Nonlinear Symmetry-Fragmentation of Nonabelian Anyons In Symmetry-Enriched Topological Phases: A String-Net Model Realization

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2506.24115
• Title: Nonlinear Symmetry-Fragmentation of Nonabelian Anyons In Symmetry-Enriched Topological Phases: A String-Net Model Realization
• Authors: Nianrui Fu, Siyuan Wang, Yu Zhao, Yidun Wan (Department of Physics, Fudan University)
• Classification: cond-mat.str-el, cond-mat.stat-mech, hep-th, math-ph, math.MP
• Publication Date: October 11, 2025 (arXiv v2)
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2506.24115v2

Abstract

Symmetry-enriched topological (SET) phases combine intrinsic topological order with global symmetry, producing novel symmetry phenomena. While SET phases with abelian anyons have been relatively well understood, cases involving nonabelian anyons remain elusive. This obscurity stems from the inherent multidimensional internal gauge space of nonabelian anyons—a feature that was clarified and further explored in the authors' recent work. These internal spaces may undergo highly nontrivial transformations under global symmetry operations. This paper employs an exactly solvable model—the multi-fusion Hu-Geer-Wu string-net model—to reveal how the internal gauge space of nonabelian anyons transforms under symmetry operations. The authors discover a universal phenomenon: global symmetry fragmentation (GSF), wherein symmetry-invariant anyons exhibit internal Hilbert space decomposition into eigensubspaces labeled by fractional symmetry charges. These fragmentation structures realize genuine nonlinear symmetry representations, transcending traditional linear and projective classifications.

Research Background and Motivation

Core Problems

1. Symmetry transformation challenges for nonabelian anyons: Conventional topological quantum field theory (TQFT) treats anyons as abstract simple objects in modular tensor categories, obscuring their internal gauge structure. For nonabelian anyons, the manner in which their multidimensional internal Hilbert space transforms under global symmetry operations remains unclear.
2. Incomplete theoretical description of SET phases: Existing symmetry grading theories do not directly correspond to how anyons transform under global symmetry, particularly for nonabelian anyons.

Research Significance

1. Application prospects for topological quantum computation: The D(S₃) model has been proven capable of supporting universal quantum computation. Understanding its behavior in symmetry-enriched phases may provide new control mechanisms for topological quantum computation.
2. Fundamental questions in theoretical physics: Symmetry-enriched topological phases represent novel physical structures beyond the Landau-Ginzburg paradigm and ordinary topological order.

Limitations of Existing Methods

1. Conventional TQFT approach: Treats anyons as structured simple objects, unable to reveal internal gauge structure.
2. Standard string-net models: Require manual assignment of global symmetry and cannot reveal the internal space of anyons.

Core Contributions

1. Proposed the global symmetry fragmentation (GSF) phenomenon: Discovered that the internal Hilbert space of symmetry-invariant anyons decomposes into eigensubspaces with fractional symmetry charges.
2. Constructed an extended HGW string-net model: Enables explicit study of the internal space of nonabelian anyons and their symmetry transformations.
3. Revealed nonlinear symmetry representations: Demonstrated that the symmetry representations realized by fragmentation structures are neither linear nor projective, but genuinely nonlinear.
4. Established exactly solvable models for SET phases: By lifting input unitary fusion categories (UFC) to multi-fusion categories, describes SET phases without ad hoc addition of global symmetry information.

Detailed Methodology

Model Construction

Fundamental String-Net Model

• Lattice structure: Two-dimensional trivalent lattice with one tail per plaquette
• Configuration space: Edges and tails labeled by S₃ group elements
• Constraints: Each vertex satisfies S₃ group multiplication rule ijk = 1

Multi-Fusion Category Input

The extended HGW model uses a multi-fusion category M as input:

$M = \begin{pmatrix} \{1_{++}, r_{++}, r^2_{++}, s_{++}, rs_{++}, sr_{++}\} & \{\alpha_{+-}, \beta_{+-}\} \\ \{\alpha_{-+}, \beta_{-+}\} & \{1_{--}, r_{--}, r^2_{--}, s_{--}, rs_{--}, sr_{--}\} \end{pmatrix}$

where diagonal elements represent degrees of freedom in different symmetry sectors, and off-diagonal elements represent domain wall degrees of freedom.

