Instability of the Haldane Phase: Roles of Charge Fluctuations and Hund's Coupling

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2507.05089
• Title: Instability of the Haldane Phase: Roles of Charge Fluctuations and Hund's Coupling
• Author: Satoshi Nishimoto (Department of Physics, Dresden University of Technology & Institute for Theoretical Solid State Physics, IFW Dresden)
• Classification: cond-mat.str-el (Strongly Correlated Electron Systems)
• Publication Date: October 15, 2025
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2507.05089v2

Abstract

This study systematically investigates the stability of the symmetry-protected topological (SPT) Haldane phase in spin-1/2 Heisenberg ladders and half-filled Hubbard ladders with ferromagnetic Hund interactions. Using the density matrix renormalization group (DMRG) method, the authors analyze key characteristics of the Haldane phase: long-range string order, finite spin gap, and characteristic entanglement spectrum degeneracy. In pure Heisenberg ladders, the Haldane phase emerges immediately with any finite Hund coupling and continues to strengthen. In contrast, in Hubbard ladders with charge fluctuations, non-trivial stability regions exist, revealing a robust yet bounded region where SPT order persists despite significant charge fluctuations.

Research Background and Motivation

Core Issues

1. Robustness of Topological Phases: The stability of symmetry-protected topological phases under competing interactions and additional degrees of freedom remains a central challenge in condensed matter physics
2. Gap Between Idealized Models and Real Materials: While the Haldane phase is well-established in idealized spin models, its stability in realistic materials with significant charge fluctuations and orbital degrees of freedom remains unclear
3. Emergence of Novel Quantum Systems: Synthetic quantum systems such as metal-organic frameworks, organic molecular chains, and ultracold atom ladders exhibit fundamental features of the Haldane phase, but their stability under weakened electronic correlations and enhanced charge fluctuations becomes a critical question

Research Significance

• Fundamental Scientific Value: Deeper understanding of the stability mechanisms of topological phases in quantum magnetism
• Applied Value: Provides guidance for developing novel topological quantum materials
• Theoretical Advancement: Fills the gap in quantitative understanding of charge fluctuation effects on SPT phases

Core Contributions

1. Systematic Research Framework: Establishes a complete theoretical and numerical framework for studying SPT Haldane phase stability
2. Precise Phase Boundary Determination: Accurately determines phase boundaries between SPT Haldane phase and trivial Mott/Hund insulating phases
3. Quantification of Charge Fluctuation Effects: First quantitative analysis of charge fluctuation impacts on Haldane phase stability
4. Discovery of Novel "Hund Insulator": Identifies an insulating phase stabilized purely by Hund coupling
5. Establishment of Experimental Criteria: Provides fundamental criteria for observing Haldane physics in fermionic ladder materials

Methodology Details

Model Definitions

Heisenberg Ladder Model

H_Heis = J ∑_{γ=1,2} ∑_i S_{γ,i} · S_{γ,i+1} - J_H ∑_i S_{1,i} · S_{2,i}

where J > 0 is the antiferromagnetic intra-chain coupling and J_H > 0 is the ferromagnetic Hund coupling.

Hubbard Ladder Model

H_Hub = -t ∑_{γ=1,2} ∑_{i,σ} (c†_{γ,i,σ}c_{γ,i+1,σ} + H.c.) 
        + U ∑_{γ,i} n_{γ,i,↑}n_{γ,i,↓} - J_H ∑_i S_{1,i} · S_{2,i}

Effective Mapping Mechanism

Ferromagnetic Hund coupling promotes triplet formation on rungs, restricting the low-energy Hilbert space to the triplet subspace. After projection, an effective spin-1 Heisenberg chain is obtained:

H_eff = (J/2) ∑_i S̃_i · S̃_{i+1} - (J_H/4)L

Numerical Methods

• DMRG Calculations: Open boundary ladders with up to 241×2 sites, retaining χ=10,000 density matrix eigenstates
• Key Observables:
  1. String correlation function: $O_{str}(i,j) = ⟨S̃^z_i \exp(iπ\sum_{k=i+1}^{j-1} S̃^z_k) S̃^z_j⟩$
  2. Spin gap: $Δ_s = \lim_{L→∞}[E_0(L,1) - E_0(L,0)]$
  3. Entanglement spectrum: Eigenvalue spectrum from Schmidt decomposition
  4. Spin-spin correlation functions

Experimental Setup

Computational Parameters

• System Size: L×2 ladders with L up to 241
• Boundary Conditions: Open boundaries with edge spin-1/2 sites removed to eliminate edge state contributions
• Precision Control: Retention of χ=10,000 states with extrapolation to χ→∞ when necessary

