2025-11-18T23:58:14.198926

Hong-Ou-Mandel effect with two frequency-entangled photons of vastly different color

Mann, Chrzanowski, Placke et al.
In the original formulation of the Hong-Ou-Mandel (HOM) experiment, when two otherwise indistinguishable photons are incident upon the two input ports of a balanced beam splitter, they coalesce, always leaving via the same output port. It is often interpreted that this interference arises due to the indistinguishability of the single photons at the beam splitter; the situation, however, is often more nuanced. Here, we demonstrate an analog of HOM interference between two photons of completely different color. To do so, we utilize a quantum frequency converter based on sum- and difference-frequency generation as an `active' beam splitter -- coupling frequency-entangled red and telecom single photons with an octave-spanning energy difference of 282 THz. We achieve an uncorrected two-photon interference visibility beyond 90%. This work presents the first demonstration of HOM interference between two single photons of distinctly different color, deepening our understanding of what underlies quantum interference. It also suggests a novel approach to interfacing photonic qubits in heterogeneous quantum systems where frequency conversion and quantum interference are unified.
academic

Hong-Ou-Mandel Effect with Two Frequency-Entangled Photons of Vastly Different Color

Basic Information

  • Paper ID: 2504.03304
  • Title: Hong-Ou-Mandel effect with two frequency-entangled photons of vastly different color
  • Authors: Felix Mann, Helen M. Chrzanowski, Marlon Placke, Felipe Gewers, Sven Ramelow
  • Classification: quant-ph (Quantum Physics)
  • Publication Date: October 16, 2025 (arXiv v3)
  • Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2504.03304v3

Abstract

This paper demonstrates the Hong-Ou-Mandel (HOM) interference phenomenon between two photons of completely different colors. The research team employs a quantum frequency converter based on sum/difference frequency generation as an "active" beam splitter, coupling frequency-entangled red light (637 nm) and telecommunication-band (1587 nm) single photons with an energy difference spanning eight octaves (282 THz). The experiment achieves uncorrected two-photon interference visibility exceeding 90%, representing the first realization of HOM interference between single photons of drastically different colors, thereby deepening our understanding of the nature of quantum interference.

Research Background and Motivation

Problem Definition

Traditional Hong-Ou-Mandel experiments require two photons to be indistinguishable in all degrees of freedom to observe quantum interference. However, this understanding oversimplifies the fundamental mechanisms of quantum interference.

Significance

  1. Theoretical Importance: Challenges the conventional notion that "photon indistinguishability is equivalent to interference capability"
  2. Technical Applications: Provides new methods for photonic qubit interfaces in heterogeneous quantum systems
  3. Network Construction: Unifies frequency conversion and quantum interference processes, simplifying quantum network architecture

Limitations of Existing Methods

  • Traditional HOM experiments are limited to photons of identical frequency
  • Passive beam splitters cannot handle photon pairs with enormous frequency differences
  • Existing color HOM experiments exhibit relatively small frequency differences (maximum 805 GHz)

Research Motivation

By achieving HOM interference across eight octaves of frequency difference, the work demonstrates that the essence of quantum interference is path indistinguishability rather than photon indistinguishability, and provides new technical pathways for quantum information processing.

Core Contributions

  1. First realization of HOM interference between single photons of drastically different colors, with frequency difference reaching 282 THz, 350 times larger than previous experiments
  2. Proposed and validated a novel scheme using quantum frequency converters as active beam splitters
  3. Achieved 91.4±0.3% raw visibility, far exceeding the classical limit of 50%
  4. Unified frequency conversion and quantum interference processes, providing new interface schemes for heterogeneous quantum systems
  5. Deepened understanding of the fundamental mechanisms of quantum interference, emphasizing the importance of path indistinguishability

Detailed Methodology

Task Definition

Realize Hong-Ou-Mandel interference between two single photons with 282 THz frequency difference (637 nm red light and 1587 nm telecommunication light), and measure the interference visibility.

