2025-11-16T07:19:11.854987

A Late-time Radio Search for Highly Off-axis Jets from PTF Broad-lined Ic Supernovae in GRB-like Host Galaxy Environments

Schroeder, Ho, Dastidar et al.
Hydrogen/Helium-poor stripped-envelope core-collapse supernovae with broad lines (SNe Ic-bl) almost always accompany the nearby ($z < 0.3$) jetted relativistic explosions known as long duration gamma-ray bursts (GRBs). However, the majority of SNe Ic-bl have no detected GRB counterpart. At least some of these SNe should harbor off-axis jets, whose afterglow may become detectable at late times, particularly at radio wavelengths. Here, we present Karl G. Jansky Very Large Array radio observations (rest frame times of $\sim 3$-$4\times10^{3}$ days post SN discovery) of a sample of 14 SNe Ic-bl discovered by the Palomar Transient Factory (PTF) that have been demonstrated to originate from the same host environments as the SNe Ic-bl associated with nearby GRBs. Of the 14 SNe, we identify three that are radio detected, one of which (PTF10tqv, $z = 0.0795$) is consistent with an off-axis jet with energy similar to classical GRBs (${\sim 10^{51}}$-${10^{51.7}~}$erg). Using recently developed synchrotron radiation code, we find that for our 11 non-detections, which are among the deepest limits obtained for Ic-bl, we rule out an off-axis jet with an energy of $\gtrsim 10^{51}~{\rm erg}$ in circumburst densities of $\gtrsim 10^{-1}~{\rm cm}^{-3}$. We predict that well-spaced monitoring of newly discovered SNe Ic-bl from $\sim 10~$days to $\sim 10~$years (rest frame) to luminosities of $\sim 10^{27}~{\rm erg~s}^{-1}~{\rm Hz}^{-1}$ will constrain the existence of highly off-axis jets ($\gtrsim60^\circ$) with classical GRB energies. The VLA Sky Survey will probe jets that are $\lesssim 60^\circ$ off-axis, whereas the Deep Synpotic Array 2000 will probe jets out to $\sim 90^\circ$ off-axis, demonstrating the importance of utilizing radio surveys to supplement targeted observations.
academic

A Late-time Radio Search for Highly Off-axis Jets from PTF Broad-lined Ic Supernovae in GRB-like Host Galaxy Environments

Basic Information

  • Paper ID: 2507.15928
  • Title: A Late-time Radio Search for Highly Off-axis Jets from PTF Broad-lined Ic Supernovae in GRB-like Host Galaxy Environments
  • Authors: Genevieve Schroeder, Anna Y. Q. Ho, Ranadeep G. Dastidar, Maryam Modjaz, Alessandra Corsi, Paul C. Duffell
  • Classification: astro-ph.HE (High Energy Astrophysics)
  • Publication Date: Draft version October 14, 2025
  • Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2507.15928

Abstract

This study presents late-time radio observations of 14 Ic-bl type supernovae discovered by the Palomar Transient Factory (PTF) using the Karl G. Jansky Very Large Array (VLA), conducted approximately 3000-4000 days post-discovery (rest-frame). These supernovae originate from host galaxy environments identical to those of Ic-bl supernovae associated with nearby gamma-ray bursts (GRBs). Among the 14-object sample, three radio sources were detected, with PTF10tqv consistent with an off-axis jet possessing energy comparable to classical GRBs (~10^51-10^51.7 erg). For the 11 non-detections, the study excludes off-axis jet models with energy ≳10^51 erg in surrounding media with density ≳10^-1 cm^-3.

Research Background and Motivation

Scientific Background

  1. Connection between Ic-bl Supernovae and GRBs: Hydrogen/helium-deficient broad-lined Type Ic supernovae (SNe Ic-bl) are almost invariably accompanied by long-duration gamma-ray bursts (GRBs) in the nearby universe (z<0.3), yet most Ic-bl supernovae show no detected GRB counterpart.
  2. Off-axis Jet Theory: According to fundamental predictions of the GRB collimation model, certain Ic-bl supernovae may have produced relativistic jets whose directions deviate from our line of sight (θobs), rendering early GRB signals unobservable.
  3. Late-time Radio Afterglow Observability: At late times, GRB jets expand such that the jet opening angle (θj) exceeds the observation angle θobs, or the relativistic beaming angle increases, making synchrotron radiation afterglows observable.

