Topological nodal $i$-wave superconductivity in PtBi$_2$

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2507.01774
• Title: Topological nodal $i$-wave superconductivity in PtBi$_2$
• Authors: Susmita Changdar, Oleksandr Suvorov, Andrii Kuibarov, Setti Thirupathaiah, Grigoriy Shipunov, Saicharan Aswartham, Sabine Wurmehl, Iryna Kovalchuk, Klaus Koepernik, Carsten Timm, Bernd Büchner, Ion Cosma Fulga, Sergey Borisenko, Jeroen van den Brink
• Institutions: Leibniz Institute for Solid State and Materials Research (IFW Dresden) and multiple collaborating institutions
• Classification: cond-mat.supr-con (Condensed Matter Physics - Superconductivity)
• Submission Date: July 2, 2025 (arXiv v1)
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2507.01774

Abstract

This work reports the observation of nodal structures in the superconducting gap of the Weyl semimetal PtBi$_2$ using angle-resolved photoemission spectroscopy (ARPES), providing the first experimental evidence for a superconductor with unconventional $i$-wave pairing symmetry ($l=6$). Below 10K, the topological surface states (Fermi arcs) of PtBi$_2$ undergo a superconducting transition and open a gap, while the bulk remains in the normal state. The superconducting nodes are located precisely at the center of the Fermi arcs, suggesting the existence of topologically protected Majorana cones in momentum space. Theoretical calculations indicate the emergence of zero-energy, non-dispersive Majorana flat bands at surface step edges, making PtBi$_2$ an ideal platform for studying and manipulating Majorana bound states.

Research Background and Motivation

Core Questions

This research aims to explore unconventional superconducting pairing mechanisms beyond traditional $d$-wave symmetry and to identify intrinsic topological superconductors.

Significance of the Problem

1. Exploring the boundaries of superconducting pairing symmetry: Conventional superconductors exhibit $s$-wave ($l=0$) pairing, while cuprate high-temperature superconductors exhibit $d$-wave ($l=2$) pairing. However, experimental evidence for higher-order pairing symmetries with $l>2$ has been lacking.
2. Scarcity of topological superconductors: Intrinsic topological superconductor materials are extremely rare, and existing candidate materials (such as Sr$_2$RuO$_4$, Td-MoTe$_2$, etc.) show contradictory experimental results.
3. Application prospects of Majorana fermions: Majorana bound states have important applications in topological quantum computing.

Limitations of Existing Methods

• Experimental evidence for existing topological superconductor candidates is contradictory, and no material has been definitively proven to be an intrinsic topological superconductor
• Direct spectroscopic observations of higher-order pairing symmetries ($l>2$) are lacking
• High-resolution characterization of gap structures in surface superconductivity is absent

Research Motivation

As a non-centrosymmetric Weyl semimetal, PtBi$_2$ exhibits a superconducting transition in its topological surface states at low temperatures, providing a unique platform for studying unconventional superconducting pairing and topological superconductivity.

Core Contributions

1. First experimental observation of $i$-wave superconductivity: Direct observation of $l=6$ $i$-wave pairing symmetry using high-resolution ARPES, providing the first spectroscopic evidence beyond $d$-wave pairing.
2. Discovery of nodal structure in surface state superconductivity: Observation of superconducting gap nodes at the center of Fermi arcs, with the gap exhibiting significant anisotropy (maximum value ~3.6 meV).
3. Confirmation of topologically protected Majorana cones: The nodal structure directly implies the existence of topologically protected Majorana cones on the surface, with six Majorana cones per surface sharing the same topological winding number.
4. Prediction of Majorana flat bands at step edges: Theoretical calculations demonstrate the existence of zero-energy, non-dispersive Majorana hinge states at surface step edges.
5. Achievement of unprecedented experimental precision: Momentum resolution of 2.2 mÅ$^{-1}$ and energy resolution of 1.7 meV, setting a record in solid-state photoemission spectroscopy.

