Optimizing the quantum interference between single photons and local oscillator with photon correlations

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2504.12111
• Title: Optimizing the quantum interference between single photons and local oscillator with photon correlations
• Authors: Hubert Lam, Juan R. Álvarez, Petr Steindl, Ilse Maillette de Buy Wenniger, Stephen Wein, Anton Pishchagin, Thi Huong Au, Sebastien Boissier, Aristide Lemaître, Wolfgang Löffler, Nadia Belabas, Dario A. Fioretto, Pascale Senellart
• Classification: quant-ph (Quantum Physics)
• Publication Date: April 16, 2025
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2504.12111

Abstract

Quantum interference between single photons and coherent states represents a crucial tool for characterizing and engineering non-Gaussian quantum states in continuous-variable optical quantum technologies. Semiconductor quantum dots, as a key platform for efficient single-photon generation, hold significant potential in this context. The critical parameter governing quantum interference between single photons and classical light fields is the average wavepacket overlap between the two optical fields. This paper reports two homodyne photon correlation techniques capable of precisely measuring the overlap between single photons generated by quantum dot cavity devices and pulsed laser light. Characteristic signals of quantum interference appear in the photon correlations at the outputs of the interference beamsplitter for optical fields with different statistical properties. By comparing the behavior of maximum overlap, we measure either the Hong-Ou-Mandel visibility between two outputs or photon bunching in a single output. Through careful tuning of the laser across various degrees of freedom, we maximize the overlap to 76%, with the primary limiting factors being spectral and temporal profile mismatches as well as low-frequency charge noise in the single-photon source.

Research Background and Motivation

Problem Background

1. Continuous-variable quantum computing requirements: Within the continuous-variable quantum information processing framework, non-Gaussian operations are necessary to achieve universal quantum computation. The intrinsic non-Gaussian nature of single photons makes them ideal tools for implementing such operations.
2. Importance of single-photon-coherent state interference: The interference of single photons with coherent states at a beamsplitter is a powerful tool that, combined with appropriate heralding schemes, can generate various non-Gaussian states, including displaced Fock states and photon number superposition states.
3. Limitations of existing techniques: Most current single-photon-coherent state interference experiments rely on frequency-converted heralded single-photon sources, which are based on probabilistic generation processes with inherent efficiency limitations.
4. Advantages of quantum dot technology: Semiconductor quantum dots, as an emerging technology for deterministic single-photon generation, offer the advantages of on-demand deterministic production and integrated device architecture.

Research Motivation

This research aims to introduce quantum dot single-photon sources into the continuous-variable framework, quantify the interference between laser pulses and single photons generated by quantum dot cavities, and develop methods for precisely measuring and optimizing their mode overlap.

Core Contributions

1. Proposed two complementary homodyne photon correlation techniques for assessing and optimizing the mode overlap M between quantum dot single photons and laser pulses
2. Extended Hong-Ou-Mandel interference theory to apply to interference of optical fields with different photon number statistics
3. Achieved 76% high mode overlap, the highest overlap value reported to date for on-demand semiconductor quantum dot single-photon sources with pulsed laser light
4. Developed real-time optimization methods enabling real-time feedback optimization of mode overlap through monitoring autocorrelation signals
5. Provided a complete theoretical model accurately describing photon correlation behavior in interference of optical fields with different statistical properties

Methodology Details

Task Definition

The objective of this research is to precisely measure and optimize the average wavepacket overlap M between single photons generated by quantum dot cavity devices and pulsed laser light. The input consists of photon streams from two optical fields, and the output is a quantitative measurement of the overlap.

