Ultra-long MeV transient from a relativistic jet: a tidal disruption event candidate

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2507.18694
• Title: Ultra-long MeV transient from a relativistic jet: a tidal disruption event candidate
• Authors: Gor Oganesyan, Elias Kammoun, Annarita Ierardi and 14 other co-authors
• Classification: astro-ph.HE (High-Energy Astrophysics)
• Publication Date: October 15, 2025
• Journal: Astronomy & Astrophysics (under submission)
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2507.18694

Abstract

On July 2, 2025, the Gamma-ray Burst Monitor (GBM) aboard the Fermi Gamma-ray Space Telescope detected three short-timescale MeV transient sources with overlapping sky positions. These events were designated GRB 250702D, B, and E (collectively referred to as DBE), with eruptions separated by approximately 1-2 hours. The Neil Gehrels Swift Observatory and the Nuclear Spectroscopic Telescope Array (NuSTAR) conducted a 10-day follow-up observation of this anomalously long-duration MeV transient (lasting >3 hours), revealing soft X-ray emission with steep temporal decay ($\propto t^{-1.9 \pm 0.1}$). The time-averaged spectrum during the outburst is well described by a single power law $dN_γ/dE \propto E^{-1.5}$, while upper limits above 100 MeV indicate a spectral cutoff between 10-100 MeV. Using standard gamma-ray opacity arguments, the researchers derived a lower limit on the bulk Lorentz factor of the jet. Combined with the steep X-ray decay, these constraints point to a relativistic jet origin. The properties of DBE are inconsistent with established GRB spectral-energy relations, excluding the possibility of classical long GRB progenitors. Instead, the fundamental characteristics of DBE resemble previously reported jetted tidal disruption events (TDEs). In the relativistic TDE scenario, DBE represents the first such event detected in MeV gamma-ray emission.

Research Background and Motivation

Problem Background

1. Classification dilemma of gamma-ray bursts: Traditionally, short-timescale MeV transient sources are classified as gamma-ray bursts (GRBs), but not all such events originate from classical GRB progenitors (such as collapsing stars or neutron star mergers).
2. New understanding of tidal disruption events: When a star is tidally disrupted by a massive compact object, a relativistic jet may be produced. To date, only four relativistic TDEs have been identified: Swift J164449.3+573451, Swift J2058.4+0516, Swift J1112.2-8238, and AT 2022cmc, but none have been detected in the MeV gamma-ray band.
3. Anomalous observational characteristics: The DBE event exhibits an exceptionally long MeV emission duration (>3 hours), far exceeding the typical timescale of classical GRBs (0.1-100 seconds), requiring new physical explanations.

Research Significance

• Filling observational gaps: First detection of a possible relativistic TDE in the MeV band, providing new observational evidence for understanding these extreme astrophysical phenomena
• Expanding GRB classification: Challenging the traditional GRB classification system and advancing understanding of the diversity of high-energy transient sources
• Exploring physical mechanisms: Providing crucial data for investigating black hole-star interactions and relativistic jet formation mechanisms

Core Contributions

1. First MeV-band TDE detection: Reports the first suspected relativistic tidal disruption event detected in the MeV gamma-ray band
2. Comprehensive multi-wavelength analysis: Combines observational data from Fermi/GBM, Swift/XRT, and NuSTAR, providing complete spectral analysis from soft X-rays to MeV gamma-rays
3. Physical parameter constraints: Through gamma-ray opacity arguments, provides strict lower limit constraints on the jet's bulk Lorentz factor (Γ > 7d²/⁵_{L,100 Mpc})
4. Radiation mechanism identification: Argues that the observed emission is most likely produced by synchrotron radiation from sub-TeV electrons
5. GRB relation verification: Demonstrates that DBE does not conform to the Amati and Yonetoku spectral-energy relations of classical long GRBs, supporting non-classical GRB origin

Methodology Details

Observational Data Processing

Fermi/GBM Data Analysis

1. Orbital background estimation: Employs a modified Orbital Subtraction Viewer (OSV) tool, utilizing the Fermi satellite's 90-minute orbital periodicity to estimate background using observations from 15 or 30 orbits before and after
2. Spectral extraction: Extracts energy spectra of the three D, B, and E bursts from daily GBM data in the energy range 10 keV - 40 MeV
3. Response matrix generation: Generates GBM response matrices based on precise positions provided by Swift/XRT

X-ray Data Analysis

1. Swift/XRT: Performs time-resolved spectral analysis of soft X-rays in the 0.3-10 keV band, employing an absorbed power-law model
2. NuSTAR: Conducts observations in the hard X-ray band (3-79 keV) with 39 ks exposure time and net exposure ~32 ks

Physical Constraint Methods

Bulk Lorentz Factor Lower Limit

Using MeV compactness constraints, the bulk Lorentz factor lower limit is derived:

$\Gamma > \left[\frac{\eta(\beta)\sigma_T\left(\frac{\epsilon_{max}}{2}\right)^{2\beta-1}(1+z)^{2\beta}d_L^2(z)F_0(1-\beta)}{2\delta t_v m_e c^4\left[1-\left(\frac{\epsilon_0}{\epsilon_{max}}\right)^{1-\beta}\right]}\right]^{\frac{1}{4+2\beta}}$

where β ≈ 0.5 is the spectral index and δt_v ≈ 100s is the observed variability timescale.

