Exploring two dimensional $\mathbb{Z}_2$ invariant phases with time reversal symmetry and their transitions with topological operations

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2504.20021
• Title: Exploring two dimensional $\mathbb{Z}_2$ invariant phases with time reversal symmetry and their transitions with topological operations
• Author: Ryan C. Spieler (University of Texas, Austin)
• Classification: cond-mat.str-el hep-th
• Publication Date: October 13, 2025 (v2 version)
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2504.20021

Abstract

This paper systematically investigates phase transitions between theories with $\mathbb{Z}_2$ and time reversal symmetry in two-dimensional spacetime using various topological operations. The phases under consideration (and their associated conformal field theories, CFTs) fall into two categories: bosonic phases defined on non-orientable manifolds and fermionic phases sensitive to $\text{Pin}^-$ structures. In both cases, the analysis yields eight phase diagrams, with the two sets of eight diagrams connected through fermionization/bosonization. Starting from seed CFTs, the CFTs governing each transition are obtained. Many of these exhibit criticality with enhanced symmetry. Beyond demonstrating how many symmetry-enhanced CFTs behave in their natural habitat, this work discusses the fermionic analogue of $\mathbb{Z}_2$ bosonic operations, which has not been previously discussed in the literature.

Research Background and Motivation

Core Problem

This research addresses the systematic understanding of phase transition structures in two-dimensional quantum field theories with $\mathbb{Z}_2 \times \mathbb{Z}_2^T$ symmetry, where $\mathbb{Z}_2^T$ denotes time reversal symmetry.

Significance and Motivation

1. Symmetry as an organizing principle: Symmetry serves as the dominant organizing force in theoretical physics, with its definition recently extended to encompass all topological defects in quantum field theories.
2. Systematic understanding of phase transitions: By coupling theories to background fields for symmetries, one can track the effects of various topological operations (such as gauging symmetries and superposing with invertible topological theories), which typically generate new field theories describing the low-energy limits of different phases.
3. Orbifold groupoid structure: These operations organize field theories into an orbifold groupoid consisting of field theories connected by invertible topological operations.
4. Literature gap: Existing literature lacks systematic discussion of the fermionic analogue of $\mathbb{Z}_2$ bosonic operations.

Core Contributions

1. Systematic analytical framework: Establishes a complete framework for studying phase transitions in two-dimensional theories with $\mathbb{Z}_2 \times \mathbb{Z}_2^T$ symmetry.
2. Classification of eight phase diagrams:
   • Bosonic phases: 8 phase diagrams and their connecting topological operations
   • Fermionic phases: 8 phase diagrams, connected to bosonic diagrams through fermionization/bosonization
3. CFT network construction: Starting from seed CFTs (Ising CFT and Majorana CFT), obtains a complete CFT network governing all phase transitions through topological operations.
4. First systematic treatment of fermionic operations: Provides the first systematic discussion in the literature of the fermionic analogue of $\mathbb{Z}_2$ bosonic operations.
5. Symmetry-enhanced criticality: Demonstrates how many CFTs exhibiting symmetry-enhanced criticality behave in their natural environments.

Detailed Methodology

Theoretical Framework

Bosonic Theory Component

Background field setup:

• $A \in H^1(X;\mathbb{Z}_2)$: Background field for $\mathbb{Z}_2$ symmetry
• $w_1 \in H^1(X;\mathbb{Z}_2)$: First Stiefel-Whitney class of the tangent bundle, serving as the background field for time reversal symmetry

Topological operations:

1. Gauging operation $O$: $O : Z[A,w_1, w_2] \mapsto \sum_{a\in H^1(X;\mathbb{Z}_2)} (-1)^{\int a\cup \check{A}} Z[a,w_1, w_2]$
2. SPT superposition $S_1$: $S_1 : Z[A,w_1, w_2] \mapsto Z[A,w_1, w_2](-1)^{\int A\cup w_1}$
3. Haldane phase superposition $S_2$: $S_2 : Z[A,w_1, w_2] \mapsto Z[A,w_1, w_2](-1)^{\int w_2}$

Fermionic Theory Component

Pin⁻ structures and ABK invariants:

Fermionic theories require Pin⁻ structures $\eta$, with the corresponding partition function defined through the Arf-Brown-Kervaire (ABK) invariant:

$Z_{ABK}[\eta] = \exp\left[\frac{\pi i}{4}ABK(\eta)\right] = \sum_{a\in H^1(X;\mathbb{Z}_2)} \exp\left[\frac{\pi}{2}iq_\eta(a)\right]$

where the quadratic form $q_\eta$ satisfies: $q_\eta(a+b) = q_\eta(a) + q_\eta(b) + 2\int a \cup b$

Fermionization formula: $Z_F[C] = \sum_{a\in H^1(X;\mathbb{Z}_2)} Z_B[a] \exp\left[\frac{\pi i}{4}(ABK(a \cdot \eta) - ABK(\eta)) + \pi i \int a \cup C\right]$

Phase Structure Analysis

Bosonic Phase Classification

1. Trivial phase: $Z_{Tri}[A] = 1$
2. Spontaneous symmetry breaking phase: $Z_{SSB}[A] = \delta(A)$
3. Modified SSB phase: $Z_{SSB'}[A,w_1] = \delta(A + w_1)$
4. SPT phase: $Z_{SPT}[A,w_1] = (-1)^{\int A\cup w_1}$
5. Haldane phase: $Z_{Hald}[w_1] = (-1)^{\int w_2}$
6. Composite phases: Combinations of various phases

Fermionic Phase Classification

Eight fermionic phases obtained by fermionizing bosonic phases, following $\mathbb{Z}_8$ superposition rules:

Experimental Setup

CFT Construction Method

Bosonic CFT seed: Starting from Ising CFT $S_1 = \int [(D_A\phi)^2 + \phi^4]$

Fermionic CFT seed: Starting from Majorana CFT $S_1 = \int i\bar{\chi} \not{D}_{C \cdot \eta} \chi$

Implementation of Topological Operations

By systematically applying topological operations $O$, $S_1$, $S_2$ and their fermionic analogues $O_F$, $S_1^F$, $S_2^F$, a complete CFT network is generated.

