2025-11-10T02:53:53.239965

The non-simply connected Price twist for the 4-sphere

Isoshima, Suzuki
A cutting and pasting operation on a $P^2$-knot $S$ in a $4$-manifold is called the Price twist. The Price twist for the $4$-sphere $S^4$ yields at most three $4$-manifolds up to diffeomorphism, namely, the $4$-sphere $S^4$, the other homotopy $4$-sphere $Σ_{S}(S^4)$ and a non-simply connected $4$-manifold $τ_{S}(S^4)$. In this paper, we study some properties and diffeomorphism types of $τ_{S}(S^4)$ for $P^2$-knots $S$ of Kinoshita type.
academic

The non-simply connected Price twist for the 4-sphere

Basic Information

  • Paper ID: 2505.09332
  • Title: The non-simply connected Price twist for the 4-sphere
  • Authors: Tsukasa Isoshima, Tatsumasa Suzuki
  • Classification: math.GT (Geometric Topology)
  • Publication Date: October 14, 2025
  • Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2505.09332

Abstract

This paper investigates the Price twist—a cut-and-paste operation on P2P^2-knots in 4-manifolds. For the Price twist of the 4-sphere S4S^4, at most three diffeomorphism classes of 4-manifolds are produced: the original 4-sphere S4S^4, another homotopy 4-sphere ΣS(S4)\Sigma_S(S^4), and a non-simply connected 4-manifold τS(S4)\tau_S(S^4). This paper studies the properties and diffeomorphism type of τS(S4)\tau_S(S^4) corresponding to Kinoshita-type P2P^2-knots SS.

Research Background and Motivation

Problem Background

  1. Price twist theory: The Price twist is an important operation in 4-manifold topology, analogous to the more well-known Gluck twist, but acting on real projective plane knots (P2P^2-knots) rather than 2-sphere knots.
  2. Research gap: Although the second type of Price twist ΣS(X)\Sigma_S(X) has been extensively studied (related to Gluck twist), the third type of Price twist τS(X)\tau_S(X) has remained virtually unstudied.
  3. Kinoshita-type knots: All known P2P^2-knots are Kinoshita-type (i.e., connected sums of 2-knots with unknotted P2P^2-knots), providing a foundation for systematic study.

Research Motivation

  1. Filling theoretical gaps: Systematically studying the topological properties of non-simply connected Price twist τS(S4)\tau_S(S^4)
  2. Classification problems: Determining the diffeomorphism types of τS(S4)\tau_S(S^4) produced by different P2P^2-knots
  3. Relations with known 4-manifolds: Comparing τS(S4)\tau_S(S^4) with other known rational homology 4-spheres (such as spun manifolds, Pao manifolds, and Iwase manifolds)

Core Contributions

  1. Establishing the relationship between Price twist and pochette surgery: Proving that Price twist is a special case of pochette surgery
  2. Computing fundamental groups and homology groups: Determining that the fundamental group of τS(T2,2n+1)\tau_{S(T_{2,2n+1})} is the dihedral group D∣2n+1∣D_{|2n+1|}
  3. Classification theorem for ribbon 2-knots: For 1-fusion ribbon 2-knots KK, proving that τK\tau_K is diffeomorphic to τS(T2,n)\tau_{S(T_{2,n})} (where n=det⁡(K)n = \det(K))
  4. Constructing concrete examples: Providing numerous concrete ribbon knot examples and their Price twist classifications
  5. Studying double covers: Proving that the double cover of τS(T2,2n+1)\tau_{S(T_{2,2n+1})} is diffeomorphic to L2n+1#S2×S2L_{2n+1}\#S^2 \times S^2

Detailed Methodology

Task Definition

Studying the topological properties of the non-simply connected Price twist τS(S4)=τK\tau_S(S^4) = \tau_K of Kinoshita-type P2P^2-knots S=K#P0S = K\#P_0 in the 4-sphere S4S^4, including:

  • Computing homology groups and fundamental groups
  • Diffeomorphism classification
  • Comparison with other known 4-manifolds

