Spin demons in d-wave altermagnets

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2504.11062
• Title: Spin demons in d-wave altermagnets
• Authors: Pieter M. Gunnink, Jairo Sinova, Alexander Mook (Johannes Gutenberg University Mainz)
• Classification: cond-mat.str-el (Condensed Matter Physics - Strongly Correlated Electron Systems)
• Publication Date: August 29, 2025 (arXiv preprint)
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2504.11062

Abstract

Demons are a type of plasmon consisting of out-of-phase oscillations of electrons from different energy bands. This paper demonstrates that d-wave altermagnets—a recently discovered class of collinear magnetic materials—naturally realize spin demon modes, which consist of out-of-phase motion of two spin species. Spin demon modes exist outside the particle-hole continuum of one spin species, rendering them significantly underdamped with quality factors exceeding 10. The study shows that spin demon modes carry magnetic moments and inherit the d-wave symmetry. The paper considers both three-dimensional and two-dimensional d-wave altermagnets, demonstrating the existence of spin demon modes in both cases.

Research Background and Motivation

Problem Background

1. Discovery of Altermagnets: Altermagnets are a recently discovered class of collinear magnets possessing sublattice transposition symmetry involving rotational or mirror operations, with spin-split Fermi surfaces exhibiting d-wave (or higher even-parity) ordering.
2. Theory of Demon Modes: Demon modes are acoustic, electrically neutral plasmons first proposed by Pines in 1956, consisting of out-of-phase oscillations of electrons from different energy bands, and were first experimentally observed by Husain et al. in 2023.
3. Potential of Spin-Split Fermi Surfaces: The existence of spin-split Fermi surfaces in altermagnets provides the possibility for out-of-phase oscillations of two spin densities, thereby realizing demon modes.

Research Motivation

• Explore how the unique electronic structure of altermagnets supports novel collective excitations
• Understand the physical properties and symmetry characteristics of spin demon modes
• Provide theoretical foundations for experimental detection and applications

Core Contributions

1. First Prediction of Spin Demon Modes: Discovery of spin-polarized demon modes in d-wave altermagnets composed of out-of-phase oscillations of two spin species
2. Establishment of Theoretical Framework: Development of a complete theoretical framework describing spin demon modes based on the random phase approximation (RPA)
3. Revelation of d-wave Symmetry: Demonstration that spin demon modes inherit the d-wave symmetry of altermagnets, with magnetic moments changing sign in different propagation directions
4. Dimensional Universality: Proof that spin demon modes exist in both three-dimensional and two-dimensional d-wave altermagnets
5. High Quality Factor: Calculations show that spin demon modes possess high quality factors (>10), forming long-lived quasiparticles

Detailed Methodology

Task Definition

Investigation of collective excitation modes in d-wave altermagnets, with particular focus on out-of-phase oscillations of spin density and their physical properties.

Theoretical Framework

1. Altermagnet Model

The low-energy dispersion relation of d-wave altermagnets is adopted: $\epsilon_{\sigma k} = \frac{\hbar^2 k^2}{2m_0} + \sigma \frac{\hbar^2(k_x^2 - k_y^2)}{2m^*}$

where σ denotes the spin index, $m_0 = 0.4m_e$, $m^* = 1.25m_0$, and Fermi energy $\epsilon_F = 0.5$ eV.

2. Random Phase Approximation (RPA)

The spin-resolved response function satisfies: $\begin{pmatrix} \chi_{\uparrow\uparrow} & \chi_{\uparrow\downarrow} \\ \chi_{\downarrow\uparrow} & \chi_{\downarrow\downarrow} \end{pmatrix}^{-1} = \begin{pmatrix} \chi_{\uparrow}^{(0)} & 0 \\ 0 & \chi_{\downarrow}^{(0)} \end{pmatrix}^{-1} - v_q \begin{pmatrix} 1 & 1 \\ 1 & 1 \end{pmatrix}$

3. Spin-Spin Response Function

The key spin-spin response function is: $\chi_{S^z S^z}(q,\omega) = \frac{\chi_{\uparrow}^{(0)} + \chi_{\downarrow}^{(0)} - 4v_q\chi_{\uparrow}^{(0)}\chi_{\downarrow}^{(0)}}{\epsilon(q,\omega)}$

where the dielectric function is: $\epsilon(q,\omega) = 1 - v_q(\chi_{\uparrow}^{(0)} + \chi_{\downarrow}^{(0)})$

Technical Innovations

1. Projected Spin-Splitting Parameter: Introduction of $\eta_\sigma(\theta)$ to describe the effective spin splitting at different angles: $\eta_\sigma(\theta) = \sqrt{\tilde{m}m_0}\left(1 + \sigma\frac{m_0}{m^*}\cos 2\theta\right)$
2. Analytical Solution: Analytical approximation of the spin demon mode frequency, yielding the dispersion relation $\omega_d(q) = v_d\eta_{min}(\theta)q$
3. Quality Factor Calculation: Computation of damping and quality factor via Laurent-Taylor expansion: $Q = \frac{\omega_d}{\gamma}, \quad \gamma = \frac{\text{Im}[\epsilon(q,\omega)]}{\partial_\omega \text{Re}[\epsilon(q,\omega)]}\bigg|_{\omega=\omega_d}$

