The possible frustrated superconductivity in the kagome superconductors

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2504.18336v2
• Title: The possible frustrated superconductivity in the kagome superconductors
• Authors: Hong-Min Jiang, Wen-Qian Dong, Shun-Li Yu, Z. D. Wang
• Classification: cond-mat.supr-con (Condensed Matter Physics - Superconductivity)
• Publication Date: May 16, 2025 (arXiv preprint)
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2504.18336v2

Abstract

Geometric frustration has long been a persistent research interest in condensed matter physics. While geometric frustration traditionally focuses on magnetic systems, little attention has been paid to "frustrated superconductivity" that may arise when superconducting interactions conflict with crystal symmetry. Recently discovered kagome superconductors provide a unique opportunity to investigate this phenomenon, as the frustrated lattice structure and interference effects between three sublattices can promote frustrated superconducting interactions. This paper proposes a theory supporting a frustrated superconducting state arising from on-site s-wave superconducting pairing combined with nearest-neighbor pairing hopping and the unique geometric frustration of the kagome lattice structure. In this state, mutual 2π/3 phase differences in superconducting pairing phases lead to sixfold modulation of the amplitude and break time-reversal symmetry through 4π phase variation along the Fermi surface, while remaining immune to impurities and producing a pronounced Hebel-Slichter peak below Tc. Notably, the theory also reveals a disorder-induced superconducting pairing transition from the frustrated superconducting state to isotropic s-wave superconductivity without passing through nodal states, recovering and explaining behaviors observed experimentally.

Research Background and Motivation

1. Problems to be addressed:
   • Experimental results on superconducting pairing symmetry in kagome superconductor AV₃Sb₅ show discrepancies and contradictions
   • Conventional theories struggle to simultaneously explain time-reversal symmetry breaking and conventional s-wave superconducting features
   • Lack of deep understanding of how geometric frustration affects superconductivity
2. Importance of the problem:
   • Kagome superconductors are at the frontier of topological superconductivity and quantum materials research
   • Understanding their superconducting mechanism is crucial for designing novel quantum materials
   • Geometric frustrated superconductivity is an entirely new physical concept with fundamental scientific value
3. Limitations of existing approaches:
   • Existing theories cannot uniformly explain seemingly contradictory experimental observations
   • Traditional superconductivity theory does not account for lattice geometric frustration effects on superconducting pairing
   • Lack of theoretical framework capable of explaining disorder-induced phase transitions
4. Research motivation:
   • Borrowing concepts of geometric frustration from magnetic systems, first propose "frustrated superconductivity"
   • Construct a new theoretical framework through nearest-neighbor pairing hopping and sublattice interference effects
   • Provide unified explanation for various experimental phenomena in kagome superconductors

Core Contributions

1. First proposal of frustrated superconductivity concept: Extends geometric frustration from magnetic systems to superconducting systems, establishing a new physical picture
2. Construction of complete theoretical model: Includes on-site s-wave pairing, nearest-neighbor pairing hopping, and kagome lattice structure Hamiltonian
3. Prediction of unique superconducting state properties: Pairing phases on three sublattices differ by 2π/3, producing sixfold modulation and time-reversal symmetry breaking
4. Explanation of experimental contradictions: Provides unified explanation for Hebel-Slichter peak, impurity-free states, and disorder-induced pairing symmetry transitions
5. Provision of new physical insights: Reveals the crucial role of sublattice interference effects in determining superconducting properties

Detailed Methodology

Task Definition

Investigate the properties of superconducting states on kagome lattices considering nearest-neighbor pairing hopping, particularly analyzing how geometric frustration affects superconducting pairing symmetry and physical properties.