Experimental Results

Main Results

Bosonic Phase Diagram Network

Eight phase diagrams obtained, interconnected through topological operations:

• $PD_1 = (Tri, SSB)$: Fundamental phase diagram
• $PD_2 = (SPT, SSB)$: Obtained by applying $S_1$
• $PD_3 = (Hald, Hald+SSB)$: Obtained by applying $S_2$
• And so forth...

Fermionic Phase Diagram Network

Similarly, eight fermionic phase diagrams obtained:

• $PD_1 = (Tri, ABK)$: Fundamental fermionic phase diagram
• Other seven phase diagrams generated by superposing ABK phases

CFT Duality Relations

Important duality relations discovered, such as the fermionic version of Kramers-Wannier duality: $\int [i\bar{\chi} \not{D}_{(C+w_1) \cdot \eta} \chi + \frac{\pi i}{4} ABK(C \cdot \eta)] \leftrightarrow \int [i\bar{\chi} \not{D}_{C \cdot \eta} \chi]$

Symmetry-Enhanced Criticality

Many obtained CFTs exhibit symmetry-enhanced criticality, including:

• Ising + SPT
• Ising + Haldane
• Majorana + ABK
• Various gapless SPT phases

Related Work

Theoretical Foundations

1. Generalized symmetry theory: Based on Gaiotto et al.'s work on generalized global symmetries
2. Topological field theory: Utilizing Witten et al.'s research on SL(2,Z) actions
3. Orbifold groupoid: Adopting the orbifold groupoid framework of Gaiotto-Kulp

Symmetry-Protected Topological Phases

1. SPT classification: Based on Kapustin et al.'s classification of symmetry-protected topological phases
2. Fermionic SPT: Utilizing Fidkowski-Kitaev's $\mathbb{Z}_8$ classification of one-dimensional fermionic topological phases

CFT Duality Networks

1. Two-dimensional dualities: Extending Karch-Tong's duality network for Z₂ gauge fields and Arf invariants
2. Three-dimensional dualities: Inspired by Seiberg et al.'s work on three-dimensional duality networks

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Complete classification: Successfully classifies all two-dimensional phases with $\mathbb{Z}_2 \times \mathbb{Z}_2^T$ symmetry and their phase transitions
2. Fermi-Bose correspondence: Establishes explicit correspondence between bosonic and fermionic topological operations
3. CFT network: Constructs a complete CFT network, demonstrating rich symmetry-enhanced critical phenomena

Limitations

1. Pin⁺ theory: For fermionic time reversal symmetry with $T^2 = (-1)^F$, the analytical method cannot be directly generalized since Pin⁺ structures do not correspond to quadratic refinements
2. Higher-dimensional generalization: Methods primarily apply to two dimensions; higher-dimensional cases require additional considerations
3. Non-abelian symmetries: Current framework primarily handles abelian symmetries

Future Directions

1. Pin⁺ structure analysis: Develop new methods for handling Pin⁺ structures
2. More complex symmetries: Generalize to more complex symmetry groups such as $\mathbb{Z}_2 \times H$
3. Non-invertible symmetries: Explore non-invertible symmetries in the presence of time reversal symmetry
4. Higher-dimensional generalization: Extend methods to three and higher dimensions

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Strong systematicity: Provides a complete and systematic analytical framework covering all possible phases and phase transitions
2. Technical innovation: First systematic establishment of correspondence between bosonic and fermionic topological operations
3. Mathematical rigor: Based on rigorous topological field theory and differential geometry tools
4. Deep physical insights: Reveals rich symmetry-enhanced critical phenomena

Weaknesses

1. Limited scope of applicability: Primarily restricted to two dimensions and specific symmetry groups
2. Lack of experimental verification: Theoretical results lack concrete experimental verification in condensed matter physics
3. Computational complexity: Calculation of certain topological invariants may be complex in practical applications

Impact

1. Theoretical contribution: Provides new theoretical tools for understanding quantum phase transitions and topological phases
2. Methodological value: The orbifold groupoid method may be applicable to other symmetries and dimensions
3. Interdisciplinary significance: Connects condensed matter physics, high-energy physics, and mathematical topology

Applicable Scenarios

1. Theoretical condensed matter physics: Studying quantum spin systems with time reversal symmetry
2. Topological insulators: Understanding phase transitions and edge states of topological insulators
3. Quantum critical points: Analyzing quantum critical points with enhanced symmetry
4. Mathematical physics: Serving as a tool for studying topological field theory and modular forms

References

The paper cites 61 important references, primarily including:

1. Generalized symmetries: Gaiotto, Kapustin, Seiberg, Willett (2015) - Foundational theory of generalized global symmetries
2. Orbifold groupoid: Gaiotto, Kulp (2021) - Orbifold groupoid framework
3. Duality networks: Karch, Tong (2019) - Duality networks for Z₂ gauge fields and Arf invariants
4. SPT classification: Kapustin, Thorngren, Turzillo, Wang (2015) - Fermionic symmetry-protected topological phases
5. Topological field theory: Witten (2016) - Fermionic path integrals and topological phases