On the weighted Wiener-Lévy theorem: analogue on Euclidean space, strong converse on LCA group and applications to modulation spaces

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2507.16516
• Title: On the weighted Wiener-Lévy theorem: analogue on Euclidean space, strong converse on LCA group and applications to modulation spaces
• Authors: Divyang G. Bhimani, Karishman B. Solanki
• Classification: math.FA (Functional Analysis)
• Submission Date: Submitted to arXiv on July 30, 2025; revised on October 14, 2025
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2507.16516v2

Abstract

This paper investigates Banach algebra-valued function spaces in the weighted Fourier algebra $A^q_\omega(\Gamma,\mathcal{X})$, which consists of Fourier transforms of functions in $L^q_\omega(G,\mathcal{X})$. Here $\omega$ is a Beurling-Domar type weight on a discrete abelian group $G$, $\Gamma$ is the dual group of $G$, and $\mathcal{X}$ is a unital commutative Banach algebra. The authors establish a strong converse theorem for the Wiener-Lévy theorem in the vector-valued weighted setting: if $F$ is an $\mathcal{X}$-valued function defined on $\mathbb{C}$ such that for all $f\in A^1_\omega(\Gamma,\mathbb{C})$, the composition $F\circ f:\Gamma\to\mathcal{X}$ belongs to $A^q(\Gamma,\mathcal{X})$ (with $1\leq q <2$), then $F$ must be real analytic on $\mathbb{R}^2$. The paper also establishes multivariate analogues and results for locally compact abelian groups, with applications to weighted modulation spaces, Wiener composition spaces, and Fourier composition spaces.

Research Background and Motivation

Problem Background

The classical Wiener theorem states that if $f \in A(\mathbb{T})$ (the class of functions with absolutely convergent Fourier series on the unit circle) and $f$ is nowhere zero, then $1/f \in A(\mathbb{T})$. Lévy generalized this result: if $F$ is analytic in some neighborhood containing the range of $f$, then $F \circ f \in A(\mathbb{T})$. The converse of this result was established by Katznelson and others, forming the celebrated Wiener-Lévy-Katznelson theorem.

Research Motivation

1. Importance of Weights: Weight functions are widely applied in analysis to quantify growth and decay conditions, with important applications in signal theory, frame theory, sampling theory, and Gabor analysis.
2. Vector-Valued Setting: In operator theory, one frequently needs to study operator-valued functions on Banach or Hilbert spaces, making vector-valued analogues theoretically significant.
3. Nonlinear Mappings: Composition operators provide simple examples of nonlinear mappings, with crucial applications in studying nonlinear partial differential equations.
4. Existing Limitations: While the Wiener-Lévy theorem in weighted spaces has been studied, the strong converse theorem in the vector-valued weighted setting has not yet been established.

Core Contributions

1. Establishment of Strong Converse Theorem in Vector-Valued Weighted Setting: This is the first generalization of the classical theorem by Helson, Kahane, Katznelson, and Rudin under the weights considered.
2. Proof of Sharpness of Parameter $q$: The range $q < 2$ is shown to be sharp; when $q=2$, the conclusion fails, with $F(z)=|z|$ (non-real analytic) serving as a counterexample.
3. Establishment of Analogues in Euclidean Fourier Algebra: For regularly growing weights $\omega$, analogues of the Wiener-Lévy theorem are established in $A^q_\omega(\mathbb{R}^d)$.
4. Applications to Time-Frequency Analysis Spaces: Results are applied to weighted modulation spaces, Wiener composition spaces, and Fourier composition spaces, supplementing related work in these fields.
5. Illumination of Nonlinear Phenomena in Dispersive PDEs: The results contribute to understanding the dynamics of dispersive PDEs in these spaces.