Research Motivation

  1. Filling Observational Gaps: Previous studies suffered from small sample sizes, insufficient radio sensitivity, and limited temporal coverage, with no confirmed detections of off-axis jets from Ic-bl supernovae to date.
  2. Validating Theoretical Predictions: Modjaz et al. (2020) found that the host galaxy environments of PTF Ic-bl supernovae are indistinguishable from GRB-SN host environments, predicting these samples may be analogs of off-axis GRB-SNe.
  3. Technical Advantages: The radio band is more suitable than optical wavelengths for searching off-axis afterglows, as supernova emission is expected to dominate over afterglow signals across large viewing angles and observational epochs.

Core Contributions

  1. Deep Late-time Radio Observations: Provides the deepest radio luminosity limits for Ic-bl supernovae to date, extending observations to ~3000-4000 days post-discovery.
  2. Discovery of Off-axis Jet Candidate: Identifies PTF10tqv's radio emission as consistent with an off-axis jet with energy ~10^51-10^51.7 erg, comparable to inferred classical GRB values.
  3. Stringent Parameter Space Constraints: For non-detections, excludes off-axis jets with energy ≳10^51 erg in surrounding media with density ≳10^-1 cm^-3.
  4. Future Observational Strategy: Proposes concrete observational strategies and technical pathways for systematic discovery of off-axis jets from Ic-bl supernovae.

Methodology Details

Sample Selection

The study employs 14 PTF Ic-bl supernovae identified by Modjaz et al. (2020), characterized by:

  • Discovery epoch: 2009-2012
  • Redshift range: z = 0.015-0.158
  • Host environments similar to GRB-SNe (low metallicity environments)
  • Produced by similar massive star progenitors

Observational Setup

  1. VLA Observations:
    • Observing frequency: 10 GHz (4 GHz bandwidth)
    • Configuration: B and C configurations
    • Observation period: May-September 2020
    • Post-discovery time: 3239-3970 days (observer frame)
  2. Supplementary Observations:
    • MeerKAT 3.1 GHz observations (PTF10tqv)
    • Archival data: VLASS, LoTSS-DR2, RACS and other survey data

Theoretical Models

  1. FIREFLY Code: Employs newly developed synchrotron radiation code to generate off-axis afterglow light curves
  2. Model Parameters:
    • Two-parameter enhanced fireball model
    • Jet opening angle θj ~ 7°
    • Fixed parameters: p=2.133, εe=εB=0.1, χ=1
    • Free parameters: total jet energy E, interstellar medium density n
  3. Three Off-axis Angles: θobs = 30°, 60°, 90°

Experimental Setup

Data Processing

  1. Radio Data: Processed using CASA VLA calibration pipeline
  2. Flux Measurement: Flux density measured using pwkit/imtool programs
  3. Upper Limit Determination: 3σ upper limits provided for non-detections

Model Grid

  • Energy range: 10^49-10^52 erg
  • Density range: 10^-4-10^2 cm^-3
  • Frequencies: 3, 6, 10 GHz
  • Three off-axis angles

Experimental Results

Primary Detection Results

  1. PTF10tqv:
    • 10 GHz flux: 70±7.6 µJy (3623 days)
    • 3.1 GHz flux: 93±12 µJy (5296 days)
    • Spectral index: β = -1.1±0.3
    • Temporal variability: Significant temporal evolution with brightness decline of ~3×
  2. Other Detections:
    • PTF10xem: Radio emission consistent with host galaxy center, not supernova-related
    • PTF11lbm and PTF09sk: Weak signals present but unconfirmed

Parameter Space Constraints

  1. Non-detection Constraints:
    • Luminosity limits: ~1.5×10^26-4.7×10^27 erg s^-1 Hz^-1
    • For θobs ≤ 30°: Excludes most measured long GRB n-E parameter pairs
    • For θobs ≥ 60°: Cannot exclude GRB parameters when n < 10^-2 cm^-3
  2. PTF10tqv Model Fitting:
    • Allowed parameter range: 10^51 ≲ E ≲ 10^51.7 erg
    • Density constraints: n ≳ 10^-2.8 cm^-3
    • Consistent with classical GRB parameters

Detection Rate Analysis

  • Candidate detection rate: 1/14 ≈ 7%
  • Consistent with theoretical expectations: Based on Ic-bl and GRB local rates, ~1-10% of Ic-bl are predicted to produce successful GRB jets

