Josephson Anomalous Vortices

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2504.17779
• Title: Josephson Anomalous Vortices
• Authors: Dan Crawford, Stefan Ilić, Pauli Virtanen, Tero T. Heikkilä (Department of Physics and Nanoscience Center, University of Jyväskylä, Finland)
• Classification: cond-mat.supr-con (Condensed Matter Physics - Superconductivity)
• Publication Date: October 13, 2025
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2504.17779

Abstract

This paper demonstrates the emergence of vortices with circulating currents in Josephson junctions, which are associated with odd-frequency triplet pairing when the barrier consists of a weak ferromagnet with strong spin-orbit coupling. Through symmetry analysis, the authors prove the existence of an additional term in the superconducting free energy—a rotational invariant—that produces magnetoelectric effects even when the previously considered Lifshitz invariant vanishes. Using a microscopic model based on the modified Usadel equation, the authors demonstrate that the size, shape, and position of these vortices can be controlled by gate manipulation of Rashba spin-orbit coupling in the weak link, and suggest detection via scanning magnetometry.

Research Background and Motivation

Research Problem

The core problem addressed in this paper is the discovery and understanding of a novel type of vortex in superconducting heterostructures—Josephson anomalous vortices (JAV). These vortices appear in weak ferromagnetic Josephson junctions with strong spin-orbit coupling, manifesting as circulating current density patterns.

Significance

1. Theoretical Importance: Discovery of a new term in the superconducting free energy—the rotational invariant—extending understanding of magnetoelectric effects
2. Experimental Value: Provides a new method for controlling vortex characteristics through gate manipulation
3. Application Prospects: Offers new physical mechanisms for superconducting electronics and quantum device design

Existing Limitations

Traditional vortex research has primarily focused on Abrikosov vortices and magnetoelectric effects based on the Lifshitz invariant. When the Lifshitz invariant vanishes, there lacks an effective theoretical framework for describing magnetoelectric effects.

Research Motivation

Inspired by exotic vortex phases in superfluid helium-3, the authors explore the possibility of realizing more exotic vortex phases in superconducting systems with triplet pairing amplitudes.

Core Contributions

1. Discovery of a New Rotational Invariant: Identification of a previously insufficiently studied rotational invariant term in the superconducting free energy
2. Proposal of Josephson Anomalous Vortices: Discovery of a novel coreless vortex with unique circulating current distribution
3. Establishment of Microscopic Theory: Provision of a complete microscopic theory based on the modified Usadel equation
4. Controllable Manipulation Scheme: Demonstration of methods to control vortex size, position, and shape through Rashba "islands"
5. Prediction of Experimental Detection: Suggestion of scanning magnetometry for detecting magnetic fields produced by these vortices

Methodology Details

Task Definition

Investigation of vortex phenomena in S-FM-S (superconductor-ferromagnet-superconductor) Josephson junctions when the ferromagnetic layer possesses strong spin-orbit coupling. Input parameters include exchange field strength J, Rashba spin-orbit coupling strength α, and junction geometry; outputs include current density distribution and pairing amplitude texture.

Theoretical Framework

Phenomenological Theory

The superconducting free energy density is expressed as:

F = FS + FL + FR

Where:

• FS: Standard Ginzburg-Landau free energy
• FL: Lifshitz invariant term FL = dk[ψ*Πkψ + ψ(Πkψ)*]
• FR: Rotational invariant term FR = iejkΠjψ(Πkψ)*

The key finding is the expression for the rotational invariant ejk:

ejk = κTr[Fjkhiσi]

where κ is a material parameter and Fjk is the SU(2) field strength tensor.

Microscopic Model

Based on the quasiclassical Green's function method, the anomalous Green's function has spin structure:

f = fsσ0 + fiσi

where fs is the singlet component and fi is the triplet component.

The microscopic expression for the rotational invariant is:

Frot = iζ(∇̂fs × ∇̂*f*z) · ẑ

The resulting circulating current density is:

Jrot = 2eζ (fscurl f*z + f*s curl fz)

Technical Innovations

1. Symmetry Analysis: Systematic analysis of how time-reversal and inversion symmetry breaking affect free energy terms
2. Boundary Term Treatment: Connection of the rotational invariant with boundary effects to explain the circulating current generation mechanism
3. Topological Classification: Use of Poincaré index for topological classification of vortex and antivortex modes
4. Numerical Solution: Development of numerical methods for solving the modified Usadel equation

Experimental Setup

Model Parameters

• Temperature: T = 0.1Δ0/kB
• Energy unit: Superconducting gap Δ0
• Length unit: Superconducting coherence length ξ0
• Junction size range: (0.1×0.1)ξ0² to (5×5)ξ0²

Material Parameters

• Exchange field: J = Δ0 ẑ (perpendicular to interface)
• Rashba spin-orbit coupling: HSO = α(ẑ × k) · σ
• Diffusion parameter: ℏη = 0.01Δ0ξ0⁴

Computational Methods

Quasiclassical Green's function theory is used to solve spatially-dependent pairing amplitudes and current density distributions, with self-consistent solutions obtained through numerical iteration.

