Smarr formula for black holes with primary and secondary scalar hair

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2505.02368
• Title: Smarr formula for black holes with primary and secondary scalar hair
• Authors: Yun Soo Myung (Sogang University), Theodoros Nakas (Institute for Basic Science)
• Classification: gr-qc (General Relativity and Quantum Cosmology), hep-th (High Energy Physics - Theory)
• Publication Date: May 5, 2025 (arXiv preprint)
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2505.02368

Abstract

This paper revisits the thermodynamics of black holes with primary and secondary scalar hair in the shift and Z₂ symmetric subclass of beyond-Horndeski gravity theory. Through specific fine-tuning of the scalar parameter q relative to the black hole mass, singular black hole solutions with primary scalar hair can be simplified to regular Bardeen solutions with secondary scalar hair. The authors first demonstrate that conventional thermodynamic methods fail to produce consistent Smarr formulas for both solutions under consideration. To address this issue, the method introduced in Phys.Rev.Lett. 132 (2024) 19, 191401 is employed to derive the first law of black hole thermodynamics and the Smarr formula, providing a consistent thermodynamic description for scalar-haired black holes. As an additional result, the analysis reveals the connection between primary and secondary scalar hair solutions.

Research Background and Motivation

Core Problems

1. Challenge to the No-Scalar-Hair Theorem: The traditional no-scalar-hair theorem states that black holes are completely characterized by mass, angular momentum, and electric charge. However, research over the past two decades has demonstrated that black holes can indeed acquire scalar hair in modified gravity theories.
2. Thermodynamic Consistency Issue: While the thermodynamic analysis of black holes in general relativity is well-established, extending the same analysis to solutions from modified gravity theories is not always straightforward and sometimes fails to produce meaningful results.
3. Difficulties with the Smarr Formula: For black hole solutions from scalar-tensor theories, it is difficult to satisfy the Smarr formula, which describes a specific decomposition of black hole mass involving thermodynamic quantities such as temperature and entropy, as well as other physical quantities like angular velocity and electric potential.

Research Significance

• Theoretical Completeness: Establishing a complete thermodynamic framework for black holes in modified gravity theories is crucial for understanding the deeper nature of gravity
• Regular Black Holes: For regular black holes (compact objects with an event horizon but no interior singularity), the first law of black hole thermodynamics requires modification
• Classification of Scalar Hair: Distinguishing the thermodynamic properties of primary scalar hair (additional parameters independent of mass) and secondary scalar hair (completely determined by black hole mass)

Core Contributions

1. Demonstration of Traditional Method Failure: Systematically proves that conventional thermodynamic methods fail to produce consistent Smarr formulas for black holes with primary and secondary scalar hair
2. Application of New Thermodynamic Framework: Successfully applies the method proposed by Hajian and Tekin, promoting dimensional coupling constants to conserved charges, resolving the consistency problem of the Smarr formula
3. Unified Thermodynamic Description: Establishes a complete first law of thermodynamics and Smarr formula for scalar-haired black holes in beyond-Horndeski gravity
4. Connection Between Primary and Secondary Scalar Hair: Reveals the deep connection between the two classes of scalar hair solutions, indicating they share a common underlying origin

Detailed Methodology

Theoretical Framework

The research is based on beyond-Horndeski gravity theory with shift (φ→φ+const.) and Z₂ (φ→-φ) symmetries, with the action given by:

$S = \frac{1}{16\pi} \int d^4x \sqrt{-g} (L_H^2 + L_H^4 + L_{bH})$

where:

• $L_H^2 = G_2(X)$ (Horndeski term)
• $L_H^4 = G_4(X)R + G_{4X}[(\square\phi)^2 - (\nabla_\mu\nabla_\nu\phi)(\nabla^\mu\nabla^\nu\phi)]$ (Horndeski term)
• $L_{bH} = F_4(X)\epsilon^{\mu\nu\rho\sigma}\epsilon_{\alpha\beta\gamma\sigma}\partial_\mu\phi\partial^\alpha\phi(\nabla_\nu\nabla^\beta\phi)(\nabla_\rho\nabla^\gamma\phi)$ (beyond-Horndeski term)

Black Hole Solution Construction

Primary Scalar Hair Solution

For specific model function choices: $G_2(X) = -\frac{2\eta}{\lambda^2}X^{5/2}, \quad G_4(X) = 1-\eta X^{5/2}, \quad F_4(X) = \eta\sqrt{X}$

The black hole solution is obtained: $ds^2 = -h(r)dt^2 + \frac{dr^2}{h(r)} + r^2d\Omega^2$

$h(r) = 1 - \frac{2M}{r} + \frac{\sqrt{2}\eta q^5}{3}\frac{\lambda}{r}\left(1 - \frac{r^3}{(r^2+\lambda^2)^{3/2}}\right)$

where q is the primary scalar hair parameter independent of mass M.

Secondary Scalar Hair Solution (Bardeen Solution)

By fine-tuning $q^5 = \frac{3\sqrt{2}M}{\eta\lambda}$, the above solution simplifies to the regular Bardeen solution:

$\bar{h}(r) = 1 - \frac{2Mr^2}{(r^2+\lambda^2)^{3/2}}$

In this case, the scalar charge is completely determined by mass M, constituting secondary scalar hair.

New Thermodynamic Method

Problems with Traditional Approach

Traditional thermodynamic analysis reveals:

1. For primary scalar hair, the Smarr relation cannot be satisfied: $M \neq c_s T_H S + c_q \Phi_q q$
2. For the Bardeen solution, the first law fails: $T_H \neq T_h \equiv \frac{1}{4\pi}\frac{d\bar{h}}{dr}|_{r=r_h}$

New Method: Promotion of Coupling Constants

Adopting the Hajian-Tekin method, dimensional coupling constants η and λ are promoted to free parameters. By introducing auxiliary fields, they become conserved charges without modifying the background solution.

