Non-extensive and quasi-homogeneous geometrothermodynamics

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2506.21342
• Title: Non-extensive and quasi-homogeneous geometrothermodynamics
• Authors: Hernando Quevedo (Instituto de Ciencias Nucleares, UNAM, et al.), María N. Quevedo (Universidad Militar Nueva Granada)
• Classification: gr-qc (General Relativity and Quantum Cosmology)
• Publication Date: October 16, 2025
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2506.21342

Abstract

This paper investigates the thermodynamic properties of black holes, accounting for the non-extensive nature of entropy at both thermodynamic and statistical levels. The authors propose that Rényi entropy determines the fundamental thermodynamic equation of black holes and express it through quasi-homogeneous functions. Consequently, the Rényi parameter becomes an independent thermodynamic variable that must be treated within an extended thermodynamic framework. As a specific case, the authors employ geometrothermodynamic formalism to demonstrate that Schwarzschild black holes can achieve stability at specific Rényi parameter values.

Research Background and Motivation

Core Problems

1. Non-extensivity Issue: The Bekenstein-Hawking entropy formula $S_{BH} = A/4$ is proportional to the event horizon area rather than volume, resulting in non-extensive entropy
2. Statistical-Thermodynamic Inconsistency: Hawking temperature derivation employs Boltzmann-Gibbs statistics (applicable to extensive systems), yet black hole entropy is non-extensive
3. Stability Problem: Static black hole thermodynamics in standard Einstein gravity exhibits instability

Research Significance

• Black hole thermodynamics represents a crucial branch of theoretical physics, connecting general relativity, quantum field theory, and thermodynamics
• Resolving the non-extensivity problem is fundamental to understanding the nature of black holes
• Stability analysis relates to black hole phase transitions and physical realizability

Limitations of Existing Approaches

• Although Tsallis entropy is non-extensive, it violates the zeroth law of black hole thermodynamics
• Traditional methods treat non-extensive systems using extensive thermodynamics, creating inherent contradictions
• Lack of a unified geometric framework for handling quasi-homogeneous systems

Core Contributions

1. Established a quasi-homogeneous theoretical framework for Rényi entropy, demonstrating that the Rényi parameter must be treated as an independent thermodynamic variable
2. Developed quasi-homogeneous geometrothermodynamic theory, providing three classes of Legendre-invariant metrics
3. Revealed new stable phases of Schwarzschild black holes, achieving stability within specific Rényi parameter ranges
4. Provided geometric description of phase transitions, identifying second-order phase transitions through curvature singularities

Methodology Details

Task Definition

The study examines black hole thermodynamic properties using Rényi entropy, with inputs comprising black hole parameters (mass M, angular momentum J, charge Q) and the Rényi parameter r, yielding complete thermodynamic descriptions and stability analyses.

Rényi Entropy Framework

Rényi entropy is defined as: $S_R = \frac{1}{r}\ln(1 + rS_{BH})$

where $r \in (-\infty, 1]$ is the non-extensivity parameter, and $r \to 0$ recovers the Bekenstein-Hawking entropy.

Quasi-homogeneity Conditions

For Kerr-Newman black holes, the quasi-homogeneity condition: $S_R(\lambda^{\beta_a}E^a) = \lambda^{\beta_{S_R}}S_R(E^a)$

requires quasi-homogeneity coefficients satisfying: $\beta_Q = \beta_M, \quad \beta_J = 2\beta_M, \quad \beta_r = -2\beta_M, \quad \beta_{S_R} = 2\beta_M$

Geometrothermodynamic Metrics

Three classes of Legendre-invariant metrics:

Metric I: $g_I = \sum_{a,b,c} \left(\beta_c E^c \frac{\partial\Phi}{\partial E^c}\right) \frac{\partial^2\Phi}{\partial E^a\partial E^b} dE^a dE^b$

Metric II: $g_{II} = \sum_{a,b,c,d} \left(\beta_c E^c \frac{\partial\Phi}{\partial E^c}\right) \eta^d_a \frac{\partial^2\Phi}{\partial E^b\partial E^d} dE^a dE^b$

Metric III: $g_{III} = \sum_{a,b} \left(\beta_a E^a \frac{\partial\Phi}{\partial E^a}\right) \frac{\partial^2\Phi}{\partial E^a\partial E^b} dE^a dE^b$

Technical Innovations

1. Quasi-homogeneous Euler identity: $\sum \beta_a I_a E^a = \beta_\Phi \Phi$
2. Correspondence between curvature singularities and phase transitions: Metric singularity conditions directly correspond to thermodynamic stability conditions
3. Thermodynamic interpretation of Rényi parameter: Derived from geometric consistency requirements

Experimental Setup

Research Objects

Schwarzschild black holes serve as the primary research subject, with event horizon $r_h = 2M$ and area $A = 16\pi M^2$.