Experimental Architecture

1. Single-Photon Source System

• Quantum dot structure: InGaAs quantum dots grown by molecular beam epitaxy, embedded at the center of a λ GaAs optical cavity positioned between two AlGaAs/GaAs distributed Bragg reflectors
• Cavity structure: Micropillar cavity with 18 pairs of top and 36 pairs of bottom reflective mirrors
• Tuning mechanism: Quantum dot embedded in a p-i-n junction, with optical transitions tuned to cavity resonance at approximately 925 nm via the quantum-confined Stark effect
• Excitation method: Coherent resonant excitation using a mode-locked Ti:sapphire laser with pulse duration ~10 ps and repetition rate of 82 MHz

2. Interference Measurement System

• Beamsplitter configuration: Single-mode fiber beamsplitter with near-balanced splitting ratio ensuring near-ideal spatial overlap
• Spectral shaping: Spectral shaping of the coherent state through a pair of Fabry-Pérot etalons (FWHM = 14.5 pm)
• Polarization control: Independent polarizers and zero-order waveplate sets for each optical field
• Timing adjustment: Fine tuning of laser and single-photon arrival times using a free-space delay line

Measurement Methods

1. Hong-Ou-Mandel Visibility Analysis

Measuring cross-correlations between the two beamsplitter outputs using the formula:

$M = V_{HOM}\left(1 + \frac{\mu_\alpha}{2\mu_\psi}g^{(2)}_\alpha(0) + \frac{\mu_\psi}{2\mu_\alpha}g^{(2)}_\psi(0)\right)$

where $V_{HOM}$ is the Hong-Ou-Mandel visibility, and $\mu_\alpha$ and $\mu_\psi$ are the average photon numbers of the coherent state and single-photon stream, respectively.

2. Bunching Analysis

Analyzing photon bunching characteristics at individual beamsplitter outputs:

$g^{(2)}_{auto}(0) = \frac{\mu^2_\alpha + \mu^2_\psi g^{(2)}_\psi(0) + 2\mu_\alpha\mu_\psi(1+M)}{(\mu_\alpha + \mu_\psi)^2}$

Technical Innovations

1. Extended HOM theory: Extending traditional Hong-Ou-Mandel interference theory to interference of optical fields with different photon number statistics
2. Dual verification method: Cross-correlation and autocorrelation methods mutually verify results, enhancing measurement reliability
3. Real-time optimization algorithm: Utilizing monotonic dependence of autocorrelation signals for real-time feedback optimization
4. Multi-degree-of-freedom control: Precise control and measurement of overlap across temporal, spectral, polarization, and other degrees of freedom

Experimental Setup

Device Parameters

• Quantum dot emission wavelength: ~925 nm
• Purcell-enhanced radiative lifetime: τ_LT = (170±5) ps
• Operating temperature: 5 K (closed-cycle cryostat)
• Normalized second-order intensity correlation: g^(2)_ψ(0) = 4.12 ± 0.05%
• Indistinguishability of consecutive emitted photons: M_ψ = (90.5 ± 0.1)%

Detection System

• Detectors: Superconducting nanowire single-photon detectors (SNSPDs)
• Correlation measurement: Simultaneous measurement of cross-correlations and autocorrelations
• System efficiency: Total efficiency of single-photon source and entire system η ≈ 3%

Calibration Methods

• Power calibration: Controlling local oscillator power using calibrated variable attenuators
• Polarization calibration: Monitoring interference visibility through narrowband continuous-wave laser calibration
• Polarization-dependent efficiency compensation: Accounting for polarization-dependent detection efficiency of SNSPDs

Experimental Results

Main Results

1. Maximum Overlap Achievement

• Measured overlap: M = 0.76 ± 0.01 (parallel polarization configuration)
• After post-processing correction: M = 0.81 ± 0.01
• Comparison with continuous wave: Approaching but slightly lower than the previously reported maximum of 83%

2. Overlap Stability

Overlap remains stable across nearly four orders of magnitude variation in μ_α, validating the precision of the calibration method.

3. Multi-Polarization Control

Continuous control of overlap M from maximum value of 0.76 to zero achieved through adjusting relative polarization of interfering optical fields.

