ(o)
• State Definition: Environment state sₜ is the concatenation of all object states
• Action Space: Action a ∈ A specifies offsets in end-effector pose
• Task Objective: Learn a neuro-symbolic policy capable of solving new tasks from a collection of demonstration trajectories D = {τ⁰,...,τᴹ}

Model Architecture

1. Neuro-Symbolic Policy Components

The neuro-symbolic policy comprises three core components:

Predicates P:

• Definition: Binary functions with type parameters Θ that specify relationships between objects
• Function: Abstract environment state s into symbolic state s̄ = ψ(s,P)
• Example: onTop(cube, cube) represents stacking relationships between cubes

Operators Σ:

• Structure: Contains type parameters Θ, precondition sets (pre⁺, pre⁻), and effect sets (eff⁺, eff⁻)
• Function: Define transition models in abstract state space
• Representation: Uses PDDL format, supporting symbolic planning

Skills Π:

• Composition: Each skill πᵢ = (fᵢ, gᵢ) contains subgoal sampler gᵢ and subgoal-conditioned controller fᵢ
• Function: Execute concrete operators in abstract plans

2. Policy Execution Flow

1. Abstract Plan Generation:
   • Abstract initial state s₀ and goal state set Sₘ
   • Use symbolic planning algorithm to generate operator sequences
   • Select optimal plan via Levenshtein distance
2. Plan Execution:
   • Sequentially execute skills corresponding to each operator in the plan
   • Subgoal sampler proposes subgoals satisfying operator effects
   • Subgoal-conditioned controller executes concrete actions until effects are satisfied

Technical Innovations

1. Two-Stage Predicate Learning Method

Candidate Generation Stage:

• Construct candidate predicates based on relative features observed in demonstrations
• Use clustering methods to identify dense regions in feature space
• Create candidate predicates for each cluster

Abstract Selection Stage: Optimize objective function:

max P⊂C ∑τ∈D |ψ(P,τ)| - α|Σ(P,D)|

Subject to: |ψ(P,τ)| = |plan(P,Σ,τ₀,τₙ)| ∀τ ∈ D

This objective function balances:

• Fine-grained segmentation (maximizing number of abstract states)
• Operator complexity control (minimizing number of operators)
• Plan optimality guarantee (constraint condition)

2. Skill Learning with State Transition Constraints

• Segment demonstration trajectories according to symbolic representations
• Use transition function φσ to retain only state information relevant to operators
• Train subgoal-conditioned controllers via behavioral cloning
• Learn subgoal samplers using kernel density estimation

Experimental Setup

Datasets

Experiments are conducted in three simulated robotic environments using MuJoCo physics engine and robosuite simulation framework:

1. Building Environment: Robot must assemble rectangular blocks in correct order to build bridge structures
2. Pouring Environment: Robot must pour tea from teapot into cup and place filled cup on tray
3. Painting Environment: Robot must paint blocks with brush and place painted blocks into box

Evaluation Metrics

• Success Rate: Percentage of task completions
• Data Efficiency: Performance with varying numbers of demonstrations
• Generalization Capability: Performance across three scenarios
  • Scenario I: Unseen initial object poses
  • Scenario II: Unseen goal configurations
  • Scenario III: More objects than in training

Comparison Methods

1. Critical Region (CR): Ablation experiment using criticality concept for predicate scoring and selection
2. Hierarchical Neural Network (HNN): Ablation experiment replacing symbolic planning with neural network high-level policy

Implementation Details

• Number of demonstrations: 100, 200, 300
• Optimization algorithm: Beam search for predicate selection
• Skill learning: Multi-layer perceptron + behavioral cloning
• Planning algorithm: Off-the-shelf symbolic planner

Experimental Results

Main Results

Experimental results show the proposed method outperforms baseline methods across all environments and scenarios:

1. Data Efficiency: With 300 demonstrations, the method achieves high success rates across all environments and generalization scenarios
2. Generalization Capability:
   • HNN completely fails in Scenarios II and III
   • CR method shows poor generalization due to learning overly complex symbolic representations
   • Proposed method maintains stable high success rates across all scenarios
3. Specific Performance Data:
   • Outperforms baselines across all demonstration quantity settings
   • Demonstrates good balance between data efficiency and generalization

