2025-11-16T09:01:12.425008

$n$-Valued Groups, Kronecker Sums, and Wendt's Matrices

Buchstaber, Kornev
The article presents results on the well-known problem concerning the structure of integer polynomials $p_n(z; x, y)$, which define multiplication laws in $n$-valued groups $\mathbb{G}_n$ over the field of complex numbers $\mathbb{C}$. We show that the $n$-valued multiplication in the group $\mathbb{G}_n$ is realized in terms of the eigenvalues of the Kronecker sum of companion Frobenius matrices for polynomials of the form $t^n - x$ in the variable $t$. The notion of a Wendt $(x, y, z)$-matrix is introduced. When $x = (-1)^n$, $y = z = 1$, one recovers the classical Wendt matrix, whose determinant is used in number theory in connection with Fermat's Last Theorem. It is shown that for each positive integer $n$, the polynomial $p_n$ is given by the determinant of a Wendt $(x, y, z)$-matrix. Iterations of the $n$-valued multiplication in the group $\mathbb{G}_n$ lead to polynomials $p_n(z; x_1, \dots, x_m)$. We prove the irreducibility of the polynomial $p_n(z; x_1, \dots, x_m)$ over various fields. For each $n$, we introduce the notion of classes of symmetric $n$-algebraic $n$-valued groups. The group $\mathbb{G}_n$ belongs to one of these classes. For $n = 2, 3$, a description of the universal objects of these classes is obtained.
academic

nn-Valued Groups, Kronecker Sums, and Wendt's Matrices

Basic Information

  • Paper ID: 2505.04296
  • Title: nn-Valued Groups, Kronecker Sums, and Wendt's Matrices
  • Authors: Victor Buchstaber, Mikhail Kornev
  • Classification: math.GR (Group Theory), math.NT (Number Theory)
  • Publication Date: May 2025 (arXiv version 2, revised October 14, 2025)
  • Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2505.04296

Abstract

This paper investigates the structural properties of integer-coefficient polynomials pn(z;x,y)p_n(z; x, y) that define the multiplication law of nn-valued groups GnG_n over the complex numbers. The authors prove that the nn-valued multiplication in GnG_n can be realized through eigenvalues of Kronecker sums of companion Frobenius matrices corresponding to polynomials of the form tn−xt^n - x. The paper introduces the concept of Wendt (x,y,z)(x, y, z)-matrices, which recover the classical Wendt matrices when x=(−1)nx = (-1)^n and y=z=1y = z = 1. The determinants of these classical Wendt matrices are related to Fermat's Last Theorem in number theory. The authors prove that for each positive integer nn, the polynomial pnp_n can be expressed as the determinant of a Wendt (x,y,z)(x, y, z)-matrix. Iteration of the nn-valued multiplication in GnG_n leads to polynomials pn(z;x1,…,xm)p_n(z; x_1, \ldots, x_m), and the paper proves the irreducibility of these polynomials over various fields.

Research Background and Motivation

Problem Background

The theory of nn-valued groups originated from a construction proposed by Buchstaber and Novikov in 1971 within the framework of characteristic class theory. In nn-valued groups, the product of any two elements is a multiset containing nn points. This structure has important applications in multiple mathematical fields:

  1. Algebraic Geometry: Related to addition theorems on elliptic curves
  2. Number Theory: Related to Fermat's Last Theorem and Wendt matrices
  3. Integrable Systems: Applications in multivalued discrete dynamics
  4. Representation Theory: Related to tensor product decomposition of group representations

Research Motivation

The main motivations for this paper include:

  1. Structural Problems: Understanding the coefficient structure of polynomials pn(z;x,y)p_n(z; x, y) that define nn-valued group multiplication
  2. Matrix Realization: Characterizing nn-valued multiplication through linear algebraic methods (Kronecker sums, Frobenius matrices)
  3. Number-Theoretic Connections: Establishing connections with classical Wendt matrices and Fermat's Last Theorem
  4. Irreducibility: Investigating irreducibility properties of related polynomials over different fields

Limitations of Existing Methods

  • Previous research has primarily focused on low-dimensional cases (n≤7n \leq 7)
  • Lack of a unified matrix-theoretic framework for handling general nn-valued groups
  • Insufficient understanding of number-theoretic properties of polynomial coefficients

