Precise Measurement of Short-Range Correlations in Nuclei from Bremsstrahlung Gamma Ray Emission in Low-Energy Heavy-Ion Collisions

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2504.13929
• Title: Precise Measurement of Short-Range Correlations in Nuclei from Bremsstrahlung Gamma Ray Emission in Low-Energy Heavy-Ion Collisions
• Authors: Junhuai Xu, Qinglin Niu, Yuhao Qin, Dawei Si, et al. (Collaborative work from Tsinghua University, Nanjing University, Chinese Academy of Sciences, and other institutions)
• Classification: nucl-ex (Nuclear Experiment), nucl-th (Nuclear Theory)
• Publication Date: September 25, 2025 (arXiv v3: July 2, 2025)
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2504.13929

Abstract

This paper reports the first high-precision experimental measurement of neutron-proton bremsstrahlung gamma-ray emission in the symmetric ¹²⁴Sn+¹²⁴Sn reaction (25 MeV/u). Through observation of spectral hardening phenomena, the proportion of short-range correlations (SRCs) in ¹²⁴Sn nuclei is precisely extracted as (20±3)%. This result provides novel, direct, and unambiguous evidence for nucleon short-range correlations, demonstrating that low-energy heavy-ion collisions provide a new pathway for studying nuclear structure related to quark-level dynamics.

Research Background and Motivation

Core Problem

Dense nuclear matter in nuclei and neutron stars exhibits short-range correlations (SRCs), wherein nucleons form spacetime-correlated pairs beyond the mean-field approximation. Precise measurement of the SRC proportion is crucial for revealing potential quark-level dynamical features in the nuclear medium.

Significance

1. Nuclear Structure Understanding: SRCs are responsible for the high-momentum tail (HMT) in the nucleon momentum distribution. These high-momentum components significantly affect nuclear matter properties, particularly the density dependence of nuclear symmetry energy.
2. Quark-Nucleon Connection: SRCs are predominantly composed of neutron-proton pairs in the isoscalar (T=0) channel, tending toward ud diquark configurations. This directly correlates with the EMC effect, establishing a direct link between short-range nucleon correlations and quark-level modifications of nuclear structure.
3. Neutron Star Physics: SRCs are essential for understanding nuclear matter behavior under extreme density conditions such as in neutron stars.

Limitations of Existing Methods

1. Electron-Nucleus Scattering Experiments: Current understanding of SRCs primarily derives from electron-nucleus scattering and proton-nucleus knockout experiments.
2. Insufficient Heavy-Ion Collision Exploration: Although heavy-ion collisions (HICs) can create bulk dense nuclear matter in the laboratory, research utilizing HICs to search for SRC signatures remains relatively scarce.
3. Limited Precision in Previous Experiments: The authors' earlier measurement of bremsstrahlung gamma-ray spectra in ⁸⁶Kr+¹²⁴Sn collisions had limited statistical precision and energy range.

Innovations in This Work

Use of a symmetric reaction system (¹²⁴Sn+¹²⁴Sn) for high-statistics, extended-energy measurements, enabling unambiguous extraction of the R_HMT value in ¹²⁴Sn nuclei while avoiding ambiguities from asymmetric systems.

Core Contributions

1. First High-Precision Measurement: Achieved the highest-mass measurement of bremsstrahlung gamma rays (up to 100 MeV) in the symmetric ¹²⁴Sn+¹²⁴Sn reaction.
2. Precise SRC Proportion Extraction: Through spectral hardening analysis, precisely determined the high-momentum tail proportion R_HMT = (20±3)% in ¹²⁴Sn.
3. Resolution of Historical Problem: Resolved the long-standing question regarding the origin of high-energy gamma rays in low-energy heavy-ion collisions since the 1980s.
4. Establishment of New Detection Method: Established bremsstrahlung emission as a novel and sensitive probe for nucleon SRCs.
5. Theory-Experiment Integration: Through comparison of IBUU-MDI transport model with experimental data, provided direct quantitative evidence for SRC existence.
6. Connection of Nuclear and Quark Physics: Results are consistent with global analysis based on QCD factorization schemes (C¹²⁴_n=16%, C¹²⁴_p=24%).

