On novel Hamiltonian descriptions of some three-dimensional non-conservative systems

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2504.10729
• Title: On novel Hamiltonian descriptions of some three-dimensional non-conservative systems
• Authors: Aritra Ghosh (IIT Bhubaneswar), Anindya Ghose-Choudhury (Diamond Harbour Women's University), Partha Guha (Khalifa University)
• Classification: math-ph math.DS math.MP math.SG nlin.CD nlin.SI
• Publication Date: October 12, 2025 (arXiv v2)
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2504.10729

Abstract

This paper proposes novel Hamiltonian descriptions for several three-dimensional systems, including two celebrated systems describing the three-wave interaction problem and some well-known chaotic systems, namely the Chen system, Lü system, and Qi system. The authors demonstrate that all these systems can be described within a Hamiltonian framework where the Poisson matrix J is supplemented by an impedance matrix R. Although such impedance-Hamiltonian systems are manifestly non-conservative, the authors construct higher-order Poisson matrices N = JR + RJ through the Jordan product, thereby obtaining new bi-Hamiltonian systems. Finally, the authors discuss conformal Hamiltonian dynamics on Poisson manifolds and prove that, through appropriate parameter selection, simplified three-wave interaction models as well as Chen and Lü systems can be described in this manner, where the accompanying non-conservative dynamical component is described through Euler vector fields.

Research Background and Motivation

Problem Background

Hamiltonian dynamical framework is a powerful tool for describing the time evolution of dynamical systems, providing profound insights into the structure and symmetries of the physical world based on "energy principles." Traditional Hamiltonian dynamics is defined on even-dimensional phase spaces with natural symplectic structures. However, many important physical systems, particularly three-dimensional non-conservative systems, are difficult to describe directly within the conventional Hamiltonian framework.

Research Motivation

1. Theoretical Requirements: Three-dimensional dynamical systems play an important role in chaos theory and require suitable Hamiltonian descriptions to understand their geometric structures
2. Methodological Limitations: Existing methods primarily focus on bi-Hamiltonian and Nambu-metriplectic descriptions, lacking a unified framework for handling non-conservative systems
3. Practical Applications: Three-dimensional non-conservative systems in plasma physics, fluid mechanics, and other fields require new mathematical tools

Limitations of Existing Methods

• Traditional Poisson structures require system conservativity, unsuitable for dissipative systems
• Existing descriptions of non-conservative systems lack uniformity
• Absence of systematic methods for constructing conservative bi-Hamiltonian systems from non-conservative systems

Core Contributions

1. Introduction of Impedance-Hamiltonian Systems: Proposes a novel framework describing non-conservative three-dimensional systems by supplementing the Poisson matrix J with a symmetric impedance matrix R
2. Construction of Higher-Order Poisson Matrices: Constructs new Poisson matrices through the Jordan product N = JR + RJ, deriving new conservative bi-Hamiltonian systems from known non-conservative systems
3. Unified Description of Multiple Classical Systems: Demonstrates that simplified three-wave interaction models, Rabinovich systems, Chen systems, Lü systems, and Qi systems can all be described within the impedance-Hamiltonian framework
4. Conformal Hamiltonian Dynamics: Shows that through appropriate parameter selection, certain systems can be described using conformal Hamiltonian dynamics on Poisson manifolds

Detailed Methodology

Core Theoretical Framework

Definition of Impedance-Hamiltonian Systems

Consider a Poisson matrix J on a Poisson manifold (M,Λ), given a Hamiltonian function H and symmetric matrix R, the impedance-Hamiltonian system is defined as:

$\dot{x} = (J - R)(\nabla H)$

where x represents local coordinates and R describes the non-conservative portion of the dynamics.

Special Properties of Three-Dimensional Systems

In the three-dimensional case, the Poisson matrix is isomorphic to a three-dimensional vector:

$J = \begin{pmatrix} 0 & -J_z & J_y \\ J_z & 0 & -J_x \\ -J_y & J_x & 0 \end{pmatrix} \leftrightarrow \mathbf{J} = (J_x, J_y, J_z)$

The Jacobi identity simplifies to: $\mathbf{J} \cdot (\nabla \times \mathbf{J}) = 0$

Construction of Higher-Order Poisson Matrices

New Poisson matrices are constructed through the Jordan product: $N = JR + RJ$

This matrix is manifestly antisymmetric and can define new bi-Hamiltonian systems when satisfying the Jacobi identity.

Conformal Hamiltonian Dynamics

Conformal Hamiltonian vector fields are defined as: $X^a_H = \Lambda(dH, \cdot) + a\Gamma$

where Γ is the dilation/Euler operator and a is a real constant. This allows description of non-conservative systems with constant divergence.

