Effective Field Theory of Perturbations on Arbitrary Black Hole Backgrounds with Spacelike Scalar Profile

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2507.02066
• Title: Effective Field Theory of Perturbations on Arbitrary Black Hole Backgrounds with Spacelike Scalar Profile
• Authors: Shinji Mukohyama, Emeric Seraille, Kazufumi Takahashi, Vicharit Yingcharoenrat
• Classification: gr-qc (General Relativity and Quantum Cosmology), hep-th (High Energy Physics - Theory)
• Publication Date: July 4, 2025 (arXiv:2507.02066v2, October 15, 2025)
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2507.02066

Abstract

This paper develops an effective field theory (EFT) for perturbations with spacelike scalar profiles on arbitrary black hole backgrounds within the framework of scalar-tensor theories. The EFT construction is based on the fact that in the unitary gauge, the scalar field is chosen as one of the spatial coordinates, and the background scalar field spontaneously breaks diffeomorphism invariance along its gradient direction. The residual symmetry on constant scalar field timelike hypersurfaces is referred to as (2+1)-dimensional diffeomorphism invariance. By requiring that the EFT action in unitary gauge remains invariant under (2+1)-dimensional diffeomorphism transformations, a set of consistency relations imposed on the EFT parameters is derived. For concreteness, the EFT is applied to study the background dynamics of a class of non-static spherically symmetric solutions, with particular focus on black hole solutions with time-varying mass. This EFT framework is broadly applicable to any black hole background as long as the scalar field maintains its spacelike character in the spacetime region of interest.

Research Background and Motivation

Problem Definition

The core problem addressed in this research is: how to construct an effective field theory framework for scalar-tensor theories on arbitrary black hole backgrounds with spacelike scalar profiles. This is an important problem in the study of modified theories of general relativity.

Significance

1. Strong-field gravity tests: The gravitational wave detection by the LIGO-Virgo-KAGRA collaboration has opened a new era for testing strong-field gravity, requiring quantitative characterization of theories beyond general relativity
2. Cosmological problems: Gravitational modifications provide potential pathways to solving cosmological puzzles including dark energy, inflation, and dark matter
3. Theoretical completeness: Existing EFT frameworks are primarily focused on timelike scalar profiles, while systematic studies of the spacelike case remain relatively lacking

Limitations of Existing Methods

1. Background restrictions: Previous spacelike scalar profile EFTs were mainly limited to static spherically symmetric backgrounds or slowly rotating backgrounds
2. Limited applicability: Lack of a unified framework applicable to arbitrary black hole backgrounds
3. Consistency conditions: Absence of systematic consistency relations to ensure diffeomorphism invariance of the EFT

Research Motivation

To construct a model-independent EFT framework applicable to arbitrary black hole backgrounds, providing a unified theoretical tool for testing scalar-tensor theories in strong gravitational regions.

Core Contributions

1. Generalization of EFT framework: Extends the spacelike scalar profile EFT from static spherically symmetric backgrounds to arbitrary black hole backgrounds
2. Consistency relations: Systematically derives consistency relations ensuring (2+1)-dimensional diffeomorphism invariance
3. Background dynamics: Establishes a complete set of dynamical equations for spherically symmetric non-static backgrounds
4. Concrete applications: Provides analytical solutions for linearly time-varying mass black holes as specific examples of framework application
5. Model independence: Provides a unified description method independent of specific covariant theories

Methodology Details

Task Definition

Construct an EFT action in unitary gauge that remains invariant under (2+1)-dimensional diffeomorphism transformations and can describe scalar-tensor theory perturbations on arbitrary black hole backgrounds.

Theoretical Framework

EFT Building Blocks

In unitary gauge, the scalar field $\Phi$ is chosen as the radial coordinate $r$, i.e., $\bar{\Phi} = \bar{\Phi}(r)$. Key building blocks include:

1. Normal vector: $n_\mu = \frac{\nabla_\mu \Phi}{\sqrt{\nabla_\alpha \Phi \nabla^\alpha \Phi}} \to \frac{\delta_r^\mu}{\sqrt{g^{rr}}}$
2. Extrinsic curvature: $K_{\mu\nu} = h_\sigma^\mu \nabla_\sigma n_\nu$, where $h_{\mu\nu} = g_{\mu\nu} - n_\mu n_\nu$
3. (2+1)-dimensional geometric quantities: Such as the (2+1)-dimensional Ricci scalar $^{(3)}R$

ADM Decomposition

Employs ADM decomposition relative to the radial coordinate $r$: $g_{\mu\nu}dx^\mu dx^\nu = N^2 dr^2 + h_{ab}(dx^a + N^a dr)(dx^b + N^b dr)$

where $N$ is the lapse function, $N^a$ is the shift vector, and $h_{ab}$ is the induced metric on constant $\Phi$ hypersurfaces.

