Perturbations of Black Holes in Einstein-Maxwell-Dilaton-Axion (EMDA) Theories

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2508.04589
• Title: Perturbations of Black Holes in Einstein-Maxwell-Dilaton-Axion (EMDA) Theories
• Authors: C.N. Pope, D.O. Rohrer, B.F. Whiting
• Classification: hep-th (High Energy Physics - Theory), gr-qc (General Relativity and Quantum Cosmology)
• Publication Date: October 10, 2025 (arXiv v2)
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2508.04589

Abstract

This paper extends the authors' previous work on linearized perturbations of static black holes in Einstein-Maxwell-Dilaton (EMD) theory to a broader theoretical framework that includes an axion field. Perturbations in a three-parameter family of EMDA theories are investigated. The equations describing linearized perturbations are always separable, but can only be decoupled when the three parameters are restricted to a one-parameter EMDA theory family, characterized by parameter $b$, which determines the coupling of the axion to the $\epsilon^{\mu\nu\rho\sigma} F_{\mu\nu} F_{\rho\sigma}$ term. In the special case $b=1$, the theory is related to $\mathcal{N}=2$ supergravity. In this case, perturbations in the axial and polar sectors are related through a remarkable transformation, which generalizes the transformation discovered by Chandrasekhar for Reissner-Nordström perturbations in Einstein-Maxwell theory. This transformation has the form of a model in supersymmetric quantum mechanics. The existence of this mapping between axial and polar perturbations appears to be related to the presence of an underlying supergravity supporting the solution, although the black hole background is non-extremal and therefore not supersymmetric.

Research Background and Motivation

Problem Background

The study of linearized perturbations of black holes has a long history, tracing back to Regge and Wheeler's work on Schwarzschild solutions in the 1950s. Subsequent work extended this to black holes with charge and/or angular momentum. An important application of these perturbation analyses is the study of stability problems, where mode stability is the first step.

Research Motivation

1. Need for Theoretical Extension: Supergravity theories typically involve scalar fields beyond the metric and Maxwell field, making linearized perturbation analysis considerably more complex than in pure Einstein or Einstein-Maxwell gravity.
2. Supersymmetric Associations: In the Schwarzschild and Reissner-Nordström cases, Chandrasekhar discovered supersymmetric quantum mechanical relationships between axial and polar modes, and these theories themselves can be extended to supergravity.
3. Stability Analysis: There is a need to determine mode stability of static black hole solutions in EMDA theory, particularly as the axion coupling parameter varies.

Limitations of Existing Approaches

In the previous EMD case, axial perturbations were governed by two decoupled second-order equations, while polar perturbations were governed by three decoupled second-order equations, making it impossible to establish a one-to-one mapping between the two sectors.

Core Contributions

1. Theoretical Framework Extension: Extended EMD theory to include the axion field in EMDA theory, investigating linearized perturbations in a three-parameter theory family.
2. Decoupling Condition Determination: Proved that perturbation equations can only be completely decoupled when parameters are restricted to $a=1, c=-2$, forming a one-parameter theory family.
3. Supersymmetric Association Discovery: In the case $b^2=1$, established a remarkable mapping relationship between axial and polar sectors, generalizing Chandrasekhar's result.
4. Stability Proof: Proved mode stability of static black hole solutions in supersymmetric EMDA theory ($b^2=1$).
5. Instability Threshold: Determined conditions for possible perturbation mode instability when $b$ is sufficiently large, providing a specific threshold $b > \sqrt{365/112} \approx 1.80525$.

Detailed Methodology

Theoretical Framework

The EMDA theory under investigation is described by the Lagrangian: $L = \sqrt{-g}\left[R - \frac{1}{2}(\partial\phi)^2 - e^{a\phi}F^2 - \frac{1}{2}e^{c\phi}(\partial\chi)^2 + b\chi \tilde{F}^{\mu\nu}F_{\mu\nu}\right]$

where $\tilde{F}_{\mu\nu} = \frac{1}{2}\epsilon^{\mu\nu\rho\sigma}F_{\rho\sigma}$ is the Hodge dual of the Maxwell tensor.

Background Solution

The Gibbons-Maeda static charged black hole is used as the background solution: $ds^2 = -\Delta dt^2 + \frac{dr^2}{\Delta} + R^2(d\theta^2 + \sin^2\theta d\phi^2)$

where the axion field vanishes in the background: $\chi = 0$.

Perturbation Analysis Method

1. Perturbation Classification

Perturbations are divided into two disjoint sets:

• Axial: $(δB_0, δB_1, δB_2, δF_{03}, δF_{13}, δF_{23}, δχ)$
• Polar: $(δν, δμ_1, δμ_2, δψ, δF_{01}, δF_{02}, δF_{12}, δφ)$

2. Variable Separation

The method of separation of variables is employed with time dependence $e^{-iωt}$ and angular dependence given by spherical harmonics $P_ℓ(\cos\theta)$.

3. Equation System

Through Einstein equations, Maxwell equations, axion equations, and Bianchi identities, a coupled system of six first-order radial equations is obtained.

Decoupling Conditions

Key Finding

Complete diagonalization of the system is only possible when parameters satisfy $a=1, c=-2$. This corresponds to the case where the Lagrangian possesses a global $R$ symmetry.