Detailed Methodology

Experimental Techniques

ARPES Measurement Strategy

Dual-photon energy scheme:

1. He-I light source (21.2 eV): Combined with FeSuMa analyzer for panoramic Fermi surface scanning, confirming sample quality and crystal orientation
2. Laser light source (6 eV): Focused near the M point of the Brillouin zone for ultra-high-resolution measurements
   • Advantages: Low kinetic energy photoelectrons enhance surface state signals and suppress bulk contributions
   • Gap extraction: Multi-angle analysis using leading edge, momentum distribution curves (MDC), and energy distribution curves (EDC)

Sample Preparation and Measurement

• Measurements on four different batches of PtBi$_2$ single crystals with multiple cleavages to verify reproducibility
• Two surface terminations: kagome-type (KT) and decorated honeycomb (DH) surfaces
• Temperature range: 2.5K to 30K, spanning the superconducting transition temperature $T_c \sim 10$K

Theoretical Analysis Methods

Symmetry Analysis

Based on the $C_{3v}$ point group symmetry of PtBi$_2$, the superconducting state is classified according to irreducible representations:

• $A_1$ representation: Fully symmetric, does not require nodes
• $E$ representation: Two-dimensional representation, requires breaking rotational or time-reversal symmetry
• $A_2$ representation: Anti-symmetric representation, forces nodes at the arc center

The observed nodal structure excludes $A_1$ and $E$, confirming $A_2$ symmetry. For $A_2$, the lowest-order time-reversal symmetric basis function is $\sin(6\phi)$, corresponding to $l=6$ $i$-wave pairing.

DFT-BdG Calculations

Model construction:

1. Wannier model constructed from density functional theory (DFT)
2. Introduction of $i$-wave pairing in semi-infinite slab geometry: $\Delta(\mathbf{k}) = V_0 \sin(6\phi)$
3. Pairing term limited to the first three surface layers ($V_0 \neq 0$)
4. Solution of Bogoliubov-de-Gennes equations to obtain surface Bloch spectral density

Parameter fitting:

• Pairing strength $V_0 = 15-20$ meV determined by comparing calculated gaps with experimental data
• Finite lifetime of 0.05 meV introduced for numerical calculations

Effective Tight-Binding Model

Model characteristics:

• Captures lattice symmetry and relative positions of Weyl cones
• Neglects topologically trivial Fermi surface crossings
• Ensures sufficient separation of Weyl cones in momentum space

Geometric configurations:

• Slab geometry: Infinite in $x$ and $y$ directions, finite in $z$ direction, for studying surface Majorana cones
• Prism geometry: Infinite in $y$ direction, finite in $x$ and $z$ directions, for calculating hinge states

Technical Innovations

1. Ultra-high-resolution measurements: Through optimization of photon energy and analyzer configuration, achieving unprecedented momentum and energy resolution capable of resolving fine structures of Fermi arcs.
2. Node localization method: Combining leading edge analysis, peak tracking, and temperature-dependent measurements to confirm node positions from multiple perspectives.
3. Symmetry-constrained analysis: Utilizing point group symmetry to rigorously restrict possible pairing symmetries, establishing direct connection between observed nodal structure and $i$-wave pairing.
4. Multi-scale theoretical modeling: From first-principles DFT calculations to effective models, cross-scale verification of topological properties.

Experimental Setup

Sample Characteristics

• Material: Trigonal non-centrosymmetric Weyl semimetal PtBi$_2$ (space group $P3_1m$)
• Electronic structure: 12 Weyl cones located approximately 47 meV above the Fermi level
• Superconducting properties: $T_c \sim 10$K, surface state superconductivity only, bulk remains metallic

Measurement Conditions

• Photon sources:
  • He-I discharge lamp: 21.2 eV
  • Laser: 6.0 eV
• Analyzers:
  • FeSuMa: Isotropic angular resolution
  • Conventional analyzer: Higher energy and momentum resolution
• Temperature: 2.5K - 30K (base temperature 2.5K)

Data Analysis Methods

1. Gap extraction: Superconducting gap determined from EDC leading edge position
2. Angular dependence: Gap variation measured at different angles $\theta$ along the Fermi arc (with $\Gamma$-M direction as 0°)
3. Temperature dependence: Gap evolution tracked with temperature to determine $T_c$

Experimental Results

Main Results

1. Ultra-high-resolution imaging of Fermi arcs (Figure 1)

• Momentum resolution: MDC full-width at half-maximum (FWHM) = 2.2 mÅ$^{-1}$
• Energy resolution: EDC FWHM = 1.7 meV
• Significance: This represents the smallest FWHM value for such line shapes in the history of solid-state photoemission spectroscopy, demonstrating that Fermi arcs are extraordinarily localized electronic states in energy, momentum, and real space.

2. Anisotropic superconducting gap (Figure 2)

Node confirmation:

• Gap closure observed at $\theta = 0°$ ($\Gamma$-M direction)
• Same node location reproducibly observed across four different samples and multiple cleavages

Gap angular distribution:

• $\theta = 0°$: Minimum gap (node)
• $\theta = \pm 90°$: Maximum gap, approximately 3.6 meV
• $\theta = \pm 125°$: Gap closure again (Fermi arc mixing with bulk states)
• Possible plateau structure at $\theta = \pm 45°$, suggesting higher-order harmonic mixing

Coherence peak shift: From $\theta = 0°$ to $\pm 90°$, coherence peak shifts toward higher kinetic energy by approximately 3.6 meV, consistent with maximum gap value.

