Hydrostatic equilibrium in multi-Weyl semimetals

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2504.20361
• Title: Hydrostatic equilibrium in multi-Weyl semimetals
• Authors: Jewel Kumar Ghosh, Francisco Peña-Benítez, Patricio Salgado-Rebolledo
• Classification: cond-mat.str-el (Condensed Matter Physics - Strongly Correlated Electron Systems), hep-th (High Energy Physics - Theory)
• Submission Date: April 2024, Revised October 2025
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2504.20361

Abstract

This paper investigates the hydrostatic equilibrium of multi-Weyl semimetals, systems characterized by Weyl-like quasiparticles with anisotropic dispersion relations $ω^2 \sim k_\parallel^2 + k_\perp^{2n}$ (where n is a positive integer). Multi-Weyl systems are distinguished by the absence of Lorentz invariance, instead possessing reduced spacetime symmetry $(SO(1,1) × SO(2)) ⋉ R^4$. The authors propose a covariant formulation of the low-energy theory, enabling minimal coupling of fermionic fields to external geometric backgrounds and $U(1)$ gauge fields. The non-Lorentzian field theory structure necessitates the introduction of Aristotelian spacetime analogous to string Newton-Cartan geometry. This approach enables systematic investigation of hydrodynamic properties through derivation of the system's partition function, with applicability extending beyond multi-Weyl models to systems with similar spacetime symmetry groups, such as Bjorken flow.

Research Background and Motivation

Problem Background

Multi-Weyl semimetals (mWSMs) are an emerging class of topological materials with the following characteristics:

1. Anisotropic energy dispersion: Unlike conventional Weyl semimetals exhibiting linear dispersion in all momentum directions, mWSMs display quadratic or cubic dispersion in certain directions
2. Higher-order topological charge: Weyl nodes possess higher topological charge n (n>1)
3. Reduced symmetry: Absence of complete Lorentz invariance, possessing only $(SO(1,1) × SO(2)) ⋉ R^4$ symmetry

Research Motivation

1. Theoretical gap: While gauge anomalies of multi-Weyl fermions have been thoroughly understood, the role of gravitational anomalies remains unexplored
2. Geometric coupling: Understanding the interplay between topology and geometry in these materials requires careful treatment
3. Hydrodynamic description: Establishing a hydrodynamic theory framework applicable to non-Lorentz invariant systems is necessary
4. Broad applicability: The theoretical framework extends to other systems with similar symmetries, such as Bjorken flow

Core Contributions

1. Construction of novel non-Lorentzian curved spacetime: Proposing a geometric background suitable for multi-Weyl particle propagation with $(SO(1,1) × SO(2))$ structure group
2. Development of covariant effective action: Establishing a covariant action compatible with the equivalence principle, curved spacetime, and gauge fields
3. Derivation of Ward identities: Obtaining Ward identities associated with spacetime and internal charges
4. Establishment of constitutive relations: Deriving zeroth-order constitutive relations for conserved currents
5. Provision of universal theoretical framework: The method applies to any system with spacetime group G (fermionic or bosonic)

Detailed Methodology

Symmetry Analysis and Action Principle

Spacetime Symmetry Group

The system's spacetime symmetry group is: $G = (SO(1,1) × SO(2)) ⋉ R^4$

where coordinates decompose as $x^μ = (x^a, x^i)$, with $a = 0,1$ (Lorentzian directions) and $i = 2,3$ (Euclidean directions).

Multi-Weyl Operator

Starting from Weyl fermions with $SU(2)_n$ flavor symmetry, coupled to constant background field $A = \frac{m}{2}δ_{k̄k}τ^{k̄}dx^k$, the multi-Weyl operator in the effective theory is: $D_{eff} = p_a σ^a + m^{1-n}(p_+^n σ_- + p_-^n σ_+)$

where $p_+ = p_1 + ip_2$ is the complex momentum.

Multi-Weyl Particles in Curved Spacetime

Gauge Theory Construction

External fields are encoded as gauge connections valued in the Lie algebra $G × U(1)$: $A = e^A P_A + \frac{1}{2}Ω^{AB} M_{AB} + A Q$

where:

• $e^A$: vierbein (tetrad)
• $Ω^{AB} = Ω ϵ^{AB} + ω ε^{AB}$: spin connection
• $A$: Abelian electromagnetic potential

Torsion Decomposition

A key feature of the geometry is the intrinsic nature of torsion. The torsion two-form decomposes as: $T^A = \stackrel{\circ}{T}^A + \hat{T}^A$

where $\stackrel{\circ}{T}^A$ is intrinsic torsion (depending only on anholonomy coefficients) and $\hat{T}^A$ is extrinsic torsion (depending on the spin connection).