Experimental Setup

Parameter Selection

• Effective masses: $m_0 = 0.4m_e$, $m^* = 1.25m_0$
• Fermi level: $\epsilon_F = 0.5$ eV
• Wave vector range: $q/k_F \lesssim 0.5$
• Angular range: Rotation within the spin-splitting plane of the altermagnet

Computational Methods

1. Numerical solution of dielectric function zeros to determine collective modes
2. Analytical approximation to verify numerical results
3. Comparative analysis of three-dimensional and two-dimensional cases

Experimental Results

Main Results

1. Existence of Spin Demon Modes

• Sharp resonance peaks observed in the spin-spin response function $\text{Im}[\chi_{S^z S^z}(q,\omega)]$
• Resonance frequencies follow fourfold rotational symmetry, vanishing along high-symmetry axes

2. Quality Factor Analysis

• Three-dimensional case: Quality factor $Q > 10$ for $\theta < 23°$
• Two-dimensional case: More stable with angular extent to $39.9°$
• Quality factor increases with enhanced band anisotropy of the altermagnet

3. Magnetic Moment Characteristics

• Spin demon modes carry finite magnetic moments: $\mu_d \approx 0.025\mu_B$ (at $q = 0.05k_F$)
• Magnetic moments change sign in different quadrants, reflecting d-wave symmetry
• External magnetic field causes frequency shift: approximately 0.1% relative shift (at 1T field)

Dimensional Comparison

Three-dimensional vs. Two-dimensional Features:

• Two-dimensional spin demon modes are more stable
• Two-dimensional case admits analytical solution: $v_d^{2D} = \frac{2}{\sqrt{3}}v_F\eta_{min}(\theta)q$
• Quality factor: $Q^{2D} = \frac{3\sqrt{4\eta_{min}^2(\theta) - 3\eta_{maj}^2(\theta)}}{\eta_{min}(\theta)}$

Symmetry Analysis

Spin demon modes perfectly inherit the symmetry of d-wave altermagnets:

• Most pronounced along $x$ and $y$ axes
• Vanishing along nodal directions
• Magnetic moment sign reflects fourfold symmetry with propagation direction

Related Work

Demon Mode Research

1. Theoretical Development: Pines (1956) initial proposal → Predictions in various materials → First experimental observation in 2023
2. Related Systems: Bilayer electron gases, Weyl semimetals, spin-polarized two-dimensional electron gases

Altermagnet Research

1. Fundamental Theory: Pioneering work by Šmejkal et al.
2. Transport Properties: Anomalous Hall effect, spin-splitting torques
3. Magnons: Chiral-split magnon bands

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Novel Collective Excitations: d-wave altermagnets naturally support spin demon modes
2. High-Quality Quasiparticles: Quality factors >10, forming long-lived excitations
3. Symmetry Inheritance: Perfect manifestation of d-wave altermagnet symmetry characteristics
4. Dimensional Universality: Existence in both three-dimensional and two-dimensional systems

Experimental Observability

• SPEELS: Spin-polarized electron energy loss spectroscopy can directly measure $\text{Im}[\chi_{S^z S^z}(q,\omega)]$
• Raman Scattering: Cross-polarized Raman scattering provides alternative detection means
• Energy Scale: Spin demon mode energies reach $\epsilon_F/2 \sim 250$ meV, within experimental resolution

Limitations

1. RPA Approximation: Beyond-RPA correction effects not considered
2. Idealized Model: Disorder and defects in actual samples not accounted for
3. Multi-domain Structure: Magnetic domains in real samples may affect observations

Future Directions

1. Material Realization: Search for suitable d-wave altermagnet materials
2. Experimental Verification: Design of concrete experimental schemes
3. Application Exploration: Potential applications of spin demon modes in spintronics
4. Theoretical Extension: Consideration of more complex interactions and disorder effects

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Theoretical Innovation: First prediction of spin demon modes in altermagnets with novel concepts
2. Rigorous Calculations: Based on mature RPA theory with consistent numerical and analytical results
3. Clear Physical Picture: Excellent explanation of spin demon mode physics and symmetry
4. Complete Dimensionality: Consideration of both three-dimensional and two-dimensional cases with universal conclusions

Weaknesses

1. Theoretical Level: Limited to RPA level, lacking consideration of higher-order corrections
2. Material Specificity: Lack of detailed analysis of specific altermagnet materials
3. Experimental Guidance: While experimental observability is discussed, specific experimental designs are lacking

Impact

1. Academic Value: Provides new theoretical perspective for altermagnet physics
2. Practical Prospects: Potential applications in quantum materials and spintronics
3. Methodological Contribution: Provides methodological reference for studying collective excitations in similar systems

Applicable Scenarios

• Theoretical research on d-wave altermagnet materials
• Design of spintronic devices
• Exploration of novel collective excitations in quantum materials
• Spectroscopic studies of magnetic materials

References

The paper cites 38 important references covering altermagnet theory, demon mode research, and many-body theory, providing a solid theoretical foundation for the research.