Nonlocal correlations for semiclassical states in loop quantum gravity

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2506.19729
• Title: Nonlocal correlations for semiclassical states in loop quantum gravity
• Authors: Filipe H. C. Menezes, N. Yokomizo (Federal University of Minas Gerais, Brazil)
• Classification: gr-qc (General Relativity and Quantum Cosmology)
• Publication Date: October 13, 2025
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2506.19729

Abstract

This paper calculates two-point correlation functions of the area operator for semiclassical states in loop quantum gravity (LQG) in the large-spin limit. The study considers both intrinsic and extrinsic coherent states, as well as a new class of semiclassical states constructed as perturbations of Livine-Speziale coherent states. For conventional coherent states, the correlation functions exhibit short-range behavior with exponential decay over distance. By introducing perturbations arising from correlated fundamental excitations and decay of the gravitational field along paired loops, new states are obtained that display long-range correlations while maintaining the peakedness properties of the unperturbed state. The perturbed coherent states include examples that reproduce the typical correlation decay associated with geometric quantum fluctuations of free gravitons on the background metric. This behavior represents a natural requirement for compatibility between semiclassical states in quantum gravity and the physical regime described by perturbative quantum gravity.

Research Background and Motivation

Problem Background

1. Classical Limit Problem: Loop quantum gravity (LQG), as a quantum gravity theory, must reduce to general relativity in the appropriate semiclassical regime. While consistent classical limits have been observed in highly symmetric spacetimes (such as cosmology and black holes), a complete description of the classical limit for general spacetimes remains an open problem.
2. Construction of Semiclassical States: Existing semiclassical states (such as Livine-Speziale coherent states and thermal kernel states), while exhibiting peakedness on classical geometric configurations, have correlation properties that do not match expectations from perturbative quantum gravity.
3. Importance of Correlation Functions: In perturbative quantum gravity, quantum fluctuations of the gravitational field are highly entangled, with correlations of field amplitude fluctuations decaying polynomially as 1/d² at large distances. This correlation is responsible for the appearance of the area law of entanglement entropy and represents a necessary criterion for semiclassical state selection in any quantum gravity theory.

Research Motivation

Existing LQG semiclassical states do not display the same 1/d² correlation decay behavior as in the continuum, making them incompatible with the semiclassical regime described by perturbative quantum gravity. Therefore, it is necessary to construct new semiclassical states that maintain peakedness and small fluctuation properties while displaying the correct long-range correlations.

Core Contributions

1. Calculated correlation functions of existing coherent states: For the first time, systematically computed the area-area two-point correlation functions of Livine-Speziale coherent states and thermal kernel states in the large-spin limit, finding that both exhibit short-range correlations with correlation lengths spanning only a few lattice sites.
2. Proposed a new method for constructing perturbed coherent states: Through angular momentum recoupling theory, constructed perturbed states that maintain semiclassical properties by composing the spins of two-loop states with the spins of LS coherent states.
3. Achieved tunable long-range correlations: The newly constructed states can display long-range correlations, particularly reproducing 1/d² decay behavior consistent with quantum fluctuations of free gravitons.
4. Provided analytical calculation methods: Derived analytical expressions for properties of perturbed states in the large-spin limit, including normalization, spin probability distributions, and correlation functions.

Detailed Methodology

Task Definition

Calculate the two-point correlation function of the area operator for semiclassical states in loop quantum gravity: $G(A_\ell, A_{\ell'}) = \langle A_\ell A_{\ell'} \rangle - \langle A_\ell \rangle \langle A_{\ell'} \rangle$

where $A_\ell = a_0 J_\ell$ is the area operator and $a_0 = 8\pi G\hbar\gamma_0$ is the area gap.

