Neutrinos from Primordial Black Holes in Theories with Extra Dimensions

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2505.23414
• Title: Neutrinos from Primordial Black Holes in Theories with Extra Dimensions
• Authors: Luis A. Anchordoqui, Francis Halzen, Dieter Lüst
• Classification: hep-ph (High Energy Physics - Phenomenology)
• Publication Date: May 2025 (Preprint)
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2505.23414

Abstract

This paper proposes a novel theoretical framework to explain the ultra-high-energy neutrino event KM3-230213A. The authors note a striking coincidence between the quantum gravity scale in dark dimension scenarios ($M_* \sim 10^{9}~{\rm GeV}$) and the neutrino energy scale in KM3-230213A ($E_\nu\sim 10^{8}~{\rm GeV}$), and propose explaining this phenomenon through Hawking evaporation of five-dimensional (5D) primordial black holes. 5D primordial black holes are larger, colder, and longer-lived than 4D black holes of equal mass, and decay "invisibly" primarily through gravitational coupling and inert coupling modes, thereby evading existing gamma-ray observational constraints.

Research Background and Motivation

Core Issues

1. Anomalous Nature of KM3-230213A Event: The KM3NeT collaboration observed the highest-energy neutrino event to date, with energy range $10^{7.8} \lesssim E_\nu/{\rm GeV} \lesssim 10^{8.9}$
2. Observational Anomaly: Despite longer operational periods and larger effective areas, IceCube and the Pierre Auger Observatory have not detected neutrinos with $E_\nu \gtrsim 10^{7.6}$ GeV
3. Multi-messenger Constraints: Astrophysical high-energy neutrino sources typically produce bright gamma-ray signals, yet the KM3-230213A event lacks a corresponding gamma-ray counterpart

Research Motivation

• Scale Coincidence: The striking agreement between the 5D Planck scale in dark dimension scenarios ($M_* \sim 10^9$ GeV) and the neutrino energy scale of KM3-230213A
• Constraint Evasion: Traditional 4D primordial black hole explanations face severe gamma-ray constraints, necessitating a new theoretical framework
• Quantum Gravity Probe: The potential role of black holes as probes of quantum gravity UV physics

Core Contributions

1. Proposed 5D Primordial Black Hole Evaporation Mechanism: First connection between 5D primordial black holes in dark dimension scenarios and ultra-high-energy neutrino events
2. Resolution of Gamma-Ray Constraints: Naturally evades strict gamma-ray observational constraints through the bulk radiation characteristics of bulk black holes
3. Established Sterile-Active Neutrino Oscillation Model: Combines "shortcut" effects in extra dimensions to provide resonance enhancement mechanism
4. Quantitative Parameter Space Analysis: Demonstrates consistency of the model with IceCube limits on supermassive dark matter particle decay

Methodology Details

Theoretical Framework: Dark Dimension Scenario

In large extra dimension theories, standard model fields are confined to a three-dimensional brane, while gravity permeates the bulk of compact space. The dark dimension scenario connects the compact space size $R_\perp$ to the dark energy scale through the anti-de Sitter distance conjecture:

$R_\perp \sim \lambda \Lambda^{-1/4}$

where $\Lambda \sim 10^{-120}M_p^4$ is the cosmological constant and $\lambda \sim 10^{-3}$. This yields a 5D Planck scale of:

$M_* \sim m_{KK}^{1/3} M_p^{2/3} \sim 10^9 \text{ GeV}$

5D Black Hole Properties

Key properties of d-dimensional black holes:

Schwarzschild Radius: $r_s \sim \frac{1}{M_*}\left(\frac{M}{M_*}\right)^{1/(d-3)}$

Temperature: $T \sim M_* \left(\frac{M_*}{M}\right)^{1/(d-3)}$

Lifetime: $\tau_H \sim S r_s = \frac{1}{M_*}\left(\frac{M}{M_*}\right)^{(d-1)/(d-3)}$

Entropy: $S \sim (M/M_*)^{(d-2)/(d-3)}$

For the 5D case ($d=5$), a black hole with mass $M \sim 10^{11}$ GeV radiates at a temperature of approximately $10^8$ GeV during the final stages of evaporation, precisely matching the KM3-230213A energy scale.

