Probing Vortex Dynamics in 2D Superconductors with Scanning Quantum Microscope

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2505.03003
• Title: Probing Vortex Dynamics in 2D Superconductors with Scanning Quantum Microscope
• Authors: Sreehari Jayaram, Malik Lenger, Dong Zhao, Lucas Pupim, Takashi Taniguchi, Kenji Watanabe, Ruoming Peng, Marc Scheffler, Rainer Stöhr, Mathias S. Scheurer, Jurgen Smet, Jörg Wrachtrup
• Classification: cond-mat.supr-con cond-mat.mtrl-sci quant-ph
• Publication Date: September 24, 2025 (arXiv:2505.03003v2)
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2505.03003

Abstract

This study employs scanning quantum microscopy to investigate the local magnetic response of the two-dimensional superconductor 2H-NbSe₂. The technique enables static and dynamic sensing of superconducting vortices with 30-nanometer spatial resolution, revealing unexpected phenomena related to the intrinsic properties of 2D superconductors. The research demonstrates that vortices do not arrange into a hexagonal lattice but instead form a distorted vortex glass state with extended vortex sizes. Vortices exhibit strong local dynamical behavior due to thermal excitations. Upon approaching the critical temperature, pronounced melting of the vortex glass is observed, producing different configurations under different cooling conditions. Through spin Hahn echo measurements, vortex fluctuations are detected, revealing spin decoherence phenomena that persist even well below the critical temperature, with enhanced decoherence at lower temperatures.

Research Background and Motivation

Problem Description

Vortex behavior in 2D superconductors differs significantly from bulk superconductors. In bulk Type-II superconductors, externally applied magnetic field-induced vortices form ordered hexagonal lattices (Abrikosov vortex crystals). However, in 2D superconductors, vortex behavior becomes complex due to thickness-related strong confinement effects, enhanced sensitivity to disorder, and quantum correlation effects.

Significance

1. Fundamental Scientific Value: 2D superconductors provide a versatile platform for exploring novel interactions and quantum phenomena
2. Technical Challenges: Conventional nanoscale probing techniques (such as STM, MFM, nano-SQUIDs) cannot simultaneously provide the spatial and temporal resolution required to capture the emerging magnetic dynamics in 2D superconductors
3. Theoretical Expectations: Vortices in 2D systems are expected to extend into Pearl vortices, arranged in a glass state lacking translational invariance

Limitations of Existing Methods

• STM: Requires ultraclean conductive surfaces and is highly sensitive to preparation residues; even protective hBN encapsulation presents challenges
• Conventional Nanoprobes: Lack the capability to simultaneously achieve high spatial and temporal resolution
• Indirect Measurements: Transport measurements can only indirectly infer vortex behavior

Core Contributions

1. First Implementation: Direct visualization of vortex dynamics in 2D superconductors using single-spin scanning quantum microscopy (SQM)
2. Discovery of Anomalous Vortex Arrangement: Observation of a distorted vortex glass state rather than the expected hexagonal lattice
3. Revelation of Cooling Rate Dependence: Demonstration that vortex glass condensation is a stochastic process strongly dependent on cooling rate
4. Discovery of Anomalous Temperature Dependence: Magnetic noise persists far below Tc and is enhanced at lower temperatures
5. Establishment of New Experimental Platform: Confirmation of single-spin microscopy as a powerful platform for studying fluctuations in 2D superconductors

Detailed Methodology

Experimental Setup

The study employs a 1.8K low-temperature atomic force microscope combined with scanning quantum microscopy based on single nitrogen-vacancy (NV) centers in diamond. Experimental samples consist of 2H-NbSe₂ flakes of varying thicknesses:

• Sample S1: 5.1 nm thickness (7 layers), with partial regions of 12.6 nm
• Sample S2: 11.59 nm thickness, fully encapsulated in hBN

Measurement Techniques

Static Magnetic Field Imaging

• Spatial Resolution: 30 nm
• Magnetic Field Sensitivity: Sub-microtesla level
• Scanning Range: Micrometer-scale regions

Dynamic Measurements

• Hahn Echo Sequence: Measurement of T₂ coherence time
• Frequency Range: kHz to MHz
• Temperature Range: 2K to 10K

Data Analysis Methods

Autocorrelation Analysis

Quantification of vortex arrangement order through autocorrelation function calculation of magnetic field maps:

• Hexagonal lattices display clear sixfold symmetry
• Disordered glass states display diffuse correlation peaks

Theoretical Modeling

Description of vortex motion at finite temperature using Langevin equations:

η(∂r/∂t) = F_pin + F_thermal + F_interaction

where η is the damping coefficient, F_pin is the pinning force, F_thermal is the thermal force, and F_interaction is the vortex-vortex interaction force.

Experimental Setup

Sample Preparation

• Material: 2H-NbSe₂ flakes
• Substrate: Silicon oxide substrate
• Encapsulation: hBN protective layer
• Preparation Method: Mechanical exfoliation and transfer techniques

Measurement Conditions

• Temperature Range: 1.8K - 10K
• Magnetic Field: Several millitesla applied field
• Environment: Ultrahigh vacuum low-temperature environment

Experimental Parameters

• NV-Sample Distance: Controllable nanometer-scale spacing
• Scanning Step Size: Adjusted according to desired resolution
• Integration Time: Measurement time per point optimized for adequate signal-to-noise ratio

Experimental Results

Thickness Dependence of Vortex Arrangement

Thin Sample (5.1 nm)

• Observation: Highly distorted vortex glass state
• Characteristics: Autocorrelation map displays diffuse, irregular features
• Boundary Effects: Vortex configuration strongly constrained by sample boundaries