EFT Action

The most general unitary gauge EFT action is: $S = \int d^4x \sqrt{-g} \mathcal{L}(g^{rr}, K_\mu^\nu, ^{(3)}R_\mu^\nu, \nabla_\mu, r)$

Consistency Relations

(2+1)-dimensional Diffeomorphism Invariance

By applying the chain rule to Taylor expansion coefficients, consistency relations are obtained: $\frac{\partial}{\partial x^a}\bar{L} = \bar{L}_{g^{rr}}\partial_a \bar{g}^{rr} + \bar{L}_K \partial_a \bar{K} + \bar{L}_{\sigma_\mu^\nu}\partial_a \bar{\sigma}^\mu_\nu + \cdots$

Shift Symmetry (Optional)

If the EFT is required to be invariant under scalar field shifts $\Phi \to \Phi + \text{const}$, additional consistency relations are obtained: $\frac{\partial}{\partial r}\bar{L} = \bar{L}_{g^{rr}}\partial_r \bar{g}^{rr} + \bar{L}_K \partial_r \bar{K} + \cdots$

Technical Innovations

1. Systematic generalization: Systematically extends the methodology of timelike scalar profile EFT to the spacelike case
2. Consistency assurance: Systematically derives consistency relations through the chain rule, ensuring EFT symmetry
3. Arbitrary background applicability: Not limited to specific background geometries, with broad applicability
4. Stueckelberg technique: Provides a systematic method for recovering full 4-dimensional diffeomorphism invariance

Experimental Setup

Background Metric

Employs a spherically symmetric but not necessarily static metric ansatz: $\bar{g}_{\mu\nu}dx^\mu dx^\nu = -A(t,r)dt^2 + \frac{dr^2}{B(t,r)} + F(t,r)(d\theta^2 + \sin^2\theta d\phi^2)$

Simplifying Assumptions

• $F(t,r) = r^2$ (areal coordinates)
• $M^2(t,r) = M_*^2 = \text{const}$ (constant Planck mass)
• $\gamma_{\mu\nu} = 0$, $\alpha_\mu^\nu = \alpha(x)\bar{\sigma}_\mu^\nu$

Specific Application Case

Studies linearly time-varying mass black holes: $A(t,r) = B(t,r) = 1 - \frac{r_c(t)}{r}$ where $r_c(t) = r_s + 2\dot{m}(t-t_0)$

Experimental Results

Background Equations

Derives a complete set of background Einstein equations containing four independent equations:

1. $rr$ component equation
2. $tt$ component equation
3. $tr$ component equation
4. $\theta\theta - tt$ component equation

Analytical Solutions for Linearly Time-Varying Mass Black Holes

Analytical Solution for $\alpha$ Parameter

$\alpha(t,r) = -4\dot{m}^2 M_*^2 \left\{\frac{6r_c(r-r_c) + r^2}{(r-r_c)^2} + \frac{6r_c}{2r-3r_c}\log\left[2\left(\frac{r}{r_c}-1\right)\right]\right\}$

Analytical Solution for $\tilde{\beta}$ Parameter

$\tilde{\beta}(t,r) = \frac{2M_*^2}{r}\left(\sqrt{1-\frac{r_c}{r}} - \sqrt{1-\frac{r_s}{r}}\right) - \frac{r_c\alpha}{2r^{3/2}\sqrt{r-r_c}}$

Key Findings

1. Singularity removal: Apparent singularities at $r = 3r_c/2$ can be eliminated through appropriate choice of integration constants
2. Static limit consistency: In the static limit $\dot{m} = 0$, solutions reduce to known static cases
3. Asymptotic behavior: In the region $r/r_c \to \infty$, $\alpha(t,r) \simeq -4\dot{m}^2 M_*^2$
4. Regularity: All EFT parameters are regular in the region $r > \max(r_c, r_s)$

