Gödel's Universe and the Local Limit of Nonlocal Gravity

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2504.14537
• Title: Gödel's Universe and the Local Limit of Nonlocal Gravity
• Authors: Z. Mardaninezhad (Georg-August-University), B. Mashhoon (IPM & University of Missouri)
• Classification: gr-qc (General Relativity and Quantum Cosmology)
• Publication Date: September 2, 2025
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2504.14537

Abstract

This paper investigates Gödel's universe within the framework of the local limit of nonlocal gravity. The theory is distinguished from Einstein's general relativity (GR) by introducing a scalar sensitivity function S(x)—a characteristic property of the gravitational field—which vanishes in the GR limit. The study demonstrates that when S is constant, Gödel spacetime is a solution to the modified gravitational field equations, consistent with the spatial homogeneity of Gödel's universe.

Research Background and Motivation

Core Problems

1. Exploring nonlocal generalizations of general relativity: Investigating whether the local limit of nonlocal gravity theory (NLG) can accommodate the classical Gödel universe solution
2. Unified description of gravitational theory: Developing a nonlocal theoretical framework for gravity, analogous to nonlocal constitutive relations of media in electromagnetism
3. New understanding of spacetime geometry: Describing spacetime's gravitational properties through the scalar sensitivity function S(x)

Research Significance

• Gödel's universe is an important exact solution in general relativity containing closed timelike curves, crucial for understanding spacetime causal structure
• Nonlocal gravity theory can simulate dark matter effects in the linear regime, with important cosmological applications
• This research provides a new pathway for exploring the nonlinear regime of modified gravity theories

Limitations of Existing Methods

• Complete nonlocal gravity theory involves highly nonlinear partial integro-differential equations that are difficult to solve for nontrivial exact solutions
• Apart from Minkowski spacetime, no other exact solutions of NLG have been found to date
• de Sitter spacetime is not a solution of NLG, limiting the theory's applicability

Core Contributions

1. Demonstrated compatibility of Gödel spacetime: Under the condition that S is constant, Gödel's universe is an exact solution of the local limit of nonlocal gravity
2. Established modified field equations: Derived modified Einstein field equations containing the sensitivity function S(x)
3. Revealed corrections to physical parameters: Discovered that energy density and pressure are corrected according to Ω → (1+S)^(1/2)Ω
4. Verified theoretical consistency: The constant nature of S perfectly aligns with the spatial homogeneity and temporal stationarity of Gödel's universe

Detailed Methodology

Theoretical Framework

1. Teleparallel Equivalent of General Relativity (TEGR)

A gravitational theory based on the Weitzenböck connection, where:

• Tetrad field: λ^μ_α̂(x), α̂ = 0,1,2,3
• Metric relation: g_μν(x) = λ^μ_α̂(x)λ^ν_β̂(x)η_α̂β̂
• Weitzenböck connection: Γ^μ_αβ = λ^μ_ρ̂∂_αλ^ρ̂_β

2. Nonlocal Gravity (NLG)

Generalizing TEGR through nonlocal constitutive relations:

N_μνρ(x) = ∫ K(x,x') {C_μνρ(x') + p̌[Č_μ(x')η_νρ - Č_ν(x')η_μρ]}√(-g(x'))d⁴x'

where K(x,x') is the theory's causal kernel function.

3. Local Limit

When the kernel function degenerates to a delta function:

K(x,x') = S(x)/√(-g(x)) δ(x-x')

the local constitutive relation is obtained:

H_μνρ = (√(-g)/κ)[(1+S)C_μνρ + Sp̌(Č_μg_νρ - Č_νg_μρ)]

Treatment of Gödel Metric

Metric Form

ds² = -dt² - 2√2U(x)dtdy + dx² - U²(x)dy² + dz²

where U(x) = e^(√2Ωx), Ω > 0 is a constant parameter.

Tetrad Field Selection

e^μ_0̂ = (1,0,0,0), e^μ_1̂ = (0,1,0,0)
e^μ_2̂ = (-√2,0,U⁻¹,0), e^μ_3̂ = (0,0,0,1)

Torsion Tensor Calculation

Non-zero components:

C₁₂² = -C₂₁² = √2Ω
C₁₂₀ = -C₂₁₀ = -2ΩU
C₁₂₂ = -C₂₁₂ = -√2ΩU²

Derivation of Modified Field Equations

Through calculation of the tensor M_μν = Q_μν - N_μν, the modified Einstein equations are obtained:

⁰G_μν + Λg_μν - κT_μν = M_μν

Key calculations include:

1. Q̄_μν terms: From quadratic terms of the torsion tensor
2. Q̌_μν terms: From contributions of the torsion pseudovector
3. N_μν terms: From spatial derivatives of the sensitivity function

Experimental Setup

Mathematical Verification Framework

The paper employs rigorous mathematical derivation for verification, primarily including:

1. Tensor calculations: Computing each tensor component in Gödel spacetime individually
2. Field equation solving: Substituting the Gödel metric into the modified field equations
3. Consistency verification: Verifying mutual consistency of all field equation components

Physical Constraint Conditions

• Causality requirement: 1 + S > 0, ensuring physical reasonableness of the theory
• Spatial homogeneity: S can only depend on the x coordinate
• Cosmological constant constraint: Λ ≤ 0, consistent with physical reality

Experimental Results

Main Findings

1. Constancy of the Sensitivity Function

By solving the system of modified field equations:

Ω² - Λ - κρₛ = Ω(√2S' - ΩS)
Ω² + Λ - κpₛ = -Ω²S

and five other independent equations, the consistency condition is obtained: S' = 0

2. Modified Equation of State

The original GR relations:

-Λ + Ω² = κρ, Λ + Ω² = κp

are modified to:

-Λ + (1+S)Ω² = κρₛ, Λ + (1+S)Ω² = κpₛ

3. Rescaling of Physical Parameters

The corrections to energy density and pressure can be expressed as: Ω → (1+S)^(1/2)Ω

This means the angular velocity of Gödel's universe is rescaled in the modified theory.

