Dynamic Models for Two Nonreciprocally Coupled Fields: A Microscopic Derivation for Zero, One, and Two Conservation Laws

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2507.01105
• Title: Dynamic Models for Two Nonreciprocally Coupled Fields: A Microscopic Derivation for Zero, One, and Two Conservation Laws
• Authors: Kristian Blom, Uwe Thiele, Aljaž Godec
• Classification: cond-mat.stat-mech, cond-mat.soft, nlin.PS
• Submission Date: July 2025
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2507.01105

Abstract

This paper constructs dynamical models for two nonreciprocally coupled fields with zero, one, and two conservation laws. Starting from two microscopic nonreciprocally coupled Ising models and employing mean-field approximation, closed evolution equations for spatially resolved magnetization at each lattice are obtained. When only single-spin flip dynamics are permitted, the macroscopic equations in the thermodynamic limit are closely related to nonreciprocal Allen-Cahn equations, i.e., without conservation laws. Similarly, considering only spin-exchange dynamics within each lattice, the thermodynamic limit yields equations analogous to nonreciprocal Cahn-Hilliard models, i.e., with two conservation laws. In the case of spin-exchange dynamics both within and between lattices, two nonreciprocally coupled equations are obtained that together form one conservation law. For each case, the possible linear instabilities are systematically mapped. Furthermore, numerous additional models are obtained by combining different dynamics.

Research Background and Motivation

Problem Definition

Nonreciprocal interactions in multicomponent systems have attracted widespread attention, appearing in diverse physical and biological systems including nonequilibrium fluids, predator-prey networks, and many-body lattice models. At the microscopic scale, nonreciprocity reflects effective violations of Newton's third law or breakdown of detailed balance. At the collective level, such interactions enable mixtures to resist coarsening and instead exhibit nontrivial spatiotemporal structures.

Research Significance

1. Missing Theoretical Foundation: Existing nonreciprocal field theories are typically based on phenomenological and symmetry arguments rather than microscopic principles
2. Role of Conservation Laws: The presence or absence of conservation laws is a core organizational principle of these systems, yet their microscopic origins remain insufficiently understood
3. Pattern Formation Mechanisms: Understanding how nonreciprocal interactions produce different pattern-forming behaviors in systems with and without conservation laws is essential

Limitations of Existing Approaches

• Most nonreciprocal field theory models lack rigorous microscopic foundations
• Lack of systematic approaches to handle different numbers of conservation laws
• Insufficient understanding of direct connections between nonreciprocal Ising models and continuous field theories

Core Contributions

1. Microscopic Derivation: First systematic derivation of macroscopic field equations with different numbers of conservation laws from nonreciprocal Ising models
2. Unified Framework: Establishes a unified framework encompassing cases with zero, one, and two conservation laws
3. Linear Stability Analysis: Systematic linear stability analysis for each case, identifying various instability types
4. Model Classification: Constructs 16 distinct nonreciprocal partial differential equation models covering all possible dynamical combinations
5. Theoretical Insights: Demonstrates that at the mean-field level, nonreciprocal Ising models cannot exhibit Turing instability

Methodology Details

Task Definition

The task is to derive macroscopic continuous equations describing the dynamics of two nonreciprocally coupled scalar fields from microscopic nonreciprocal Ising models through mean-field approximation and thermodynamic limit, and to analyze their stability properties.

Model Architecture

1. Nonreciprocal Ising Model Setup

Consider two square lattices labeled μ ∈ {a,b}, each containing N = NₓNᵧ spins. The local interaction energy for each spin is:

$E_i^μ = -σ_i^μ h_i^μ$

where the local field is defined as: $h_i^μ = H^μ + J^μ \sum_{\langle ij \rangle} σ_j^μ + K^μ σ_i^ν$

Here Hμ is the external magnetic field, Jμ is the intra-lattice coupling strength, and Kμ is the directional inter-lattice coupling strength.

2. Three Types of Dynamics

Single-Spin Flip Dynamics (Zero Conservation Laws):

• Transition rate: $w(σ_i^μ) = \frac{1}{2τ}[1 - \tanh(\frac{ΔE_i^μ}{2})]$
• Leads to nonreciprocal Allen-Cahn equations

Intra-lattice Spin-Exchange Dynamics (Two Conservation Laws):

• Nearest-neighbor spins exchange within the same lattice
• Leads to nonreciprocal Cahn-Hilliard equations

Intra- and Inter-lattice Spin-Exchange Dynamics (One Conservation Law):

• Permits spin exchange both within and between lattices
• Leads to nonreciprocal reactive Cahn-Hilliard models

Technical Innovations

1. Application of Mean-Field Approximation

Using mean-field approximation: $h_i^μ \approx \langle h_i^μ \rangle = H^μ + J^μ \sum_{\langle ij \rangle} m_j^μ + K^μ m_i^ν$

where $m_i^μ = \langle σ_i^μ \rangle$ is the expectation value of single-spin magnetization.

2. Thermodynamic Limit Treatment

In the thermodynamic limit, using gradient expansion: $\sum_{\langle ij \rangle} m_j^μ = 4m^μ + ∇²m^μ + O(∇⁴m^μ)$

3. Identification of Lyapunov Functions

For reciprocal interactions (Kₐ = Kᵦ), the mean-field free energy Fmₐ,mᵦ serves as a Lyapunov function.