Ablation Study Analysis

1. CR Baseline Analysis:
   • Learns more complex symbolic representations (more predicates and operators)
   • Operators have more parameters on average, increasing skill learning complexity
   • Over-complexity leads to reduced generalization
2. HNN Baseline Analysis:
   • Lacks generalization capability of symbolic planning
   • Fails when facing new goals and more objects
   • Validates importance of symbolic planning for generalization

Interpretability Analysis

1. Predicate Visualization: By overlaying images where predicates are true, all learned predicates can be assigned meaningful names
2. Operator Interpretation: Learned operators can be clearly expressed in PDDL syntax with explicit preconditions and effects
3. Plan Interpretability: Generated abstract plans are fully interpretable, facilitating understanding and debugging

Related Work

Symbolic Representation Learning

Related work falls into two categories:

1. Learning Symbols Given Skills: Early work using radial basis function classifiers, Boolean satisfiability problems, neural network binary bottleneck layers, etc.
2. Learning Skills Given Symbols: Combining symbolic planning with reinforcement learning, using symbolic abstractions to guide imitation learning, etc.

Uniqueness of This Work

This paper is the first to simultaneously learn relational symbolic abstractions and neural skills from raw demonstrations, filling a gap in the field.

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Method Effectiveness: The neuro-symbolic imitation learning framework successfully addresses learning for long-term multi-step tasks
2. Performance Advantages: Significant improvements over baseline methods in data efficiency, generalization capability, and interpretability
3. Technical Contributions: The proposed predicate learning method and unified framework provide new research directions for the field

Limitations

1. Simulation Environment Constraints: Currently validated only in simulation; real robot applicability requires further verification
2. Object Type Assumptions: Method relies on predefined object types; adaptability to new object categories is limited
3. Demonstration Quality Dependency: Method performance depends on high-quality demonstration data

Future Directions

The authors propose three main future research directions:

1. Real Robot Validation: Verify practical applicability of the framework on real robots
2. Multi-Task Extension: Explore applications in multi-task imitation learning
3. Online Adaptation: Study online adaptation of skills and symbolic representations to support new object categories and failure recovery

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Problem Importance: Addresses an important problem in imitation learning with practical application value
2. Method Innovation:
   • First to unify symbol and skill learning
   • Proposes novel predicate learning objective function
   • Designs effective two-stage learning strategy
3. Experimental Sufficiency:
   • Three different robotic environments
   • Multiple generalization scenario tests
   • Appropriate baseline comparisons and ablation studies
4. Result Convincingness: Significant performance improvements and good interpretability
5. Writing Clarity: Clear paper structure and accurate technical descriptions

Weaknesses

1. Experimental Environment Limitations:
   • Validation only in simulation
   • Relatively simple environments; real-world complexity not fully considered
2. Method Limitations:
   • Depends on predefined object types and features
   • Clustering hyperparameter ε selection may affect performance
   • Beam search does not guarantee global optimality
3. Baseline Comparisons: Baseline methods are relatively simple; lacks comparison with more advanced methods
4. Theoretical Analysis: Lacks theoretical guarantees for convergence and generalization capability

Impact

1. Academic Contribution:
   • Opens new direction in neuro-symbolic imitation learning
   • Provides effective solution for long-term task learning
   • Method has good generalizability
2. Practical Value:
   • Applicable to complex robotic tasks
   • Provides interpretable decision processes
   • High data efficiency suitable for practical applications
3. Reproducibility:
   • Clear technical detail descriptions
   • Website link provided, likely containing code
   • Explicit experimental setup

Applicable Scenarios

1. Robotic Manipulation Tasks: Particularly suitable for tasks requiring multi-step operation sequences
2. Structured Environments: Works best in environments with relatively fixed object types and relationships
3. Interpretability-Required Applications: Medical, educational, and other domains requiring understanding of decision processes
4. Data-Limited Scenarios: More advantageous than pure neural network methods when demonstration data is limited

References

The paper cites 61 relevant references covering important works in imitation learning, symbolic learning, reinforcement learning, task and motion planning, and other domains, providing solid theoretical foundation for the research.

Overall Assessment: This is a high-quality research paper that addresses an important problem in robotic learning, proposes innovative solutions, and validates method effectiveness through comprehensive experiments. Despite some limitations, its academic contributions and practical value are significant, providing important impetus for field development.