Greybody factors in scalar-tensor gravity and beyond

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2507.17329
• Title: Greybody factors in scalar-tensor gravity and beyond
• Authors: Georgios Antoniou, Thomas D. Pappas, Panagiota Kanti
• Classification: gr-qc (General Relativity and Quantum Cosmology)
• Publication Date: October 12, 2025 (arXiv v2)
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2507.17329

Abstract

This paper investigates three subtheories within the beyond-Horndeski action framework that support scalarized black hole solutions, seeking correction features relative to General Relativity (GR). First, the propagation of massless scalar fields and vector test fields in analytic spherically symmetric black hole backgrounds derived from parity-odd beyond-Horndeski theory is studied, revealing significant corrections in the profiles of effective gravitational potentials, greybody factors, absorption cross-sections, and quasinormal frequencies when deviating from the GR limit. Subsequently, attention is focused on gravitational perturbations themselves, employing complete theoretical analysis that accounts for the scalar field's backreaction on the metric. Using scalarized black holes from shift-symmetric Horndeski theory and quadratic-quartic scalar-Gauss-Bonnet theory as background solutions, greybody factors and quasinormal modes in the axial sector are computed. In both theories, corresponding directly to effective potential forms with multiple extrema, modified (suppressed or non-monotonic) greybody curves and altered quasinormal frequencies (smaller oscillation frequencies and larger damping times) are found, particularly as the hair-generating parameter increases.

Research Background and Motivation

Problem Background

Black holes are among the most mysterious celestial objects in the universe. According to General Relativity, only a few physical quantities can characterize a black hole: mass, electromagnetic charge, and angular momentum. Early discussions of the possibility of scalar hair in scalar-tensor gravity theories prompted corresponding discussions of no-hair theorems. However, with the revival of Horndeski theory, these no-hair theorems proved to be temporary, and numerous black hole solutions with scalar hair were discovered.

Research Motivation

1. Theoretical Completeness Requirements: Horndeski and beyond-Horndeski actions provide a universal and flexible mathematical framework that, through careful selection of coupling function forms, can generate black hole solutions with attractive features.
2. Observational Verification Needs: These solutions and their associated observables may provide pathways for exploring fundamental gravitational theories and discovering new physics in strong-field regimes.
3. Filling Theoretical Gaps: To the authors' knowledge, greybody factors have not previously been computed in the non-decoupling limit of modified gravity with additional scalar fields.

Limitations of Existing Methods

Traditional test field analyses neglect the scalar field's backreaction on the metric, failing to accurately describe physical phenomena in the complete theory. A complete theoretical analysis method accounting for scalar field backreaction is required.

Core Contributions

1. First Complete Theoretical Analysis: First computation of greybody factors accounting for scalar field backreaction in modified gravity theories
2. Multi-theoretical Framework Study: Systematic investigation of three distinct scalar-tensor theory subclasses: parity-odd beyond-Horndeski theory, shift-symmetric Horndeski theory, and quadratic-quartic scalar Gauss-Bonnet theory
3. Discovery of New Physical Phenomena: Discovery of non-monotonic greybody factor behavior induced by effective potentials with multiple extrema
4. Quasinormal Mode-Greybody Factor Correlation: Establishment of direct correspondence between quasinormal mode frequencies and greybody factors
5. Analytical and Numerical Results: Provision of exact results for analytic black hole solutions and comprehensive analysis of numerical scalarized black holes

Detailed Methodology

Theoretical Framework

Research is based on the beyond-Horndeski theory action:

S = S_H + S_bH

where S_H represents Horndeski terms and S_bH represents beyond-Horndeski terms.

Background Spacetime

Static spherically symmetric black hole solutions are considered with line element:

ds² = -A(r)dt² + dr²/B(r) + r²(dθ² + sin²θdφ²)

Analysis Methods

1. Test Field Analysis

For massless scalar and electromagnetic fields propagating in fixed gravitational backgrounds, the method of separation of variables is employed:

Ψ̃(t,r,θ,φ) = ∫dω̃ Ψ(r)/r Y_ℓ^m(θ,φ) e^(-iω̃t)

The master equation is transformed into Schrödinger-type form:

d²Ψ/dr*² + [ω̃² - V_eff(r*)]Ψ = 0

2. Complete Theoretical Analysis

Linear perturbations of both metric and scalar field are considered:

g_μν = g_μν^(0) + ε δg_μν
φ = φ^(0) + ε δφ

In the axial sector, scalar perturbations decouple, yielding master equations for gravitational perturbations.

Boundary Conditions

• Greybody Factors: Incident plus reflected waves at infinity, transmitted wave at the horizon
• Quasinormal Modes: Pure outgoing waves at infinity, pure ingoing waves at the horizon

Experimental Setup

Research Objects

1. Parity-odd Beyond-Horndeski Theory: Analytic black hole solutions with parameters (p₁, p₂)
2. Shift-symmetric Horndeski Theory: Numerical scalarized black hole solutions with hair parameter α
3. Quadratic-Quartic Scalar GB Theory: Stable scalarized black hole solutions with parameters α and ζ

Computational Methods

• Sixth-order WKB method for quasinormal mode computation
• Shooting method for boundary value problems
• Numerical integration for coupled differential equation systems

Parameter Selection

• Parity-odd theory: p₁M = 0.05, 1; p₂ ∈ -0.4, 0.2
• Shift-symmetric theory: γ/r_h² = -2, with seven reference points selected
• Quadratic-quartic theory: ζ/α = -1, with seven reference points along existence curves