3. Temperature-dependent behavior (Figures 2c, 2e)

Behavior at node:

• EDC at 2.5K and 20K nearly overlap at the node
• Completely reproducible after temperature cycling

At maximum gap:

• 6K: Gap clearly visible
• 10K: Gap reduced but still open
• 15K: Gap closed
• 20K: No significant difference from 15K

$T_c$ determination: $10K < T_c < 15K$, consistent with previous studies.

Theoretical Calculation Results

DFT-BdG spectral density (Figure 3a)

• Normal state ($V_0=0$): Fermi arc clearly visible, zero gap throughout arc
• Superconducting state ($V_0=21$ meV):
  • Gap closes only at $k_y=0$ (node)
  • Finite gap elsewhere
  • Weak residual spectral weight on arc due to 0.05 meV numerical lifetime

Gap fitting (Figure 3b)

Calculation results for three pairing strengths:

• $V_0 = 7$ meV (black)
• $V_0 = 15$ meV (red)
• $V_0 = 21$ meV (green)

Comparison with experiment:

• Best fit: $V_0 = 15-20$ meV
• Maximum gap position: Calculated at 0.04 Å$^{-1}$, experimental at $0.06 \pm 0.01$ Å$^{-1}$
• Position close to experimental value even with only lowest-order $i$-wave harmonic

Majorana cones and hinge states (Figures 3c-e)

Slab geometry calculations:

• Top surface: 6 Majorana cones (red), winding number $w=-1$
• Bottom surface: 6 Majorana cones (blue), winding number $w=+1$
• Bulk state: Weyl cones (green) remain metallic

Anomalous topological characteristics:

• All six Majorana cones on a single surface share the same winding number (determined by symmetry)
• Total winding number non-zero, constituting anomalous topological superconductor
• Top and bottom surface winding numbers opposite, total sum zero

Hinge states in prism geometry:

• Within $k_y$ range, top and bottom surface Majorana cones overlap in prism Brillouin zone
• Four degenerate zero-energy modes appear (black)
• Hinge states localized at prism edges (Figure 3e)
• Beyond this momentum range, hinge states lose topological protection, deviating from zero energy

Summary of Experimental Findings

1. Direct evidence of $i$-wave pairing: Nodal structure perfectly matches $\sin(6\phi)$ form of $A_2$ symmetry
2. Establishment of topological superconductivity: Sign change on chiral non-degenerate Fermi arcs directly produces surface Majorana cones
3. Controllable Majorana states: Zero-energy flat bands at step edges provide feasible pathways for experimental detection and manipulation
4. Material reproducibility: Consistent results across multiple samples and cleavage planes ensure reliability of observations

Related Work

History of Unconventional Superconductivity Research

$d$-wave superconductors

• Cuprate high-temperature superconductors: YBa$_2$Cu$_3$O$_7$, Bi$_2$Sr$_2$CaCu$_2$O$_{8+x}$
• Critical role of ARPES: Direct mapping of momentum-space gap nodal structure, establishing $d$-wave pairing

Higher-order pairing theory

• $f$-wave pairing ($l=3$): Theoretical proposals for UPt$_3$, CoO$_2$-based superconductors
• Chiral $f$-wave: Theoretical predictions in hole-doped semiconductors
• Current status: Lack of spectroscopic evidence for $l>2$ pairing

Topological Superconductor Candidate Materials

Reported materials

1. Sr$_2$RuO$_4$: Long considered chiral $p$-wave superconductor, but recent experiments raise questions
2. Transition metal dichalcogenides: Td-MoTe$_2$ (signs of $s_\pm$ topological superconductivity), 4Hb-TaS$_2$ (chiral superconductivity)
3. Uranium-based heavy fermion systems: UTe$_2$ (near-ferromagnetic spin triplet)
4. $\beta$-PdBi$_2$: Centrosymmetric topological superconductor, but full gap contradicts node evidence
5. Kagome materials: RbV$_3$Sb$_5$ (spin-polarized $p$-wave)

Common issues

Different experimental methods (ARPES, STM, $\mu$SR, thermal conductivity) yield contradictory results, with no material definitively proven to be an intrinsic topological superconductor.