Evaluation Metrics

1. String Order Parameter: $|O_{str}(-∞,∞)|$, approximately 0.3743 in Haldane phase
2. Spin Gap: Energy difference between singlet and triplet excitations
3. Entanglement Spectrum Degeneracy: Characteristic even-fold degeneracy in SPT phase
4. Charge Fluctuations: Local charge variance $δn^2 = ⟨n^2_{γ,i}⟩ - ⟨n_{γ,i}⟩^2$

Experimental Results

Haldane Phase in Heisenberg Ladders

• Immediate Emergence: Any finite J_H > 0 immediately produces Haldane phase
• Scaling Behavior: In small J_H/J region, string order parameter follows $|O_{str}| ∝ \sqrt{J_H/J}$ scaling
• Convergence: String order parameter continuously approaches spin-1 Heisenberg chain value with increasing J_H/J

Charge Fluctuations in Hubbard Ladders

• Cooperative Suppression: Coulomb repulsion U and Hund coupling J_H cooperatively reduce charge fluctuations
• Stable Region: Haldane phase remains stable when local charge variance δn² ≲ 0.4
• Phase Boundary: Clear boundary separating trivial insulating phase from topological Haldane phase

Key Findings

1. Hund Insulator: Even at U/t = 0, pure Hund coupling (J_H/t ≳ 4) can stabilize insulating phase
2. Linear Onset: Unlike the square-root behavior in Heisenberg ladders, string order parameter shows approximately linear onset in Hubbard ladders
3. Perfect Correspondence: Finite spin gap region perfectly matches finite string order region

Strong Coupling Analysis

Effective exchange coupling: $J_{eff} = 4t^2/(U + J_H/2)$ Predicted asymptotic behavior: $Δ_s/t = \{4t/(U + J_H/2)\}Δ^{S=1}_s$

Related Work

Theoretical Background

• SPT Phase Theory: Based on classification theory by Chen, Gu, Wen, and others
• Haldane Phase Research: From Haldane's original work to modern topological understanding
• Fermionic Ladder Systems: Recent studies on orbital degeneracy and charge dynamics effects

Experimental Progress

• Traditional Materials: Realization in transition metal oxides
• Novel Systems: Metal-organic frameworks, organic molecular chains, ultracold atom ladders
• Technical Challenges: Maintaining topological order under weakened correlations and enhanced charge fluctuations

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Stability Mechanism: Haldane phase exhibits robustness against moderate charge fluctuations but becomes unstable when electron itinerancy is too strong
2. Phase Diagram Establishment: Clear demarcation between trivial insulating phase and SPT Haldane phase
3. Experimental Guidance: Provides quantitative criteria for realizing SPT phases in correlated itinerant systems

Physical Picture

• Cooperative Effects: Subtle interplay between spin and charge degrees of freedom determines topological order stability
• Competing Mechanisms: Competition between charge fluctuations and spin correlations
• Threshold Effects: Existence of clear stability thresholds

Future Directions

1. Doped Systems: Exploration of unconventional superconductivity in doped Haldane systems
2. Multi-orbital Effects: Investigation of orbital degeneracy impact on topological phases
3. Experimental Verification: Verification of theoretical predictions in specific materials

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Rigorous Methodology: High-precision DMRG calculations with sufficiently large system sizes
2. Clear Physical Picture: Well-defined mapping from microscopic models to effective theory
3. Comprehensive Results: Consistency verification through multiple independent observables
4. High Practical Value: Provides clear parameter guidance for experiments

Technical Innovations

1. Edge State Treatment: Clever boundary condition design eliminates edge state interference
2. Finite-Size Scaling: Finite-size scaling analysis in critical regions
3. Multi-Observable Verification: Consistency checks among string order, gap, and entanglement spectrum

Limitations

1. Model Simplification: Real materials may contain more complex interactions
2. Parameter Range: Primarily focused on specific parameter regions
3. Temperature Effects: Does not consider finite-temperature stability

Impact Assessment

• Theoretical Significance: Deepens understanding of SPT phase stability
• Experimental Guidance: Provides quantitative criteria for material design
• Methodological Value: Establishes standard methods for studying topological phases in fermionic systems

Applicable Scenarios

1. Quantum Material Design: Guides synthesis of new materials with Haldane phase
2. Cold Atom Systems: Provides parameter optimization guidance for ultracold atom experiments
3. Theoretical Research: Offers methodological reference for related topological phase studies

Technical Details Supplement

Strong Coupling Expansion

Second-order effective Hamiltonian obtained via Schrieffer-Wolff transformation:

J_leg = 4t²/(U + J_H/2)

Excitation energy: $Δ = U + J_H/2$

Numerical Convergence

• Density matrix truncation error controlled below 10⁻¹⁰
• System size extrapolation ensures accuracy in thermodynamic limit
• Consistency verification among multiple central estimators

This research provides important theoretical foundation and numerical verification for understanding topological phase stability in strongly correlated electron systems, with significant implications for advancing quantum materials science.