Experimental Results

Parity-odd Beyond-Horndeski Theory Results

Effective Potential and Greybody Factors

• Effective potential exhibits single-peak barrier form
• As p₂ increases from negative to positive values, barrier height increases and greybody factors are suppressed
• Vector fields experience stronger suppression than scalar fields

Absorption Cross-sections

• Scalar fields: Low-energy limit σ_abs = 4πr_h² (horizon area)
• Vector fields: Low-energy limit σ_abs → 0
• High-energy limit: Both field types approach the same geometric cross-section σ_geo = πr_p²/A(r_p)

Quasinormal Modes

• More negative p₂ values: Reduced real part, less negative imaginary part (increased damping time)
• Reduced oscillation frequency, enhanced stability

Shift-symmetric Horndeski Theory Results

Emergence of Multi-extremum Potentials

• Small α/M² values: Single-peak barrier
• Large α/M² values: Multiple extrema appear (potential wells and multiple peaks)
• Significant discrepancies between complete theory and test field analysis

Non-monotonic Greybody Factor Behavior

• Potential wells lead to enhancement in mid-frequency regions
• Multiple barriers cause high-frequency suppression
• Non-monotonic greybody factor curves emerge

Quasinormal Mode Corrections

• Increasing α/M²: Overall increase in real part, decrease in imaginary part (reduced stability)
• Non-monotonic behavior appears in large α/M² regions

Quadratic-Quartic Scalar GB Theory Results

Extreme Multi-extremum Behavior

• Nearly all solutions exhibit multi-extremum potential forms
• Depths/heights of potential wells and peaks increase dramatically with α/M²

Complex Greybody Factor Structure

• Low-energy region: Suppression effects not pronounced
• High-energy region: Multiple extrema and overall suppression appear
• Maximum α/M² values correspond to most complex structures

Non-linear Quasinormal Mode Evolution

• Both real and imaginary parts exhibit increase and decrease regions with varying α/M²
• Highest hair parameter corresponds to larger real part and smaller imaginary part (increased damping time)

Related Work

Greybody Factor Research

Greybody factors have been extensively employed in General Relativity and extended gravity theory research, particularly in string theory-inspired and higher-dimensional theories. This paper extends such investigations to scalar-tensor theories.

Quasinormal Mode Research

Quasinormal modes are important tools for studying black hole dynamics and stability. Recent research has established direct correspondence between quasinormal modes and greybody factors.

Scalarized Black Holes

Since the revival of Horndeski theory, numerous scalarized black hole solutions have been discovered. This paper represents the first computation of greybody factors for these solutions in the non-decoupling limit.

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Universal Correction Effects: All investigated scalar-tensor theories exhibit greybody factors and quasinormal frequencies significantly different from GR
2. Importance of Potential Shape: Multi-extremum structures of effective potentials are directly reflected in greybody factor and quasinormal mode behavior
3. Criticality of Backreaction: Fundamental differences between complete theory and test field analyses demonstrate the importance of scalar field backreaction
4. Observational Signatures: Scalarized black holes may exhibit unique Hawking radiation spectra and gravitational wave signals

Physical Insights

• Potential wells tend to enhance greybody factors, particularly in low-frequency regions
• Potential barriers tend to suppress greybody factors
• Increasing hair parameters typically lead to reduced oscillation frequencies and increased damping times

Limitations

1. Only axial sector perturbations are considered
2. Restricted to linear perturbation theory
3. Some results based on specific parameter choices
4. Complex couplings in the polar sector not considered

Future Directions

1. Extension to polar sector analysis
2. Investigation of rotating scalarized black holes
3. Exploration of nonlinear effects
4. Connection with gravitational wave observations

In-depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Pioneering Research: First complete greybody factor analysis in modified gravity theories
2. Rigorous Methodology: Combines analytical and numerical methods, validates results across multiple theoretical frameworks
3. Deep Physical Insights: Establishes clear connections between effective potential structure and observables
4. Comprehensive Calculations: Encompasses full range from test field to complete theory analysis
5. Novel Results: Discovers new physical phenomena such as non-monotonic greybody factors

Weaknesses

1. Limited Scope: Only axial perturbations considered; polar sector may contain richer physics
2. Parameter Dependence: Some results based on specific parameter choices; universality remains to be verified
3. Observational Connection: Lacks comparison with and constraints from actual observational data
4. Numerical Precision: Stability of numerical calculations in extreme parameter regions may be problematic

Impact

1. Theoretical Contribution: Provides new computational framework for black hole physics in modified gravity theories
2. Methodological Value: Established analytical methods applicable to other scalar-tensor theories
3. Observational Significance: Provides theoretical predictions for future gravitational wave and black hole observations
4. Cross-disciplinary Impact: Connects gravitational theory, black hole physics, and observational astrophysics

Applicable Scenarios

1. Theoretical Research: Black hole perturbation analysis in modified gravity theories
2. Numerical Relativity: Numerical simulation verification of scalarized black holes
3. Observational Astrophysics: Theoretical template construction for gravitational wave signals
4. Cosmological Applications: Strong-field tests in dark energy theories

References

The paper cites 79 relevant references, spanning from classical no-hair theorems to recent scalarized black hole research, reflecting the complete development trajectory of the field. Important references include Horndeski's original work, recent scalarized black hole discoveries, and latest research on the relationship between greybody factors and quasinormal modes.

Summary: This is a pioneering work of significant importance in modified gravity theory. Through rigorous theoretical analysis and numerical computation, it reveals for the first time the greybody factor characteristics of scalarized black holes, laying an important foundation for further development in this field.