Iteration Sums of The Euler Totient Function Regarding Powers of Fermat Primes

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2508.05698
• Title: Iteration Sums of The Euler Totient Function Regarding Powers of Fermat Primes
• Authors: Xiang Li, Allison Pacelli (Pioneer Research Number Theory)
• Classification: math.GM (General Mathematics)
• Publication Date: October 9, 2025
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2508.05698

Abstract

The Euler totient function, as a cornerstone of number theory, has been extensively studied and applied across numerous disciplines. This paper explores the patterns exhibited by iterations of the totient function. The paper first covers fundamental definitions and established theorems, then investigates cases involving multiple applications of the totient function, such as φ(φ(φ(n))). It presents theorems concerning the terminal behavior of such iterations. Subsequently, the paper applies innovative summation methods to iterative applications of the totient function, in the form φ(n)+φ(φ(n))+φ(φ(φ(n)))+···, also expressible as ∑φⁱ(n). The paper proves new theorems regarding this summation for all powers of Fermat primes and derives elegant results concerning powers of 3. This work pioneers the study of summations of iterated totient function values.

Research Background and Motivation

Problem Definition

The core problem this research addresses is: What mathematical properties and patterns do the sums of these iterated values exhibit when the Euler totient function is repeatedly applied to positive integers n?

Importance Analysis

1. Theoretical Value: The totient function is fundamental in number theory; studying its iterative properties helps deepen understanding of number-theoretic structures
2. Applied Value: The totient function has important applications in cryptography (such as the RSA algorithm) and the Chinese Remainder Theorem
3. Mathematical Elegance: Iterative summation reveals elegant patterns in mathematics, particularly the special properties of Fermat primes

Limitations of Existing Research

• Early research (such as Pillai's 1929 work) primarily focused on the number of steps required for iteration to reach 1
• Research by Erdős and others (1990) concentrated on the terminal behavior of iterations
• Lacks systematic research on summations of iterated values

Research Motivation

The innovation of this paper lies in proposing a new perspective on iterative summation: not only studying the behavior of φ(φ(···φ(n)···)), but also investigating the sum properties of φ(n)+φ(φ(n))+φ(φ(φ(n)))+···.

Core Contributions

1. Established convergence theory for totient function iterations: Proved that any positive integer converges to 1 after finitely many totient function iterations
2. Discovered that iterations must pass through 2: Proved that for any positive integer greater than 2, its totient iteration sequence must equal 2 at some step
3. Proposed iteration summation formulas for powers of Fermat primes: Provided closed-form expressions for the iterative totient summation of k-th powers of all Fermat primes p
4. Derived elegant results for powers of 3: Proved that φ(3ᵏ)+φ(φ(3ᵏ))+···+φ(2)=3ᵏ
5. Pioneered a new research direction: First systematically studied the summation problem for iterated totient function values

Methodology in Detail

Theoretical Foundation Construction

Core Definitions

Definition 1 (Coprimality): For positive integers a and b, if gcd(a,b)=1, then a and b are said to be coprime.

Definition 2 (Totient Function): For n≥1, φ(n) denotes the count of positive integers less than or equal to n that are coprime to n.

Definition 3 (Multiplicative Function): If for all coprime positive integer pairs (a,b), f(ab)=f(a)f(b) holds, then f is called a multiplicative function.

Key Lemmas and Theorems

Lemma 1 (Linear Congruence): For the congruence equation ax≡b(mod m), if gcd(a,m)=g and g|b, then there are exactly g solutions.

Theorem 1 (Chinese Remainder Theorem): For coprime integers m₁,m₂, the system of congruences

x ≡ a (mod m₁)
x ≡ b (mod m₂)

has a unique solution x(mod m₁m₂).

Theorem 2 (Multiplicativity of the Totient Function): If gcd(m,n)=1, then φ(mn)=φ(m)φ(n).

Theorem 3 (Totient Function Computation Formula): $φ(n) = n\prod_{i=1}^{k}\left(1-\frac{1}{p_i}\right)$ where n=p₁^{a₁}p₂^{a₂}···pₖ^{aₖ} is the prime factorization of n.