Methodology Details

Experimental Design

Experimental Apparatus

The experiment was conducted at the Radioactive Ion Beam Line 1 (RIBBL1) of the Heavy Ion Research Facility in Lanzhou (HIRFL), using the CSHINE (Compact Spectrometer for Heavy Ion Experiment) spectrometer:

1. Charged Particle Detection: 6 silicon strip detector telescopes (SSDTs), covering 20°<θ_lab<60°
2. Neutron Detection: 4×5 plastic scintillator array (2.0 m from target) and liquid scintillator detector (5.13 m from target)
3. Gamma-Ray Detection:
   • 4×4 CsI(Tl) crystal array (70×70×250 mm³ per unit)
   • Three plastic scintillator rings for cosmic ray veto
   • Dual-range amplifiers recording signals with optimized energy range up to 100 MeV
   • Four fast BaF₂ gamma detectors providing start time (T0)
4. Trigger System: FPGA-based implementation of six trigger conditions (Trg1-Trg6), including various combinations of CsI(Tl)-SSDT and neutron array-SSDT coincidences.

Data Processing and Analysis

Gamma-Ray Event Reconstruction

1. Cluster Identification Algorithm: Identifies clustered CsI(Tl) hits within a |ΔT|<50 ns time window.
2. Event Topology Feature Discrimination:
   • Gamma events: Small spatial extension (δy small), energy concentrated in core (E_core≈E_tot)
   • Cosmic ray muons: Large spatial extension (δy large), E_tot>E_core
3. Background Subtraction:
   • Background measured with beam off (primarily cosmic ray muons and low-energy residual gamma radiation)
   • Background spectrum normalized using counts above 110 MeV
   • Pure gamma-ray spectrum obtained after background subtraction

Detector Response Correction

1. Geant4 Simulation: Generates detector response matrix describing detection efficiency for gamma rays of different energies.
2. Nonlinearity Correction: Detector response correction functions (DRCFs) obtained through high-energy gamma beam tests, quantifying deviations from linear calibration.
3. Systematic Error: Uncertainty from linear calibration assumption is within 4%.

Theoretical Model: IBUU-MDI

Model Foundation

Employs the isospin-dependent Boltzmann-Uehling-Uhlenbeck (IBUU) transport model combined with momentum-dependent interaction (MDI):

1. Nucleon Momentum Distribution Initialization: Incorporates SRC and HMT effects.
2. Asymmetric Nuclear Matter Parameterization:

$\rho_N(k) = \begin{cases} B_N, & k \leq k_F^N \\ \eta(1 + s\delta)/k^4, & k_F^N < k \leq \lambda k_F^N \\ 0, & k > \lambda k_F^N \end{cases}$

where s=+1 (protons) or -1 (neutrons), δ is the isospin asymmetry parameter, and λ is the high-momentum cutoff parameter.

3. Normalization Conditions:
   • Total probability normalization: $4\pi\int_0^\infty \rho_N(k)k^2dk = 1$
   • HMT proportion definition: $4\pi\int_{k_F}^\infty \rho_N(k)k^2dk = R_{HMT}$

Bremsstrahlung Production Mechanism

1. np Collision Process: Based on Bertsch criterion and Pauli exclusion principle.
2. Perturbative Method: Due to low bremsstrahlung yield, perturbative method employed to calculate photon production probability per np collision.
3. One-Boson-Exchange (OBE) Model:

$\frac{d^2P}{d\Omega dE_\gamma} = 1.67 \times 10^{-7} \times \frac{[1-(E_\gamma/E_{max})^2]^\alpha}{E_\gamma/E_{max}}$

where α = 0.7319 - 0.5898β_i, and E_max is the total available energy in the center-of-mass frame.

Maximum Likelihood Analysis

Likelihood function defined as: $\ln L'(R_{HMT}) = \sum_i n_i \ln p_i(R_{HMT})$

where n_i is the count in the i-th energy bin from experiment, and p_i is the theoretical probability of falling into that bin. Analysis restricted to 35 < E^cm_γ < 100 MeV range (excluding low-energy collective resonances and statistical emission).

Experimental Setup

Reaction System

• Projectile/Target Nucleus: ¹²⁴Sn (symmetric system)
• Beam Energy: 25 MeV/u
• Advantage: Symmetric reaction eliminates ambiguities from different HMT in projectile and target nuclei in asymmetric systems.

Data Quality

1. Significantly Enhanced Statistics: Substantial improvement compared to earlier ⁸⁶Kr+¹²⁴Sn experiments.
2. Extended Energy Range: Gamma-ray energy extended to 100 MeV.
3. Background Control: Effective signal-background discrimination through beam on/off comparison.