Main Technical Methods

1. Connection between Price Twist and Pochette Surgery

Theorem 3.1: The Price twist of Kinoshita-type P2P^2-knots is a special case of pochette surgery:

  • S4S^4 ≅ S4(eK,1/0,0)S^4(e_K, 1/0, 0) (trivial twist)
  • ΣK#P0(S4)\Sigma_{K\#P_0}(S^4) ≅ S4(eK,1/0,1)S^4(e_K, 1/0, 1) (Gluck twist)
  • τK#P0(S4)\tau_{K\#P_0}(S^4) ≅ S4(eK,2,0)S^4(e_K, 2, 0) (non-simply connected Price twist)

2. Handle Calculus Techniques

Introducing two special types of handle moves:

  • Move α: Allowing sign changes of generators in relations without affecting diffeomorphism type
  • Move β: Allowing exchange of roles of conjugate generators

3. τ-Handle Diagram Method

Introducing τ-handle diagram notation to simplify calculations, where each 2-handle has a 0-framed meridian, allowing arbitrary changes to self-intersection numbers without affecting diffeomorphism type.

Key Theorems

Theorem 3.5 (Fundamental Group Computation)

π1(τS(T2,2n+1))≅D∣2n+1∣\pi_1(\tau_{S(T_{2,2n+1})}) \cong D_{|2n+1|} (dihedral group)

Proof Strategy:

  1. Obtaining presentation from τ-handle diagram: ⟨x,y∣x2=1,(yx−1)ny(xy−1)nx=1⟩\langle x,y | x^2 = 1, (yx^{-1})^n y(xy^{-1})^n x = 1 \rangle
  2. Simplifying to standard dihedral group presentation via Tietze transformations

Theorem 4.13 (Classification of 1-Fusion Ribbon Knots)

For 1-fusion ribbon 2-knots KK: τK≅τS(T2,n)\tau_K \cong \tau_{S(T_{2,n})}, where n=det⁡(K)n = \det(K)

Proof Method:

  1. Utilizing ribbon representation R(m1,n1,…,ms,ns)R(m_1,n_1,\ldots,m_s,n_s)
  2. Simplifying τ-handle diagrams to standard form via moves α and β
  3. Computing determinants using Alexander polynomials

Experimental Setup

Data Sources

  1. Knot table data: Using ribbon knot data with crossing number ≤ 12
  2. Ribbon representations from literature: From works of Kawauchi, Lamm, and others
  3. Computational verification: Verifying theoretical results through handle calculations

Analysis Objects

  • All ribbon 1-knots with crossing number ≤ 12 (except 6 special examples)
  • 2-bridge knots
  • Pretzel knots
  • 2-plat knots

Experimental Results

Main Results

1. Uniformity of Homology Groups

All τK\tau_K have the same homology groups:

\mathbb{Z} & (n = 0,4) \\ \mathbb{Z}_2 & (n = 1,2) \\ 0 & (n = 3) \end{cases}$$ #### 2. Diversity of Fundamental Groups - $\tau_{S(T_{2,2n+1})}$: Fundamental group is $D_{|2n+1|}$ - Certain 2-fusion knots: Fundamental group is Coxeter group $W(3,3,\infty)$ or $W(3,5,\infty)$ #### 3. Specific Classification Results - **2-bridge knots**: $\tau_{S(k)} \cong \tau_{S(T_{2,\det(k)})}$ - **Pretzel knots $P(-p,p,q)$**: When $|p| \neq 1$, $\tau_{R(D(P(-p,p,q)))} \cong \tau_{S(T_{2,p})}$ ### Ablation Studies Verifying theory through analysis of special cases: - **Exceptional knots**: 12n553, 12n556, 31#61#3*1, 31#31#3*1#3*1 all have 2-fusion - **Same knot with different representations**: Different ribbon representations of the same 1-knot may produce 2-knots with different fusion numbers ### Important Findings #### 1. Distinction from Known 4-Manifolds **Corollaries 3.6-3.8**: When $n \neq -1,0$, $\tau_{S(T_{2,2n+1})}$ is not homotopy equivalent to: - Any spun or twist-spun manifold $S(M)$, $\tilde{S}(M)$ - Any Pao manifold $L_m$, $L'_m$ - Any Iwase manifold $M(p,q,r;\alpha,\beta,\gamma)$ #### 2. Double Cover Structure **Proposition 4.31**: $\tau_{S(T_{2,2n+1})}$ admits a double cover $\Sigma_2(\tau_{S(T_{2,2n+1})}) \cong L_{2n+1}\#S^2 \times S^2$ ## Related Work ### Major Related Research 1. **Gluck twist**: Classical operation on 2-knots, extensively studied 2. **Pochette surgery**: 4-manifold surgery theory introduced by Iwase-Matsumoto 3. **Pao and Iwase manifolds**: Known families of rational homology 4-spheres 4. **Ribbon knot theory**: Fusion number theory by Kanenobu-Marumoto and others ### Novelty of This Work 1. **First systematic study**: The third type of Price twist has been virtually unstudied 2. **Unified framework**: Establishing connection with pochette surgery provides a unified treatment method 3. **Complete classification**: Providing complete diffeomorphism classification for the 1-fusion case ## Conclusions and Discussion ### Main Conclusions 1. **Essence of Price twist**: Non-simply connected Price twist is essentially a special pochette surgery 2. **Classification theorem**: The Price twist of 1-fusion ribbon knots is completely determined by their determinant 3. **New family of 4-manifolds**: Constructing a new family of rational homology 4-spheres with dihedral fundamental groups ### Limitations 1. **Kinoshita conjecture dependence**: Assuming all $P^2$-knots are Kinoshita-type (not yet proven) 2. **High fusion cases**: Classification remains incomplete for fusion number ≥ 2 3. **Computational complexity**: Handle calculations may be difficult for complex ribbon knots ### Future Directions 1. **Question 4.29**: Is the fundamental group of $\tau_{S(T_{p,q})}$ always a Coxeter group? 2. **Question 4.30**: Are n-fusion ribbon knots always diffeomorphic to some $\tau_{S(T_{n+1,m})}$? 3. **Non-Kinoshita-type knots**: If non-Kinoshita-type $P^2$-knots exist, what are their Price twists? ## In-Depth Evaluation ### Strengths 1. **Significant theoretical contribution**: First systematic study of an important but overlooked topological operation 2. **Methodological innovation**: Introduction of τ-handle diagrams and moves α, β greatly simplifies calculations 3. **Complete results**: Providing complete classification theorem for the 1-fusion case 4. **Rich computations**: Providing numerous concrete examples and detailed calculations 5. **Deep connections**: Establishing connections with multiple known theories ### Weaknesses 1. **Technically demanding proofs**: Extensive handle calculations make some proofs difficult to verify 2. **Ad hoc handling of special cases**: Treatment of some exceptional cases appears somewhat temporary 3. **Numerous open problems**: Leaving multiple important open questions ### Impact 1. **Pioneering research**: Laying foundation for Price twist theory 2. **Methodological contribution**: τ-handle diagram method may apply to other 4-manifold problems 3. **Classification theory**: Providing new tools and examples for 4-manifold classification theory ### Applicable Scenarios 1. **4-manifold topology research**: Providing new methods for studying diffeomorphism classification of 4-manifolds 2. **Knot theory applications**: Topological applications of ribbon knots 3. **Surgery theory**: Providing unified framework for various 4-manifold surgery theories ## References The paper cites important literature in the field, including: - Price (1977): Original definition of Price twist - Gompf-Stipsicz (2023): Standard textbook on 4-manifolds and Kirby calculus - Iwase-Matsumoto (2004): Pochette surgery theory - Kanenobu-Marumoto (1997): Fusion number theory for ribbon knots --- This paper makes significant contributions to 4-manifold topology, not only filling gaps in Price twist theory but also establishing deep connections with other theories, laying a solid foundation for further development in the field.