The role of friction forces in arterial mechanical thrombectomy: a review

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2505.03632
• Title: The role of friction forces in arterial mechanical thrombectomy: a review
• Authors: Mahesh S. Nagargoje, Virginia Fregona, Giulia Luraghi, Francesco Migliavacca, Guglielmo Pero, Jose Felix Rodriguez Matas
• Classification: physics.med-ph
• Publication Year: 2025
• Paper Type: Review Article
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2505.03632

Abstract

This review article systematically analyzes the mechanisms of friction forces in mechanical thrombectomy (MT) and their impact on the treatment efficacy of acute ischemic stroke (AIS). The research focuses on friction forces generated from three types of interactions: thrombus-vessel, thrombus-stent retriever (SR), and SR-vessel. Through analysis of in vitro experimental studies conducted between 2015-2025, the review reveals that fibrin-rich thrombi are more difficult to retrieve due to higher friction coefficients (3-4 times higher than red blood cell-rich thrombi). This review provides an important theoretical foundation for optimizing MT techniques and developing next-generation thrombectomy devices.

Research Background and Motivation

Research Questions

1. Clinical Challenges: Despite multiple clinical trials demonstrating the superiority of mechanical thrombectomy in treating acute ischemic stroke, procedural success rates remain uncertain
2. Friction Mechanisms: The specific mechanisms of friction forces during MT remain insufficiently understood, particularly regarding interactions between different thrombus types and devices

Significance

1. Disease Burden: Acute ischemic stroke is a leading cause of death from cardiovascular disease, imposing enormous economic burden globally
2. Treatment Revolution: The introduction of MT technology has fundamentally transformed stroke treatment, though room for improvement remains
3. Personalized Treatment: Understanding friction mechanisms facilitates development of personalized treatment strategies based on thrombus type and vascular anatomy

Existing Limitations

1. Difficulty Obtaining In Vivo Friction Values: Lack of accurate methods for measuring in vivo friction coefficients
2. Inconsistent In Vitro Research: Existing in vitro studies show significant variations and large standard deviations
3. Incomplete Theoretical Models: Current computational simulation models lack consideration of adhesive contact

Core Contributions

1. Systematic Review: First systematic review of friction force research in MT, analyzing relevant literature from 2015-2025
2. Three-Dimensional Friction Framework: Establishes analytical framework for friction forces from three types of interactions: thrombus-vessel, thrombus-SR, and SR-vessel
3. Thrombus Type Effects: Quantifies the impact of different thrombus types on friction coefficients, revealing that fibrin-rich thrombi have 3-4 times higher friction coefficients than red blood cell-rich thrombi
4. Technical Guidance: Provides theoretical guidance for optimizing existing SR designs and developing next-generation thrombectomy technologies
5. Future Directions: Identifies research challenges and future development directions in this field

Methodology Details

Literature Search Strategy

• Search Period: March 2025
• Search Keywords: "in vitro mechanical thrombectomy"
• Databases: PubMed, Web of Science, Google Scholar
• Language Restriction: English language literature only
• Selection Criteria: Following PRISMA guidelines, 34 qualifying studies were selected from 225 initial articles

Inclusion and Exclusion Criteria

Inclusion Criteria:

• In vitro studies calculating friction or retrieval forces
• Peer-reviewed journal articles published 2015-2025
• English language literature

Exclusion Criteria:

• Conference papers, book chapters, dissertations, and preprints
• Studies not involving friction force analysis

Theoretical Foundation of Friction

Based on classical friction theory from da Vinci and Coulomb, using the mathematical expression:

F = μN

Where:

• F: Friction force
• μ: Coefficient of friction
• N: Normal force

Technical Innovation Points

1. Three-Dimensional Friction Analysis Framework

First systematic classification of friction forces in MT into three independent yet interrelated components:

• Thrombus-Vessel Friction (F_clot-vessel)
• Thrombus-SR Friction (F_clot-SR)
• SR-Vessel Friction (F_SR-vessel)

2. Biotribological Perspective

Introduces biotribological concepts into MT research, accounting for significant differences in friction characteristics between biological tissues and non-biological materials

3. Thrombus Heterogeneity Analysis

In-depth analysis of how thrombus composition affects friction characteristics:

• Fibrin-rich thrombi: High elastic modulus, low hydration capacity, high friction coefficient
• Red blood cell-rich thrombi: Low elastic modulus, high hydration capacity, low friction coefficient

Experimental Setup and Results Analysis

Data Sources

34 studies selected through PRISMA process, with particular focus on 8 articles specifically investigating MT friction forces

Key Experimental Findings

1. Thrombus-Vessel Interaction

• Material Differences: Friction coefficients of biological tissues significantly exceed those of non-biological materials
• Thrombus Type: Friction coefficient between fibrin-rich thrombi and vessel walls is 3-4 times higher than red blood cell-rich thrombi
• Lubrication Effects: Red blood cell-rich thrombi maintain longer hydration duration, forming a lubricating layer

2. SR-Vessel Interaction

• Curved Vessel Effects: SR undergoes compression in acutely curved vessels, reducing retrieval efficiency
• Vessel Diameter Effects: Smaller distal vessels demonstrate significantly higher retrieval forces
• Force Variations: Significant differences exist in retrieval forces among different SR designs