Detailed Methodology

Basic Setup and Definitions

Weight Function Definition:

• Weight $\omega: G \to [1,\infty)$ satisfies the submultiplicativity condition: $\omega(x+y) \leq \omega(x)\omega(y)$
• Admissible weights satisfy the Beurling-Domar condition: $\sum_{n\in\mathbb{N}} \frac{\log\omega(nx)}{n^2} < \infty$
• $q$-algebra weights satisfy subconvolution and integral conditions

Weighted Fourier Algebra: $A^q_\omega(\Gamma,\mathcal{X}) = \{\hat{f} : \Gamma \to \mathcal{X} : f \in L^q_\omega(G,\mathcal{X})\}$

Main Theorems

Theorem 1.4 (Strong Converse Theorem): Let $1 \leq q < 2$, $G$ be a non-compact locally compact abelian group, $\Gamma$ be its dual group, $\omega$ be an admissible weight, and $\mathcal{X}$ be a unital commutative Banach algebra. If the composition operator $T_F$ satisfies one of the following conditions:

• $T_F$ maps $A^1_\omega(\Gamma,\mathbb{C}^2)$ to $A^q(\Gamma,\mathbb{C}^2)$
• $T_F$ maps $A^1_\omega(\Gamma,\mathbb{C})$ to $A^q(\Gamma,\mathcal{X})$
• $T_F$ acts on $A^q_\omega(\Gamma,\mathbb{C}^2)$
• $T_F$ acts on $A^q_\omega(\Gamma,\mathcal{X})$

then $F$ is real analytic on its domain, and $F(0)=0$ when $G$ is non-discrete.

Theorem 1.5 (Sufficient Condition): Let $\omega$ be an admissible weight of regular growth on $\mathbb{R}^d$. If $F: I \to \mathcal{X}$ (where $I \subset \mathbb{C}$) is real analytic and $F(0)=0$, then $T_F$ acts on $A^q_\omega(\mathbb{R}^d,\mathcal{X})$.

Proof Techniques

Key Lemmas:

1. Local Boundedness (Lemma 3.1): Utilizing Domar's Urysohn lemma and translation invariance to establish local boundedness of $T_F$ at each point.
2. Neighborhood Mapping (Lemma 3.2): Through partition of unity and Bochner-Phillips results, proving that $T_F$ maps some neighborhood of the origin to a bounded set.
3. Lower Bound Estimates (Lemma 3.3): Improving Katznelson-Rudin lower bound estimates, providing lower bounds for $\|e^{if}\|_{A^q}$ for trigonometric polynomials $f$.

Proof Strategy:

1. First prove the discrete group case, then extend to locally compact groups using group structure theory
2. Establish continuity of $F$
3. Prove real analyticity through Fourier series analysis
4. Handle the Euclidean case using scaling properties

Experimental Setup

Theoretical Verification

As this is a pure mathematical theory paper, results are verified through rigorous mathematical proofs rather than numerical experiments.

Weight Function Examples

The paper provides concrete examples of multiple classes of weight functions:

• Polynomial weights: $\omega_s(x) = (1+|x|)^s$
• Exponential weights: $\omega(x) = e^{|x|^b}$ (with $0 < b < 1$)
• Japanese weights: $\omega(x) = (1+|x|^2)^{s/2}$

Application Verification

The theoretical utility is verified by applying results to time-frequency analysis spaces.

Experimental Results

Main Results

Sharpness: The restriction $q < 2$ is proven to be sharp; when $q=2$, the function $F(z)=|z|$ provides a counterexample.

Generality: Results generalize several classical theorems:

• Taking $\omega \equiv 1$ and $\mathcal{X} = \mathbb{C}$ recovers Rudin's theorem
• Taking $q=1$ recovers the theorem of Helson et al.

Application Results: Theorem 1.7: For time-frequency analysis spaces, if $T_F$ maps $X$ to $Y$, where $(X,Y)$ can be:

• $(M^{p,1}_\omega, M^{p,q})$ (modulation spaces)
• $(W^{p,1}_\omega, W^{p,q})$ (Wiener composition spaces)
• $(FW(L^p,\ell^1_\omega), FW(L^p,\ell^q))$ (Fourier composition spaces)

then $F$ must be real analytic on its domain.

