Phonon- and magnon-mediated decoherence of a magnonic qubit

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2506.08823
• Title: Phonon- and magnon-mediated decoherence of a magnonic qubit
• Authors: Vemund Falch, Arne Brataas, and Jeroen Danon (Center for Quantum Spintronics, Norwegian University of Science and Technology)
• Classification: cond-mat.mes-hall
• Publication Date: October 16, 2025
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2506.08823

Abstract

This paper investigates decoherence of magnonic qubits in small ferrimagnetic insulators by calculating relaxation and dephasing rates arising from magnon-phonon and magnon-magnon interactions. The authors combine the Bloch-Redfield description with Keldysh nonequilibrium field theory to obtain explicit expressions for the rates. For a qubit defined by the uniform mode with quadratic dispersion, decay into two phonons is found to be the only allowed relaxation process at zero temperature. In yttrium iron garnet (YIG), the low resonance frequency and heavy unit cell strongly suppress this process. The study reveals that the dephasing rate is inversely proportional to the magnet size and damping, potentially becoming substantial for small and clean magnets.

Research Background and Motivation

Problem Definition

The quantum computing field seeks optimal qubit implementations with long coherence times, high gate fidelities, fast operation speeds, and scalability. Magnons, quantized spin excitations in ordered magnets, have attracted considerable attention due to their unique properties, particularly the intrinsic low damping of insulating magnets such as YIG.

Research Significance

1. Quantum Computing Development Needs: Despite significant progress in quantum computing, optimal qubit implementations remain to be identified
2. Magnon Quantum Properties: Magnons have demonstrated non-classical behavior, including single-magnon states, antibunched magnons, and squeezed states
3. Strong Coupling Characteristics: Magnons exhibit strong coupling with electrons, photons, superconducting qubits, and phonons
4. Practical Application Potential: Magnonic systems have been proposed as platforms for quantum logic gates and quantum memory

Limitations of Existing Approaches

Existing research on magnonic qubits has primarily focused on implementation schemes, while lacking in-depth theoretical analysis of coherence properties and decoherence mechanisms arising from environmental interactions.

Core Contributions

1. Theoretical Framework Establishment: A comprehensive theoretical framework for calculating magnonic qubit decoherence rates is established by combining the Bloch-Redfield master equation method with Keldysh formalism
2. Analytical Expression Derivation: Analytical expressions for relaxation and dephasing rates are derived for a simple magnon model with quadratic dispersion
3. Physical Mechanism Revelation: The unique allowed relaxation process at zero temperature is identified as two-phonon emission, strongly suppressed in YIG
4. Size Effect Analysis: The scaling relationship between dephasing rate and magnet size and Gilbert damping is revealed
5. Material Optimization Guidance: Important theoretical guidance is provided for the feasibility of magnonic quantum devices

Methodology Details

Task Definition

Investigation of decoherence phenomena in a specific magnon mode (wave vector k₀) serving as a qubit in small ferrimagnetic insulators, arising from interactions with other magnon modes and phonon modes.

Theoretical Model Architecture

1. System Hamiltonian

The total Hamiltonian comprises three parts:

Ĥ = Ĥ₀ + ĤE + V̂

• Ĥ₀: Free Hamiltonian of the k₀ magnon mode
• ĤE: Hamiltonian of environmental modes (other magnons and phonons)
• V̂: Interaction terms, including magnon-phonon coupling V̂⁽ᵖ⁾ and magnon-magnon coupling V̂⁽ᵐ⁾

2. Magnon-Phonon Interaction

The interaction contains three main contributions:

• V̂⁽¹¹⁾: One-magnon-one-phonon processes
• V̂⁽¹²⁾: One-magnon-two-phonon processes
• V̂⁽²¹⁾: Two-magnon-one-phonon processes

3. Bloch-Redfield Equation

Under the Born-Markov approximation, the evolution equation for the reduced density matrix:

d/dt ρₙₘ⁰ = -iωₙₘρₙₘ⁰ - ∑ₖₗ Rₙₘₖₗρₖₗ⁰

Technical Innovations

1. Keldysh Formalism Application

• Keldysh path integral formulation for nonequilibrium systems
• Correlation function calculation via functional derivatives
• Treatment of finite lifetime effects

2. Analytical Calculation Methods

• Quadratic dispersion relation obtained in the long-wavelength limit
• Momentum summations converted to integrals
• Closed-form analytical expressions derived

3. Many-Body Interaction Treatment

• Systematic treatment of magnetoelastic anisotropy coupling
• Inclusion of local modulation from exchange interactions
• Consideration of four-magnon interaction processes

Experimental Setup

Material Parameters

The study primarily focuses on YIG with the following parameters:

• Lattice constant: a = 12.376 Å
• Exchange energy: Eₑₓ = 3.45 meV
• Sound velocities: vₜ = 3843 m/s, vₗ = 2vₜ
• Magnon-phonon coupling constants: B∥ = 4.12 meV, B⊥ = 8.24 meV

Theoretical Assumptions

1. Weak Damping Limit: ηₖ, η̃q,λ → 0
2. Long-Wavelength Approximation: ka ≪ 1
3. Uniform Mode: Selection of k₀ = 0 as the qubit mode
4. Continuum Approximation: Conversion of summations to integrals

Calculation Methods

• Holstein-Primakoff transformation for spin operators
• Rotating wave approximation to neglect rapidly oscillating terms
• Separate calculation of relaxation rate Γ₁ and dephasing rate Γφ

Experimental Results

Main Results

1. Relaxation Rate Contributions

The relaxation rate Γ₁ contains four independent contributions:

One-magnon-two-phonon processes:

Γ₁⁽¹²⁾ = γ⁺ₗ,ₜ + γ⁻ₗ,ₜ + γ⁺ₗ,ₗ + γ⁺ₜ,ₜ

Two-magnon-one-phonon processes:

Γ₁⁽²¹⁾ = γ⁽ᶜ⁾ + γ⁽ⁿᶜ⁾

Four-magnon processes:

Γ₁⁽ᵐ⁾ ≈ (T²K²z)/(16π³ℏE³ₑₓ) e⁻ℏω₀/T

2. Zero-Temperature Behavior

In the T → 0 limit, only the γ⁺α,β terms survive, corresponding to the decay of the qubit excited state into two phonons.

