Noninvertible symmetries in the B model TFT

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2504.02023
• Title: Noninvertible symmetries in the B model TFT
• Authors: Andrei Căldăraru, Tony Pantev, Eric Sharpe, Benjamin Sung, Xingyang Yu
• Classification: hep-th (High Energy Physics - Theory)
• Publication Date: March 2025 (arXiv preprint)
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2504.02023

Abstract

This paper investigates noninvertible symmetries in general (not necessarily rational) superconformal field theories (SCFTs) and their topological B-twist on Calabi-Yau manifolds. The article first provides a detailed overview of defects in the topological B model. In the topological B model, all defects are topological operators that define (typically noninvertible) symmetries of the topological field theory, though only a subset remain topological in the physical (untwisted) theory. For a general target space Calabi-Yau X, the paper discusses the geometric realization of these defects as complex Lagrangians and complex coisotropic submanifolds on X×X that are simultaneously A-twisted and B-twisted, and discusses their fusion products. The possible noninvertible symmetries in the B model are more general than those describable by fusion categories. The paper describes realizations of some Tambara-Yamagami categories in the B model with elliptic curve targets, and argues that elliptic curves cannot admit Fibonacci or Haagerup structures.

Research Background and Motivation

Problem Definition

1. Core Problem: Understanding the role of noninvertible symmetries in string theory compactifications on Calabi-Yau manifolds, particularly their concrete realization within the B model topological field theory framework.
2. Significance:
   • Noninvertible symmetries are important concepts in modern quantum field theory, especially in 2D theories
   • The B model provides a concrete mathematical framework (derived categories) for studying noninvertible symmetries
   • Important for understanding the structure of symmetries in string theory compactifications
3. Existing Limitations:
   • Conventional noninvertible symmetry research is typically limited to finite fusion categories
   • Lack of concrete realizations in general Calabi-Yau geometry
   • Derived categories are richer than fusion categories, but their relationship remains unclear
4. Research Motivation:
   • Utilize the concreteness of derived categories in the B model to understand noninvertible symmetries
   • Establish correspondence between topological defects and derived category objects
   • Provide geometric understanding of noninvertible symmetries in Calabi-Yau compactifications

Core Contributions

1. Established a complete mathematical framework for B model defects: Describing line operators and defects through integral transforms in the derived category D^b(X×X)
2. Demonstrated that derived categories satisfy most fusion category axioms: Except for finiteness and semisimplicity conditions
3. Constructed concrete noninvertible symmetry structures on elliptic curves:
   • Realized Z_n×Z_n Tambara-Yamagami structures
   • Proved that elliptic curves cannot admit Fibonacci or Haagerup structures
4. Provided geometric criteria for topological defects in physical theories: Complex Lagrangians and complex coisotropic submanifolds that are simultaneously A and B-twisted
5. Described decomposition and condensation defects: Their realization in derived category language
6. Provided concrete computational methods for quantum dimensions: Through alternating sums of Ext groups

Detailed Methodology

Theoretical Framework

Defect Description in the B Model

Defects in the B model are described through integral transforms. Given a kernel K ∈ D^b(X×Y), the corresponding integral transform is:

Φ(K)(E) = p_Y∗(K ⊗ p_X*E)

where p_X,Y are projection maps.

Fusion Product Realization

The fusion product of two defects corresponds to composition of integral transforms:

K_XY ∗ K_YZ = q∗(p*_XY K_XY ⊗ p*_YZ K_YZ)

Direction Reversal Operation

For a defect K on Calabi-Yau X, its adjoint is defined as:

K† = (σ*K)∨[dim X]

where σ is the transpose map.

Topological Criteria

Simultaneous A and B-Twist Condition

A defect remains topological in the physical theory if and only if it can be simultaneously A-twisted and B-twisted. This requires the support manifold S to satisfy:

• S is a complex coisotropic submanifold of X×X
• Curvature condition: F + π₁B₁ - π₂B₂ = 0 on S
• Almost para-complex structure condition: (ω⁻¹F)² = +1

K-Theory Simplification

To simplify calculations, the paper primarily works at the K-theory level:

K_num(E×E) = Z⟨O, O_p×E, O_E×p, O_Δ, O_q⟩

Experimental Setup

Research Objects

1. Elliptic curves: Primary research target, computing various noninvertible symmetry structures
2. K3 surfaces: Verifying the universality of the method
3. General Calabi-Yau manifolds: Discussing universally present noninvertible symmetries

Computational Methods

1. K-theory calculations: Reducing fusion rules to linear algebra problems
2. Stability analysis: Using Bridgeland stability conditions to identify simple objects
3. Ext group calculations: Computing junction operator spaces using spectral sequences