Experimental Results

Main Results

Vortex Mode Classification

Classification via Poincaré index P:

• P = +1: Vortex mode
• P = -1: Antivortex mode
• P > 1: Multiple singularity modes

Size Effects

1. Optimal Size: Junctions of (1×1)ξ0² most readily produce vortex modes
2. Small Size: (0.1×0.1)ξ0² junctions primarily produce antivortex modes
3. Large Size: (5×5)ξ0² junctions exhibit complex multi-singularity structures

Magnetic Field Strength

The magnetic field strength produced by vortices scales as:

B0 = µ0σDΔ0t/(4eξ0) ≈ 1 mT × (t/ξ0)[σD/(1.6×10⁷ S/m)][Δ0/(200 µeV)]

For typical parameters, magnetic field strength can reach the mT level, sufficient for detection by current magnetometry techniques.

Pairing Amplitude Texture

The triplet pairing amplitude exhibits rich texture structure:

1. fx, fy Components: Form rotational patterns similar to magnetic textures
2. fz Component: Exhibits incomplete winding phase texture
3. Amplitude Relations: |fs| > |fz| > |fx| ∼ |fy|

Parameter Dependence

• Exchange Field Optimization: Effect strongest when J ∼ Δ0
• Spin-Orbit Coupling: Vortex characteristics enhance with increasing α
• Phase Bias: Rotational invariant effect perturbed by Josephson current when φ ≳ α²ξ0²

Manipulation and Detection Schemes

Gate Control

Vortex manipulation through defining Rashba "islands" in the weak link:

• Size Control: Adjust vortex size by modifying island dimensions
• Position Control: Move vortex center by changing island position
• Shape Control: Design asymmetric island structures to modulate vortex shape

Detection Techniques

Recommended magnetometry methods:

1. Magnetic Force Microscopy: Spatial resolution 10-50 nm
2. Scanning Nitrogen-Vacancy Centers: Resolution approximately 50 nm
3. Nano-SQUID: High-sensitivity magnetic field detection

Material Platforms

Recommended experimental platforms:

1. Thin Film Bilayers: YIG/InAs, EuS/InAs
2. Ferromagnetic Alloys: Pd/Ni, Cu/Ni alloys
3. van der Waals Heterostructures: CrI3/MoS2, CrI3/WSe2

Related Work

Traditional Vortex Theory

• Abrikosov Vortices: Quantized magnetic flux vortices based on phase winding
• Josephson Vortices: Elongated coreless vortices
• Proximity Effect Vortices: Induced vortices in normal metals

Spin-Orbit Coupling Effects

• Lifshitz Invariant: Describes magnetoelectric effects in non-centrosymmetric superconductors
• Edelstein Effect: Spin-charge conversion induced by spin-orbit coupling
• Superconducting Diode Effect: Asymmetric critical current phenomenon

Triplet Superconductivity

• Odd-Frequency Pairing: Cooper pairs with broken temporal parity
• Spin Texture: Spatial modulation of triplet order parameter
• Topological Superconductivity: Superconducting states with nontrivial topological properties

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Discovery of novel Josephson anomalous vortices driven by rotational invariants
2. Establishment of a complete theoretical framework describing the generation mechanism of these vortices
3. Proposal of practical manipulation and detection schemes

Limitations

1. Quasiclassical Approximation: Requires weak ferromagnetic conditions (J ≲ Δ0)
2. Size Constraints: Vortices primarily appear in structures at the coherence length scale
3. Temperature Effects: Theory primarily applicable at low temperatures
4. Material Requirements: Requires simultaneous weak ferromagnetism and strong spin-orbit coupling

Future Directions

1. Experimental Verification: Realization and observation of JAV in recommended material platforms
2. Nonlinear Effects: Study of vortex dynamics under large current conditions
3. Quantum Applications: Exploration of potential JAV applications in quantum computing
4. Topological Properties: Investigation of topological protection characteristics of vortices

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Theoretical Innovation: Discovery of a new physical mechanism—the rotational invariant—filling theoretical gaps
2. Complete Methodology: Comprehensive description from phenomenology to microscopic theory
3. Experimental Guidance: Provision of specific material selection and detection schemes
4. Numerical Verification: Detailed numerical calculations supporting theoretical predictions
5. Clear Presentation: Logical structure with sufficient technical details

Weaknesses

1. Lack of Experimental Verification: Remains purely theoretical work without experimental validation
2. Parameter Sensitivity: Vortex emergence conditions are relatively stringent, potentially difficult to achieve experimentally
3. Background Signal Separation: Insufficient discussion on effectively separating background ferromagnetic signals in magnetometry measurements
4. Stability Analysis: Lacks detailed analysis of vortex stability

Impact

1. Academic Value: Provides new theoretical framework for superconducting vortex physics
2. Technical Prospects: Offers new ideas for superconducting electronics device design
3. Interdisciplinary Significance: Connects multiple fields including superconductivity, magnetism, and topological physics

Applicable Scenarios

1. Basic Research: Superconducting vortex physics and magnetoelectric effect studies
2. Device Applications: Controllable vortex devices and superconducting electronics
3. Quantum Technology: Topological quantum computing and quantum information processing

References

The paper cites 46 important references, spanning from Abrikosov's pioneering work to the latest scanning magnetometry techniques, reflecting deep academic foundation and comprehensive grasp of field development. Key references include Ginzburg-Landau theory, quasiclassical Green's function methods, and related work on spin-orbit coupled superconductivity.

Overall Assessment: This is a high-quality theoretical physics paper making important theoretical contributions to superconducting vortex physics. Although lacking experimental verification, the theoretical framework is complete and predictions are concrete, providing clear guidance for future experimental research. The paper's innovation and scientific value are noteworthy.