Analysis of Specific Systems

Simplified Three-Wave Interaction Model

System equations: $\dot{x} = -2y^2 + \gamma x + z + \delta y$$\dot{y} = 2xy + \gamma y - \delta x$
$\dot{z} = -2xz - 2z$

Can be represented as an impedance-Hamiltonian system with:

• Hamiltonian function: $H = x^2 + y^2 + z$
• Poisson and impedance matrices as shown in equation (3.10)

Chen System

System equations: $\dot{x} = \alpha y - \alpha x$$\dot{y} = (\gamma - \alpha)x + \gamma y - xz$$\dot{z} = xy - \beta z$

Using Hamiltonian function $H = \frac{x^2}{2} - \alpha z$ and corresponding J and R matrices, the system can be completely described.

Lü System

Similarly, the Lü system can be described using the same Hamiltonian function but with different matrix structures.

Experimental Results and Verification

Jacobi Identity Verification

The authors verify through direct calculation that N = JR + RJ satisfies the Jacobi identity conditions in various systems:

1. Simplified Three-Wave Interaction Model: Satisfied for arbitrary real parameter values
2. Rabinovich System: Satisfied when k₂ = -k₃
3. Chen System: Satisfied when α = γ
4. Lü System: Satisfied for arbitrary real parameter values
5. Modified Lü System and Qi System: Do not satisfy the Jacobi identity

Bi-Hamiltonian System Construction

For systems satisfying the conditions, new conservative bi-Hamiltonian systems can be constructed. For example, from the simplified three-wave interaction model:

$\dot{x} = 2\gamma y^2 - \gamma\delta y + 2z^2 - \frac{\gamma z}{2}$$\dot{y} = -2\gamma xy + \gamma\delta x$$\dot{z} = -4xz^2 + \gamma xz$

This system conserves two Hamiltonian functions.

Related Work

Historical Development

• Gümral and Nutku (1993): Proved that every Hamiltonian system in three dimensions is bi-Hamiltonian
• Gao (2000): Established the relationship between necessary and sufficient conditions for Hamiltonian descriptions of three-dimensional systems and Jacobi's last multiplier
• Esen et al. (2016-2020): Studied bi-Hamiltonian properties of multiple three-dimensional chaotic systems

Innovations of This Work

Compared to existing work, this paper is the first to:

1. Systematically introduce the concept of impedance matrices
2. Establish a general method for constructing conservative systems from non-conservative systems
3. Provide alternative descriptions of conformal Hamiltonian dynamics

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Unified Framework: Impedance-Hamiltonian systems provide a unified mathematical description for multiple important three-dimensional non-conservative systems
2. Construction Method: The Jordan product N = JR + RJ provides a systematic method for constructing new conservative bi-Hamiltonian systems from non-conservative systems
3. Geometric Insights: Conformal Hamiltonian dynamics reveals the geometric structures of certain non-conservative systems

Limitations

1. Scope of Applicability: Not all systems' N = JR + RJ satisfy the Jacobi identity
2. Parameter Restrictions: Conformal Hamiltonian descriptions require specific parameter relationships
3. Physical Interpretation: The physical meaning of the impedance matrix is unclear in certain systems

Future Directions

1. Extended Applications: Extend the framework to port-Hamiltonian systems with external ports
2. Dynamical Analysis: Study the dynamical properties of newly constructed bi-Hamiltonian systems
3. Higher-Dimensional Generalizations: Explore applications of the framework to higher-dimensional systems

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Theoretical Innovation: Proposes a novel mathematical framework for handling non-conservative systems with significant theoretical value
2. Systematicity: Provides unified descriptions of multiple important three-dimensional systems, demonstrating the universality of the method
3. Mathematical Rigor: All calculations and proofs are carefully verified with rigorous mathematical derivations
4. Geometric Insights: Provides new perspectives on understanding the structure of non-conservative systems from a geometric viewpoint

Weaknesses

1. Lack of Physical Intuition: The choice of impedance matrix R sometimes appears artificial, lacking clear physical motivation
2. Application Limitations: Certain systems (such as modified Lü and Qi systems) cannot be fully incorporated into the framework
3. Unverified Practical Value: The practical application value of newly constructed bi-Hamiltonian systems requires further exploration

Impact

1. Theoretical Contribution: Opens new avenues for Hamiltonian descriptions of non-conservative systems, potentially influencing related mathematical physics research
2. Methodological Value: The provided construction methods can be applied to research on other dynamical systems
3. Interdisciplinary Potential: The framework may find applications in plasma physics, fluid mechanics, and other fields

Applicable Scenarios

This method is particularly suitable for:

1. Three-dimensional non-conservative systems requiring Hamiltonian descriptions
2. Geometric analysis of chaotic systems
3. Construction and study of bi-Hamiltonian structures
4. Applications of conformal geometry in dynamical systems

References

The paper cites abundant relevant literature, primarily including:

• Arnold's classical mechanics textbooks
• Pioneering work by Gümral and Nutku on three-dimensional bi-Hamiltonian systems
• Morrison's research on metriplectic systems
• van der Schaft's theory on port-Hamiltonian systems
• Original literature on various three-dimensional chaotic systems

Overall Assessment: This is a high-quality mathematical physics paper that makes important theoretical contributions to Hamiltonian descriptions of non-conservative systems. While further development is needed in practical applications, its theoretical framework possesses significant academic value and development potential.