Anyon Spectrum Analysis

Anyon Types in D(S₃) Phase

This phase contains 8 types of anyons: A, B, C, D, E, F, G, H, where:

• A, B are abelian anyons
• C, D, E, F, G, H are nonabelian anyons with multidimensional internal spaces

Internal Space Structure

Each anyon's internal states are labeled by pairs (p, α):

• p ∈ S₃: flux type
• α: charge space label (dimension of S₃ representation space)

Symmetry Transformation Mechanism

EM Exchange Symmetry

Z₂ symmetry exchanges anyon types C and F:

• Type C: only trivial flux but 2-dimensional charge space
• Type F: two flux types but trivial charge space

Domain Wall Crossing

Symmetry transformation occurs when anyons cross domain walls; transformation matrices can be read directly from the z-tensor.

Experimental Results

Symmetry Fragmentation Patterns

Type H Anyons

Internal space decomposes into two symmetry eigenstates:

• H_r + H_{r²}: symmetry charge 2/3
• H_r - H_{r²}: symmetry charge 1/6

Type G Anyons

Internal space does not undergo fragmentation; acquires symmetry charge 1/3 as a whole.

Composite C⊕F Anyons

4-dimensional representation decomposes into two 2-dimensional representations:

• span{C₁₁ ± F_r, C₁₂ ± F_{r²}}: symmetry charges 0 and 1/2 respectively

Nonlinear Representation Verification

Through combining two consecutive symmetry transformations, the nonlinearity of the representation is verified:

$\sum_b \omega_{ab}\rho^{\tilde{J}}_{ab}(G_{em})\rho^{\tilde{J}}_{bc}(G_{em}) = \rho^{\tilde{J}}_{ac}(1) = 1$

where the ω tensor is generated by Pachner moves and possesses nontrivial component structure, making these representations neither linear nor projective.

Concrete Examples

Nonlinear Representation of Type H Anyons

• ρ_{H+}(G_) = e^{-i2π/3}
• ρ_(G_) = e^{iπ/3}

Composition rule: $\rho_{H±}(G_{em})\rho_{H±}(G_{em}) = e^{i2π/3}\rho_{H±}(1)$

This composition law cannot be realized through linear or projective representations.

Theoretical Significance and Applications

Theoretical Contributions

1. Extended symmetry theory: First explicit description of symmetry transformations of nonabelian anyons in SET phases.
2. Discovery of new representation types: Nonlinear symmetry representations transcend traditional classifications.
3. Established systematic framework: Provides exactly solvable models for studying general SET phases.

Application Prospects

1. Topological quantum computation: Utilize symmetry fragmentation to improve gate operations and algorithmic efficiency.
2. Quantum material design: Provides pathways for engineering novel symmetry-enriched quantum materials.
3. Theoretical physics: Establishes foundation for studying interactions between nonabelian global symmetries and nonabelian anyons.

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Strong theoretical innovation: First systematic study of symmetry transformations of nonabelian anyons in SET phases, discovering the universal phenomenon of global symmetry fragmentation.
2. Rigorous methodology: Based on exactly solvable extended HGW string-net models, all results have rigorous mathematical derivations.
3. Profound results: The discovered nonlinear symmetry representations transcend traditional linear and projective classifications, revealing the deep structure of SET phases.
4. Practical value: Provides new theoretical tools for topological quantum computation and quantum material design.

Limitations

1. Limited concrete examples: Primarily focuses on EM exchange symmetry in D(S₃) phase; verification with more examples would strengthen the generality of conclusions.
2. Lack of experimental verification: Theoretical predictions require experimental or numerical validation.
3. Computational complexity: Calculations may become extremely difficult for more complex groups and anyon systems.

Impact

1. Academic value: Provides new research directions for condensed matter physics, topological quantum field theory, and mathematical physics.
2. Practical prospects: May advance development of topological quantum computation technology.
3. Theoretical completeness: Fills important gaps in SET phase theory.

Applicable Scenarios

1. Theoretical research: Applicable to studying symmetry properties of various SET phases.
2. Quantum computation: Provides theoretical foundation for topological quantum computation based on nonabelian anyons.
3. Materials science: Guides design of topological materials with specific symmetries.

Conclusions and Outlook

This paper systematically studies the behavior of nonabelian anyons in symmetry-enriched topological phases through the extended HGW string-net model, discovering the universal phenomenon of global symmetry fragmentation and proving that the corresponding symmetry representations are genuinely nonlinear. This discovery not only deepens our understanding of SET phases but also opens new possibilities for topological quantum computation and quantum material design.

Future research directions include:

1. Study of interactions between nonabelian global symmetries and nonabelian anyons
2. Exploration of algebraic global symmetries (non-group symmetries)
3. Application of theory to practical topological quantum computation schemes

References

This work builds upon the authors' previous series of works on extended HGW string-net models and is closely related to important literature in topological quantum field theory, symmetry-enriched topological phase theory, and related fields. Particularly noteworthy are connections to the Levin-Wen string-net model, quantum double model theory, and symmetry grading theory.