Bosonic Representation Framework

Employing the bosonic representation of LQG, which maps spin network states to states of bosonic variables:

• Each node $i$ is associated with a pair of creation and annihilation operators $(a^A_i, a^{A\dagger}_i)$, $A=0,1$
• SU(2) generators: $\vec{J}_i = \frac{1}{2}\vec{\sigma}_{AB} a^{A\dagger}_i a^B_i$
• Spin operator: $J_i = \frac{1}{2}\delta_{AB} a^{A\dagger}_i a^B_i$

Coherent State Construction

LS Coherent States

Determined by parameters $\{(\lambda_{n\mu}, \vec{v}_{n\mu})\}$: $|LS, \{\lambda_{n\mu}, \vec{v}_{n\mu}\}\rangle = P_G P_A \bigotimes_{n\mu} |\lambda_{n\mu}, \vec{v}_{n\mu}\rangle$

where $P_A$ is the area-matching projection operator and $P_G$ is the Gaussian projection operator.

Thermal Kernel States

Labeled by parameters $\{H_\ell, t_\ell\}$: $|HK, \{H_\ell, t_\ell\}\rangle = P_G P_A \bigotimes_\ell |H_\ell, t_\ell\rangle$

Perturbed State Construction

Spin Composition Operation

Define the unitary map for angular momentum addition: $T_i: H_i \otimes H_i \rightarrow H_i$$|j_a m_a\rangle_i \otimes |j_b m_b\rangle_i \mapsto \sum_{J,M} C^{JM}_{j_a m_a j_b m_b} |JM\rangle_i$

Perturbed State Definition

$|\Psi\rangle = |\Psi_0\rangle + \gamma \sum_{\alpha_1,\alpha_2} c_{\alpha_1\alpha_2} |\square\square\rangle$

where:

• $|\Psi_0\rangle$ is the LS coherent state with fixed spin
• $|\square\square\rangle = \mathcal{N} |\Psi_0\rangle \cdot |\alpha_1\alpha_2\rangle$ is the perturbation term
• $|\alpha_1\alpha_2\rangle$ is the two-loop state
• $\gamma \ll 1$ is the small perturbation parameter

Experimental Setup

Lattice Model

A cubic lattice $\Gamma$ with periodic boundary conditions containing $N^3$ nodes is employed. Each node corresponds to a cube, and each link corresponds to a face. Normal vectors are chosen parallel to Euclidean coordinate axes: $\vec{v}_{n1} = -\vec{v}_{n4} = \frac{\hat{x}}{2}, \quad \vec{v}_{n2} = -\vec{v}_{n5} = \frac{\hat{y}}{2}, \quad \vec{v}_{n3} = -\vec{v}_{n6} = \frac{\hat{z}}{2}$

Large-Spin Limit

The large-spin limit $j_0 \gg 1$ is considered, under which:

• The spin probability distribution of LS coherent states approaches a Gaussian distribution
• Asymptotic approximations can be used to calculate correlation functions

Experimental Results

Correlation Functions of LS Coherent States

In the large-spin limit, the correlation function for a one-dimensional sublattice is: $G(R) \simeq \frac{j_0}{5} e^{-2.3R}$

The correlation length $\xi \simeq 0.43$ indicates short-range correlations.

Correlation Functions of Thermal Kernel States

$G(R) \simeq \frac{j_0}{(1+4tj_0)} [2(1+4tj_0)]^{-R}$

The correlation length $\xi = \frac{1}{\log[2(1+4tj_0)]} < \frac{1}{\log 2} \simeq 1.44$ also exhibits short-range correlations.

Properties of Perturbed States

Normalization

$\langle\Psi|\Psi\rangle = 1 + \gamma^2 \sum_{\alpha_1\alpha_2} (c_{\alpha_1\alpha_2})^2$

Spin Expectation Value and Fluctuations

$\langle J_\ell \rangle = j_0 + \frac{\gamma^2}{2j_0} \sum_{\alpha_1\cup\alpha_2 \ni \ell} (c_{\alpha_1\alpha_2})^2$

Relative fluctuation: $\frac{\sigma_{j_\ell}}{\langle J_\ell \rangle} = \frac{\gamma}{2j_0} \sqrt{\sum_{\alpha_1\cup\alpha_2 \ni \ell} (c_{\alpha_1\alpha_2})^2}$

In the large-spin limit, this approaches zero, preserving semiclassical properties.

