Unraveling dark Higgs mechanism via dark photon production at an e^+ e^- collider

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2506.20208
• Title: Unraveling dark Higgs mechanism via dark photon production at an e^+ e^- collider
• Authors: Song Li, Jin Min Yang, Mengchao Zhang, Yang Zhang, Rui Zhu
• Classification: hep-ph (High Energy Physics - Phenomenology)
• Publication Date: October 14, 2025 (arXiv v2)
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2506.20208

Abstract

In phenomenological studies of dark photons, the origin of their mass is often overlooked. However, in theoretical constructions, the dark photon mass typically arises through the dark Higgs mechanism, leading to the existence of a light (non-decoupling) dark Higgs particle. This work investigates the effects of such a dark Higgs particle on collider detection of dark photons. The focus is on the process where the final-state dark photon radiates a dark Higgs, termed dark final-state radiation (dark FSR). Taking into account the effects on signal cross-section and the missing mass squared distribution, the BaBar invisible dark photon search is reanalyzed, and new exclusion limits on invisible dark photons are provided.

Research Background and Motivation

Problem Background

1. Dark matter detection impasse: The natural parameter space of traditional WIMP models has been largely excluded by experiments, prompting research to shift toward "dark sector" models
2. Dark photon mass origin: In dark photon phenomenology studies, the mass is typically assumed to arise from the Stueckelberg mechanism, but this treatment neglects the existence of the dark Higgs particle
3. Theoretical completeness: The Stueckelberg mechanism is valid only when the dark Higgs self-coupling λ and dark gauge coupling g' satisfy λ ≫ g', but this condition often does not hold in practical models

Research Motivation

1. Filling theoretical gaps: Existing research primarily considers visible dark photon decays, with insufficient investigation of dark Higgs effects in the invisible case
2. Experimental reanalysis: Reassessing the exclusion capability of existing experiments by considering dark FSR effects
3. Phenomenological refinement: Establishing a more complete dark sector theoretical framework that includes the full effects of the dark Higgs mechanism

Core Contributions

1. First study of invisible dark photon + dark Higgs system: Considering dark FSR effects in the e^+e^- → γA's process
2. Development of dark shower method: Resolving collinear divergence problems in the high-energy limit
3. Establishment of merging technique: Merging dark shower results with fixed-order calculations for reliable theoretical predictions
4. Reanalysis of BaBar data: Providing new exclusion limits considering dark FSR effects
5. Quantification of systematic uncertainties: Assessing the impact of the dark Higgs mechanism on experimental limits

Methodology Details

Theoretical Framework

Dark Sector Model

The model is based on spontaneously broken dark U(1)' gauge symmetry, with Lagrangian:

L_dark = (D_μS)†D^μS - (1/4)F'_μνF'^μν + μ²S†S - (1/4)λ(S†S)² + χ̄(i∂/ - m_χ)χ - εeJ^EM_μA'_μ

Where:

• S is the complex dark Higgs field with vacuum expectation value v = 2μ/√λ
• A' is the dark photon field
• χ is a light dark fermion enabling invisible dark photon decay
• ε is the kinetic mixing parameter

Particle Mass Relations

After symmetry breaking, the particle masses are:

• Dark Higgs mass: m²_s = (1/2)λv²
• Dark photon mass: m²_A' = g'²v²
• Simplified assumption: m_s = m_A' = m

Dark Final-State Radiation (Dark FSR)

Physical Process

Dark FSR describes the process where the final-state dark photon emits a dark Higgs: A' → A's, realized through A'A's and A'(a↔∂_μs) interactions.

Splitting Functions

The leading-order splitting kernels are:

• P^A'_T→s+A'_L(z) = zz̄ (transverse → longitudinal)
• P^A'_L→s+A'_T(z) = 2z/z̄ (longitudinal → transverse)

Where z is the energy fraction and z̄ = 1-z.

Dark Shower Technique

Collinear Divergence Problem

When (m_A' + m_s) ≪ √s, fixed-order calculations exhibit non-physical enhancement or divergence.

Solution

1. Veto algorithm: Employing transverse momentum-ordered evolution scheme
2. Pythia8.3 implementation: Modifying Hidden Valley model code
3. Alternating splitting: Alternating invocation of A'_T → sA'_L and A'_L → sA'_T processes

Merging Procedure

Using ΔR = √((Δη)² + (Δφ)²) as the phase-space division criterion:

• ΔR < ΔR_cut: Using dark shower results
• ΔR > ΔR_cut: Using fixed-order matrix element results

Experimental Setup

BaBar Experimental Parameters

• Collision energy: √s ~ 10 GeV (near Υ(2S), Υ(3S), Υ(4S) resonance peaks)
• Integrated luminosity: 53 fb^-1
• Selection criteria:
  • E_γ > 3 GeV
  • |cosθ_γ| < 0.6
  • -4 < M²_X < 36 GeV²

Model Parameters

• Dark fine structure constant: α' = 0.5 (benchmark value)
• Mass range: m ∈ 0.001, 2 GeV
• Kinetic mixing: ε as scanning parameter

