2025-11-14T02:04:11.574398

Dynamic shadow of a black hole with a self-interacting massive complex scalar hair

Wang, Zhang, Chen et al.
We research dynamic shadows of a black hole with a self-interacting massive complex scalar hair. The complex scalar field $ψ$ evolves with time $t$, whose magnitude on apparent horizon $|ψ_{h}|$ starts from zero, undergoes a sharp rise followed by rapid oscillations, and eventually converges to a constant value. The variation of the photon sphere radius $r_{ps}$ is similar to that of the magnitude $|ψ_{h}|$. The emergence of the complex scalar hair $ψ$ causes the apparent horizon radius $r_{h}$ to start increasing sharply, and smoothly approaches a stable value eventually. The shadow radius $R_{sh}$ of the black hole with an accretion disk increases with $t_{o}$ the time at the observer's position. In the absence of an accretion disk, the shadow radius $R_{sh}$ is larger and also increases as $t_{o}$ increases. Furthermore, we slice the dynamical spacetime into spacelike hypersurfaces for all time points $t$. For the case with an accretion disk, the variation of $R_{sh}$ is similar to that of the apparent horizon $r_{h}$, because the inner edge of the accretion disk extends to the apparent horizon. In the absence of an accretion disk, the variation of $R_{sh}$ is similar to that of the photon sphere $r_{ps}$, because the black hole shadow boundary is determined by the photon sphere. Since the variation of $r_{ps}$ is induced by $ψ$, it can be stated that the variation in the size of the shadow is likewise caused by the change of $ψ$. Regardless of the presence or absence of the accretion disk, the emergence of the complex scalar hair $ψ$ causes the radius $R_{sh}$ of the shadow to start changing. Moreover, we investigate the time delay $Δt$ of lights propagating from light sources to observer. These findings not only enrich the theoretical models of dynamic black hole shadows but also provide a foundation for testing black hole spacetime dynamics.
academic

Dynamic shadow of a black hole with a self-interacting massive complex scalar hair

Basic Information

  • Paper ID: 2507.20569
  • Title: Dynamic shadow of a black hole with a self-interacting massive complex scalar hair
  • Authors: Mingzhi Wang, Cheng-Yong Zhang, Songbai Chen, Jiliang Jing
  • Classification: gr-qc (General Relativity and Quantum Cosmology)
  • Publication Date: October 16, 2025 (arXiv v2)
  • Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2507.20569

Abstract

This paper investigates the dynamic shadow of a black hole with a self-interacting massive complex scalar hair. The complex scalar field ψ evolves with time t, with its amplitude |ψh| on the event horizon starting from zero, undergoing rapid rise and fast oscillations, and finally converging to a constant value. The variation of the photon sphere radius rps is similar to that of the amplitude |ψh|. The emergence of complex scalar hair ψ causes the event horizon radius rh to begin increasing sharply, ultimately smoothly approaching a stable value. The black hole shadow radius Rsh with an accretion disk increases with the observer's time coordinate to. Without an accretion disk, the shadow radius Rsh is larger and also increases with to. The study reveals that the evolution of complex scalar hair directly affects the dynamic changes of the black hole shadow, providing a theoretical foundation for testing black hole spacetime dynamics.

Research Background and Motivation

Problem Background

  1. Observational Impetus: The Event Horizon Telescope (EHT) successfully captured images of the black holes M87* and Sgr A*, marking a milestone in black hole physics
  2. Theoretical Limitations: Existing black hole shadow research primarily focuses on static or stationary black holes, while actual astrophysical processes (such as stellar collapse, black hole perturbations, black hole mergers) produce dynamic spacetimes
  3. Observational Requirements: The EHT team is creating a "movie" of Sgr A* due to its rapidly changing appearance, requiring understanding of black hole dynamic structure

Research Significance

  • Dynamic black hole images are crucial for black hole and gravitational theory research
  • The next-generation Event Horizon Telescope (ngEHT) may capture dynamic black hole images
  • Provides unprecedented insights into understanding the temporal evolution of black hole spacetime

Limitations of Existing Methods

  • Most studies only consider static black hole shadows
  • Research on black hole images in dynamic spacetimes is extremely rare
  • Lack of systematic theoretical framework to describe the dynamic effects of scalar hair on black hole shadows

Core Contributions

  1. Established theoretical model for dynamic black hole shadows: First systematic study of dynamic shadows of black holes with self-interacting massive complex scalar hair
  2. Revealed correlation between scalar field and shadow evolution: Demonstrated that variations in the complex scalar field ψ directly lead to dynamic changes in the photon sphere radius and black hole shadow
  3. Distinguished different physical scenarios: Detailed analysis of different evolution patterns of black hole shadows with and without accretion disks
  4. Provided time delay analysis: Investigated time delay effects of light propagation in dynamic spacetime
  5. Offered theoretical predictions for observations: Provided theoretical foundation and predictions for future dynamic black hole image observations

Methodology Details

Task Definition

Study the shadow characteristics of dynamic black holes with self-interacting massive complex scalar hair at different moments, analyze the effects of scalar field evolution on shadow size and shape, and calculate time delays in light propagation.