Core Contributions

  1. Established connections between nn-valued groups and Kronecker sums: Proved that nn-valued multiplication in GnG_n can be realized through eigenvalues of Kronecker sums of companion Frobenius matrices
  2. Introduced Wendt (x,y,z)(x,y,z)-matrices: Generalized classical Wendt matrices and established direct connections with nn-valued group polynomials
  3. Proved polynomial irreducibility: Established irreducibility of pn(z;x1,…,xm)p_n(z; x_1, \ldots, x_m) over multiple fields including the complex numbers and rationals
  4. Classified symmetric nn-algebraic nn-valued groups: Provided complete classification and descriptions of universal objects for n=2,3n=2,3
  5. Established connections with discriminants: Proved that determinants of Wendt matrices can be expressed as discriminants of certain polynomials
  6. Provided number-theoretic applications: Used Wolstenholme's theorem to prove divisibility properties of polynomial coefficients

Methodology Details

Problem Formulation

Study the multiplication operation on nn-valued groups GnG_n: x∗y=[(xn+εryn)n∣r=1,…,n]x \ast y = [(\sqrt[n]{x} + \varepsilon^r \sqrt[n]{y})^n | r = 1, \ldots, n] where ε\varepsilon is a primitive nn-th root of unity. The goal is to understand the structure of the polynomial pn(z;x,y)p_n(z; x, y) defining this multiplication.

Core Theoretical Framework

1. Kronecker Sum Realization

Theorem: The nn-valued multiplication can be realized through Kronecker sums: pn(zn;x,y)=χ(F(0,…,0,(−1)n+1x)⊕F(0,…,0,(−1)n+1y);z)p_n(z^n; x, y) = \chi(F(0, \ldots, 0, (-1)^{n+1}x) \oplus F(0, \ldots, 0, (-1)^{n+1}y); z)

where FF is the companion Frobenius matrix and ⊕\oplus denotes the Kronecker sum.

2. Wendt (x,y,z)(x,y,z)-Matrices

Define the Wendt (x,y,z)(x,y,z)-matrix as a yy-circulant matrix: Circy(wn+(−1)n+1x+y,(n1)w,…,(nn−1)wn−1)\text{Circ}_y\left(w^n + (-1)^{n+1}x + y, \binom{n}{1}w, \ldots, \binom{n}{n-1}w^{n-1}\right)

Main Theorem: pn(z;x,y)=det⁡(Wendt(x,y,z)-matrix)p_n(z; x, y) = \det(\text{Wendt}(x,y,z)\text{-matrix})

3. Classification of Symmetric nn-Algebraic nn-Valued Groups

For the case n=2n=2: Theorem 1: The universal symmetric 2-algebraic 2-valued group is defined by a polynomial family over the coefficient ring C[k2,k4,k6]\mathbb{C}[k_2, k_4, k_6]: P2(z;x,y)=σ12−4σ2+2k2σ3+(k42−k6k2)σ32+2k4σ1σ3+2k6σ2σ3P_2(z; x, y) = \sigma_1^2 - 4\sigma_2 + 2k_2\sigma_3 + (k_4^2 - k_6k_2)\sigma_3^2 + 2k_4\sigma_1\sigma_3 + 2k_6\sigma_2\sigma_3

For the case n=3n=3: Theorem 2: There exist two classes of symmetric 3-algebraic 3-valued groups:

  • Type (i): When k0=−27k_0 = -27, corresponding to the group G3G_3
  • Type (ii): When k0=0k_0 = 0, corresponding to the diagonal construction

Technical Innovations

  1. Introduction of Matrix Methods: First systematic use of Kronecker sums to characterize nn-valued group structures
  2. Generalization of Wendt Matrices: Extended classical Wendt matrices to parametrized forms
  3. Unified Proof of Irreducibility: Used field extension theory to uniformly handle irreducibility problems
  4. Discriminant Representation: Established new connections between polynomials and discriminants

Experimental Setup

Computational Tools

  • Symbolic computation using Wolfram Mathematica
  • Verification of symmetry conditions and associativity
  • Computation of specific polynomial coefficients

Verification Cases

The paper provides multiple concrete examples:

Example: For n=2,3,4n=2,3,4, matrix representations of pnp_n are given: p2=∣w2−x+y2wy2ww2−x+y∣p_2 = \begin{vmatrix} w^2 - x + y & 2wy \\ 2w & w^2 - x + y \end{vmatrix}

