Stabilizing dark matter with quantum scale symmetry

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2505.02803
• Title: Stabilizing dark matter with quantum scale symmetry
• Authors: Abhishek Chikkaballi, Kamila Kowalska, Rafael R. Lino dos Santos, Enrico Maria Sessolo (National Centre for Nuclear Research, Warsaw, Poland)
• Classification: hep-ph (High Energy Physics - Phenomenology)
• Publication Date: May 2025 (arXiv v2: October 11, 2025)
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2505.02803

Abstract

Within the framework of gauge-Yukawa theories with trans-Planckian asymptotic safety, quantum scale symmetry can prevent couplings that are otherwise allowed by gauge symmetry from appearing in the Lagrangian. These couplings correspond to irrelevant Gaussian fixed points of the renormalization group flow. Their absence in the theory implies that different sectors of the gauge-Yukawa theory are decoupled from each other, mimicking the effects of global or discrete symmetries. As an example, the authors impose trans-Planckian scale symmetry on a grand unified model based on the SU(6) gauge group, demonstrating that this leads to the emergence of several fermionic WIMP dark matter candidates whose coupling strengths are entirely predicted by UV completeness.

Research Background and Motivation

Core Problems

1. Dark Matter Stability Problem: Traditional non-supersymmetric grand unified theories (GUTs) typically do not contain fermionic dark matter candidates, requiring the introduction of additional global or discrete symmetries to ensure dark matter stability.
2. Naturalness of Coupling Parameters: Many BSM theories require extremely small Yukawa couplings (e.g., O(10⁻¹³)) to explain certain phenomena, but these tiny values are difficult to produce naturally within conventional frameworks.
3. UV Completeness and Predictability: How to construct particle physics models that possess both UV completeness under quantum gravity effects and make testable predictions.

Research Significance

• Theoretical Unification: Combining asymptotic safety of quantum gravity with grand unification of particle physics
• Predictive Power: Predicting low-energy physical parameters through UV boundary conditions, enhancing theoretical testability
• Naturalness: Providing a natural explanation mechanism for dark matter stability without artificially introducing symmetries

Limitations of Existing Approaches

• Traditional GUTs require artificially introducing Z₂ or other discrete symmetries to stabilize dark matter
• Certain Yukawa couplings in existing models need to be manually tuned to extremely small values
• Lack of systematic methods connecting quantum gravity effects with low-energy phenomenology

Core Contributions

1. Proposes Quantum Scale Symmetry Mechanism: Demonstrates how trans-Planckian asymptotic safety forbids certain gauge-allowed couplings through irrelevant Gaussian fixed points
2. Constructs SU(6) GUT Model: Develops a grand unified model based on SU(6)→SU(5)×U(1)ₓ→SM that naturally contains dark matter candidates
3. Achieves Fully Predictive Dark Matter Sector: The strengths of all BSM Yukawa couplings are entirely determined by UV completeness, with only mass scales requiring observational determination
4. Provides Novel Dark Matter Stabilization Scheme: Naturally achieves sector isolation through quantum scale symmetry without introducing additional symmetries

Detailed Methodology

Theoretical Framework

Asymptotic Safety Foundation: At trans-Planckian energy scales, renormalization group equations are modified by gravitational corrections:

dg_i/dt = β^(matter)_i - f_g g_i
dy_j/dt = β^(matter)_j - f_y y_j

where f_g and f_y are universal gravitational correction parameters.

Quantum Scale Symmetry Mechanism:

• When RG flow develops fixed points, couplings are classified by their scaling behavior
• Irrelevant couplings (θ < 0): IR attractive, providing predictions
• Relevant couplings (θ > 0): UV attractive, becoming free parameters
• Marginal couplings (θ = 0): requiring higher-order analysis

SU(6) Model Construction

Particle Content:

• Fermions: Per generation including 6̄₁^(F), 6̄₂^(F), 15^(F)
• Scalars: 6₁^(S), 6₂^(S), 15^(S), 21^(S), 35^(S)

Symmetry Breaking Chain:

SU(6) → SU(5)×U(1)_X → SU(3)_c×SU(2)_L×U(1)_Y×U(1)_X

Yukawa Lagrangian:

L ⊃ Σ_{i,j} y_{ij} 15^(F) 6̄_i^(F) 6̄_j^(S) + other terms + H.c.

