Probing fractional quantum Hall effect by photoluminescence

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2505.01577
• Title: Probing fractional quantum Hall effect by photoluminescence
• Authors: Aamir A. Makki, Mytraya Gattu, and J. K. Jain (Pennsylvania State University)
• Classification: cond-mat.str-el (Condensed Matter Physics - Strongly Correlated Electron Systems)
• Submission Date: January 2025
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2505.01577

Abstract

The recently discovered fractional quantum anomalous Hall (FQAH) states in twisted transition metal dichalcogenide (TMD) bilayers—fractional quantum Hall states achievable without external magnetic fields—represent a major advance in condensed matter physics. These states were first observed through photoluminescence (PL) spectroscopy. Surprisingly, even for standard fractional quantum Hall (FQH) states, a general theoretical understanding of PL is lacking. This study reveals that for ideal two-dimensional systems, the energy of emitted photons is independent of correlations, but PL intensity contains valuable information. Specifically, at finite temperatures, PL intensity peaks at Jain filling factors ν = n/(2n±1), and the temperature dependence of intensity away from these filling factors can be used to derive the binding energies of composite fermion excitons and triplons.

Research Background and Motivation

Problem Definition

1. Core Issue: Lack of theoretical understanding of photoluminescence phenomena in the fractional quantum Hall effect, particularly in the context of newly discovered fractional quantum anomalous Hall states
2. Significance: The discovery of FQAH states opens a new frontier in field-free fractional quantum Hall physics, with PL as the primary probe
3. Existing Limitations: Theoretical studies have been restricted to small systems (<10 electrons) amenable to exact diagonalization, unable to represent thermodynamic behavior
4. Research Motivation: Utilize composite fermion (CF) theory to provide comprehensive understanding in the thermodynamic limit, revealing the physical picture of CF excitons and CF triplons

Experimental Background

• Multiple Jain fractions of FQAH states identified in twisted TMD bilayers through PL and reflectance spectroscopy
• PL experiments in GaAs quantum wells showing structural features related to FQHE
• Need for theoretical framework to explain these experimental observations

Core Contributions

1. Established a complete CF theoretical framework for describing photoluminescence in FQHE
2. Identified "bright" and "dark" states: Proved that ground states at all Jain filling factors except ν̄=1/3 are dark states at T=0
3. Predicted filling factor dependence of PL intensity: Intensity maxima appear at Jain filling factors
4. Revealed formation mechanisms of CF excitons and CF triplons and methods for measuring their binding energies
5. Analyzed effects of SU(2) symmetry breaking, demonstrating robustness of main conclusions
6. Provided specific predictions for experimental comparison, particularly for TMD systems

Detailed Methodology

Theoretical Framework

Pseudospin Model

The paper employs a pseudospin model, labeling conduction and valence band Landau levels as pseudospin ↑ and ↓ states respectively, with band gap Eg as pseudoZeeman splitting. PL intensity is given by:

$P(\omega) \propto \sum_{\alpha,i} e^{-E^{in}_i/T} |\langle\phi^f_\alpha|\hat{P}|\psi^{in}_i\rangle|^2 \delta(\omega - (E^{in}_i + E_g - E^f_\alpha))$

where $\hat{P} = \sum_m \psi^\dagger_\downarrow(m)\psi_\uparrow(m)$ is the pseudospin lowering operator.

Importance of SU(2) Symmetry

In the ideal limit (B→∞, zero thickness, no disorder), interactions are pseudospin-independent, and the system possesses SU(2) symmetry. In this case, $\hat{P}$ commutes with the Hamiltonian, and emitted photon energy equals the band gap, containing no correlation information. However, PL intensity still carries important physical information.

CF Theory Application

Bright and Dark State Classification

• Dark states: $(S,S_z) = (N/2-1, N/2-1)$, annihilated by $S_z$ raising operators, prohibiting electron-hole recombination
• Bright states: $(S,S_z) = (N/2, N/2-1)$, obtainable by applying $S_-$ operator to $(S,S_z) = (N/2, N/2)$ sector

Fock Cycle Condition

Employs Fock cycle condition to determine state properties: if a wavefunction is annihilated upon further antisymmetrization, the state is a highest-weight state satisfying $S = S_z$.

Numerical Methods

Composite Fermion Diagonalization (CFD)

Constructs CF ground states in spherical geometry, including:

• Quasiparticle-quasihole pairs in different ΛL
• Calculation of overlap and Hamiltonian matrices
• Solution of generalized eigenvalue problems

Exact Diagonalization (ED) Verification

Validates CF theory predictions through ED results on small systems.

Experimental Setup

Computational Parameters

• Geometry: Spherical geometry with electrons on a sphere in radial magnetic field
• Interaction: Coulomb interaction, with energy measured in magnetic length units
• System Size: Exact diagonalization for N ≤ 16 electrons, CF calculations for larger systems
• Filling Factor Range: Focus on ν̄ = n/(2n±1) and vicinity

Comparison Methods

• Non-interacting CF model as baseline
• Exact diagonalization as benchmark
• Comparison across different CF bases

Experimental Results

Main Findings

1. Pseudospin Magnon Dispersion

Lowest pseudospin wave mode dispersion obtained through CFD:

• ν̄ = 1/3: Ground state is bright (L=0)
• ν̄ = 2/5, 3/7: Ground state is dark, dispersion exhibits roton minimum
• ν̄ = 2/3: Lowest bright and dark state energies equal within numerical error

2. Energy Gap ∆ Calculation

Define ∆ = E^bright_0 - E_0, where E_0 is ground state energy. Thermodynamic extrapolation results:

• ν̄ = 2/5: ∆ = 0.0012(3) (CFD), ≈0.007 (ED)
• ν̄ = 3/7: ∆ = 0.0066(3) (CFD)

3. Filling Factor Dependence

Figure 4 shows ∆ variation with filling factor:

• ∆ reaches local minima at Jain filling factors
• Discontinuous change in ∆ at ν̄ = n/(2n+1) produces asymmetric peaks
• PL intensity proportional to e^(-∆/T)

Ablation Studies

CF Basis Selection Effects

• Type (i) and (ii) states: CFKE conserved
• Type (iii) states: Lower CFKE, necessarily dark
• Type (iv) states: Higher CFKE, minor impact on low-energy spectrum

SU(2) Symmetry Breaking Effects

When V↑↓ = κV↑↑ (κ < 1):

• Main peaks evolve continuously
• Additional low-intensity side peaks appear
• Main conclusions remain valid at κ = 0.8
• Spin roton energy gap for ν̄ = 2/5 disappears at κ = 0.5

Comparison with Experiments

TMD Systems

In σ-configuration, experiments observe signal only at νh = -2/3, corresponding to theoretical prediction ν̄ = 1/3, consistent with zero-temperature limit prediction.

GaAs Systems

Experimentally observed peak positions show slight shifts relative to theoretical predictions, possibly due to:

• Finite transverse width breaking SU(2) symmetry
• Incomplete thermalization before recombination

Related Work

Theoretical Studies

• Early PL theory work by MacDonald et al.
• Anyon exciton theory by Rashba et al.
• Charged exciton studies by Wójs et al.
• Main limitation: Small system exact diagonalization studies

Experimental Studies

• PL observations in GaAs heterostructures
• Discovery of FQAH states in TMD bilayers
• Resonant inelastic light scattering experiments

CF Theory Development

• Jain's composite fermion theory
• Studies of spin-polarized CF systems
• Theory of mixed-spin incompressible states

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Theoretical Framework Established: First complete CF theoretical description of PL phenomena in FQHE
2. Dark State Mechanism: All Jain filling factors except ν̄ = 1/3 are dark states at T=0
3. Temperature Activation: PL intensity follows e^(-∆/T) dependence, usable for measuring CF exciton/triplon binding energies
4. Experimental Predictions: Provides specific theoretical predictions for PL experiments in TMD and GaAs systems

Physical Picture

• CF Exciton: Electron-hole pair converted to CF particle and hole, forming bound state
• CF Triplon: Away from Jain filling factors, CF exciton binds with existing anyons
• Symmetry Role: SU(2) symmetry determines emitted photon energy, but intensity contains correlation information

Limitations

1. Idealized Assumptions: Assumes B→∞ limit and perfect two-dimensional system
2. SU(2) Symmetry: Actual systems may have symmetry breaking
3. Thermalization Assumption: Assumes complete thermalization to ground state before recombination
4. CF Theory Accuracy: Lower precision for reverse-flux states like ν̄ = 2/3

Future Directions

1. Finite Thickness Effects: Consider quantum well finite width effects
2. Stronger Symmetry Breaking: Study strong SU(2) breaking cases
3. Experimental Verification: Detailed comparison with TMD and GaAs experiments
4. Extended Applications: Generalize to other fractional quantum Hall systems

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Theoretical Innovation: First systematic application of CF theory to PL problems, providing novel theoretical perspective
2. Complete Methodology: Combines analytical CF theory with numerical CFD/ED methods, covering small systems to thermodynamic limit
3. Physical Insights: Clearly reveals physical nature of novel quasiparticle states like CF excitons and CF triplons
4. Experimental Relevance: Provides important theoretical support for current hot-topic TMD FQAH research
5. Technical Rigor: Uses strict methods like Fock cycle conditions to determine state properties

Weaknesses

1. Model Limitations: Idealized assumptions may diverge from actual experimental conditions
2. Numerical Precision: CF theory has limited accuracy for certain states (e.g., ν̄ = 2/3)
3. Experimental Verification: Quantitative comparison with existing experiments insufficient
4. Applicable Scope: Primarily focuses on Jain sequence, limited coverage of other fractional states

Impact

1. Academic Value: Opens new direction for optical property research in FQHE
2. Practical Significance: Provides theoretical basis for interpreting PL experiments in TMD systems
3. Methodological Contribution: CF theory application to optical problems has exemplary significance
4. Future Development: May promote more cross-disciplinary research between optics and strongly correlated electron systems

Applicable Scenarios

1. TMD Bilayers: Directly applicable to PL studies of FQAH states in twisted TMD
2. GaAs Quantum Wells: Applicable to PL analysis of traditional FQHE systems
3. Graphene Bilayers: Generalizable to other two-dimensional material systems
4. Theoretical Research: Provides methodological reference for other optical-quantum Hall problems

References

The paper cites 57 important references, primarily including:

• Foundational FQHE theory literature (Jain, Haldane, etc.)
• PL experimental observation literature (Turberfield, Goldberg, etc.)
• Recent FQAH discovery literature in TMD (Cai, Zeng, Anderson, etc.)
• Key CF theory development literature (Park, Balram, etc.)

Overall Assessment: This is a high-quality theoretical physics paper making pioneering contributions to the important but relatively underdeveloped field of optical properties in FQHE. The paper is theoretically rigorous, methodologically innovative, and results-rich, providing powerful tools for understanding and predicting related experimental phenomena. Despite limitations from certain idealized assumptions, the established theoretical framework possesses significant academic value and practical importance.