Analysis Strategy

1. Signal enhancement: σ_tot = σ_no-FSR + σ_FSR
2. Distribution correction: Broadening of missing mass squared M²_X distribution
3. Detector effects: Using Crystal Ball function to simulate resolution
4. Statistical analysis: 90% C.L. upper limits based on CLs method

Experimental Results

Dark Shower Probabilities

Under √s = 10 GeV, α' = 0.5 conditions:

• Probability of radiating one dark Higgs: ~6% (when m ≪ √s)
• Probability of radiating ≥3 dark Higgs: <0.1%
• Mass dependence: Probability remains essentially constant when m ≪ √s, declining above threshold

Cross-Section Corrections

Dark FSR effects on total cross-section:

• Low mass region (m < 0.1 GeV): S_cxs ≈ 0.90
• High mass region: S_cxs increases with mass
• Distribution effects: S_fit ≈ 1.03-1.04 (due to signal shape modification)

New Exclusion Limits

After considering dark FSR effects:

• Relative variation: ε'/ε₀ ≈ 0.97 (m < 0.2 GeV)
• Systematic uncertainty: Maximum relative uncertainty approximately 3.4%
• Overall effect: New limits slightly stronger than original BaBar results, as cross-section enhancement dominates

Missing Mass Distribution

Dark FSR causes M²_X distribution to:

1. Peak reduction: Due to partial event transfer to high M²_X region
2. Right tail broadening: Dark Higgs radiation shifts M²_X toward higher values
3. Overall flattening: Original delta-function peak becomes finite-width distribution

Related Work

Current Status of Dark Photon Research

1. Experimental searches: Beam dump experiments, low-energy e^+e^- colliders, fixed-target experiments, etc.
2. Theoretical models: Primarily described by two parameters (m_A', ε)
3. Existing limits: Large regions of (m_A', ε) parameter space excluded

Dark Higgs-Related Research

1. Visible decay studies: Existing work considers dark photon decay to lepton pairs or charged mesons
2. Dark Higgs radiation: Primarily studies e^+e^- → A's process
3. Innovation in this work: First study of e^+e^- → γA's process in the invisible case

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Dark FSR effects are significant: On high-energy colliders, dark Higgs radiation cannot be neglected
2. Dual effects: Both enhancing signal cross-section and modifying distribution shape
3. Net effect: Cross-section enhancement dominates, leading to slightly strengthened exclusion limits
4. Theoretical completeness: Complete consideration of the dark Higgs mechanism is necessary for precise phenomenological analysis

Limitations

1. Simplified assumptions: The assumption m_s = m_A' may not be sufficiently general
2. Single experiment: Only reanalyzes BaBar data, lacking verification from other experiments
3. Parameter dependence: Results are sensitive to α' value, requiring more comprehensive parameter scans
4. Higher-order effects: Only considers leading-order dark FSR, neglecting next-to-leading-order contributions

Future Directions

1. Other experiments: Extending analysis to Belle, BESIII, and other experiments
2. Parameter scans: Systematically studying effects of different α' and mass ratios
3. Higher-order corrections: Including next-to-leading-order dark FSR and virtual corrections
4. Model extensions: Considering more complex dark sector models

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Theoretical rigor: First systematic consideration of the complete effects of dark Higgs mechanism on dark photon searches
2. Methodological innovation: Extending parton shower techniques from particle physics to dark sectors
3. Advanced techniques: Properly handling merging of dark shower with fixed-order calculations
4. Experimental relevance: Direct application to reanalysis of existing experimental data
5. Quantitative assessment: Providing quantitative estimates of systematic uncertainties

Weaknesses

1. Parameter limitations: Only considers specific model parameter combinations
2. Experimental scope: Reanalyzes data from only one experiment
3. Theoretical approximations: Some theoretical assumptions may be oversimplified
4. Statistical treatment: Statistical analysis is relatively simple and could be more refined

Impact

1. Academic value: Provides new analytical framework for dark matter theoretical research
2. Experimental guidance: Offers theoretical guidance for future dark photon search experiments
3. Method generalization: Dark shower technique applicable to other dark sector studies
4. Phenomenological advancement: Promotes dark photon phenomenology toward more complete development

Applicable Scenarios

1. High-energy e^+e^- colliders: Particularly suitable for Belle II, future super τ-charm factories, etc.
2. Dark sector models: Applicable to various dark matter models with dark Higgs mechanism
3. Precision measurements: Particularly important for experimental analyses requiring precise theoretical predictions
4. New physics searches: Provides theoretical support for Beyond Standard Model physics searches

References

The paper cites 85 references, covering dark matter experimental searches, dark photon theory, parton shower techniques, statistical analysis methods, and other aspects, reflecting the breadth and depth of the research. Important references include dark photon search results from BaBar and Belle experiments, as well as foundational work on dark sector theory.

Overall Assessment: This is a high-quality theoretical physics paper of significant importance in dark photon phenomenology. The paper not only treats the dark Higgs mechanism more completely from a theoretical perspective but also develops new computational techniques and applies the results to actual experimental data analysis. While some limitations exist, it makes substantial contributions to the field's development.