Fixed Point Analysis

Trans-Planckian Fixed Point: The system at f_y = 0.016 exhibits fixed point solutions showing:

• 8 irrelevant eigendirections (predictive)
• 2 marginal directions
• 1 relevant direction (free parameter)

Sector Decoupling: Quantum scale symmetry forbids mixing terms y₁₂ = y₂₁ = 0, leading to mass matrix diagonalization:

M_f = (1/√2) * [y₁₁v₁  0    ]
                [0      y₂₂v₂]

Experimental Predictions and Phenomenology

Dark Matter Candidates

Singlet Fermionic DM (v_ < v_):

• Mass: m_DM ≃ √2 y_{ν2} v_
• Annihilation via Z' resonance: m_Z' ≈ 2m_DM
• Mass range: 2.5-5 TeV (Figure 5)

Doublet Fermionic DM (v_ ≪ v_):

• Analogous to supersymmetric Higgsino
• Predicted mass: m_DM ≈ 1.1 TeV
• Mass splitting constraint: δm_DM ≥ 200 keV

Coupling Predictions

Irrelevant Yukawa coupling predictions at μ = 1 TeV:

• y_u = 0.69, y_D = 1.1, y_L = 0.55
• y_{ν1} = 0.57, y_{ν2} = 0.51
• U(1)_X gauge coupling: g_X(1 TeV) = 0.07

Mass Matrices

Neutral Fermion Mass Matrix:

M_ν = (1/2√2) * [Complex 5×5 matrix containing light-heavy neutrino mixing]

The lightest neutrino remains massless, with heavy Majorana neutrinos forming the dark sector.

Numerical Results and Constraints

RG Flow Analysis

• Figure 2 displays coupling evolution from deep UV to electroweak scale
• Low-energy predictions show weak dependence on gravitational parameters f_g, f_y
• "Focusing" behavior: irrelevant couplings driven by relevant gauge couplings

Dark Matter Abundance Constraints

• Singlet DM: ⟨σv⟩ ≳ 2.15×10⁻²⁶ cm³/s
• Z' mass constraint: 5 TeV ≲ m_Z' ≲ 9 TeV
• Doublet DM: inelastic scattering limits m_Z' ≲ 50 TeV

Scalar Sector

The authors discuss three possible gravitational correction scenarios:

• Scenario A: f_λ ≪ -2 (completely irrelevant, conflicts with phenomenology)
• Scenario B: -1 ≲ f_λ < 0 (mixed case)
• Scenario C: f_λ ≫ 0 (all relevant, adopted in this work)

Related Work

Asymptotic Safety Research

• Pioneering work by Reuter et al. establishing asymptotic safety of gravity
• Subsequent developments extending it to matter-gravity systems
• This work belongs to the series applying AS to specific BSM models

GUTs and Dark Matter

• Traditional SU(N) GUTs lack natural fermionic dark matter candidates
• SO(10) models can contain fermionic DM but require specific symmetry breaking
• This work provides systematic schemes for SU(6) and higher-rank SU(N) groups

Quantum Gravity Phenomenology

• Early successes include Higgs mass predictions, top quark mass, etc.
• Recent work extends to flavor physics, neutrino masses, dark matter, etc.
• This work contributes a novel symmetry protection mechanism

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Quantum Scale Symmetry Replaces Artificial Symmetries: Naturally forbids certain couplings through irrelevant Gaussian fixed points, achieving sector decoupling
2. Fully Predictive Dark Matter Sector: All interaction strengths except mass scales are determined by UV completeness
3. Robust Phenomenological Predictions: Low-energy predictions are insensitive to uncertainties in gravitational calculations

Technical Advantages

• Maximum Predictive Power: 8 irrelevant directions vs. 1 relevant direction
• Natural Small Couplings: Extremely small Yukawa couplings produced through exponential suppression mechanisms
• Testability: Mass scales constrained through relic abundance and other observables

Limitations

1. Simplified Scalar Sector: Incomplete fixed point analysis of scalar potential
2. Single-Loop Approximation: Higher-order corrections may affect marginal coupling behavior
3. Gravitational Parameter Uncertainty: Despite robust predictions, still depends on f_y ≠ 0 assumption

Future Directions

1. Complete scalar potential FRG analysis
2. Extension to higher-rank SU(N) groups
3. Detailed dark matter phenomenology including multi-component dark matter
4. Possible connections with gravitational wave signals

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Conceptual Innovation: First systematic application of quantum scale symmetry as a dark matter stabilization mechanism
2. Theoretical Consistency: Successfully combines asymptotic safe quantum gravity with grand unification
3. Strong Predictive Power: Provides concrete, testable phenomenological predictions
4. Technical Rigor: Detailed RG analysis and fixed point calculations

Weaknesses

1. Scalar Sector Treatment: Relatively simplified treatment of scalar potential, potentially affecting completeness
2. Phenomenological Constraints: Some experimental constraints could be treated more precisely
3. Model Dependence: Results sensitive to specific SU(6) model choices

Impact

• Theoretical Significance: Opens new research directions for quantum gravity phenomenology
• Practical Value: Applicable to other GUT models and dark matter theories
• Reproducibility: Provides detailed computational details and parameters

Applicable Scenarios

1. BSM theories requiring natural dark matter stabilization mechanisms
2. Grand unified models seeking UV completeness
3. Phenomenological studies of quantum gravity effects

References

The paper cites 120 relevant references, covering:

• Fundamental asymptotic safety theory 1-29
• Quantum gravity phenomenology applications 34-58
• Grand unification and dark matter 64-70
• Renormalization group techniques 97-99

This work provides an innovative stabilization mechanism for dark matter theory, demonstrating how quantum gravity effects manifest in low-energy physics, representing an important contribution to the interdisciplinary field of quantum gravity and particle physics.