Quantum Simulation of Nuclear Dynamics in First Quantization
Spagnoli, Lissoni, Roggero
The study of real time dynamics of nuclear systems is of great importance to provide theoretical predictions of cross sections relevant for both terrestrial experiments as well as applications in astrophysics. First principles simulations of these dynamical processes is however hindered by an exponential cost in classical resources and the possibility of performing scalable simulations using quantum computers is currently an active field of research. In this work we provide the first complete characterization of the resource requirements for studying nuclear dynamics with the full Leading Order (LO) pionless EFT Hamiltonian in first quantization employing simulation strategies using both product formulas as well as Quantum Signal Processing. In particular, we show that time evolution of such an Hamiltonian can be performed with polynomial resources in the number of particles, and logarithmic resources in the number of single-particle basis states. This result provides an exponential improvement compared with previous work on the same Hamiltonian model in second quantization. We find that interesting simulations for low energy nuclear scattering could be achievable with tens of millions of T gates and few hundred logical qubits suggesting that the study of simple nuclear reactions could be amenable for early fault tolerant quantum platforms.
academic
Quantum Simulation of Nuclear Dynamics in First Quantization
Real-time dynamics of nuclear systems are crucial for predicting scattering cross sections in ground-based experiments and astrophysical applications. However, first-principles simulation of these dynamical processes is limited by the exponential cost of classical computational resources. This paper provides the first complete characterization of resource requirements for studying nuclear dynamics using first quantization with a complete leading-order (LO) pionless effective field theory (EFT) Hamiltonian, employing both product formulas and quantum signal processing (QSP) strategies. The study demonstrates that time evolution of such Hamiltonians can be achieved with polynomial resources in particle number and logarithmic resources in the number of single-particle basis states, representing an exponential improvement compared to second quantization methods. Interesting simulations of low-energy nuclear scattering may require only tens of millions of T gates and several hundred logical qubits, suggesting that simple nuclear reaction studies may be feasible on early fault-tolerant quantum platforms.
Scientific Significance: Nuclear dynamics simulation is crucial for understanding stellar nucleosynthesis, neutrino property experiments, neutrinoless double-beta decay, and other fundamental physics questions
Computational Challenge: Although ab initio methods for nuclear structure have made significant progress, a general, controllable, and scalable simulation strategy for complete nuclear reaction dynamics remains lacking
Quantum Advantage Potential: Quantum computing promises to provide near-term significant impact in simulating dynamical processes
Exploiting Sparsity: In nuclear reaction simulation, particle number η is fixed and much smaller than the number of single-particle states Ω; first quantization can exploit this property
Reducing Resource Requirements: Expecting to achieve qubit count O(η log Ω) and logarithmic gate cost dependence
Early Application Feasibility: Providing practical nuclear physics applications for the forthcoming fault-tolerant quantum computers
First Complete Resource Characterization: Provides complete quantum simulation resource estimates for the full LO pionless EFT Hamiltonian (including three-body interactions) in first quantization
Exponential Improvement: Achieves exponential improvement over second quantization methods in volume Ω:
Qubit count: O(Ω) → O(η log Ω)
T gate count (second-order Trotter): O(Ω) → Õ(η^{3/2} log Ω)
Multiple Algorithm Implementations: Provides detailed implementation and resource analysis for three classes of algorithms:
Innovative Block Encoding Scheme: Designs new block encoding methods for contact interactions, achieving O(η) gate cost by exploiting fermionic statistics
Fermionic Half-Norm Generalization: Generalizes the fermionic half-norm concept from second quantization to first quantization for precise Trotter error bound estimation
Practical Parameter Assessment: Uses realistic nuclear physics parameters for resource estimation, showing that 16-nucleon simulation can be completed with approximately 10^7 T gates and ~200 logical qubits
Kinetic Energy Operator (diagonal in momentum space):
T=K(QFT⊗dη)†∑i=0η−1∑w=0d−1∑p=02m−1qw2Πw,i(p)(QFT⊗dη)
where K = ℏ²/(2μa²)(2π/2^m)², and q_w is the momentum component accounting for periodic boundary conditions.
Potential Energy Operators (diagonal in position space):
V2=2C∑i,j=i∑ri,rjδri,rjΠi(ri)Πj(rj)V3=6G∑i,j=i,k=i,j∑ri,rj,rkδri,rjδri,rkΠi(ri)Πj(rj)Πk(rk)
39 Roggero et al., PRD 101, 074038 (2020) - First pionless EFT quantum simulation
40 Watson et al., arXiv:2312.05344 - Second quantization improvement
51 Su et al., PRX Quantum 2, 040332 (2021) - Chemistry first quantization
56,57 Low & Chuang, PRL 118, 010501; Quantum 3, 163 - QSP theory
62 Su et al., Quantum 5, 495 (2021) - Fermionic half-norm
63 Childs et al., PRX 11, 011020 (2021) - Trotter error theory
67 Berry et al., PRA 110, 012612 (2024) - GQSP efficiency doubling
Overall Assessment: This is a high-quality theoretical quantum algorithm paper making important contributions to nuclear physics quantum simulation. Through rigorous theoretical analysis and detailed resource estimation, it first demonstrates the feasibility of simple nuclear reaction quantum simulation on early fault-tolerant quantum computers. The methods are innovative, the analysis comprehensive, and the work significantly advances the field. Main limitations are lack of experimental verification and incomplete end-to-end cost analysis, which can be addressed in follow-up work. Recommended for publication in high-impact quantum computing or nuclear physics journals.