Previous Research on PtBi$_2$

• Weyl semimetal properties: 12 Weyl cones, Fermi arcs connecting surface projections
• Discovery of surface superconductivity: STM and transport measurements confirm $T_c \sim 10$K
• Bulk state remains normal: Unique phenomenon of surface-state-only superconductivity

Advantages of This Work

1. Direct spectroscopic evidence: ARPES directly observes nodes and gap distribution
2. Strict symmetry constraints: Node location and distribution uniquely correspond to $i$-wave pairing
3. Tight theory-experiment coupling: DFT calculations and effective models verify results at multiple scales
4. Reproducibility: Consistent results across multiple samples and cleavage planes

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. First experimental discovery of $i$-wave superconductivity: The Fermi arc superconducting state in PtBi$_2$ exhibits $l=6$ pairing symmetry, surpassing all known superconductors.
2. Establishment of intrinsic topological superconductor: Nodal structure directly proves the existence of six topologically protected Majorana cones on the surface, constituting an anomalous topological superconducting phase.
3. Prediction of Majorana hinge states: Theoretical calculations demonstrate zero-energy, non-dispersive Majorana flat bands at step edges, providing clear targets for experimental detection.
4. Record-breaking measurement precision: Creates precision records in solid-state photoemission spectroscopy, showcasing the unique properties of Fermi arcs as extraordinary electronic states.

Discussion of Physical Mechanisms

Open questions regarding pairing mechanisms

• Comparison with cuprates:
  • Cuprates: Strong electronic correlations drive $d$-wave pairing
  • PtBi$_2$: Highly delocalized electronic states, no strong correlation signatures
• Role of topological properties: Fermi arc topology may play a key role in stabilizing $i$-wave pairing, but specific mechanisms require further investigation.

Coexistence of surface and bulk states

• Bulk remains metallic while surface undergoes superconducting transition
• How does this coexistence affect topological protection of Majorana cones?
• Does the gapless bulk state hinder quantum computing applications?

Limitations

1. Obstacles to quantum computing applications:
   • Coexistence of gapless bulk state hinders direct application
   • Requires ultrathin samples to suppress bulk contributions
   • Or requires breaking time-reversal symmetry to open surface gap
2. Pairing mechanism unclear:
   • Lack of understanding of microscopic origin of $i$-wave pairing
   • How do topological surface states produce such high-order pairing symmetry?
3. Experimental resolution limitations:
   • Precise behavior of gap function near nodes cannot be determined
   • Whether $\pm 45°$ plateau is a robust feature of higher-order harmonic mixing remains unclear
4. Absence of direct observation of hinge states:
   • Theoretically predicted Majorana states at step edges not yet experimentally verified
   • Requires local probing techniques (e.g., STM) for verification

Future Directions

Experimental directions

1. Direct detection of hinge states:
   • Search for zero-bias conductance peaks at step edges using STM
   • Verify topological protection through magnetic field dependence
2. Ultrathin sample preparation:
   • Reduce bulk contributions, enhance surface superconducting signal
   • Potentially achieve fully superconducting state
3. Time-reversal symmetry breaking:
   • Apply magnetic fields to study gap opening of Majorana cones
   • Explore chiral Majorana edge states or corner states
4. Josephson junction structures:
   • Control superconducting phase difference between top and bottom surfaces
   • Implement planar Josephson junctions for quantum computing

Theoretical directions

1. Pairing mechanism research:
   • Establish microscopic theory connecting topological surface states to $i$-wave pairing
   • Study role of Fermi arc chirality and non-degeneracy in pairing
2. Many-body effects:
   • Consider electron-phonon interactions, spin-orbit coupling, etc.
   • Effects of competing order parameters (charge density waves, spin density waves)
3. Topological phase transitions:
   • Study topological phase transitions under external fields (magnetic field, strain)
   • Explore transitions from anomalous topological superconductor to other topological phases

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Scientific Significance

• First experimental observation: First direct spectroscopic evidence of $l>2$ unconventional superconducting pairing, milestone achievement
• Definitive evidence for topological superconductivity: Multiple verification through nodal structure, symmetry analysis, and theoretical calculations provide most convincing evidence for intrinsic topological superconductor to date
• New quantum phase: Discovery of anomalous topological superconducting phase expands classification of topological quantum states

2. Experimental Excellence

• Ultimate resolution: 2.2 mÅ$^{-1}$ momentum resolution and 1.7 meV energy resolution set historical records
• Multi-sample verification: Systematic study of four samples with multiple cleavages ensures result reliability
• Comprehensive characterization: Temperature and angular dependence fully characterize gap structure and node properties