Model Architecture

Total Hamiltonian:

H = H₀ + Hₚ + Hₚₕ

1. Tight-binding term H₀:

   H₀ = -∑⟨ij⟩σ (tᵢⱼc†ᵢσcⱼσ + H.c.) - μ∑ᵢσ c†ᵢσcᵢσ
   

2. On-site superconducting pairing Hₚ:

   Hₚ = ∑ᵢ (Δᵢc†ᵢ↑c†ᵢ↓ + H.c.)
   

3. Pairing hopping term Hₚₕ:

   Hₚₕ = J∑⟨ij⟩ (c†ᵢ↑c†ᵢ↓cⱼ↓cⱼ↑ + H.c.)
   

Key physical picture:

• The pairing hopping term is analogous to nearest-neighbor interactions in magnetic systems
• On the kagome lattice, positive pairing hopping J leads to minimum energy when pairing phases on three sublattices differ by 2π/3
• This phase arrangement produces "superconducting frustration" analogous to magnetic frustration

Technical Innovations

1. Geometric frustrated superconductivity: First application of geometric frustration concepts to superconducting systems
2. Sublattice interference effects: Utilizes kagome lattice sublattice structure to explain experimental phenomena
3. Phase frustration mechanism: Achieves time-reversal symmetry breaking through geometric arrangement of pairing phases
4. Unified theoretical framework: Single model explains multiple seemingly contradictory experimental results

Experimental Setup

Computational Parameters

• Energy unit: Hopping parameter t = 1
• Temperature: T = 1×10⁻⁵ (near zero temperature)
• Chemical potential: Adjusted to 1/6 hole doping (van Hove singularity filling)
• Pairing interaction: Vₛ = 1.4
• Pairing hopping strength: J as variational parameter

Numerical Methods

1. Self-consistent calculation: Solve superconducting order parameter through Bogoliubov-de Gennes equation
2. Free energy comparison: Determine stability of different solutions
3. Real-space calculation: Employ supercell technique when studying impurity effects
4. T-matrix method: Analyze sublattice selectivity of impurity scattering

Evaluation Metrics

• Superconducting order parameter amplitude and phase distribution
• Density of states and local density of states
• Nuclear spin-lattice relaxation rate (T₁T)⁻¹
• Free energy and phase stability

Experimental Results

Main Results

1. Phase diagram:
   • J < 0.11: Conventional s-wave superconducting state is stable
   • J > 0.11: Frustrated superconducting state becomes ground state
   • Pairing hopping strength determines phase transition point
2. Characteristics of frustrated superconducting state:
   • Three sublattice pairing phases: e^(-i2π/3), 1, e^(i2π/3)
   • Sixfold amplitude modulation on Fermi surface: maximum |Δ| (M point), minimum |Δ|/2 (midpoint)
   • Time-reversal symmetry breaking: 4π phase variation along Fermi surface
3. Physical properties:
   • Hebel-Slichter peak: Pronounced (T₁T)⁻¹ peak appears below Tc
   • Impurity immunity: Strong impurities do not produce in-gap states
   • Sublattice selectivity: Impurities primarily affect electronic states on the same sublattice

Disorder-Induced Phase Transition

Key findings:

• As random impurity strength W increases, average phase difference ϕ jumps from 2π/3 to 0
• Density of states transforms from V-shaped (frustrated state) to U-shaped (s-wave state)
• Transition does not pass through nodal states, consistent with experimental observations

Critical disorder strength:

• J = 0.13: Wc ≈ 0.25
• J = 0.14: Wc ≈ 0.35
• Stronger pairing hopping requires stronger disorder to destroy frustrated state

Sublattice Interference Effects

Important findings:

• Impurity effects on the same sublattice are strongest, effects on different sublattices are weak
• van Hove singularities MA, MB, MC correspond to sublattices A, B, C respectively
• Impurity scattering exhibits momentum selectivity, primarily affecting specific van Hove points

