Interaction of domain walls with scalar particles in the early Universe

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2504.20120
• Title: Interaction of domain walls with scalar particles in the early Universe
• Authors: D. P. Filippov, A. A. Kirillov (National Research Nuclear University MEPhI, Moscow, Russia)
• Classification: gr-qc (General Relativity and Quantum Cosmology), astro-ph.CO (Cosmology and Nongalactic Astrophysics)
• Publication Date: April 28, 2025 (arXiv preprint)
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2504.20120

Abstract

This paper investigates the interaction between domain walls and scalar particles in the early Universe. The research demonstrates that when the temperature of a scalar particle gas, driven by cosmic expansion, drops below a critical threshold, domain walls suddenly become opaque and trap particles within. Accounting for the pressure of trapped scalar particles, this effect leads to a time delay in domain wall collapse and postponement of primordial black hole formation.

Research Background and Motivation

1. Problem Background

Recent observations from the Hubble and James Webb Space Telescopes have confirmed the existence of supermassive black holes in the early Universe, yet their formation mechanisms at high redshift remain unknown. Primordial black holes (PBHs), as non-stellar black holes, represent an important topic in contemporary cosmology regarding their formation mechanisms.

2. Research Motivation

• Observational Requirements: Explaining the existence of supermassive black holes in the early Universe
• Theoretical Gaps: Existing theories provide incomplete descriptions of primordial black hole formation mechanisms
• Physical Processes: Need to consider the effects of domain wall interactions with surrounding media on their dynamics
• Dark Matter Connection: Scalar particles may play the role of cold dark matter candidates

3. Limitations of Existing Approaches

Previous studies primarily focused on domain wall collapse without medium interactions, lacking systematic analysis of the interactions between surrounding particles and domain walls, particularly regarding scalar particles as dark matter candidates.

Core Contributions

1. Established an interaction model between scalar fields and domain walls, deriving analytical expressions for reflection coefficients
2. Discovered a temperature threshold effect, where domain walls suddenly become opaque below a critical temperature
3. Proposed a delayed collapse mechanism, where scalar particle pressure causes time delays in primordial black hole formation
4. Provided model parameter constraints, determining the parameter space capable of producing primordial black holes
5. Predicted natural formation of dark matter halos, providing theoretical foundations for dark matter structures around primordial black holes

Methodology Details

Task Definition

Investigate the interaction between closed domain walls and scalar particles in the early Universe, analyzing how this interaction affects the dynamical evolution of domain walls and the formation process of primordial black holes.

Model Architecture

1. Field Theory Model

Consider the potential of a complex scalar field $\phi = re^{i\theta}$: $V = \frac{1}{4}\left(\phi^*\phi - \frac{f^2}{2}\right)^2 + \Lambda^4(1-\cos\theta)$

where $f$ is the vacuum expectation value and $\Lambda$ is the symmetry-breaking parameter.

2. Domain Wall Structure

After inflation ends, the spatial dependence of the domain wall is: $\theta(x) = 4\arctan\left[\exp\left(\frac{2x}{d}\right)\right]$

with wall thickness: $d = \frac{2f}{\Lambda^2}$

3. Interaction Lagrangian

$L_{int} = \frac{1}{2}\alpha_0(\phi + \phi^*)\varphi^2$

where $\varphi$ is a massive scalar field and $\alpha_0$ is the interaction constant.

Technical Innovations

1. Reflection Coefficient Calculation

Using quantum mechanical methods, the reflection coefficient for the scalar field is obtained: $R = \left[1 + \exp(q(T) - w)\right]^{-1}$

where: $q(T) = \pi d\sqrt{p^2(T) + \sqrt{2\alpha_0 f}}, \quad w = \pi\sqrt{2}\sqrt{2\alpha_0 f}d^2 - 1$

2. Critical Temperature

A critical temperature $T_c$ is discovered: $T_c \approx 4 \times 10^6 \text{ GeV} \left(\frac{\alpha_0}{1 \text{ GeV}}\right)^{1/2}\left(\frac{f}{10^{13} \text{ GeV}}\right)^{1/2}$

When $T < T_c$, the domain wall becomes completely opaque to scalar particles.

3. Dynamical Equations

The domain wall equation of motion accounting for particle pressure: $\dot{v}(t) = (1-v^2(t))\left[\frac{1}{\sigma}(P_2(t)-P_1(t)) - \frac{2\pi}{r(t)} + 3H(t)v(t)\right]$

where $\sigma = 4f\Lambda^2$ is the surface energy density.

Experimental Setup

Dataset

Standard cosmological parameters used:

• Hubble constant: $H_0 = 67$ km/s/Mpc
• Cold dark matter density: $\Omega_{CDM,0} = 0.27$
• Critical density today: $\rho_{c,0} = 4.8 \times 10^{-6}$ GeV/cm³

Model Parameters

• Field parameters: $f = 10^{13}$ GeV, $\Lambda = 0.05$ GeV
• Scalar particle mass: $m = 10^3$ GeV
• Interaction strength: $\alpha_0 = 1$ GeV
• Inflationary e-folds: $N_{inf} = 60$

Numerical Solution

Coupled differential equations are solved, including:

1. Domain wall equation of motion (11)
2. Internal gas temperature and density evolution equations (18)
3. External gas temperature and density evolution equations (19)

Experimental Results

Main Results

1. Reflection Coefficient Behavior

Figure 1 displays the variation of reflection coefficient with temperature, showing a sharp transition at critical temperature $T_c \approx 4 \times 10^6$ GeV, transitioning from transparent to completely opaque state.