Systematic Error Sources

1. Detector Calibration: Linear response assumption (4%)
2. Background Subtraction: Variations from different subtraction schemes
3. Fitting Process: Statistical fluctuations in maximum likelihood fitting

Experimental Results

Main Results

Gamma-Ray Energy Spectrum

• Laboratory Frame Spectrum: Successfully measured bremsstrahlung gamma rays in the 35-100 MeV range.
• Center-of-Mass Transformation: Converted to center-of-mass frame via Lorentz transformation for theoretical comparison.
• Spectral Features: Observed pronounced spectral hardening, with high-energy end exceeding theoretical predictions without HMT.

SRC Proportion Extraction

Through maximum likelihood analysis (Figure 4):

• Optimal Value: R_HMT = (20.1±2.1)% (statistical error)
• Final Result: R_HMT = (20±3)% (including systematic errors)
• Fitting Range: Quadratic fit over 5-35% R_HMT
• Stability Check: Varying E^cm_γ lower limit (33-44 MeV) does not change optimal value.

Theory-Experiment Comparison

Figure 4(a) displays comparison of theoretical predictions (filtered through detector response) for different R_HMT values with experimental data:

• R_HMT=0% theoretical curve significantly softer, unable to explain high-energy gamma rays
• R_HMT=20% theoretical curve provides best agreement with experimental data
• Theoretical spectra uniformly scaled by 2.5×10⁹ to match data range (shape analysis)

Physical Significance

Connection to nPDF

According to collinear factorization scheme, nuclear nucleon PDF can be expressed as linear combination of free nucleon PDF and SRC pair PDF:

• For ¹²⁴Sn (A=124, δ=0.194):
  • Neutron proportion in SRC pairs: C¹²⁴_n = 16%
  • Proton proportion in SRC pairs: C¹²⁴_p = 24%
• Consistency with High-Energy Data: These values agree with global analysis results based on high-energy data.

Resolution of Historical Problem

Resolved the long-standing question regarding the origin of high-energy gamma rays in low-energy heavy-ion collisions observed by Njock et al. in the 1980s, confirming their source as HMT effects induced by SRCs.

Experimental Verification

• Look-Elsewhere Effect Check: Varying analysis energy lower limit does not affect results.
• Background Subtraction Scheme Test: Different schemes yield consistent results.
• Detector Response Variation: Standard deviation from different calibration and response datasets used as error.

Related Work

Evolution of SRC Research Methods

Traditional Methods

1. Electron-Nucleus Scattering:
   • Jefferson Lab Hall A experiment (Shneor et al., 2007): Study of proton-proton SRC via ¹²C(e,e'pp) reaction
   • Momentum sharing experiments (Hen et al., 2014): Study in unbalanced Fermi systems
   • CLAS detector (Duer et al., 2018): Detection of high-momentum protons and neutrons in neutron-rich nuclei
2. Proton-Nucleus Knockout:
   • Tang et al. (2003): Measurement of np short-range correlations via (p,2p+n)
   • Piasetzky et al. (2006): Demonstration of strong dominance of proton-neutron correlations
   • Inverse kinematics experiments (Patsyuk et al., 2021): 48 GeV/c carbon beam nucleon knockout

Heavy-Ion Collision Method

1. Theoretical Predictions:
   • Xue et al. (2016): First proposal that np bremsstrahlung can probe HMT
   • Guo et al. (2021): Calculation of high-momentum nucleon pair effects on hard photons
2. Experimental Attempts:
   • Authors' earlier work (Qin et al., 2024): First observation of non-zero HMT in ⁸⁶Kr+¹²⁴Sn collisions
   • Present work: Significant improvement in precision and clarity

Connection to EMC Effect

• Weinstein et al. (2011): Establishment of link between SRC and EMC effect
• Schmookler et al. (2019): Correction structure of protons and neutrons in correlated pairs
• Denniston et al. (2024): QCD factorization scheme extraction of parton distributions in SRC pairs

Other Detection Methods

• Wang et al. (2017): Nucleon emission in intermediate-energy nuclear collisions
• Hagel (2025): Possible SRC signatures in intermediate-energy heavy-ion collisions
• Reichert and Aichelin (2025): Subthreshold particle production in proton-nucleus collisions

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. First High-Precision Measurement: Achieved highest-mass measurement of bremsstrahlung gamma rays in symmetric heavy-ion collision systems.
2. SRC Proportion Determination: R_HMT = (20±3)% in ¹²⁴Sn, corresponding to C¹²⁴_n=16%, C¹²⁴_p=24%.
3. New Detection Pathway: Established low-energy heavy-ion collisions as a new method for studying nucleon SRCs and their connection to parton dynamics.
4. Theoretical Verification: IBUU-MDI transport model successfully describes experimental observations.