3. Numerical Results in YIG

For a qubit with ω₀/2π = 20 GHz:

• Two-phonon process prefactor: ~8 × 10⁻⁴ s⁻¹
• Two-magnon-one-phonon process prefactor: ~3 × 10⁴ s⁻¹
• Four-magnon process prefactor: ~9 × 10³ s⁻¹

4. Dephasing Rate Scaling Relation

Γφ ∝ 1/(αN) × (T/ℏω₀)³/² × e⁻ℏω₀/T

where α is the Gilbert damping parameter and N is the number of unit cells.

Key Findings

1. Strong Suppression Effect: The two-phonon process in YIG is strongly suppressed due to the heavy unit cell and low frequency
2. Size Dependence: The dephasing rate is inversely proportional to magnet size, potentially becoming large in small magnets
3. Damping Dependence: The dephasing rate is inversely proportional to Gilbert damping, with faster dephasing in clean magnets
4. Temperature Scaling: Different processes exhibit different temperature dependencies

Related Work

Magnon Quantum Information Processing

• Double-Well Structure Scheme: Utilizing double-well structures formed by dipolar interactions
• Kerr Effect Scheme: Exploiting nonlinear magnon Kerr effect for anharmonic level structures
• Quantum Logic Gates: Complete sets of quantum logic gates based on magnonic qubits

Magnon-Phonon Interaction Theory

• Magnetoelastic coupling theory by Streib et al.
• Magnetoelastic modes and magnon lifetime studies by Rückriegel et al.
• Microscopic theoretical models of magnon damping

Quantum Decoherence Theory

• Bloch-Redfield master equation method
• Keldysh nonequilibrium field theory
• Applicability of Born-Markov approximation

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Zero-Temperature Relaxation Mechanism: At zero temperature, magnonic qubits can only relax through two-phonon emission
2. YIG Advantages: The heavy unit cell and low resonance frequency in YIG strongly suppress the two-phonon process
3. Size Effects: The dephasing rate inversely scales with magnet size and damping, potentially becoming a limiting factor for small and clean magnets
4. Theoretical Lower Bound: The calculated results provide a fundamental theoretical lower bound for magnonic qubit decoherence

Limitations

1. Continuum Approximation: Neglects discrete level structure, requiring magnet size ≫ 200 nm
2. Neglect of Dipolar Interactions: The simplified model does not include long-range dipolar interactions
3. Born-Markov Approximation: The approximation breaks down when Γφ ≫ ηₖ
4. Surface Effects: Does not account for surface imperfections and impurity effects in practical devices

Future Directions

1. Non-Markovian Dynamics: Investigation of complete retarded interactions when Born-Markov approximation fails
2. Geometric Effects: Inclusion of dipolar interactions and finite-size effects
3. Non-Resonant Contributions: Calculation of non-resonant processes with finite broadening beyond continuum approximation
4. Experimental Verification: Comparison with millikelvin experimental results to validate theoretical predictions

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Theoretical Completeness: A comprehensive theoretical framework for magnonic qubit decoherence is established
2. Advanced Methodology: Skillful combination of Bloch-Redfield and Keldysh methods for many-body problems
3. Analytical Solvability: Closed-form analytical expressions obtained under reasonable approximations
4. Deep Physical Insights: Reveals the physical essence and scaling relationships of different decoherence mechanisms
5. High Practical Value: Provides important theoretical guidance for magnonic quantum device design

Shortcomings

1. Model Simplification: Neglect of dipolar interactions may underestimate relaxation rates in certain geometric configurations
2. Limited Applicability Range: Continuum approximation restricts applicability to small-size devices
3. Insufficient Experimental Comparison: Lacks direct quantitative comparison with existing experimental data
4. Non-Markovian Effects: Born-Markov approximation may fail in clean small magnets

Impact

1. Theoretical Contribution: Provides important theoretical foundation for magnonic quantum information processing
2. Practical Guidance: Assists in optimizing material selection and geometric design of magnonic quantum devices
3. Field Advancement: Promotes cross-disciplinary fusion of magnonics and quantum information science
4. Methodological Demonstration: Exemplifies effective theoretical approaches for complex many-body quantum systems

Application Scenarios

1. Material Screening: Evaluation of potential of different magnetic materials as qubit carriers
2. Device Design: Guidance for size and geometric optimization of magnonic quantum devices
3. Experimental Interpretation: Provides theoretical framework for interpreting magnon coherence experiments
4. Technology Roadmap Assessment: Evaluation of feasibility of magnonic quantum computing technology

References

The paper cites 81 important references, covering:

• Quantum computing fundamentals (Feynman, Ladd, et al.)
• Magnonics research (Serga, Chumak, Yuan, et al.)
• Quantum decoherence theory (Redfield, Burkard, et al.)
• Magnon-phonon interactions (Streib, Rückriegel, et al.)
• Keldysh field theory methods (Kamenev, et al.)

Overall Assessment: This is a high-quality theoretical physics paper providing in-depth theoretical analysis of the decoherence problem in magnonic qubits. The paper employs advanced methods, rigorous calculations, and meaningful results, with significant value for the field of magnonic quantum information processing. Despite certain limitations in theoretical approximations, it establishes an important theoretical foundation for the development of this field.