For primary scalar hair, introducing the dimensionless parameter $\xi \equiv \eta q^5$, it is found that $\Phi_q dq + \Phi_\eta d\eta = 0$, indicating that η and q are not independent. The first law simplifies to:

$dM = T_H dS + \Phi_\lambda d\lambda$

For the Bardeen solution, the first law is directly obtained as:

$dM = T_H dS + \Phi_\lambda d\lambda$

Experimental Results

Verification of the First Law of Thermodynamics

Primary Scalar Hair

• Surface Energy: $E_s = \frac{\sqrt{S}}{2\sqrt{\pi}}$
• λ-related Energy: $E_\lambda = \frac{\xi\lambda}{3\sqrt{2}}\left[1 - \frac{S^{3/2}}{(S+\pi\lambda^2)^{3/2}}\right]$
• Mass Decomposition: $M = E_s + E_\lambda$
• Smarr Formula: $M = 2T_H S + \Phi_\lambda \lambda$

Secondary Scalar Hair (Bardeen Solution)

• Surface Energy: $E_s = \frac{\sqrt{S}}{2\sqrt{\pi}}$
• λ-related Energy: $E_\lambda = \frac{(S+\pi\lambda^2)^{3/2} - S^{3/2}}{2\sqrt{\pi S}}$
• Mass Decomposition: $M = E_s + E_\lambda$
• Smarr Formula: $M = 2T_H S + \Phi_\lambda \lambda$

Key Findings

1. Formal Consistency: The first law and Smarr formula for primary and secondary scalar hair have exactly the same form, suggesting a common underlying origin
2. Internal Energy Interpretation: In both cases, black hole mass can be interpreted as the internal energy of the system
3. Connection Relation: The connection between the λ parameter and primary scalar hair is established through the relation $\lambda = Q_s q$

Related Work

Development of No-Scalar-Hair Theorem

• Classical no-scalar-hair theorem by Bekenstein and others
• Recent discoveries of scalar hair in modified gravity theories
• Development of Horndeski and beyond-Horndeski gravity theories

Black Hole Thermodynamics

• Establishment of the Bekenstein-Hawking entropy formula
• Original derivation of the Smarr formula
• Challenges of thermodynamics in modified gravity theories

Regular Black Holes

• Classical studies of the Bardeen solution
• Origins in nonlinear electromagnetism theory
• Reinterpretation in scalar-tensor theories

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Method Validity: The Hajian-Tekin method successfully resolves the thermodynamic consistency problem for scalar-haired black holes, providing a new framework for black hole thermodynamics in modified gravity theories
2. Unified Description: Establishes a unified thermodynamic description for primary and secondary scalar-haired black holes, revealing the intrinsic connection between them
3. Theoretical Insight: Demonstrates that by appropriately handling coupling constants, the fundamental principles of black hole thermodynamics, including the first law and Smarr formula, can be recovered

Limitations

1. Specific Theory: The research is limited to a specific subclass of beyond-Horndeski gravity, requiring verification of the method's applicability in other modified gravity theories
2. Static Case: Only static, spherically symmetric black holes are considered; the case of rotating black holes requires further investigation
3. Parameter Tuning: The transition from primary to secondary scalar hair requires specific parameter fine-tuning, and the physical significance of this tuning needs deeper understanding

Future Directions

1. Extended Applications: Apply the method to other modified gravity theories and more general black hole solutions
2. Dynamical Studies: Investigate the dynamical evolution and stability of scalar-haired black holes
3. Observational Effects: Explore the impact of scalar hair on the observational characteristics of black holes

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Theoretical Innovation: Successfully applies a new thermodynamic framework, resolving the long-standing consistency problem in the thermodynamics of scalar-haired black holes
2. Mathematical Rigor: Detailed and rigorous calculations clearly demonstrate the failure of traditional methods and the success of the new approach
3. Physical Insight: Reveals the deep connection between primary and secondary scalar hair, providing important theoretical insights
4. Practical Value: Provides practical thermodynamic tools for black hole research in modified gravity theories

Weaknesses

1. Scope of Applicability: The universality of the method requires verification within a broader theoretical framework
2. Physical Interpretation: The physical significance of promoting coupling constants to conserved charges requires deeper discussion
3. Experimental Verification: Lacks experimental or observational verification pathways

Impact

1. Theoretical Contribution: Opens new directions for black hole thermodynamics research in modified gravity theories
2. Methodological Value: Provides a general method for handling thermodynamic problems in modified gravity theories
3. Interdisciplinary Connection: Connects multiple research fields including gravity theory, black hole physics, and thermodynamics

Applicable Scenarios

• Black hole thermodynamics research in modified gravity theories
• Theoretical analysis of scalar-tensor theories
• Thermodynamic property studies of regular black holes
• Applications of beyond-Horndeski gravity theory

References

The paper cites 28 important references, covering:

• Classical works on the no-scalar-hair theorem 1,2
• Horndeski and beyond-Horndeski gravity theories 4-8
• Foundational literature on black hole thermodynamics 13-15,20
• Latest thermodynamic methods 21
• Related research on the Bardeen solution 19,22

Summary: This is a high-quality theoretical physics paper that successfully resolves the thermodynamic consistency problem for scalar-haired black holes in modified gravity theories. By adopting a new thermodynamic framework, it not only establishes a complete thermodynamic description but also reveals the deep connections between different types of scalar hair solutions. This work provides important theoretical tools and new research directions for black hole studies in modified gravity theories.