Related Work

Historical Research

  1. Early Radio Searches: Berger et al. (2003), Soderberg et al. (2006) and others conducted off-axis afterglow searches for core-collapse supernovae
  2. PTF/ZTF Samples: Corsi et al. (2016, 2023) conducted systematic radio observations of PTF and ZTF samples
  3. Individual Candidates: SN 2020bvc considered as possible off-axis GRB cocoon and afterglow

Theoretical Development

  1. Jet Models: Barnes et al. (2018) theoretical modeling demonstrates that jet central engines can simultaneously produce GRBs and broad-lined spectra
  2. Afterglow Theory: Based on standard GRB afterglow theory (Sari et al. 1998) and off-axis observational predictions

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

  1. First Compelling Off-axis Jet Candidate: PTF10tqv's radio emission is consistent with an off-axis jet with classical GRB energy
  2. Stringent Constraints: Other samples exclude typical long GRB jets (E≈10^51 erg) in high-density environments
  3. Reasonable Detection Rate: ~7% detection rate consistent with local rate estimates for relativistic Ic-bl and GRBs

Limitations

  1. Sample Constraints:
    • Small sample size (14 objects)
    • Large redshift range leads to broad luminosity constraint ranges
    • Most events have only single late-time observations
  2. Model Assumptions:
    • εB = 0.1 may be overly optimistic
    • Fixed jet opening angle θj ~ 7° may not apply to all cases
    • Assumes constant density interstellar medium
  3. Observational Limitations:
    • Weak constraints on low-energy (≲10^51 erg) jets in low-density environments
    • Lack of early observational data limits constraints on rapidly decaying jets

Future Directions

  1. ZTF Sample:
    • Larger sample (~90 Ic-bl objects)
    • Lower median redshift (z=0.04)
    • Better temporal coverage
  2. Observational Strategy:
    • Recommend intensive monitoring from ~10 days to ~10 years post-discovery
    • Target luminosity ~10^27 erg s^-1 Hz^-1
    • Incorporate VLASS, DSA-2000 and other survey data
  3. Technical Development:
    • VLBI observations to determine radio source sizes
    • Deeper radio surveys
    • Multi-wavelength coordinated observations

In-depth Evaluation

Strengths

  1. Observational Depth: Provides the deepest radio luminosity limits for Ic-bl supernovae to date
  2. Theory Integration: Employs newly developed FIREFLY code for systematic model comparison
  3. Sample Selection: Sample selection based on host environment similarity possesses strong physical motivation
  4. Candidate Discovery: PTF10tqv represents the first compelling off-axis jet candidate
  5. Future Planning: Provides concrete and feasible strategies for future large-sample searches

Weaknesses

  1. Statistical Significance: Limited statistical significance of single candidate requires verification with larger samples
  2. Multiple Interpretations: PTF10tqv's radio emission admits multiple possible explanations (AGN, pulsar wind nebula, etc.)
  3. Model Dependence: Conclusions are sensitive to assumptions about microphysical parameters (particularly εB)
  4. Temporal Sampling: Most events lack multi-epoch observations, limiting constraints on temporal variability

Impact

  1. Field Contribution: Provides important observational evidence for the long-standing Ic-bl/GRB connection problem
  2. Methodological Innovation: Systematic late-time radio search strategy applicable to future large-sample studies
  3. Practical Value: Provides scientific target guidance for forthcoming radio surveys (e.g., DSA-2000)
  4. Theory Verification: Provides important observational tests for off-axis GRB models

Applicable Scenarios

  1. Transient Source Searches: Applicable to various transient sources potentially producing relativistic jets
  2. Multi-messenger Astrophysics: Can be combined with gravitational wave detection to search for electromagnetic counterparts
  3. Radio Survey Science: Provides methodological guidance for transient source science in large-scale radio surveys
  4. Supernova Physics: Deepens understanding of core-collapse supernova explosion mechanisms

References

Key references include:

  • Modjaz et al. (2020): Host environment study of PTF sample
  • Corsi et al. (2016, 2023): Previous radio search work
  • Dastidar & Duffell (2024): FIREFLY code development
  • Barnes et al. (2018): Jet-supernova theoretical models

Summary: This is a high-quality observational astrophysics paper that provides important progress on the long-standing Ic-bl supernova-GRB connection problem through deep radio observations. The research methodology is rigorous, results are scientifically significant, and it establishes a foundation for future large-sample studies. Despite limitations such as sample size constraints, its pioneering discoveries and systematic approach make it an important contribution to the field.