Limitations

1. Energy Range:
   • Low-energy end (<30 MeV) affected by collective resonances and statistical emission
   • High-energy end limited by detector energy range (maximum 100 MeV)
2. Absolute Yield Normalization:
   • Cannot determine total number of np collisions due to active trigger mode
   • Only shape analysis possible rather than absolute yield comparison
3. Systematic Effects:
   • Dependence on nuclear mean field, collision parameter, and symmetry energy requires further investigation
   • While tests show small dependence, effects may be significant under extreme conditions
4. Model Dependence:
   • Results depend on accuracy of IBUU-MDI model
   • OBE model description of bremsstrahlung cross section may have room for improvement

Future Directions

1. Systematic Studies:
   • Systematic measurements of different nuclear masses
   • Energy dependence studies at different beam energies
   • Comparative studies of asymmetric systems
2. Higher-Energy Gamma Rays:
   • Extension of detector energy range to higher energies
   • Investigation of spectral behavior at higher energy end
3. Multi-Messenger Approach:
   • Combined multi-messenger studies incorporating hadronic probes (nucleons, pions, etc.)
   • Systematic comparison with electron scattering results
4. Theoretical Improvements:
   • More accurate transport models
   • Inclusion of additional physical processes (Δ resonances, meson production, etc.)
   • Better treatment of quantum effects
5. Exploration of Extreme Conditions:
   • Simulation of neutron star matter
   • Investigation of SRC behavior in high-density nuclear matter

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Methodological Innovation

• Unique Probe: First use of bremsstrahlung gamma rays as direct SRC probe; gamma rays unaffected by strong interactions provide "clean" signals.
• Symmetric System Advantage: Use of symmetric reactions eliminates ambiguities, representing important methodological improvement.
• Multi-Signal Verification: Effective discrimination of gamma events from cosmic ray background through event topology features.

2. Rigorous Experimental Design

• Detector Optimization: CsI(Tl) array combined with plastic scintillator veto system effectively controls background.
• Dual-Range Technology: Extends dynamic range to 100 MeV.
• Multiple Triggers: Six trigger conditions ensure data completeness.
• Background Measurement: Beam on/off comparison provides reliable background subtraction.

3. Comprehensive Data Analysis

• Topology Analysis: Effective signal-background discrimination through δy and E_core/E_tot.
• Detector Response: Geant4 simulation combined with experimental testing accurately corrects nonlinear effects.
• Statistical Method: Maximum likelihood analysis provides quantitative constraints.
• Systematic Error Assessment: Considers multiple sources including calibration, background subtraction, and fitting.

4. Tight Theory-Experiment Integration

• Transport Model: IBUU-MDI model incorporates SRC physics with predictions consistent with experiment.
• Reasonable Parameterization: k⁻⁴ momentum distribution tail conforms to theoretical expectations.
• Multi-Scale Connection: Links nuclear structure (SRC) to quark physics (nPDF).

5. Significant Result Implications

• Precision Achievement: 3% relative uncertainty represents high-precision standard.
• Clear Physical Picture: Spectral hardening directly reflects HMT existence.
• Cross-Scale Verification: Consistency with high-energy electron scattering results establishes low-energy to high-energy connection.

Limitations

1. Model Dependence

• Single Model: Only IBUU-MDI model employed; lacks cross-verification with other transport models.
• OBE Approximation: Bremsstrahlung cross section uses empirical formula; may require more precise QCD calculations.
• Parameterization Form: k⁻⁴ tail is simplified assumption; true momentum distribution may be more complex.

2. Energy Range Limitations

• Low-Energy Cutoff: Data below 35 MeV unused, losing partial information.
• High-Energy Statistics: Limited statistics near 100 MeV constrains high-energy end constraint capability.
• Intermediate Energy Gap: Energy gap exists between present work (MeV scale) and high-energy electron scattering (GeV scale).