3. Thrombus-SR Interaction

• Capture Mechanisms: Red blood cell-rich thrombi are easily captured but prone to fragmentation; fibrin-rich thrombi are difficult to capture but resistant to fragmentation
• Fragmentation Risk: Red blood cell-rich thrombi are prone to fragmentation under high friction forces, potentially causing distal embolization

Experimental Limitations

1. In Vitro Model Constraints: Most studies use silicone models, unable to fully replicate in vivo vascular characteristics
2. Thrombus Preparation: Majority of studies prepare thrombi under static conditions, differing from in vivo dynamic formation processes
3. Lack of Standardization: Absence of standardized experimental conditions and evaluation metrics across different studies

Related Work

Traditional MT Technologies

• Stent Retriever Technology: Classic devices such as Solitaire and Trevo
• Aspiration Technology: Aspiration catheter techniques such as ADAPT
• Combined Technology: Combined application of SR and aspiration catheters

Emerging Technology Development

• Dual-Cage SR Designs: Designs such as Embotrap intended for curved vessels
• Spiral Design SR: Novel designs specifically targeting hard fibrin-rich thrombi
• Multi-Articulated SR: Designs maintaining open configuration in curved vessels

Computational Modeling Research

• Finite Element Analysis: Predicting mechanical behavior during MT procedures
• Fluid Dynamics Simulation: Analyzing blood flow effects on retrieval processes
• Machine Learning: Predicting thrombus type and retrieval success rates by combining imaging data

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Critical Role of Friction: Friction forces are key factors affecting MT success rates, with different interactions producing distinct friction characteristics
2. Importance of Thrombus Type: Fibrin-rich thrombi are more difficult to retrieve due to high friction coefficients, requiring specialized device designs
3. Vascular Anatomy Effects: Acutely curved vessels significantly impact retrieval efficacy through SR compression mechanisms
4. Need for Personalized Strategies: Personalized retrieval strategies must be developed based on thrombus type and vascular anatomical characteristics

Limitations

1. Lack of In Vivo Validation: Most findings based on in vitro experiments, lacking sufficient in vivo verification
2. Insufficient Standardization: Experimental conditions and evaluation methods lack standardization, resulting in poor result comparability
3. Oversimplification of Complexity: Existing models oversimplify the complex physiological environment in vivo
4. Neglect of Adhesive Forces: Most studies overlook adhesive forces between thrombus and vessel wall

Future Directions

1. Sensor Technology: Develop implantable sensors for real-time measurement of in vivo friction forces
2. Materials Science: Develop in vitro model materials more closely approximating in vivo environments
3. Artificial Intelligence: Combine machine learning and imaging data for personalized prediction
4. Device Optimization: Design next-generation thrombectomy devices based on friction force mechanisms
5. Adhesion Mechanisms: Investigate molecular mechanisms of thrombus-vessel adhesion in depth

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Strong Systematicity: First systematic review of friction force research in MT, filling a gap in the field
2. Clear Theoretical Framework: Establishes comprehensive three-dimensional friction analysis framework, providing guidance for subsequent research
3. High Clinical Relevance: Research findings directly relate to clinical practice with important guiding significance
4. Interdisciplinary Integration: Successfully integrates knowledge from biomedical engineering, materials science, and clinical medicine
5. Strong Foresight: Clearly identifies future research directions and technology development trends

Shortcomings

1. Limited Quantitative Analysis: Due to heterogeneity of original studies, lacks sufficient quantitative meta-analysis
2. Lack of Verification Studies: As a review article, lacks original experimental verification
3. Insufficient Standardization Recommendations: While identifying standardization issues, fails to provide specific standardization recommendations
4. Missing Cost-Benefit Analysis: Does not consider cost-effectiveness comparisons of different technical approaches

Impact

1. Academic Value: Establishes theoretical foundation for MT friction force research, expected to guide substantial subsequent research
2. Clinical Guidance: Provides scientific evidence for clinicians' selection of retrieval strategies
3. Industry Promotion: Provides technology roadmap for medical device companies developing next-generation thrombectomy devices
4. Policy Support: Provides scientific support for development of relevant medical standards and guidelines

Applicable Scenarios

1. Research Guidance: Applicable to guiding basic and clinical research related to MT
2. Device Development: Applicable to design and optimization of novel thrombectomy devices
3. Clinical Training: Applicable to professional training of neurointerventional physicians
4. Standard Development: Applicable to development of industry standards and clinical guidelines

References

This review cites 34 high-quality research articles, with 8 key friction force-specific studies including:

1. Gunning et al. (2018) - First systematic study of thrombus friction coefficients
2. Elkhayyat et al. (2024) - Dynamic friction coefficient analysis of SR-vessel interaction
3. Machi et al. (2017) - Comparison of retrieval forces among different SR types
4. Kaneko et al. (2019) - SR performance research in curved vessels
5. Other relevant clinical trials and technical studies

Overall Assessment: This is a high-quality review article that systematically examines research progress on friction forces in MT, making important contributions to theoretical development and technological innovation in this field. Despite certain limitations, the theoretical framework established and research directions proposed are significant for advancing field development.