Sterile-Active Neutrino Oscillation

Basic Oscillation Mechanism

Consider a two-state system of a sterile neutrino propagating in the bulk and an active neutrino on the brane. The effective mixing angle is:

$\sin^2(2\tilde{\theta}) = \frac{\sin^2(2\theta)}{\sin^2(2\theta) + \cos^2(2\theta)[1-(E_\nu/E_{res})^2]^2}$

where the resonance energy is: $E_{res} = \sqrt{\frac{\delta m^2 \cos(2\theta)}{2\epsilon}}$

Shortcut Effect

When the brane permits fluctuations, sterile neutrinos can take geodesic "shortcuts" through bulk space, producing geometric phase differences. The shortcut parameter $\epsilon = \delta t/t$ describes the normalized difference in propagation times on the brane and in the bulk.

The oscillation probability is: $P_{sa} = \sin^2(2\tilde{\theta}) \sin^2(\delta_H D/2)$

For $E_\nu \sim 10^8$ GeV and parsec-scale distances, after phase averaging $P_{sa} \gtrsim 10^{-2}$.

Experimental Constraints and Predictions

Neutrino Production Rate Estimation

For a 5D primordial black hole with mass $M_\bullet \sim 10^{11}$ GeV during the final evaporation stage:

• Instantaneous emission of approximately $S \sim 10^3$ secondary particles
• Bulk radiation contains: 5 graviton degrees of freedom, 6 right-handed neutrino degrees of freedom, 4 sterile Dirac fermion degrees of freedom
• 27% of emitted particles are eV-scale sterile neutrinos

Within the energy range $0.95 \lesssim E_\nu/(10^8 \text{ GeV}) \lesssim 1.05$:

• Sterile neutrinos produced per primordial black hole: $\zeta_{\nu_s} \sim 0.27 S f_{\Delta E} \sim 2.7$
• Active neutrinos after oscillation: $\zeta_{\nu_a} \sim 0.027$

Density Requirements

To explain the KM3-230213A event, the required primordial black hole number density is: $n_{PBH} \sim 4 \times 10^{-32} \text{ cm}^{-3}$

Corresponding energy density: $\rho_{PBH} \sim 4 \times 10^{-21} \text{ GeV/cm}^3$

Relative to dark matter: $f_{PBH} \equiv \frac{\rho_{PBH}}{\rho_{DM}} \sim 10^{-20}$

IceCube Constraint Verification

IceCube constraints on supermassive dark matter decay can be reinterpreted as: $\Gamma_{PBH} f_{PBH} \lesssim 10^{-29.7} \text{ s}^{-1}$

Using the primordial black hole decay width $\Gamma_{PBH} \sim 10^{-17}(M/10^{10.4}\text{ g})^{-2}$ s$^{-1}$, this constraint is satisfied with a safety margin exceeding 8 orders of magnitude.

Advantages and Distinctive Features

Evasion of Gamma-Ray Constraints

• Bulk Radiation Characteristics: 5D primordial black holes primarily radiate into bulk space, remaining "invisible" to brane observers
• Emission Suppression: The phase space suppression factor $(T/r_s)^{d-4}$ between brane and bulk significantly reduces standard model mode emission
• Energy Comparison: 5D black holes emit only $O(10^{11})$ GeV energy to visible modes, $10^{28}$ times less than 4D black holes of equal mass

Resonance Enhancement Mechanism

• Line-like Features: Although Hawking radiation itself produces a broad spectrum, resonant oscillation effects generate line-like characteristics
• Energy Selectivity: Oscillation probability is significantly enhanced near the resonance energy ($E_{res} = 10^8$ GeV)
• Natural Explanation: Explains the observed energy scale without artificial parameter tuning

Limitations and Challenges

Theoretical Assumptions

1. Shortcut Parameter: The extremely small value $\epsilon \sim 5 \times 10^{-35}$ requires detailed explanation from brane dynamics theory
2. Black Hole Localization: Assumes primordial black holes are located in the bulk far from the brane, lacking detailed formation mechanism analysis
3. Model Dependence: Specific details of bulk and brane theory affect whether black holes can "escape" into the bulk