3. Insufficient Systematic Effect Study

• Impact Parameter Dependence: While claiming b-independence, detailed b-binned analysis not presented.
• Isospin Effect: Limited analysis of isospin dependence in δ=0.194 system.
• Temperature-Density Effects: Insufficient discussion of temperature and density evolution effects during collision.

4. Absolute Yield Absence

• Normalization Problem: Cannot provide absolute bremsstrahlung yield.
• Trigger Efficiency: Trigger efficiency correction in active trigger mode not fully detailed.
• Comparison Limitation: Only shape comparison possible, limiting comprehensive theory testing.

5. Experimental Details

• Detector Coverage: Partial solid angle coverage may introduce angle-dependent systematic errors.
• Calibration Uncertainty: Large energy gap between radioactive source calibration (<3 MeV) and measurement energy (>30 MeV).
• Time Resolution: 50 ns time window may include non-correlated events.

Impact

Contribution to Field

1. Methodological Breakthrough: Opens new paradigm for studying SRCs using low-energy heavy-ion collisions.
2. Historical Problem Resolution: Explains 40-year-old high-energy gamma-ray origin discovery.
3. Interdisciplinary Bridge: Connects nuclear physics, particle physics, and astrophysics.

Practical Value

1. Neutron Star Research: Provides ground-based experimental data for understanding SRCs in neutron star interiors.
2. Nuclear Structure Research: Provides precise nucleon correlation information.
3. Detector Technology: CsI(Tl) dual-range technology applicable to other experiments.

Reproducibility

1. Clear Experimental Conditions: Beam energy, target material, detector configuration detailed.
2. Open Analysis Method: Data processing flow and fitting method clearly presented.
3. Available Theoretical Model: IBUU-MDI model publicly available for independent verification.
4. Potential Challenges: Requires large accelerator facilities and complex detector arrays.

Applicable Scenarios

Ideal Applications

1. Symmetric Nuclear Systems: Avoids complexity from isospin asymmetry.
2. Medium-Mass Nuclei: A~100-200 range balances statistics and systematic effects.
3. Fermi Energy Region: 10-100 MeV/u provides appropriate bremsstrahlung yield.
4. High-Precision Requirements: Studies requiring precise SRC proportion measurement.

Extension Directions

1. Light Nuclear Systems: Investigate mass dependence.
2. Neutron-Rich Nuclei: Explore isospin-dependent SRC.
3. Higher Energies: Extension to intermediate-energy heavy-ion collisions.
4. Combined Probes: Joint analysis with pions, nucleon emission, etc.

Limiting Scenarios

1. Very Light Nuclei: Insufficient statistics, complex collective effects.
2. Extremely Asymmetric Systems: Requires more complex theoretical treatment.
3. Very Low Energies: Coulomb barrier effects dominate.
4. Very High Energies: Parton-level processes dominate.

Technical Highlights Summary

1. Detection Technology: CsI(Tl) dual-range system achieves 0-100 MeV wide dynamic range.
2. Background Control: Multi-layer veto system and topology analysis effectively suppress cosmic rays.
3. Data Analysis: Maximum likelihood method quantitatively extracts physical parameters.
4. Theoretical Modeling: Transport model successfully incorporates SRC physics and predicts observables.
5. System Verification: Multiple cross-checks ensure result reliability.

Key References

1. Hen et al. (2014) - Science 346, 614: Momentum sharing in unbalanced Fermi systems
2. Hen et al. (2017) - Rev. Mod. Phys. 89, 045002: SRC comprehensive review
3. Duer et al. (2018) - Nature 560, 617: High-momentum nucleons in neutron-rich nuclei
4. Xue et al. (2016) - Phys. Lett. B 755, 486: Theoretical prediction of np bremsstrahlung for HMT detection
5. Denniston et al. (2024) - Phys. Rev. Lett. 133, 152502: QCD factorization scheme nPDF extraction
6. Qin et al. (2024) - Phys. Lett. B 850, 138514: Earlier experimental results

Overall Assessment: This is a high-quality experimental nuclear physics paper that, through innovative experimental methodology and rigorous data analysis, achieves the first precise measurement of short-range correlation proportion in low-energy heavy-ion collisions. The research not only resolves long-standing physical questions but also opens new research directions, with significant implications for understanding connections between nuclear structure and quark physics. Despite limitations in model dependence and energy range, the overall contribution is substantial, methodology reliable, and results convincing.