Related Work

EFT Development History

1. Timelike scalar profile EFT: Initially developed by Arkani-Hamed et al. on Minkowski/de Sitter backgrounds
2. Cosmological applications: Extended by Cheung et al. to EFT of inflation/dark energy
3. Arbitrary background generalization: Generalized to arbitrary backgrounds by Mukohyama and Yingcharoenrat

Spacelike Scalar Profile Research

1. Static spherically symmetric: First developed by Franciolini et al. on static spherically symmetric backgrounds
2. Slowly rotating: Extended to slowly rotating backgrounds by Hui et al.
3. This paper's contribution: Generalization to arbitrary black hole backgrounds

Scalar-Tensor Theories

1. Horndeski theory: Most general second-order scalar-tensor theory
2. DHOST theory: Degenerate higher-order scalar-tensor theory
3. U-DHOST theory: Degenerate theory in unitary gauge

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Successful construction: Successfully constructs a spacelike scalar profile EFT framework applicable to arbitrary black hole backgrounds
2. Consistency assurance: Systematically derives consistency relations ensuring (2+1)-dimensional diffeomorphism invariance
3. Concrete applications: Verifies framework feasibility through examples of linearly time-varying mass black holes
4. Analytical solutions: Obtains complete analytical expressions for EFT parameters without requiring small parameter expansions

Limitations

1. Asymptotic regions: EFT may fail when $\bar{\Phi}'(r) \to 0$, requiring matching with EFT of trivial backgrounds
2. Strong coupling issues: Strong coupling problems of spacelike scalar profiles may not be avoidable through scordatura terms
3. Boundary conditions: EFT applicability in asymptotic regions requires more careful analysis

Future Directions

1. Perturbation dynamics: Study linear perturbation dynamics and quasinormal modes within this framework
2. Rotating black holes: Application to stationary axisymmetric black hole backgrounds
3. Higher-dimensional generalization: Extension to higher-dimensional gravity theories, such as braneworld scenarios
4. Boundary matching: Develop matching conditions with EFT of trivial backgrounds
5. Phenomenological applications: Calculate tidal Love numbers, gravitational wave speeds, and other observable quantities

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Theoretical completeness: Provides a systematic and complete theoretical framework for spacelike scalar profile EFT
2. Mathematical rigor: Consistency relations are derived rigorously with standard mathematical treatment
3. Broad applicability: Not limited to specific backgrounds, with strong universality
4. Analytical results: Obtains complete analytical solutions facilitating further phenomenological studies
5. Clear presentation: Well-structured paper with sufficient technical detail

Weaknesses

1. Limited phenomenological applications: Primarily focused on theoretical framework construction with relatively few phenomenological applications
2. Asymptotic behavior: Discussion of EFT applicability in asymptotic regions could be more thorough
3. Numerical verification: Lacks numerical calculations to verify analytical results
4. Physical interpretation: Physical meaning of certain mathematical results could be explained more deeply

Impact

1. Theoretical contribution: Provides important theoretical tools for modified gravity theories
2. Methodological value: EFT methodology application in gravity theories has exemplary significance
3. Foundation for future research: Establishes solid foundation for further phenomenological studies
4. Cross-disciplinary applications: Methods may be applicable to other theories with similar symmetry breaking

Applicable Scenarios

1. Black hole physics: Study black hole perturbations and stability in modified gravity theories
2. Gravitational wave physics: Calculate gravitational wave propagation and scattering in modified theories
3. Cosmology: Study scalar field dynamics in strong gravitational fields
4. Theoretical physics: Serve as exemplar for studying symmetry breaking and effective field theory

References

This paper cites 84 important references covering:

• Experimental progress in gravitational wave detection 1-4
• Theoretical development of modified gravity theories 11-36
• Historical development of EFT methods 37-46
• Black hole physics and no-hair theorems 57-72
• Braneworld and higher-dimensional theories 73-75

Overall Assessment: This is a high-quality theoretical physics paper making important contributions to the EFT methodology in modified gravity theories. The paper features a complete theoretical framework, rigorous mathematical treatment, and provides a solid theoretical foundation for subsequent phenomenological research. While further development in specific physical applications is warranted, its theoretical value and methodological significance are substantial.