Long-Range Correlation Functions

$G(A_\ell, A_{\ell'}) = a_0^2 \frac{\gamma^2}{4j_0^2} \sum_{\substack{\alpha_1 \ni \ell \\ \alpha_2 \ni \ell'}} (c_{\alpha_1\alpha_2})^2$

By choosing $c_{\alpha_1\alpha_2}$ proportional to the inverse of the distance between loops, 1/d² decay behavior can be realized.

Related Work

LQG Semiclassical State Research

• Intrinsic Coherent States: Livine-Speziale coherent states exhibit semiclassical properties on intrinsic geometry
• Extrinsic Coherent States: Thermal kernel states exhibit semiclassical properties on both intrinsic and extrinsic geometry
• Squeezed Vacuum States: Previously constructed via squeezing operators in 29, but with high computational complexity

Distinction from This Work

This work directly considers gauge-invariant loop excitations, simplifying calculations and automatically preserving gauge invariance.

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Limitations of Existing Coherent States: Both LS coherent states and thermal kernel states display short-range correlations with correlation lengths spanning only a few lattice sites, inconsistent with expectations from perturbative quantum gravity.
2. Success of New Perturbed States: The new states constructed through two-loop perturbations maintain semiclassical properties while displaying the required long-range correlations.
3. Compatibility with Perturbative Quantum Gravity: Perturbed states can reproduce the typical 1/d² correlation decay of free gravitons.

Limitations

1. Kinematical Framework: The constructed states remain in the kinematical Hilbert space without considering the Hamiltonian constraint.
2. Perturbative Approximation: The method is based on perturbative expansion in the small parameter $\gamma$, which may limit its applicability.
3. Specific Lattice: Calculations are primarily performed on cubic lattices; generalization to other geometries requires further investigation.

Future Directions

1. Effects of Hamiltonian Constraint: Study how the existence of correlations affects the action of the Hamiltonian constraint.
2. More General Perturbations: Consider higher-order perturbations involving more or longer loops.
3. Construction of Physical States: Extend the method to physical states satisfying all constraints.

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Important Problem: Addresses the key issue of compatibility between semiclassical states in LQG and perturbative quantum gravity.
2. Methodological Innovation: Proposes a novel perturbation method based on angular momentum recoupling that is technically sophisticated and controllable.
3. Analytical Results: Provides complete analytical calculations in the large-spin limit with clear and definitive results.
4. Clear Physical Meaning: The constructed states have transparent physical interpretation, corresponding to correlated perturbations on background geometry.

Weaknesses

1. Incomplete Constraint Treatment: Only considers Gaussian and diffeomorphism constraints; does not address the Hamiltonian constraint.
2. Lack of Numerical Verification: Main results are based on analytical approximations without numerical verification.
3. Practical Applicability Unverified: The practical value of the method requires verification in broader physical scenarios.

Impact

Academic Contribution: Provides important progress in LQG semiclassical state theory, potentially influencing research on semiclassical limits in quantum gravity.

Technical Value: The provided methodological framework can be applied to construct other quantum states with specific correlation properties.

Theoretical Significance: Deepens understanding of the importance of correlation structures in quantum gravity.

Applicable Scenarios

1. Quantum Gravity Phenomenology: Provides new semiclassical state tools for studying quantum gravity effects.
2. Cosmological Applications: May be used to study quantum fluctuations in the early universe.
3. Black Hole Physics: Offers new perspectives for understanding the microscopic origin of black hole entropy.

References

The paper cites 52 related references, primarily including:

• Foundational LQG literature 1-6
• Classical works on semiclassical state construction 14-20
• Research on bosonic representation 17,32,33
• Studies on squeezed states and correlations 29,34-37

Overall Assessment: This is a work of significant theoretical value in the field of loop quantum gravity, proposing an innovative method to address the correlation problem of semiclassical states and making meaningful contributions to research on semiclassical limits in quantum gravity. Despite certain limitations, its technical innovation and physical insights make it an important advance in the field.