Rényi Entropy Expression

$S = \frac{1}{r}\ln(1 + 4\pi r M^2)$

Thermodynamic Potential Selection

Using mass as the thermodynamic potential: $M(S,r) = \frac{1}{2}\sqrt{\frac{e^{rS}-1}{\pi r}}$

satisfying the first law: $dM = T dS + R dr$

where $T = \partial M/\partial S$ and $R = \partial M/\partial r$.

Experimental Results

Primary Thermodynamic Quantities

For fixed entropy $S$, the primary thermodynamic quantities are:

$M = \frac{1}{2}\sqrt{\frac{e^{rS}-1}{\pi r}}$

$T = \frac{e^{rS}}{8\pi M}$

$R = \frac{e^{rS}(rS-1)+1}{8\pi r^2 M}$

Phase Transition Conditions

Curvature singularity conditions for the three metrics:

• Condition I: $C_I = \frac{e^{rS}}{r^3 M^4}[e^{rS}(1-2rS) - 4e^{rS}(1-rS) + 3] = 0$
• Condition II: $C_{II} = \frac{e^{rS}(e^{rS}-2)}{r^4 M^6}[\text{complex expression}] = 0$
• Condition III: $C_{III} = \frac{e^{rS}}{\lambda^2 M^3}[e^{rS}(1+rS) - 2rS - 1] = 0$

Key Findings

1. Only Metric II exhibits curvature singularities, corresponding to condition $e^{rS} = 2$
2. Heat capacity formula: $C = \frac{2(e^{rS}-1)}{r(e^{rS}-2)}$
3. Stability transition: Heat capacity diverges at $e^{rS} = 2$, transitioning from unstable phase ($C < 0$) to stable phase ($C > 0$)

Stable Regions

Stable phases exist within the interval $r \in (\frac{\ln 2}{S}, 1]$.

Related Work

Primary Research Directions

1. Non-extensive entropy theories: Applications of Tsallis and Rényi entropy in black hole thermodynamics
2. Extended thermodynamics: Studies treating coupling constants as thermodynamic variables
3. Geometrothermodynamics: Differential geometric methods for thermodynamic systems
4. AdS/CFT framework: Extensivity issues in holographic duality

Advantages of This Work

• First systematic treatment of Rényi parameter as a thermodynamic variable
• Complete geometric description of quasi-homogeneous systems
• Resolution of Schwarzschild black hole stability problem

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Quasi-homogeneity of Rényi entropy naturally requires treating the Rényi parameter as a thermodynamic variable
2. Geometrothermodynamic methods can invariantly describe extended black hole thermodynamics
3. Schwarzschild black holes can achieve stable phases in extended thermodynamics
4. Phase transition structures are completely characterized through geometric curvature singularities

Limitations

1. Analysis primarily restricted to static Schwarzschild black holes
2. Physical interpretation of Rényi parameter requires further investigation
3. Connection to observations remains to be established

Future Directions

1. Extension to rotating black holes (Kerr black holes, etc.)
2. Investigation of more general black hole configurations
3. Exploration of the physical origin of Rényi parameters

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Strong theoretical innovation: First systematic establishment of quasi-homogeneous geometrothermodynamic theory
2. Mathematical rigor: Geometric methods ensure Legendre invariance
3. Important physical significance: Resolves fundamental contradictions in black hole thermodynamics
4. Concrete results: Provides explicit criteria for stability

Weaknesses

1. Physical interpretation: The physical mechanism of Rényi parameter as thermodynamic variable lacks clarity
2. Experimental verification: Absence of observational or numerical verification
3. Universality: Main results based on specific black hole types

Impact

• Theoretical contribution: Provides new framework for non-extensive black hole thermodynamics
• Methodological value: Geometrothermodynamic methods possess universal applicability
• Application prospects: Generalizable to other gravitational theories and black hole types

Applicable Scenarios

1. Black hole thermodynamics and phase transition research
2. Non-extensive statistical mechanics applications
3. Thermodynamic problems in gravitational theories
4. Geometric methods in thermodynamics

References

The paper cites important literature in the field, including:

• Original works on Bekenstein-Hawking entropy
• Non-extensive entropy theories (Tsallis, Rényi)
• Foundational geometrothermodynamic theory
• Related research on black hole phase transitions

Overall Assessment: This paper possesses significant theoretical value in black hole thermodynamics. By introducing a quasi-homogeneous geometrothermodynamic framework, it systematically resolves consistency issues in non-extensive black hole thermodynamics and discovers new stable phases of Schwarzschild black holes. The methodology is rigorous, results are concrete, and the work establishes an important foundation for further development in this field.