Theoretical Framework

1. Dynamic Spacetime Description

Employ the Painlevé-Gullstrand (PG) coordinate system to describe dynamic black hole spacetime:

ds2=−[1−ζ(t,r)2]α(t,r)2dt2+2α(t,r)ζ(t,r)dtdr+dr2+r2(dθ2+sin⁡2θdϕ2)ds^2 = -[1-\zeta(t,r)^2]\alpha(t,r)^2dt^2 + 2\alpha(t,r)\zeta(t,r)dtdr + dr^2 + r^2(d\theta^2 + \sin^2\theta d\phi^2)

where α and ζ are metric functions dependent on time t and radial coordinate r.

2. Lagrangian Density

The system's Lagrangian density is: L=R−FμνFμν−Dμψ(Dμψ)∗−V(ψ)L = R - F_{\mu\nu}F^{\mu\nu} - D_\mu\psi(D^\mu\psi)^* - V(\psi)

where the potential function is: V(ψ)=μ2∣ψ∣2−λ∣ψ∣4+ν∣ψ∣6V(\psi) = \mu^2|\psi|^2 - \lambda|\psi|^4 + \nu|\psi|^6

3. Photon Sphere Condition

The photon sphere satisfies the conditions: r˙=0andr¨=0\dot{r} = 0 \quad \text{and} \quad \ddot{r} = 0

The photon sphere radius rps is determined by solving: gtrgtt,t+2gtr,t−gtt,r+1rgtt=0g_{tr}g_{tt,t} + 2g_{tr,t} - g_{tt,r} + \frac{1}{r}g_{tt} = 0

Numerical Methods

1. Backward Ray Tracing

Employ backward ray tracing to compute the black hole shadow, evolving light rays backward from the observer's position to the vicinity of the black hole.

2. Geodesic Equations

Solve the null geodesic equations (23-26):

  • Time coordinate evolution equation
  • Radial coordinate evolution equation
  • Angular coordinate evolution equation
  • Angular momentum conservation

3. Spacetime Slicing Analysis

Slice the dynamic spacetime into spacelike hypersurfaces and study black hole shadow characteristics on each hypersurface with fixed time coordinate t.

Experimental Setup

Parameter Configuration

  • Potential function: V(ψ)=∣ψ∣2(1−∣ψ∣20.12)2V(\psi) = |\psi|^2(1-\frac{|\psi|^2}{0.12})^2
  • Total mass: M = 1.09239
  • Total charge: Q = 0.9
  • Gauge coupling constant: q = 3
  • Observer distance: ro = 50
  • Geometric units: G = c = M = 1

Accretion Disk Model

Consider an optically and geometrically thin accretion disk facing the observer. The emission intensity ratio is:

I_0\frac{\frac{\pi}{2}-\tan^{-1}(r-5)}{\frac{\pi}{2}-\tan^{-1}[r_h(t)-5]} & r > r_h \\ 0 & r \leq r_h \end{cases}$$ ### Observed Intensity Calculation The intensity ratio received by the observer is: $$I_{obs} = \sum_m g^4 I_{em}|_{r=r_m}$$ where g is the redshift factor and rm is the radial coordinate of the m-th intersection with the accretion disk plane. ## Experimental Results ### Scalar Field Evolution Characteristics 1. **Scalar field amplitude on event horizon**: |ψh| starts from 0, undergoes rapid rise and fast oscillations, finally converging to a stable value (~0.12) 2. **Photon sphere radius variation**: The variation pattern of rps is highly similar to |ψh|, increasing from approximately 2.6 to approximately 3.0 3. **Event horizon radius evolution**: rh smoothly increases from approximately 1.5 to approximately 2.2 ### Shadow Dynamic Characteristics #### With Accretion Disk - Shadow radius Rsh ≈ 2.15, slowly increasing with observer time coordinate to - Shadow boundary determined by the inner edge of the accretion disk, extending to the event horizon - The variation pattern of Rsh is similar to that of event horizon radius rh #### Without Accretion Disk - Shadow radius Rsh ≈ 3.95, significantly larger than with accretion disk - Shadow boundary determined by the photon sphere - The variation pattern of Rsh is similar to that of photon sphere radius rps, including oscillatory behavior ### Ray Classification and Time Delay #### Ray Types Classified according to orbital number n = φ/2π: - Black hole shadow: n < 1/4 - Direct emission: 1/4 ≤ n < 3/4 - Lensing ring: 3/4 ≤ n < 5/4 - Photon ring: n ≥ 5/4 #### Time Delay Characteristics 1. **With accretion disk**: - Photon ring has maximum delay, lensing ring secondary, direct emission minimal - Direct emission delay decreases with L and R - Lensing ring and photon ring delays first decrease then increase 2. **Without accretion disk**: - Delay tends to infinity for small L (rays spiral close to photon sphere) - Delay decreases with increasing L or R ## Related Work ### Progress in Black Hole Shadow Research - **Static shadow studies**: Extensive work focused on constraining black hole parameters, studying dark matter, and testing gravitational theories - **Dynamic shadow pioneers**: Authors previously studied dynamic shadows of Schwarzschild black holes perturbed by gravitational waves - **Boson star collapse**: Y.P. Zhang et al. studied dynamic emergence of black hole shadows in collapsing boson star spacetime ### Scalar Hair Black Holes - Nonlinear self-interactions can induce black hole bomb phenomena beyond the famous superradiance instability - Render spacetime dynamic, causing black hole shadows to vary with time ## Conclusions and Discussion ### Main Conclusions 1. **Scalar field dominates shadow evolution**: The emergence and evolution of complex scalar hair ψ directly causes dynamic changes in the black hole shadow 2. **Different boundary mechanisms**: With and without accretion disk, shadow boundaries are determined by the event horizon and photon sphere respectively, leading to different evolution patterns 3. **Observable distinguishability**: Dynamic characteristics provide new observational means to distinguish different black hole models 4. **Time delay effects**: Provide additional observational information, helping understand dynamic spacetime structure ### Limitations 1. **Model-specific dependence**: Results based on specific scalar field potential function and parameter choices 2. **Numerical computation range**: Limited by computational resources, time evolution range is restricted 3. **Observational challenges**: Actual observation of dynamic black hole shadows still faces technical challenges 4. **Simplified assumptions**: Adopted thin disk approximation and specific emission model ### Future Directions 1. **Observational verification**: Verification with next-generation observation facilities such as ngEHT 2. **Model extension**: Consider more complex scalar field models and spacetime geometries 3. **Multi-messenger astrophysics**: Study dynamic black holes combining gravitational wave observations 4. **Numerical relativity**: Develop more accurate numerical simulation methods ## In-Depth Evaluation ### Strengths 1. **Theoretical Innovation**: First systematic study of dynamic shadows of scalar hair black holes, filling theoretical gaps 2. **Methodological Completeness**: Provides complete research framework from theoretical modeling to numerical computation 3. **Deep Physical Insights**: Reveals profound connections between scalar field and shadow evolution 4. **Observational Relevance**: Provides concrete theoretical predictions for future observations 5. **Refined Technical Treatment**: Detailed analysis of different ray types and time delay effects ### Weaknesses 1. **Insufficient Parameter Sensitivity Analysis**: Insufficient exploration of how different parameter choices affect results 2. **Lack of Comparison with Observational Data**: No comparative analysis with existing EHT observational results 3. **Limited Error Analysis**: Insufficient detail in error estimation and convergence analysis of numerical computations 4. **Physical Mechanism Explanation**: Could provide deeper explanation of how scalar field specifically affects spacetime geometry ### Impact 1. **Academic Value**: Establishes foundation for dynamic black hole shadow theory with important academic significance 2. **Observational Guidance**: Provides theoretical guidance and predictions for future dynamic black hole observations 3. **Cross-disciplinary Impact**: Connects black hole physics, scalar field theory, and observational astrophysics 4. **Technical Advancement**: Promotes development of ray tracing techniques in dynamic spacetime ### Applicable Scenarios 1. **Theoretical Physics Research**: Scalar field black hole theory, dynamic spacetime geometry research 2. **Observational Astrophysics**: Theoretical support for EHT and subsequent observation projects 3. **Numerical Relativity**: Benchmark testing for dynamic black hole numerical simulations 4. **Gravitational Theory Testing**: Verification of modified gravitational theories through black hole shadows ## References This paper cites 61 important references, covering classical and cutting-edge work in multiple fields including black hole shadow theory, observational astrophysics, and numerical relativity, particularly the groundbreaking observational results from the EHT collaboration and related theoretical developments.