Effective Action and Conserved Currents

The action for minimal coupling theory is: $S = \int \text{Re} \bar{φ}\left[i\not{D}_\parallel + m^{1-n}(i\not{D}_\perp)^n\right]φ \, dV$

where $\not{D}_\parallel = E_a^μ γ^a D_μ$ and $\not{D}_\perp = E_i^μ γ^i D_μ$.

Conserved current operators are obtained through variation with respect to external fields: $δS = \int_M \left(δe^A ∧ ⋆T_A + δΩ ∧ ⋆S + δω ∧ ⋆J + δA ∧ ⋆J\right)$

Thermodynamic Equilibrium and Partition Function

Thermodynamic Variable Definition

For systems with reduced boost symmetry, the first law of thermodynamics is: $dE = TdS + α dP + μdQ - PdV$

where $α$ is the momentum chemical potential corresponding to the $P_3$ charge.

Hydrostatic Equilibrium Conditions

Equilibrium states are defined through Killing parameters $χ_K = (ξ_K, λ^{AB}_K, λ^{(Q)}_K)$, constructing the fluid velocity: $U^A = u^A + α v^A$

where:

• $β^2 = -g(ξ_K, ξ_K)$ (inverse temperature)
• $\bar{α}^2 = h(ξ_K, ξ_K)$ (reduced momentum chemical potential)

Zeroth-Order Constitutive Relations

The constitutive relations for ideal fluids are: $J^μ = ρU^μ$$S^μ = ρ^{(S)}U^μ$$J^μ = ρ^{(L)}U^μ$$T^μ_A = (\tilde{E}u_A + p\hat{v}_A)U^μ + P Δ^μ_A$

where various densities are defined through partial derivatives of pressure with respect to corresponding chemical potentials.

Experimental Verification and Applications

Material Realization

Multi-Weyl semimetals are expected to be realized in actual materials, such as:

• HgCr₂Se₄: Predicted to possess quadruple Weyl points
• SrSi₂: Another candidate material

Transport Properties

Transport phenomena predicted by the theory include:

1. Chiral magnetic effect: Enhanced by topological charge factor n
2. Vortex effects: Anisotropic response
3. Strain response: Behavior distinct from conventional Weyl semimetals

Related Work

Modern Description of Hydrodynamics

• Partition function method: Ideal fluid description developed by Jensen et al.
• Schwinger-Keldysh effective action: Description of dissipative systems
• Anomalous transport: Role of gauge and gravitational anomalies in chiral fluids

Non-Lorentzian Geometry

• Newton-Cartan spacetime: Background for Galilean field theories
• Aristotelian geometry: Theories lacking boost symmetry
• String Newton-Cartan geometry: Analogue of the geometry in this work

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Successfully constructed a covariant hydrodynamic theory for multi-Weyl semimetals
2. Established a geometric framework suitable for systems with reduced symmetry
3. Derived complete thermodynamic relations and constitutive equations
4. Demonstrated the universality of the theory for systems like Bjorken flow

Limitations

1. Ideal fluid approximation: Considers only non-dissipative effects
2. Anomaly neglect: Does not include gravitational anomaly contributions
3. Linear response: Limited to zeroth-order approximation

Future Directions

1. Anomalous transport: Systematic study of gravitational anomaly effects
2. Strain effects: Understanding geometric field response to strain
3. Non-equilibrium dynamics: Extension to Schwinger-Keldysh framework
4. Holographic duality: Utilizing gauge/gravity duality to study strong coupling regime

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Theoretical innovation: First complete geometric-hydrodynamic framework for multi-Weyl systems
2. Mathematical rigor: Detailed geometric construction and Ward identity derivation
3. Strong universality: Method applicable to broad class of non-boost invariant systems
4. Physical intuition: Clear thermodynamic interpretation and constitutive relations

Weaknesses

1. Lack of experimental verification: Theoretical predictions await experimental confirmation
2. High complexity: Geometric construction is quite technical, potentially limiting applications
3. Approximation limitations: Zeroth-order approximation may be insufficient for describing actual material behavior

Impact

This work establishes important foundations for hydrodynamic theory of non-Lorentz invariant systems, expected to advance:

1. Development of topological semimetal theory
2. New methods in non-equilibrium statistical mechanics
3. Cross-disciplinary research between high-energy physics and condensed matter physics

Applicable Scenarios

1. Multi-Weyl semimetals: Direct application target
2. Bjorken flow: Hydrodynamics in heavy-ion collisions
3. Fractonic fluids: Systems with dipole symmetry
4. Strain engineering: Geometric control of topological materials

References

The paper cites 63 important references spanning multiple fields including topological semimetals, hydrodynamic theory, and non-Lorentzian geometry, providing a solid theoretical foundation for this interdisciplinary research.