2. Domain Wall Evolution

Figure 2 presents domain wall radius evolution for different e-fold numbers ($N = 18, 20, 22$):

• $N = 18$: Domain wall successfully collapses to form a black hole
• $N = 20, 22$: Oscillatory behavior due to balance between gas pressure and surface tension

3. Parameter Space Constraints

Figure 3 provides constraints on model parameters $(f, \Lambda)$:

• Green region: Parameter space capable of producing primordial black holes
• Red region: Forbidden region violating maximum mass constraints
• Blue region: Gravitational radius smaller than wall thickness, preventing black hole formation

Ablation Studies

1. Delayed Collapse Effect

Figure 4 shows that when $f = 3 \times 10^9$ GeV, $\Lambda = 3$ GeV, the domain wall with $N = 22$ can form a black hole with significant time delay $\Delta t/10t_i \approx 10^3$.

2. Parameter Sensitivity Analysis

By varying interaction parameters, the correctness of the critical temperature formula and universality of the delay mechanism are verified.

Experimental Findings

1. Phase Transition Behavior: Domain wall transparency undergoes sharp transition at critical temperature
2. Oscillatory Phenomena: Competition between gas pressure and surface tension leads to radius oscillations
3. Delay Mechanism: Scalar particle pressure can significantly postpone primordial black hole formation
4. Dark Matter Halo Formation: Particle release process naturally forms dark matter structures around primordial black holes

Related Work

1. Domain Wall Interaction Research

• Kurakin & Rubin (2020): Reflection coefficients for fermionic fields
• Garcia et al. (2023): Dark photon interactions
• Hassan et al. (2024): Axion-like particle interactions

2. Primordial Black Hole Theory

• Belotsky et al. (2019): Domain wall collapse mechanisms
• Rubin et al. (2001): Early Universe domain wall dynamics
• Khlopov (2010): Mass constraint theory

3. Advantages of This Work

Compared to existing work, this paper is the first to systematically investigate interactions between scalar dark matter particles and domain walls, discovering a new delayed collapse mechanism.

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Critical Temperature Effect: A characteristic temperature threshold exists that determines domain wall transparency to scalar particles
2. Delayed Formation Mechanism: Scalar particle pressure can cause time delays in primordial black hole formation
3. Parameter Constraints: Model parameter ranges capable of producing primordial black holes are provided
4. Astrophysical Significance: Provides a possible explanation for the existence of supermassive black holes in the early Universe

Limitations

1. Simplified Assumptions: Thin-wall approximation employed, neglecting backreaction of field $\phi$ on domain wall shape
2. Parameter Dependence: Results are sensitive to model parameters, requiring fine-tuning
3. Single Interaction Type: Only scalar particles considered, excluding fermions or gauge fields
4. Classical Treatment: Quantum fluctuations on domain wall dynamics are neglected

Future Directions

1. Multi-field Interactions: Consider couplings of Standard Model particles with domain walls
2. Quantum Effects: Include quantum fluctuations and radiation reaction
3. Numerical Simulations: Three-dimensional numerical simulations to verify analytical results
4. Observational Tests: Search for observable effects such as gravitational wave signals

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Deep Physical Insights: Discovery of transparency phase transition induced by temperature threshold is an important physical phenomenon
2. Rigorous Mathematical Treatment: Systematic derivation of interaction and dynamical equations from field theory
3. Universal Results: Delayed collapse mechanism may apply to other types of topological defects
4. Significant Astrophysical Implications: Provides new theoretical framework for explaining early Universe black holes

Weaknesses

1. Model Complexity: Involves multiple parameters, some requiring artificial tuning to obtain expected results
2. Validity of Approximations: Thin-wall approximation may not be applicable in certain cases
3. Lack of Observational Constraints: Theoretical predictions lack direct observational verification
4. Numerical Precision: Convergence and stability of certain numerical calculations require further verification

Impact

1. Theoretical Contribution: Adds new physical mechanisms to primordial black hole formation theory
2. Interdisciplinary Value: Connects particle physics, cosmology, and astrophysics
3. Practical Prospects: May provide theoretical guidance for dark matter detection and gravitational wave observations
4. Reproducibility: Clear methodology and parameter settings facilitate verification and extension by other researchers

Applicable Scenarios

1. Early Universe Physics: Study of phase transitions and structure formation after inflation
2. Dark Matter Theory: Dynamics of scalar dark matter candidates
3. Black Hole Physics: Primordial black hole formation mechanisms and mass spectra
4. Gravitational Wave Astronomy: Predictions of gravitational wave signals from domain wall collapse

References

This paper cites 27 important references covering observational evidence, theoretical foundations, and numerical methods. Key references include:

1. Belotsky et al. (2019): Foundational theory of domain wall collapse forming primordial black holes
2. Rubin et al. (2001): Pioneering work on early Universe domain wall dynamics
3. Vilenkin & Shellard (2000): Classical textbook on topological defects
4. Particle Data Group (2024): Standard values of cosmological parameters

Summary: This is an important paper contributing to primordial black hole formation theory. By introducing scalar particle interactions with domain walls, it discovers a new delayed collapse mechanism, providing theoretical support for explaining the existence of supermassive black holes in the early Universe. Despite certain theoretical assumptions and parameter dependencies, its physical insights and mathematical treatment achieve high standards, possessing significant academic value and application prospects.