Important Findings

Corollary 1.1: Reveals that power-type nonlinearities $|u|^\alpha u$ (with $\alpha \in (0,\infty) \setminus 2\mathbb{N}$) cannot map from $M^{p,1}_\omega$ to $M^{p,q}$, which is significant for understanding nonlinear phenomena in dispersive PDEs.

Related Work

Classical Theory

• Wiener theorem (1932)
• Lévy generalization (1935)
• Katznelson converse theorem (1959)
• Helson-Kahane-Katznelson-Rudin strong converse theorem (1959-1962)

Weighted Cases

• Results by Kinani and Bouchikhi on weighted settings
• Work by Feichtinger, Kobayashi, and Sato on modulation spaces
• Development of vector-valued analogues

Time-Frequency Analysis

• Work of Bhimani-Ratnakumar on modulation spaces
• Generalizations by Kobayashi-Sato
• Applications to dispersive PDEs

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Theoretical Breakthrough: For the first time, a strong converse theorem for the Wiener-Lévy theorem is established in the vector-valued weighted setting, filling a theoretical gap in this field.
2. Technical Innovation: New techniques for handling composition operators in weighted spaces are developed, particularly improving lower bound estimation methods.
3. Application Value: Results have important applications in time-frequency analysis and dispersive PDE theory, providing new tools for understanding nonlinear phenomena.

Limitations

1. Weight Restrictions: Some results require weights to satisfy the Beurling-Domar condition, which is stronger than the GRS condition.
2. Group Restrictions: Some results apply only to Euclidean spaces and cannot be generalized to arbitrary locally compact abelian groups.
3. Parameter Range: The restriction $q < 2$, while sharp, limits the scope of applications.

Future Directions

1. Relaxation of Weight Conditions: Investigation of whether the Beurling-Domar condition can be relaxed to the GRS condition.
2. More General Groups: Exploration of analogous results on more general locally compact groups.
3. Extension of Applications: Application of these results to more problems in analysis and PDEs.

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Theoretical Depth: The paper addresses an important theoretical problem, filling a gap in the vector-valued weighted setting.
2. Technical Rigor: The proof techniques are sophisticated, particularly in handling weight functions and vector-valued cases.
3. Broad Applicability: Results have applications across multiple branches of mathematical analysis, especially in time-frequency analysis and PDE theory.
4. Clear Presentation: The paper is well-structured with precise definitions and detailed proofs.

Weaknesses

1. Pure Theoretical Nature: Lacks numerical verification or concrete computational examples.
2. High Technical Threshold: Requires deep background in functional analysis and harmonic analysis for complete understanding.
3. Strong Restrictive Conditions: Conditions such as Beurling-Domar and regular growth are relatively strong.

Impact

1. Academic Value: Provides important theoretical tools for functional analysis and harmonic analysis.
2. Application Prospects: Potential applications in signal processing, quantum mechanics, and partial differential equations.
3. Theoretical Completeness: Perfects the theoretical framework of the Wiener-Lévy theorem in weighted and vector-valued settings.

Applicable Scenarios

1. Theoretical Research: Applicable to theoretical research in functional analysis and harmonic analysis.
2. PDE Analysis: Applications in studying well-posedness of dispersive equations.
3. Signal Processing: Potential applications in time-frequency analysis and Gabor analysis.

References

The paper cites 64 important references, primarily including:

• Classical works by Helson, Kahane, Katznelson, and Rudin
• Contributions by Feichtinger on modulation spaces
• Domar's theory on weighted algebras
• Recent work in time-frequency analysis

This paper makes important contributions to functional analysis in theoretical mathematics. While technically demanding, it provides a solid theoretical foundation for further development in related fields.