Ablation Studies

1. Degree-of-Freedom Overlap Analysis

• Temporal overlap: M_t = 0.910 ± 0.005
• Spectral overlap: M_f = 0.85 ± 0.02 (original); M_f = 0.91 ± 0.02 (post-processing corrected)
• Polarization overlap: M_p = 0.976 ± 0.003 (parallel configuration)

2. Limiting Factor Identification

Primary limitations arise from:

• Spectral and temporal profile mismatches
• Low-frequency charge noise in the single-photon source
• Non-resonant light leakage from the Fabry-Pérot etalon

Real-Time Optimization Verification

Under optimal bunching conditions at μ_α/μ_ψ ≈ 2, an integration time of 1 second is sufficient for real-time feedback, reliably achieving maximum g^(2)_ = 1.243 ± 0.002.

Related Work

Traditional Single-Photon Sources

Previous experiments primarily employed frequency-converted heralded single-photon sources, which suffer from probabilistic generation and efficiency limitations.

Development of Quantum Dot Single-Photon Sources

• Recent years have witnessed major advances in quantum dot technology for deterministic single-photon generation
• This work represents the first systematic application of quantum dot sources within the continuous-variable framework

Theoretical Foundation

Built upon the foundations of Hong-Ou-Mandel interference, displaced Fock state theory, and continuous-variable quantum optics.

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Successfully validated two complementary homodyne photon correlation techniques capable of precisely measuring mode overlap between quantum dot single photons and laser light
2. Achieved 76% high overlap, approaching theoretical limits and establishing a foundation for quantum dot applications in continuous-variable quantum technologies
3. Developed real-time optimization methods providing convenient tuning means for practical applications
4. Theoretical model perfectly matches experimental results, validating understanding of interference of optical fields with different statistics

Limitations

1. Overlap has not yet reached 100%, primarily limited by spectral-temporal profile mismatches and charge noise
2. Low overall system efficiency (~3%), affecting practical application feasibility
3. Requires cryogenic operating environment (5 K), increasing system complexity
4. Non-resonant light leakage from spectral shaping requires further optimization

Future Directions

1. Improve spectral shaping techniques to reduce non-resonant light leakage
2. Optimize quantum dot device design to reduce charge noise effects
3. Enhance system integration and efficiency
4. Extend to applications in more quantum information protocols

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Strong methodological innovation: Extended HOM theory to different statistical optical fields, providing a new theoretical framework
2. Rigorous experimental design: Dual verification methods ensure result reliability, with precise multi-parameter control
3. High technical practicality: Real-time optimization functionality provides convenience for practical applications
4. Milestone-level results: Achieved new overlap records in the quantum dot single-photon source field

Weaknesses

1. Theoretical analysis could be deeper: Physical mechanism analysis of limiting factors lacks sufficient depth
2. Limited demonstration of application scenarios: Lacks demonstration of applications in specific quantum information protocols
3. Insufficient comparison with other technical approaches: Lacks systematic comparison with other types of single-photon sources

Impact

1. Academic value: Provides important contributions to the interdisciplinary field of continuous-variable quantum optics and quantum dot physics
2. Application prospects: Establishes technical foundation for quantum dot-based quantum computing and quantum communication
3. Technology promotion: Developed measurement and optimization methods have universal applicability

Applicable Scenarios

1. Continuous-variable quantum computing: Generation and manipulation of non-Gaussian states
2. Quantum state engineering: Preparation of displaced Fock states and photon number superposition states
3. Quantum metrology: Generation of high-NOON states and super-resolution phase measurement
4. Quantum networks: Calibration of remote quantum nodes and quantum teleportation

References

The paper cites 46 important references spanning multiple fields including quantum optics, quantum dot physics, and continuous-variable quantum information, providing a solid theoretical foundation for the research.

Overall Assessment: This is a high-quality experimental physics paper making important contributions at the intersection of quantum dot single-photon sources and continuous-variable quantum optics. The experimental design is excellent, theoretical analysis is comprehensive, and the results possess significant academic and practical value.