Related Work

1. Kagome superconductor experiments:
   • Experimental studies of superconducting properties in AV₃Sb₅ series compounds
   • Controversial pairing symmetry: s-wave vs. unconventional pairing
   • Evidence for time-reversal symmetry breaking
2. Theoretical research:
   • Various pairing symmetry proposals: s-wave, d-wave, f-wave, etc.
   • Interaction between charge density waves and superconductivity
   • Theoretical predictions of topological superconductivity
3. Geometric frustration:
   • Geometric frustration theory in magnetic systems
   • Quantum spin liquids on kagome lattices
   • Novel quantum states in frustrated systems

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Realization of frustrated superconductivity: New superconducting states can be realized through pairing hopping and geometric frustration
2. Unified explanation of experimental phenomena: Single theoretical framework explains multiple experimental observations in kagome superconductors
3. New physical mechanism: Sublattice interference effects are key to understanding kagome systems
4. Phase transition mechanism: Disorder can drive transition from frustrated state to conventional state

Limitations

1. Model simplification: Single-orbital tight-binding model employed; multi-orbital effects not considered
2. Parameter estimation: Microscopic origin of pairing hopping strength J requires further investigation
3. Temperature effects: Discussion primarily limited to zero-temperature regime; finite-temperature behavior needs supplementation
4. Experimental verification: More direct experimental evidence supporting existence of frustrated superconducting state is needed

Future Directions

1. Microscopic mechanism: Investigate microscopic origin and material dependence of pairing hopping
2. Multi-orbital effects: Consider multi-orbital structure in real materials
3. Dynamical properties: Study transport and dynamical response of frustrated superconducting state
4. Experimental design: Propose experimental schemes for direct detection of frustrated superconducting state

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Conceptual innovation: First proposal of "frustrated superconductivity" concept, opening new research directions
2. Theoretical completeness: Systematically analyzes various physical properties starting from microscopic Hamiltonian
3. Experimental relevance: Successfully explains multiple experimental phenomena in kagome superconductors
4. Computational rigor: Employs self-consistent Bogoliubov-de Gennes method and T-matrix theory
5. Deep physical insights: Reveals crucial role of sublattice interference effects

Weaknesses

1. Model limitations: Single-orbital model may be oversimplified; real materials are more complex
2. Parameter dependence: Key results strongly depend on choice of pairing hopping parameter J
3. Experimental evidence: While explaining existing experiments, lacks direct experimental verification of frustrated state
4. Microscopic origin: Microscopic physical origin of pairing hopping term insufficiently discussed
5. Quantitative comparison: Limited quantitative comparison with experimental data

Impact

1. Academic value: Provides new physical picture and research direction for superconductivity theory
2. Application prospects: May guide design and discovery of novel superconducting materials
3. Interdisciplinary significance: Connects two important fields: magnetic frustration and superconductivity
4. Experimental guidance: Provides theoretical framework for further experimental research on kagome superconductors

Applicable Scenarios

1. Kagome superconductors: Directly applicable to AV₃Sb₅ series materials
2. Geometrically frustrated systems: Extensible to other superconducting materials with geometric frustration
3. Multi-sublattice systems: Applicable to superconductors with multiple equivalent sublattices
4. Topological superconductivity research: Provides new insights for seeking topological superconducting states

References

The paper cites 75 related references, primarily concentrated on:

1. Experimental studies of kagome superconductor AV₃Sb₅ (References 1-51)
2. Theoretical models and pairing symmetry research (References 52-66)
3. Pairing hopping and geometric frustration theory (References 67-75)

Key references include discovery papers of AV₃Sb₅, major experimental results reports, and related theoretical work, providing solid foundation for this research.

Overall Assessment: This is a theoretically innovative work of significant importance, first introducing the concept of geometric frustration into the superconductivity field and proposing the new concept of "frustrated superconductivity." Although the model is relatively simplified, it successfully explains multiple experimental phenomena in kagome superconductors, making important contributions to theoretical development in this field. This work is expected to inspire further research on geometrically frustrated superconductivity and provide guidance for designing novel quantum materials.