Theoretical Consistency Verification

All 16 modified field equation components are satisfied under the conditions:

1. S is constant (S' = 0)
2. The parameter p̌ can be chosen arbitrarily
3. 1 + S > 0 ensures physical reasonableness

Related Work

Development of Nonlocal Gravity Theory

• Hehl & Mashhoon (2009): Established the formal framework of NLG, analogous to electromagnetic media theory
• Linear regime studies: NLG in the weak-field limit can explain dark matter phenomena
• Other nonlocal theories: Maggiore's nonlocal modifications, Woodard's cosmological applications

Research on Gödel-type Spacetimes

• Obukhov et al. (2004): Studied Gödel-type solutions in teleparallel gravity
• Energy-momentum studies: Multiple scholars investigated energy-momentum distributions in Gödel spacetime
• Causal structure: Research on the existence of closed timelike curves in Gödel's universe

Modified Gravity Theories

• f(R) theories: Generalizations of scalar-tensor theories
• Extra-dimensional models: Higher-dimensional gravity theories
• Quantum gravity phenomenology: Low-energy effective theory approaches

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Theory compatibility: Gödel's universe is completely compatible with the local limit of nonlocal gravity
2. Sensitivity function constraints: S must be constant, reflecting the symmetry of Gödel spacetime
3. Physical parameter corrections: Gravitational sensitivity leads to systematic corrections of cosmological parameters
4. Cosmological constant: In the modified theory, the cosmological constant must remain negative or zero

Physical Implications

• New perspective on spacetime geometry: The sensitivity function S(x) provides a new way to describe spacetime's gravitational properties
• Dynamical origin of dark energy: Similar to FLRW cosmology, time-dependence of S can generate dynamical dark energy
• Unified gravitational theory: Provides a unified descriptive framework for different gravitational theories

Limitations

1. Unknown kernel function: The kernel function K(x,x') in the complete NLG theory still needs to be determined through observations
2. Uniqueness of tetrad: The choice of fundamental tetrad field may have multiple possibilities
3. Nonlinear effects: The local limit may not fully capture all features of the nonlocal theory
4. Observational verification: Lack of direct observational verification methods

Future Directions

1. Other exact solutions: Finding other classical spacetime solutions of the NLG local limit
2. Cosmological applications: Studying applications of the modified theory in modern cosmology
3. Observational constraints: Constraining the sensitivity function S(x) through astrophysical observations
4. Quantum corrections: Exploring the influence of quantum effects on nonlocal gravity

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Mathematical rigor: Detailed and complete calculations with precise treatment of all tensor components
2. Deep physical insights: The correspondence between the constancy of S and Gödel spacetime's symmetry is highly illuminating
3. Theoretical consistency: Self-consistent solution of 16 field equations demonstrates the theory's internal coherence
4. Methodological innovation: First study of Gödel spacetime within the nonlocal gravity framework

Weaknesses

1. Limited applicability: Only considers the local limit, not the complete nonlocal theory
2. Weak observational connection: Lacks direct connection to real astrophysical phenomena
3. Uniqueness issues: The uniqueness of tetrad field selection requires further investigation
4. Physical interpretation: The physical origin and significance of the sensitivity function S need deeper elucidation

Academic Impact

Theoretical Value:

• Provides important exact solutions for nonlocal gravity theory
• Enriches the solution space of modified gravity theories
• Offers new perspectives for understanding the nonlocal nature of spacetime

Practical Value:

• Provides new theoretical tools for cosmological modeling
• May help address outstanding problems in modern cosmology
• Offers theoretical predictions for gravitational wave astronomy

Applicable Scenarios

1. Theoretical physics research: Modified gravity theories, nonlocal field theory studies
2. Cosmological modeling: Early universe, dark matter/dark energy problems
3. Mathematical physics: Applications of differential geometry and tensor analysis
4. Gravitational wave physics: Gravitational wave predictions in non-standard gravity theories

References

The paper cites 45 important references, primarily including:

• Classical literature: Gödel's (1949) original work, Einstein's "The Meaning of Relativity"
• Textbooks: Hawking & Ellis's "The Large Scale Structure of Space-Time," Stephani et al.'s "Exact Solutions of Einstein's Field Equations"
• Nonlocal gravity: Seminal works by Hehl & Mashhoon
• Teleparallel theory: Reviews by Maluf, Aldrovandi & Pereira, and others
• Recent research: Tabatabaei et al. on cosmological applications of NLG local limit

Overall Assessment: This is an important research work in the field of modified gravity theories. Through rigorous mathematical derivation, the authors successfully demonstrate the compatibility of Gödel's universe with the local limit of nonlocal gravity, providing new perspectives for understanding the nonlocal nature of spacetime. While observational verification and physical interpretation require further refinement, this work establishes a solid theoretical foundation for subsequent research.