3. Tight Theory-Experiment Integration

• Multi-scale theory: From DFT-BdG to effective models, cross-scale verification
• Quantitative agreement: Pairing strength $V_0 = 15-20$ meV matches experimental gap
• Predictive power: Theoretical prediction of hinge states guides future experiments

4. Clear and Rigorous Writing

• Clear logical structure: From experimental observations to symmetry analysis to topological properties
• Information-rich figures: High-quality experimental data and theoretical calculation results
• Balanced discussion: Acknowledges both contributions and limitations

Weaknesses

1. Missing Pairing Mechanism

• Fundamental issue: Fails to establish microscopic theory of $i$-wave pairing
• Relies solely on symmetry analysis to determine pairing form, lacking deep understanding of origin
• Compared to cuprate $d$-wave superconductivity, PtBi$_2$ electronic structure appears incompatible with strong correlation mechanism

2. Limited Quantum Computing Applications

• Bulk metallicity is fundamental obstacle
• Proposed solutions (ultrathin samples, magnetic field control) remain experimentally unverified
• Feasibility uncertain

3. Insufficient Experimental Details

• Node vicinity behavior: Acknowledges resolution limitations preventing precise gap function determination
• $\pm 45°$ plateau: Uncertain whether robust feature
• Hinge states: Lack direct experimental observation

4. Simplified Theoretical Models

• Effective tight-binding model neglects topologically trivial bands
• May affect quantitative description of actual material properties
• DFT calculation with pairing limited to surface layers requires further physical justification

Impact Assessment

Contributions to the field

1. Superconductivity physics:
   • Extends experimental boundary of superconducting pairing symmetry to $l=6$
   • Provides experimental platform for studying higher-order pairing mechanisms
2. Topological quantum states:
   • Discovers example of anomalous topological superconducting phase
   • Enriches material library of topological superconductors
3. Majorana physics:
   • Provides new pathway for generating and manipulating Majorana states
   • Hinge state prediction opens new research direction

Practical value

• Short-term: Model system for studying unconventional superconductivity and topological states
• Long-term: If bulk metallicity problem overcome, potential application in topological quantum computing
• Technical spillover: Ultra-high-resolution ARPES technique generalizable to other materials

Reproducibility

• Strengths:
  • Detailed experimental parameters (photon energy, temperature, analyzer settings)
  • Multi-sample verification enhances credibility
  • Clear description of theoretical calculation methods
• Challenges:
  • Requires extremely high-quality single crystal samples
  • Ultra-high-resolution ARPES equipment demanding
  • Laser ARPES technology not available in all laboratories

Applicable Scenarios

Suitable research problems

1. Unconventional superconducting mechanisms: Study how topological surface states produce higher-order pairing
2. Surface superconductivity phenomena: Understand coupling between surface and bulk electronic states
3. Majorana physics: Detect and manipulate surface Majorana cones and hinge states
4. Topological phase transitions: Study topological property evolution under external field control

Generalizable material systems

• Other topological semimetals with surface superconductivity
• Materials with chiral surface states
• Non-centrosymmetric superconductors

Technical application prospects

• Topological quantum computing (requires overcoming bulk metallicity)
• Quantum devices based on Majorana fermions
• Novel superconducting electronics

Key References (Selected)

Unconventional Superconductivity

• 1 Sigrist & Ueda, Rev. Mod. Phys. 63, 239 (1991) - Theoretical review of unconventional superconductivity
• 5 Damascelli et al., Rev. Mod. Phys. 75, 473 (2003) - ARPES studies of cuprates

Topological Superconductivity

• 12 Schnyder et al., Phys. Rev. B 78, 195125 (2008) - Classification of topological insulators and superconductors
• 33 Béri, Phys. Rev. B 81, 134515 (2010) - Gapless phases of time-reversal invariant topological superconductors

PtBi$_2$ Related

• 2 Kuibarov et al., Nature 626, 294 (2024) - First report of surface superconductivity in PtBi$_2$
• 27 Vocaturo et al., Phys. Rev. B 110, 054504 (2024) - Electronic structure calculations for PtBi$_2$
• 28 Schimmel et al., Nat. Commun. 15, 9895 (2024) - STM study of PtBi$_2$ surface superconductivity

Overall Assessment: This is a milestone experimental work providing the first direct evidence of $i$-wave superconductivity and establishing PtBi$_2$ as an intrinsic topological superconductor. Despite remaining challenges in pairing mechanisms and quantum computing applications, its scientific value and impact on the field are undeniable. This work demonstrates the powerful capability of high-precision ARPES in exploring exotic quantum states, opening new directions for condensed matter physics and topological quantum computing research.