Diagonalization Process

Eigenfunctions of the form $Z^- = f_1 G_{12} + f_2 B_{03} + f_3 χ$ are sought, where $f_i(r)$ are functions to be determined. By requiring coefficient vanishing, three decoupled second-order wave equations are obtained: $(\partial_{r_*}^2 + ω^2)Z^-_{(p)} - V^-_{(p)} Z^-_{(p)} = 0$

where $p$ is a root of the cubic equation: $p^3 r_- + p^2[2n(1+b^2)r_- - 2(1-b^2)r_- - 6r_+] - 4np(r_- + 7r_+) - 32n^2 r_+ = 0$

Supersymmetric Case Analysis

Special Properties of $b^2=1$

When $b^2=1$, the axial and polar potentials are related through a superpotential: $V^± = ±∂_{r_*}f + f^2 + 2βf$

where $f$ and $β$ are specific functions, which is precisely the characteristic form of a supersymmetric quantum mechanics model.

Relationship with $\mathcal{N}=2$ Supergravity

The EMDA theory with $a=1, c=-2, b=±1$ is the bosonic sector of a consistent truncation of STU supergravity. The complete $\mathcal{N}=2$ supergravity Lagrangian is: $L = \sqrt{-g}\left[R - \frac{1}{2}(\partial\phi)^2 - e^\phi F^2 - \frac{1}{2}e^{-2\phi}(\partial\chi)^2 + \chi \tilde{F}^{\mu\nu}F_{\mu\nu} - \frac{e^{-2\phi}}{1+\chi^2 e^{2\phi}}(e^\phi H^2 + \chi \tilde{H}^{\mu\nu}H_{\mu\nu})\right]$

Experimental Results

Stability Analysis

Positivity Proof

For the $b^2=1$ case, by parametrizing as $ℓ = 2+y, r = r_+(1+z)$, where $y≥0, z≥0$, it is proved that all axial potentials $V^-_i$ are non-negative outside the event horizon.

Algebraically Special Solutions

Special solutions with frequency $ω = ±iβ$ are found: $Z^+_{(p)} = e^{β_{(p)}r_*}\left(1-\frac{r_-}{r}\right)^{1/2}\left(4n + \frac{pr_-}{r}\right)^{-1}$$Z^-_{(p)} = e^{-β_{(p)}r_*}\left(1-\frac{r_-}{r}\right)^{-1/2}\left(4n + \frac{pr_-}{r}\right)$

Instability Threshold

For general values of $b^2$, it is found that when $b^2$ exceeds a certain threshold, the axial potential corresponding to the positive root may become negative outside the event horizon.

Threshold Calculation

The minimum threshold occurs at the $ℓ=2$ mode: $b > \sqrt{\frac{365}{112}} ≈ 1.80525$

When $b$ exceeds this value, perturbation mode instability may occur.

Related Work

Historical Development

1. Regge-Wheeler (1950s): Pioneering work on Schwarzschild perturbations
2. Chandrasekhar-Xanthopoulos (1970s-1980s): Reissner-Nordström perturbation analysis
3. Teukolsky Method: Unified description in the Newman-Penrose tetrad framework

Relationship to This Work

This paper extends the authors' previous work on EMD theory by adding the axion field and discovering deeper connections with supergravity theory.

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Complete Analysis: Successfully solved the linearized perturbation problem in EMDA theory completely, including separation, decoupling, and diagonalization.
2. Supersymmetric Association: In the $b^2=1$ case, axial and polar perturbations are related through a supersymmetric quantum mechanics transformation, consistent with the underlying $\mathcal{N}=2$ supergravity structure.
3. Stability Results: Proved mode stability in the supersymmetric case and determined the parameter range where instability may occur.

Physical Significance

The appearance of supersymmetric quantum mechanics relationships in connection with the fact that the underlying theory is supergravity provides new insights into understanding the deep structure of black hole perturbations.

Limitations

1. Parameter Restrictions: Complete decoupling is only possible at specific parameter values
2. Non-extremal Background: Although the theory is supersymmetric, the black hole background itself is not supersymmetric
3. Linearization Approximation: Analysis is limited to the linearized perturbation level

Future Directions

1. Numerical Analysis: Detailed numerical study of possible instabilities for large $b$
2. Nonlinear Extension: Investigation of nonlinear perturbation effects
3. Rotating Case: Extension to rotating black holes

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Theoretical Completeness: Provides a complete mathematical framework for black hole perturbations in EMDA theory
2. Deep Insights: Discovers profound connections between perturbation structure and supergravity theory
3. Rigorous Proofs: Provides rigorous mathematical proofs for stability and instability conditions
4. Clear Exposition: Complex calculations are presented clearly, facilitating understanding and verification

Weaknesses

1. Computational Complexity: Involves extensive complex algebraic calculations with potential risk of computational errors
2. Physical Interpretation: The physical mechanism for why specific parameter values lead to decoupling is not sufficiently explained
3. Practical Applications: The astrophysical applicability of theoretical results is unclear

Impact

1. Theoretical Contribution: Provides important theoretical tools for black hole physics in supergravity
2. Methodological Innovation: The perturbation analysis method may be applicable to other complex gravitational theories
3. Interdisciplinary Connections: Establishes bridges between gravitational theory and supersymmetric quantum mechanics

Applicable Scenarios

The method is suitable for application to:

1. Black hole stability analysis in supergravity theories
2. Black hole research in effective field theories from string theory
3. Perturbation analysis in higher-dimensional gravitational theories

References

The paper cites 42 important references, including:

• Regge & Wheeler's pioneering work
• Chandrasekhar's classical black hole perturbation theory
• Modern supergravity and string theory literature
• The authors' previous work on EMD theory

Technical Note: This paper represents high-level research in theoretical physics, involving complex mathematical derivations and profound physical insights. The calculations are rigorous, and the results have significant theoretical importance, providing new perspectives for understanding the relationship between black hole physics and supergravity theory.