Thick Sample (11.59 nm)

• Observation: More ordered hexagonal vortex lattice
• Characteristics: Autocorrelation analysis reveals arrangement approaching Abrikosov lattice
• Order: Although still distorted by geometric constraints and spatial disorder

Cooling Rate Effects

Rapid Cooling (6.3K to 2K within 1 minute)

• Magnetic Field Contrast: Weaker
• Vortex Stability: More susceptible to thermal fluctuations
• Autocorrelation Intensity: Significantly reduced

Slow Cooling (6.3K to 2K over several hours)

• Magnetic Field Contrast: Enhanced
• Vortex Arrangement: More stable lattice formation
• Autocorrelation Intensity: Markedly enhanced

Dynamic Measurement Results

Distance Dependence of T₂ Coherence Time

• Contact State: T₂ ≈ 2-4 μs
• Distant State (>1 μm): T₂ ≈ 8-12 μs
• Characteristic Length: Noise source length scale of several hundred nanometers

Anomalous Temperature-Dependent Behavior

Experiments reveal that the decoherence rate 1/T₂ increases with decreasing temperature, contrary to conventional expectations:

Experimental Data:

• 2K: Δ(1/T₂) ≈ 0.25 μs⁻¹
• 4K: Δ(1/T₂) ≈ 0.15 μs⁻¹
• 6K: Δ(1/T₂) ≈ 0.05 μs⁻¹

Theoretical Explanation: While vortex motion itself decreases with decreasing temperature, the magnetic field distribution around vortices in thin superconductors becomes increasingly sensitive to vortex position changes, resulting in enhanced decoherence.

Related Work

Traditional Vortex Research

• STM Studies: Hess et al. first observed Abrikosov flux lattices
• Transport Measurements: Indirect evidence suggesting vortex glass melting occurs more readily in thin NbSe₂ samples
• Theoretical Predictions: Pearl vortex model predicts vortex extension in 2D systems

Quantum Sensing Technology

• NV Center Magnetometry: Balasubramanian et al. established nanoscale imaging magnetometry under environmental conditions
• Low-Temperature Quantum Sensing: Thiel et al. achieved quantitative nanoscale vortex imaging using low-temperature quantum magnetometers
• Superconductor Research: Previous SQM studies primarily applied to static response of high-temperature superconductors

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Direct Observation of Vortex Glass State: First direct visualization of disordered vortex glass state in 2D superconductors
2. Thickness Effects: Demonstration of critical influence of sample thickness on vortex arrangement order
3. Dynamical Behavior: Discovery of persistent low-temperature vortex dynamics and glass phase
4. Cooling History Dependence: Revelation of complexity in thermal fluctuation and pinning interaction interplay

Physical Mechanisms

The research provides a microscopic picture of vortex behavior in 2D superconductors:

• Pearl Vortex Extension: Vortex size expansion due to vertical confinement
• Enhanced Thermal Fluctuations: Significant impact of thermal fluctuations on vortex dynamics due to 2D nature
• Disorder Effects: Important role of substrate roughness and disorder in vortex pinning

Limitations

1. Sample Quality: Surface residues may affect measurement precision
2. Temperature Range: Limited by the temperature range of low-temperature equipment
3. Magnetic Field Range: Experiments primarily conducted in low magnetic field regime
4. Temporal Resolution: Temporal resolution of dynamical measurements limited by NV spin coherence time

Future Directions

1. Higher Resolution: Development of quantum sensing techniques with higher spatial and temporal resolution
2. Different Materials: Extension to other 2D superconductor systems
3. Theoretical Development: Development of more comprehensive 2D vortex glass theory
4. Device Applications: Exploration of applications in superconducting quantum devices

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Technical Innovation: First successful application of single-spin quantum sensing technology to 2D superconductor vortex dynamics research
2. Well-Designed Experiments: Systematic investigation of multiple parameters including thickness, cooling rate, and temperature
3. Important Discoveries: Discovered anomalous temperature dependence challenges conventional understanding
4. Theory Integration: Experimental results show good agreement with theoretical models

Weaknesses

1. Limited Sample Number: Research primarily based on two samples; statistical significance may be insufficient
2. Mechanism Explanation: Interpretation of certain phenomena (such as linear magnetic field structures) requires further verification
3. Quantitative Analysis: Some results lack detailed quantitative analysis and error estimation

Impact

1. Methodological Contribution: Establishes new experimental platform for 2D superconductor research
2. Fundamental Science: Deepens understanding of 2D superconducting phenomena
3. Technical Application: Provides important information for superconducting quantum device design
4. Interdisciplinary Research: Promotes cross-disciplinary research between quantum sensing and condensed matter physics

Applicable Scenarios

1. Basic Research: Applicable to vortex research in various 2D superconductor systems
2. Material Characterization: Can be used to assess quality and properties of 2D superconducting materials
3. Device Optimization: Provides design guidance for quantum devices based on 2D superconductors
4. Theory Verification: Serves as experimental verification platform for 2D superconductor theory

References

This paper cites 57 important references covering multiple fields including superconductivity theory, experimental techniques, and quantum sensing, providing a solid theoretical and experimental foundation for the research. Particularly noteworthy is the comprehensive review of Pearl vortex theory, BKT transitions, and the development history of NV center quantum sensing technology.

Summary: This is an experimentally significant paper in 2D superconductor research that reveals complex vortex behavior in 2D superconductors through innovative quantum sensing technology, providing valuable experimental data and new research perspectives for theoretical development and practical applications in this field.