Experimental Architecture

Photon Pair Source

  • Crystal: 31 mm long periodically poled potassium titanyl phosphate (ppKTP)
  • Pump: 455 nm continuous-wave external cavity diode laser
  • Process: Quasi-phase-matched type-0 spontaneous parametric down-conversion (SPDC)
  • Bandwidth: Δνs ≈ 75 GHz (FWHM)

Quantum Frequency Converter (Active Beam Splitter)

  • Crystal: 20 mm long ppKTP with 15.75 μm poling period
  • Pump: 3 W Nd:YAG 1064 nm laser
  • Cavity: Monolithic cavity structure with power enhancement factor ~50
  • Bandwidth: Δνc ≈ 110 GHz (FWHM)
  • Conversion Efficiency: 47.6±0.7%

Detection System

  • Red Light Detection: Avalanche photodiode (APD), efficiency 35%
  • Telecommunication Light Detection: Superconducting nanowire single-photon detector (SNSPD), efficiency 90%
  • Time Resolution: Adjustable delay range 500 ps, minimum step 2.5 fs

Technical Innovations

Active Beam Splitter Principle

The quantum frequency converter implements three-wave mixing:

Ĥ_I = iℏχ(â₁â₂† - h.c.)

Output operator relations:

â₁(t) = cos(χt)â₁(0) + i sin(χt)â₂(0)
â₂(t) = i sin(χt)â₁(0) + cos(χt)â₂(0)

Key Technical Features

  1. Frequency Matching: Photon pair energy difference exactly equals 1064 nm pump photon energy
  2. Phase Matching: Precise adjustment of pump wavelength and crystal temperature
  3. Noise Suppression: Utilizes high-quality polarization of bulk ppKTP to reduce pump-induced noise
  4. Passive Locking: Monolithic cavity structure achieves thermal stability without active feedback

Experimental Setup

Experimental Parameters

  • Red Light Wavelength: 637 nm (471 THz)
  • Telecommunication Light Wavelength: 1587 nm (189 THz)
  • Frequency Difference: 282 THz
  • Pump Power: Transmitted power 700±6 mW, circulating power 35±0.3 W
  • Temperature Stability: <1 mK

Evaluation Metrics

  • Visibility: Contrast of HOM dip V = (N_max - N_min)/N_max
  • Dip Width: Full width at half maximum (FWHM) from Gaussian fitting
  • Coincidence Count Rate: Count rate of two-photon coincidence events

Measurement Procedure

  1. Scan relative delay Δτ in the telecommunication light arm
  2. Record time tags from all four detectors
  3. Calculate coincidence counts for different color combinations
  4. Fit Gaussian function to obtain visibility and width

Experimental Results

Main Results

HOM Interference Measurement

  • Raw Visibility: 91.4±0.3%
  • Corrected Visibility: 92.8±0.3% (accounting for accidental coincidences)
  • Dip Width: 7.78±0.06 ps (FWHM)
  • Theoretical Maximum Visibility: 99.4±0.2% (limited by conversion efficiency)

Single-Color Anti-Dips

  • Telecommunication-Telecommunication: Width 8.99±0.11 ps, visibility 99.8±1.2%
  • Red-Red: Width 5.99±0.34 ps, visibility 81.1±4.0%

Performance Analysis

Visibility Limiting Factors

  1. Converter Bandwidth: Frequency-dependent beam splitting ratio causes path distinguishability
  2. Spectral Filtering: Strong filtering in the telecommunication arm suppresses sinc function sidelobes
  3. System Losses: Collection efficiency and transmission losses

Temporal Characteristics

Different widths reflect the impact of spectral filtering: stronger filtering in the telecommunication arm leads to broader temporal features.