Experimental Setup

Theoretical Analysis Methods

This paper primarily employs theoretical analysis methods, including:

1. Mean-Field Theory: For handling many-body interactions
2. Linear Stability Analysis: Analyzing stability of homogeneous steady states
3. Dispersion Relation Analysis: Investigating growth rates of different wavenumber modes

Parameter Space Exploration

Systematic exploration of parameter space $(J_a, J_b, K_a, K_b, H_a, H_b)$, identifying regions of different instability types.

Experimental Results

Main Results

1. Zero Conservation Law Case (Single-Spin Flip)

The obtained equation form: $τ\frac{∂m^a}{∂t} = -M^a(m^a,m^b) \tanh\left[\frac{δF}{δm^a} - \frac{K_a-K_b}{2}m^b\right]$

2. Two Conservation Laws Case (Intra-lattice Exchange)

Nonreciprocal Cahn-Hilliard equations: $τ\frac{∂m^a}{∂t} = ∇ \cdot \left[\frac{1-(m^a)²}{2} ∇\left(\frac{δF}{δm^a} - \frac{K_a-K_b}{2}m^b\right)\right]$

3. One Conservation Law Case (Intra- and Inter-lattice Exchange)

Nonreciprocal reactive Cahn-Hilliard equations, including reaction term R(mₐ,mᵦ).

Linear Stability Analysis Results

1. Dispersion Relations

For all cases, eigenvalues satisfy: $λ_± = \frac{1}{2τ}[(J̃_a + J̃_b)(4-|k|²) - 2 ± \sqrt{4K̃_aK̃_b + (J̃_a-J̃_b)²(4-|k|²)²}]$

2. Instability Type Identification

• Hopf Instability: Oscillatory patterns appear when $K̃_aK̃_b < K₁(J̃_a,J̃_b)$
• Allen-Cahn Instability: Stationary instability at large scales
• Critical Anomalous Point: Two real eigenvalues merge at zero into a complex conjugate pair

3. Absence of Turing Instability

Demonstrates that at the mean-field level, nonreciprocal Ising models cannot exhibit Turing instability, contrasting with general nonreciprocal Allen-Cahn models.

Model Classification Results

Constructs 16 distinct nonreciprocal partial differential equation models:

• 10 models with zero conservation laws
• 5 models with one conservation law
• 1 model with two conservation laws

Related Work

Nonreciprocal Systems Research

• Nonreciprocal Allen-Cahn and Swift-Hohenberg Equations: Previous studies explored nonreciprocal extensions of non-conserved order parameters
• Nonreciprocal Cahn-Hilliard Models: Used to study pattern formation in systems with two conserved fields
• Reaction-Diffusion Systems: Describe dynamics of reactive mixtures with conservation laws

Advantages Over Related Work

1. Provides rigorous microscopic derivation rather than phenomenological construction
2. Systematically addresses all possible conservation law combinations
3. Establishes direct connections between microscopic statistical mechanics and macroscopic continuum descriptions

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Successfully derives three classes of macroscopic field equations from microscopic nonreciprocal Ising models
2. Systematically analyzes conditions for emergence of various linear instabilities
3. Constructs a complete model classification framework encompassing 16 distinct dynamical combinations
4. Demonstrates the absence of Turing instability in this system

Limitations

1. Mean-Field Approximation: Not strictly valid for square lattices
2. Gradient Expansion Truncation: Leads to ultraviolet divergence in antiferromagnetic cases
3. Linear Analysis Constraints: Only linear stability analysis performed; complete nonlinear dynamics description lacking

Future Directions

1. Beyond Mean-Field: Employ more accurate methods such as pair approximation
2. Nonlinear Analysis: Study complete nonlinear dynamics and bifurcation behavior
3. Higher-Order Terms: Include higher-order gradient terms to regularize divergences
4. Experimental Verification: Seek applications and validation in real systems

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Theoretical Rigor: Provides strict derivation from microscopic to macroscopic scales
2. Systematic Completeness: Covers all possible conservation law combinations
3. Methodological Innovation: Cleverly combines statistical mechanics and continuum theory
4. Analytical Depth: Detailed linear stability analysis reveals rich physical phenomena
5. Clear Presentation: Well-structured paper with detailed mathematical derivations

Weaknesses

1. Approximation Limitations: Limited validity of mean-field approximation in two-dimensional systems
2. Experimental Absence: Lacks numerical simulations or experimental verification
3. Application Scope: Primarily limited to theoretical analysis; practical applications require further exploration
4. Technical Challenges: Ultraviolet divergence in antiferromagnetic cases requires better treatment

Impact

1. Theoretical Contribution: Provides important microscopic foundations for nonreciprocal system theory
2. Methodological Value: Established derivation methods extensible to other systems
3. Interdisciplinary Impact: Potential influence on biophysics, soft matter physics, and related fields
4. Future Research: Lays groundwork for further theoretical and experimental investigations

Applicable Scenarios

1. Theoretical Physics: Research in nonequilibrium statistical mechanics and phase transition theory
2. Soft Matter Physics: Studies of active matter and pattern formation
3. Biophysics: Collective cell behavior and biological pattern formation
4. Materials Science: Design of material systems with nonreciprocal interactions

References

The paper includes 86 references covering important works in nonreciprocal systems, Ising models, phase-field theory, pattern formation, and related fields, providing readers with comprehensive background knowledge and directions for further research.

Overall Assessment: This is a high-quality theoretical physics paper making important contributions to the microscopic theoretical foundations of nonreciprocal systems. Despite certain technical limitations, its systematic approach and in-depth analysis provide important theoretical tools and insights for the field's development.