Observational Verification Difficulties

1. Rare Events: The required primordial black hole density is extremely low ($f_{PBH} \sim 10^{-20}$), making verification through other means difficult
2. Single Event: Explanation based on a single KM3-230213A event carries statistical uncertainty
3. Parameter Tuning: Resonance conditions require precise parameter matching

Experimental Predictions

The model predicts:

• Neutrino Line Features: Narrow spectral features near $10^8$ GeV with no corresponding gamma-ray signal
• Isotropic Distribution: If primordial black holes are uniformly distributed in the galactic halo
• Transient Characteristics: The rapid nature of black hole evaporation may produce transient signals

Comparison with Related Work

Traditional 4D Primordial Black Holes

• Gamma-Ray Problem: 4D primordial black holes ($M \sim 10^{39}$ GeV) radiate at temperature $T \sim 5$ MeV, producing strong gamma-ray signals
• Strict Constraints: Existing gamma-ray observations impose severe limits on 4D primordial black hole density

Memory Burden Effect

• Lifetime Extension: Extends black hole lifetime through $\tau_B \sim S^{1+k} r_s$
• Parameter Dependence: Requires artificial parameter $k > 1$ to evade observational constraints
• Theoretical Foundation: Lacks solid theoretical basis

Other Ultra-High-Energy Neutrino Explanations

• Cosmogenic Origin: Shows 3.5σ tension with IceCube observations
• Transient Sources: Partially alleviates tension but requires additional mechanisms
• Dark Matter Decay: Faces gamma-ray constraint challenges

Conclusions and Future Perspectives

Main Conclusions

1. Successful Explanation: The 5D primordial black hole evaporation mechanism naturally explains the energy scale of the KM3-230213A event
2. Constraint Evasion: Successfully evades strict gamma-ray observational constraints through bulk radiation characteristics
3. Theoretical Consistency: Remains consistent with existing IceCube dark matter search results
4. Predictive Power: Provides testable experimental predictions

Future Directions

1. Brane Dynamics Theory: Develop detailed brane fluctuation theory to explain the shortcut parameter
2. Numerical Simulations: Perform precise numerical calculations to determine optimal fit parameters
3. Observational Verification: Search for additional neutrino events at similar energies to test the model
4. Multi-Messenger Analysis: Combine other detection methods such as gravitational waves to search for 5D black hole signals

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Innovation: First combination of dark dimension theory with ultra-high-energy neutrino observations, providing a novel perspective
2. Self-Consistency: Internal logic of theoretical framework is consistent, with mutually supporting components
3. Predictive Power: Provides explicit experimental predictions with verifiability
4. Constraint Handling: Cleverly evades strict constraints faced by traditional 4D theory

Weaknesses

1. Parameter Tuning: Critical parameters ($\epsilon$) require extreme fine-tuning, lacking naturalness
2. Statistical Foundation: Explanation based on a single event has statistical limitations
3. Theoretical Completeness: Brane dynamics and black hole formation mechanisms require further development
4. Experimental Verification: Verification of predictions requires long-term observation and higher-precision detectors

Impact Assessment

This work has significant importance at the intersection of theoretical physics and astrophysics:

• Provides new observational testing pathways for extra dimension theories
• Opens new research directions in ultra-high-energy neutrino astrophysics
• May promote the design and construction of next-generation neutrino detectors

Applicable Scenarios

This theoretical framework is particularly suitable for:

1. Explaining ultra-high-energy neutrino events lacking gamma-ray counterparts
2. Exploring experimental signals at quantum gravity scales
3. Studying astrophysical effects of extra dimensions
4. Developing new dark matter candidate models

Overall Assessment: This is a highly innovative theoretical physics paper that cleverly combines cutting-edge concepts from particle physics, cosmology, and astrophysics. While some theoretical assumptions require further verification, the novel perspective and testable predictions it provides make it an important contribution to the field.