A Note on Carlier's Inequality

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2507.02285
• Title: A Note on Carlier's Inequality
• Authors: Regina S. Burachik (University of South Australia), J. E. Martínez-Legaz (Autonomous University of Barcelona)
• Classification: math.FA (Functional Analysis), math.OC (Optimization and Control)
• Publication Date: arXiv:2507.02285v3 math.FA 13 Oct 2025
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2507.02285

Abstract

This paper extends the quantitative version of the Fitzpatrick inequality established by Carlier in Hilbert spaces to the framework of reflexive Banach spaces. In the Hilbert space setting, an improved version of the strong Fitzpatrick inequality proposed by Voisei and Zălinescu is obtained.

Research Background and Motivation

Problem Background

1. Importance of the Fitzpatrick Inequality: The Fitzpatrick inequality is a fundamental result in monotone operator theory. For a maximal monotone mapping T, it states that FT(x,v) - ⟨x,v⟩ ≥ 0, where FT is the Fitzpatrick function.
2. Carlier's Contribution: Carlier established in 2023 a quantitative strengthening of the Fitzpatrick inequality in Hilbert spaces:

   FT(x,v) - ⟨x,v⟩ ≥ (1/λ)‖x - (I + λT)^(-1)(x + λv)‖²
   

3. Research Motivation:
   • Extend Carlier's result to more general reflexive Banach spaces
   • Improve the strong Fitzpatrick inequality within the Hilbert space framework
   • Unify and generalize existing results in monotone operator theory

Theoretical Significance

Monotone operator theory has important applications in variational analysis, optimization theory, and partial differential equations. Improvements to these inequalities have significant theoretical value for related fields.

Core Contributions

1. Extension to Banach Spaces: Extends Carlier's inequality from Hilbert spaces to the reflexive Banach space framework (Theorem 1)
2. Concrete Results for 2-Uniformly Convex Spaces: Provides explicit expressions based on normalized duality mappings in 2-uniformly convex Banach spaces (Theorem 3)
3. Improved Strong Fitzpatrick Inequality: Obtains a stronger inequality in Hilbert spaces than the Voisei-Zălinescu result, improving the coefficient from 1/4 to 1/2 (Theorem 4)
4. Unified Proof Technique: Provides a unified approach for handling this class of inequalities

Methodology

Theoretical Framework

This work is based on the following core concepts:

1. Fitzpatrick Function: For a maximal monotone mapping T : X ⇒ X*, defined as

   FT(x,v) := ⟨x,v⟩ - inf_{(z,w)∈G(T)} ⟨x-z, v-w⟩
   

2. Normalized Duality Mapping: In reflexive Banach spaces, defined as

   JX(x) := {v ∈ X* : ⟨x,v⟩ = ‖x‖‖v‖*, ‖x‖ = ‖v‖*}
   

3. Strong Monotonicity: An operator B is strongly monotone (with constant c > 0) if

   ⟨x-y, v-u⟩ ≥ c‖x-y‖²
   

Main Technical Approach

Proof Strategy for Theorem 1

1. Consider maximal monotone operators T, B : X ⇒ X*, where B is strongly monotone and has finite Fitzpatrick function
2. For wλ := (B + λT)^(-1)(x' + λv), we have (wλ, (x'-w'λ)/λ + v) ∈ G(T)
3. Utilize the dual representation of the Fitzpatrick function:

   FT(x,v) - ⟨x,v⟩ = sup_{(y,w)∈G(T)} ⟨x-y, w-v⟩
   

4. Apply strong monotonicity to obtain the key inequality

Treatment in 2-Uniformly Convex Spaces

Proposition 2: In 2-uniformly convex Banach spaces, the subdifferential operator of a strongly convex function is strongly monotone.