w^3 + x + y & 3yw & 3yw^2 \\ 3w^2 & w^3 + x + y & 3yw \\ 3w & 3w^2 & w^3 + x + y \end{vmatrix}$$ ### Number-Theoretic Verification **Proposition 8**: For primes $n \geq 5$, the polynomial $p_n(z; x, y) - (x + y + z)^n$ is divisible by $n^4xyz$. The proof employs Wolstenholme's theorem and combinatorial identities. ## Experimental Results ### Main Results #### 1. Irreducibility Results **Theorem 6**: Over a field $k$ satisfying $\gcd(n, e(k)) = 1$, the polynomial $q(\{n_i\}, \{x_j\}; z)$ is irreducible. **Theorem 7**: Over the rational numbers, when $x_1, \ldots, x_m$ are positive integers satisfying certain conditions, $p_n(z; x_1, \ldots, x_m)$ is irreducible. #### 2. Discriminant Representation **Theorem 8**: The determinant of the Wendt $(x,y,z)$-matrix can be expressed as the discriminant of the polynomial $$P_{x,y,z}(T) = ((-1)^nxT^{n-1} + (-1)^ny)(1+T)^{n-1} - T^{n-1}z$$ #### 3. Number-Theoretic Properties of Coefficients Through computation, it was discovered that coefficients of $p_n(z; x, y)$ in the basis of elementary symmetric polynomials contain arbitrarily large prime factors, exhibiting rich number-theoretic structure. ### Specific Computational Examples The paper provides complete expansion of $p_{18}(z; x, y)$, demonstrating complex prime factorizations of coefficients, for example: - $(5,0,1) \rightarrow -2 \cdot 8 \cdot 3 \cdot 67$ - $(15,0,1) \rightarrow -2^{13} \cdot 5 \cdot 4 \cdot 3 \cdot 12 \cdot 9 \cdot 31 \cdot 133 \cdot 391$ ## Related Work ### Historical Development 1. **Buchstaber-Novikov (1971)**: First introduced the concept of $n$-valued groups 2. **Buchstaber's Series of Works**: Developed algebraic theory of $n$-valued groups 3. **Wendt (1984)**: Introduced Wendt matrices in the study of Fermat's Last Theorem 4. **Recent Developments**: Connections with integrable systems and representation theory ### Related Theories - **Formal Group Theory**: Classification of 2-valued formal groups - **Elliptic Curve Theory**: Connections with addition theorems of elliptic functions - **Combinatorial Algebra**: Relationships with multivalued involution groups - **Bessel Kernel Theory**: Connections with Picard-Fuchs equations ## Conclusions and Discussion ### Main Conclusions 1. Established profound connections between $n$-valued group theory and linear algebra (Kronecker sums) 2. Generalized classical Wendt matrices and established new connections with Fermat's Last Theorem 3. Proved irreducibility of related polynomials, providing new examples for field theory 4. Provided a classification framework for symmetric $n$-algebraic $n$-valued groups ### Limitations 1. Complete classification is provided only for $n=2,3$; higher-dimensional cases remain open 2. Precise number-theoretic properties of polynomial coefficients require further investigation 3. Connections with other mathematical branches remain to be explored ### Future Directions 1. **Higher-Dimensional Classification**: Complete classification of symmetric $n$-algebraic $n$-valued groups for $n \geq 4$ 2. **Computational Methods**: Develop more efficient algorithms for computing coefficients of $p_n$ 3. **Application Extensions**: Explore applications in cryptography and coding theory 4. **Geometric Realization**: Find more geometric examples of $n$-valued groups ## In-Depth Evaluation ### Strengths 1. **Theoretical Depth**: Establishes profound connections between multiple mathematical disciplines 2. **Methodological Innovation**: Kronecker sum methods provide new tools for $n$-valued group theory 3. **Computational Verification**: Provides abundant computational examples and verifications 4. **Broad Applicability**: Connects group theory, number theory, linear algebra, and other fields ### Weaknesses 1. **Technical Complexity**: Some proofs rely excessively on computer verification 2. **Incompleteness**: Classification for higher dimensions remains incomplete 3. **Limited Applications**: Practical application scenarios require further development ### Impact 1. **Theoretical Contribution**: Provides new research framework for $n$-valued group theory 2. **Methodological Value**: Kronecker sum methods may have applications to other algebraic structures 3. **Number-Theoretic Significance**: Generalizes Wendt matrix theory, potentially helpful for Fermat's Last Theorem research ### Applicable Scenarios - Study of group actions in algebraic geometry - Research on Diophantine equations in number theory - Discrete dynamics in integrable systems - Symmetric function theory in combinatorics ## References The paper contains 45 references covering classical works in group theory and number theory to recent research results, including: - Buchstaber's series of works on $n$-valued group theory - Wendt's research on Fermat's Last Theorem - Classical textbooks on matrix theory by Horn & Johnson - Recent research on Bessel kernels and Kontsevich polynomials --- This paper has significant theoretical value, providing new research tools and perspectives for $n$-valued group theory while establishing profound connections with classical number-theoretic problems. Although certain technical details require further refinement, its innovativeness and potential impact make it an important contribution to the field.