Radiation Mechanism Analysis

By comparing synchrotron cooling timescales and dynamical timescales, the feasibility of synchrotron radiation is determined:

• Synchrotron cooling timescale: $t'_{sync} \sim 80 \Gamma_1^{1/2}(\epsilon/\epsilon_{max})^{-1/2}B'^{-3/2}$ s
• Dynamical timescale: $t'_{dyn} \sim 10^3 \Gamma_1 \delta t_2$ s

Experimental Setup

Observational Data

1. Fermi/GBM: 8 keV - 40 MeV, covering complete temporal evolution of three bursts
2. Fermi/LAT: >100 MeV, providing high-energy upper limit constraints
3. Swift/XRT: 0.3-10 keV, 10-day follow-up observations
4. NuSTAR: 3-79 keV, hard X-ray observations one day after the burst

Analysis Methods

• Spectral fitting: Uses XSPEC software with Cash statistics
• Model selection: Comparison of power-law and broken power-law models
• Background estimation: Standard polynomial fitting and orbital averaging methods

Experimental Results

Temporal Evolution Characteristics

1. MeV light curves: Three bursts with durations of ~150s (D), ~150s (B), and ~600s (E), separated by 45 minutes and 3 hours
2. X-ray decay: Soft X-ray flux decays steeply as $t^{-1.9±0.1}$, steeper than typical GRB afterglows ($t^{-1}$)

Spectral Characteristics

1. MeV spectral indices:
   • Events D and B: α = 1.5 ± 0.1
   • Event E: α = 1.64 ± 0.04
   • Combined D+B spectrum (>200 keV): α = 1.77⁺⁰·¹⁷₋₀.₁₂
2. Spectral cutoff:
   • No significant cutoff within GBM band
   • LAT upper limits indicate cutoff energy between 10-100 MeV
3. X-ray spectrum: Photon indices of 1.4-1.6, indicating non-thermal radiation

Physical Parameter Constraints

1. Bulk Lorentz factor: Γ > 7d²/⁵_{L,100 Mpc}, combined with energetic constraints yields 10 < Γ < 30
2. Distance constraints: 100 Mpc < d_L < 2 Gpc, corresponding to redshift z < 1
3. Isotropic luminosity: L_ ~ 4×10⁴⁷ d²_{L,100 Mpc} erg s⁻¹

Comparison with GRB Relations

DBE deviates from the 3σ scatter region of long GRBs in both the Amati relation (E_{p,z} - E_) and Yonetoku relation (E_{p,z} - L_) diagrams, indicating non-classical GRB origin.

Related Work

Current Status of Relativistic TDE Research

Four known relativistic TDE candidates:

• Swift J164449.3+573451 (2011): First identified relativistic TDE
• Swift J2058.4+0516 (2012): Shows similar X-ray variability characteristics
• Swift J1112.2-8238 (2015): Fainter relativistic TDE
• AT 2022cmc (2022): Recently discovered high-redshift TDE

All these events have been detected only in the hard X-ray band (<200 keV), lacking MeV gamma-ray observations.

GRB Classification Research

Traditional GRB classification is based on duration and hardness, but increasing evidence suggests the need for a more complex classification system to encompass various high-energy transient sources.

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. TDE candidate authentication: The ultra-long MeV emission, steep X-ray decay, and spectral characteristics of DBE strongly point to a relativistic TDE origin
2. First MeV detection: This is the first suspected relativistic TDE detected in the MeV gamma-ray band
3. Radiation mechanism: The observed emission is most likely produced by synchrotron radiation from sub-TeV electrons
4. Physical parameters: Jet bulk Lorentz factor 10 < Γ < 30, source distance 100 Mpc - 2 Gpc

Limitations

1. Sample constraints: The relativistic TDE sample remains small, with limited statistical significance
2. Redshift uncertainty: Host galaxy redshift has not been precisely determined, affecting physical parameter constraints
3. Alternative models: While the TDE explanation is most reasonable, other progenitor models cannot be completely excluded

Future Directions

1. Multi-messenger observations: Combining gravitational wave and neutrino detection to provide a more comprehensive physical picture
2. Sample expansion: Discovery of more such events through more sensitive MeV detectors
3. Theoretical modeling: Development of more precise relativistic TDE theoretical models

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. High observational value: First MeV-band detection of a relativistic TDE, filling an important observational gap
2. Rigorous analysis: Comprehensive multi-wavelength data analysis with rigorous physical constraint derivations
3. Methodological innovation: Data processing techniques such as orbital background subtraction ensure reliable results
4. Deep physical insights: Comprehensive physical analysis from radiation mechanisms to jet parameters

Weaknesses

1. Small statistical sample: Conclusions based on a single event require verification through additional observations
2. Large uncertainties: Distance and redshift uncertainties affect the precision of physical parameters
3. Limited alternative explanations: Discussion of other possible physical mechanisms is relatively brief

Impact

1. Scientific significance: Opens a new observational window for relativistic TDE research
2. Technical advancement: Promotes development of MeV astronomy and multi-messenger astrophysics
3. Theoretical inspiration: Provides important observational constraints for black hole-star interaction theory

Applicable Scenarios

This research methodology and conclusions are applicable to:

• Multi-wavelength observational analysis of high-energy transient sources
• Relativistic astrophysics phenomena research
• Classification and identification of GRBs and TDEs
• Physical processes in extreme gravitational environments

References

The paper cites 68 important references covering key areas including GRB observations, TDE theory, and high-energy astrophysics, providing a solid theoretical foundation and observational comparisons for the research.