The proof utilizes the geometric properties of 2-uniformly convex spaces:

‖x‖² + ‖y‖² - (1/2)‖x+y‖² ≥ (μ/2)‖x-y‖²

Technical Innovations

1. Operator Substitution Technique: Replaces the identity operator I with a strongly monotone operator B, enabling generalization from Hilbert spaces to Banach spaces
2. Clever Application of Geometric Inequalities: Utilizes the modulus of convexity properties of 2-uniformly convex spaces to establish strong monotonicity
3. Unified Analytical Framework: The same technique handles both the generalization of Carlier's inequality and the improvement of the strong Fitzpatrick inequality

Main Results

Theorem 1 (General Reflexive Banach Spaces)

Let T, B : X ⇒ X* be maximal monotone, with B strongly monotone (constant c) and finite Fitzpatrick function. Then:

FT(x,v) - ⟨x,v⟩ ≥ (c/λ) sup_{x'∈Bx} ‖x - (B + λT)^(-1)(x' + λv)‖²

Theorem 3 (2-Uniformly Convex Spaces)

In 2-uniformly convex Banach spaces (constant μ), for maximal monotone T:

FT(x,v) - ⟨x,v⟩ ≥ (μ/2λ) sup_{x'∈JX(x)} ‖x - (JX + λT)^(-1)(x' + λv)‖²

Theorem 4 (Improved Strong Fitzpatrick Inequality)

In Hilbert spaces, for maximal monotone T:

FT(x,v) - ⟨x,v⟩ ≥ (1/2) inf_{(w,z)∈G(T)} {‖x-w‖² + ‖v-z‖²}

Important Improvement: The coefficient is improved from 1/4 in the literature to 1/2.

Related Work

Historical Development

1. Fitzpatrick (1988): Established the foundational Fitzpatrick inequality
2. Voisei-Zălinescu (2009): Proposed the strong Fitzpatrick inequality
3. Carlier (2023): Provided a quantitative version in Hilbert spaces
4. This Paper: Generalizes to Banach spaces and improves existing results

Relationship to Related Work

• Directly generalizes Carlier's work
• Improves the strong inequality of Voisei-Zălinescu
• Related to earlier work by Martínez-Legaz and others on monotone operators

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Successfully extends Carlier's inequality from Hilbert spaces to reflexive Banach spaces
2. Provides explicit expressions based on normalized duality mappings in 2-uniformly convex spaces
3. Significantly improves the constant in the strong Fitzpatrick inequality

Theoretical Significance

• Unifies related inequalities in Hilbert and Banach spaces
• Provides more precise quantitative tools for monotone operator theory
• May have applications in variational inequalities and optimization problems

Limitations

1. Requires Banach spaces to be reflexive
2. In general Banach spaces, requires an additional strongly monotone operator B
3. The 2-uniform convexity condition may be restrictive in certain applications

Future Directions

1. Further relax the geometric conditions on spaces
2. Explore possibilities for generalization to non-reflexive spaces
3. Investigate applications of these improved inequalities to concrete optimization problems

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Clear Theoretical Contribution: Explicitly generalizes important theoretical results
2. Clever Technical Methods: Achieves generalization through operator substitution
3. Concrete Results: Provides explicit constant improvements
4. Concise Proofs: Clear proof strategy with appropriate technical handling

Weaknesses

1. Insufficient Application Context: Lacks concrete application examples
2. Missing Numerical Verification: No numerical experiments to validate theoretical results
3. Necessity of Generalizations: The practical significance of certain generalizations requires further clarification

Impact

• Positively advances the development of monotone operator theory
• Provides more precise theoretical tools for related fields
• May inspire further theoretical research

Applicable Scenarios

• Variational inequality theory
• Convex optimization algorithm analysis
• Monotone operator methods for partial differential equations
• Nonlinear analysis in Banach spaces

References

The paper cites classical literature in monotone operator theory, including:

• Fitzpatrick's original work
• Carlier's recent results
• Voisei-Zălinescu's work on strong inequalities
• Related literature on Banach space geometry