Breakthrough Achievements

  • Frequency Difference: 282 THz, 350 times larger than the previous maximum record (805 GHz)
  • Time Resolution Requirements: Passive beam splitter requires 3.5 fs resolution, far exceeding current technology
  • Practical Significance: Frequency difference comparable to typical parameters in fiber-based quantum networks

Related Work

Development History of HOM Interference

  1. Classical HOM: Spatial mode interference of identical-frequency photons
  2. Theoretical Proposals: Raymer et al. proposed the active beam splitter concept
  3. Early Experiments:
    • 187 THz difference (DFG/SFG)
    • 805 GHz difference (four-wave mixing)
    • 100 GHz and 22 GHz differences (electro-optic modulation)

Uniqueness of This Work

  • Frequency Span: First realization of octave-spanning color HOM interference
  • Technical Pathway: Low-noise quantum frequency converter
  • Application-Oriented: Addresses practical needs of heterogeneous quantum systems

Theoretical Foundation

Nature of Quantum Interference

The conventional view attributes HOM interference to photon indistinguishability, but a more accurate understanding is:

  • Path Indistinguishability: Output state can be realized through multiple indistinguishable paths
  • Measurement Dependence: Interference depends on whether path information can be marked

Mathematical Description

Input state: |ψ_in⟩ = â₁†â₂†|0⟩

Output state: |ψ_out⟩ = (i/2)(â₁†² + â₂†²)|0⟩

The key is that the indistinguishability of paths 2 and 3 leads to destructive interference.

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

  1. Successfully realized HOM interference across eight octaves of frequency difference with visibility exceeding 90%
  2. Demonstrated that the essence of quantum interference is path indistinguishability rather than photon indistinguishability
  3. Showcased the effectiveness of quantum frequency converters as active beam splitters
  4. Provided a new scheme for heterogeneous quantum systems that unifies frequency conversion and quantum interference

Limitations

  1. Conversion Efficiency: Current 47.6% efficiency limits maximum achievable visibility
  2. Bandwidth Matching: Imperfect matching between converter bandwidth and photon bandwidth
  3. System Complexity: Requires precise frequency and phase matching
  4. Power Requirements: Demands high-power pump lasers

Future Directions

  1. Efficiency Enhancement: Optimize converter design to improve conversion efficiency
  2. Bandwidth Engineering: Improve bandwidth matching to reduce spectral distortion
  3. Integration: Develop on-chip integrated quantum frequency converters
  4. Network Applications: Validate the technology in practical quantum networks

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

  1. Scientific Breakthrough: First realization of HOM interference at such large frequency differences
  2. Theoretical Contribution: Deepened understanding of the nature of quantum interference
  3. Technical Innovation: Successful implementation of the active beam splitter concept
  4. Practical Value: Provides new technological pathways for quantum networks
  5. Experimental Design: Precise experimental setup and detailed characterization

Weaknesses

  1. Efficiency Limitations: Conversion efficiency has room for improvement
  2. Complexity: High system complexity requiring simplification for practical implementation
  3. Cost Considerations: High-power lasers increase system cost
  4. Scalability: Challenges in extending to multi-photon interference

Impact

  1. Academic Influence: Redefines understanding of quantum interference
  2. Technology Advancement: Promotes development of quantum frequency conversion technology
  3. Application Prospects: Provides new tools for quantum networks and quantum computing
  4. Interdisciplinary: Bridges quantum optics and quantum information processing

Applicable Scenarios

  1. Quantum Networks: Interface for heterogeneous quantum systems
  2. Quantum Computing: Frequency-domain processing of photonic qubits
  3. Quantum Sensing: Precision measurements utilizing frequency entanglement
  4. Fundamental Research: Investigation of quantum interference and entanglement mechanisms

References

This paper cites 42 important references covering the theoretical foundations, experimental development, and application prospects of the HOM effect, providing comprehensive literature support for the field.

Summary: This is a groundbreaking experimental work that not only achieves unprecedented octave-spanning HOM interference from a technical standpoint, but more importantly deepens our understanding of the fundamental nature of quantum interference, opening new pathways for future quantum technology development.