Verification Indicators

1. Fusion rule verification: Checking Z_n lines, Tambara-Yamagami structures, etc.
2. Adjoint operation consistency: Verifying (K₁∗K₂)† = K₂†∗K₁†
3. Quantum dimension calculation: Computing relevant quantities through Euler pairing

Experimental Results

Main Results on Elliptic Curves

Construction of Z_n Lines

Successfully constructed line operators of various cyclic group orders. For example, Z₂ lines have K-theory classes including:

• Trivial case: (0,0,0,±1,0)
• Anti-diagonal: (0,∓2,∓2,±1,0)

Tambara-Yamagami Structures

1. Z₂×Z₂ Structure: Found multiple K-theory level solutions, including:

   η₁ = -2O_p×E - 2O_E×p + O_Δ
   D = ±2O_p×E ± 2O_E×p ∓ 2O_Δ
   

2. Z₃×Z₃ Structure: Constructed corresponding noninvertible lines D satisfying fusion rules

Negative Results

Proved that elliptic curves cannot admit the following structures:

• Fibonacci structure: All solutions contain non-integer coefficients
• Haagerup structure: Both H₂ and H₃ categories cannot be realized on elliptic curves
• Rep(S₃) structure: Although K-theory solutions exist, stability verification is needed

K3 Surface Results

Similar Z₂×Z₂ Tambara-Yamagami structures were found on K3 surfaces, verifying the universality of the method.

Quantum Dimension Calculations

For defects ∆_*V (V a rank r vector bundle), their one-loop expectation value is:

⟨∆_*V⟩ = r

This equals the rank of the line operator, providing geometric intuition.

Related Work

Noninvertible Symmetry Theory

1. Fusion category approach: Axiomatic construction of 2D TFTs with fusion category symmetries by Chang et al.
2. RCFT applications: Noninvertible symmetries discovered by Cordova and Rizi in Calabi-Yau conformal field theories
3. String theory realization: Generalized symmetry operators studied by Heckman et al. from D-brane perspective

B Model and Derived Categories

1. Classical results: Correspondence between D-branes and derived categories established by Sharpe et al.
2. Integral transforms: Mathematical theory of Fourier-Mukai transforms by Mukai and Huybrechts
3. Topological field theory: "Taffy method" by Ando and Sharpe for computing correlation functions

Geometric Realization

1. Lagrangian correspondence: Lagrangian correspondence theory in the A model
2. Complex geometry: Geometric criteria for σ-model topological defects by Kapustin and Setter

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Derived categories provide a natural framework for noninvertible symmetries: Richer and more general than fusion categories
2. Geometric criteria are explicit: The condition of simultaneous A and B-twist provides geometric characterization of physical topological defects
3. Restrictiveness of elliptic curves: Not all fusion category structures can be realized on elliptic curves

Limitations

1. Stability conditions: Current stability criteria may need reassessment, particularly for indefinite metrics
2. K-theory simplification: Verification only at K-theory level; concrete representatives in D^b(X×X) need to be found
3. Computational complexity: Calculations become extremely complex for higher-dimensional Calabi-Yau manifolds

Future Directions

1. Stability theory: Develop stability conditions applicable to defects
2. Higher-dimensional generalization: Extend results to higher-dimensional Calabi-Yau manifolds
3. Physical applications: Concrete physical applications in string theory compactifications
4. Homological mirror symmetry: Understanding corresponding structures in the A model through HMS

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Mathematical rigor: Provides a complete mathematical framework for noninvertible symmetries
2. Concrete computability: Makes abstract concepts concrete and operationalizable through derived categories
3. Geometric intuition: Provides clear geometric explanations and criteria
4. Systematic coverage: Complete treatment from theoretical framework to concrete examples

Weaknesses

1. High technical threshold: Requires deep background in algebraic geometry and derived categories
2. Computational limitations: Main results limited to low-dimensional cases
3. Physical connection: Relationship to actual string theory physics needs strengthening
4. Completeness: Some proofs rely on K-theory simplification; full rigor remains to be verified

Impact

1. Theoretical contribution: Provides new mathematical tools for noninvertible symmetry research
2. Cross-disciplinary value: Connects high energy physics, algebraic geometry, and category theory
3. Methodological innovation: Derived category methods may influence related research areas
4. Practical value: Provides new perspectives for string theory compactification research

Applicable Scenarios

1. Theoretical string theory: Symmetry analysis in Calabi-Yau compactifications
2. Topological field theory: Defect studies in 2D topological field theories
3. Algebraic geometry: Applications of derived categories and integral transforms
4. Mathematical physics: Geometric realization of noninvertible symmetries

References

The paper contains extensive references covering classical D-brane theory through the latest noninvertible symmetry research, providing readers with comprehensive background knowledge and directions for further investigation.