Iterative Properties Analysis

Convergence Theorem

Theorem 4 (Iteration Convergence): For any positive integer n, there exists m such that φᵐ(n)=1.

Proof Outline:

• The domain and codomain of the totient function are both positive integers, ensuring iteration is feasible
• By Corollary 3.2, φ(n)1
• Each iteration reduces the value by at least 1, so after n-1 iterations, the value must reach 1

Property of Passing Through 2

Lemma 2 (Parity): Except for φ(1)=φ(2)=1, for all n>2, φ(n) is even.

Theorem 5 (Iterations Must Pass Through 2): For any n>2, there exists a finite positive integer m<n-1 such that φᵐ(n)=2.

Fermat Prime Theory

Fermat Numbers and Fermat Primes

Definition 4 (Fermat Numbers): Numbers of the form Fₙ=2^{2ⁿ}+1 are called Fermat numbers.

Theorem 6 (Characterization of Fermat Primes): If a prime p=2ᵏ+1, then k must contain only 2 as a prime factor, i.e., k=2ⁿ.

This theorem illustrates the important property that primes of the form 2ᵏ+1 must be Fermat primes.

Main Results

Iterative Summation for Fermat Primes

Lemma 3: For a Fermat prime p=2ᵏ+1, $φ(p)+φ(φ(p))+···+φ(2) = 2p-3$

General Formula for Powers of Fermat Primes

Theorem 7 (Main Result): Let p be a Fermat prime. For all pᵏ (k∈Z⁺), $φ(p^k)+φ(φ(p^k))+φ(φ(φ(p^k)))+···+φ(2) = \frac{2}{p+1}\left[p^k(p-1)+2\left(\frac{p-1}{2}\right)^k\right]-1$

Special Case for Powers of 3

Corollary 7.1: For all n=3ᵏ (k∈Z⁺), $φ(3^k)+φ(φ(3^k))+φ(φ(φ(3^k)))+···+φ(2) = 3^k$

Proof Methods Analysis

Application of Mathematical Induction

The paper extensively employs mathematical induction to prove general results:

1. Base Case: Verify that the formula holds for k=1
2. Inductive Hypothesis: Assume the formula holds for k=a
3. Inductive Step: Prove that the formula also holds for k=a+1

Clever Use of Multiplicative Properties

The key technique is exploiting the multiplicativity of the totient function:

• When gcd(m,n)=1, φ(mn)=φ(m)φ(n)
• Corollary 3.1: If a contains all prime factors of b, then φ(ab)=φ(a)b

Geometric Series Summation Technique

The paper employs a "snowball" method to compute geometric series: $2^{k-1}+2^{k-2}+···+2+1 = 2^k-1$

Experimental Verification

Numerical Verification Examples

The paper verifies theoretical results through concrete calculations:

Example 1 (Iteration of n=5):

• φ(5)=4
• φ(φ(5))=φ(4)=2
• φ(φ(φ(5)))=φ(2)=1

Example 2 (Iterative Summation of n=27):

• φ(27)=18
• φ(φ(27))=φ(18)=6
• φ(φ(φ(27)))=φ(6)=2
• Sum: 1+2+6+18=27, verifying the formula for 3ᵏ

Theoretical Verification

Correctness is verified by applying the general formula to special cases:

• For Fermat prime p=3: 2·3-3=3, consistent with the formula for powers of 3
• Formula consistency is verified through substitution checks

Related Work

Historical Development Timeline

1. Euler (1763): First defined the totient function
2. Gauss (1801): Introduced the notation φ(n) and established φ(1)=1
3. Sylvester (1879): Proposed the term "totient"
4. Pillai (1929): Began studying totient function iterations
5. Erdős et al. (1990): Studied the normal behavior of iterations

Comparison with Existing Research

Termination Studies:

• Erdős et al. proved k(2ʲ)=j=log n/log 2
• Shapiro defined C(n)=x such that φˣ(n)=2
• Established ⌈log n/log 3⌉≤k(n)≤⌈log n/log 2⌉

Summation Studies:

• Dickson et al. studied asymptotic properties of ∑φ(k)
• This paper first systematically studies summations of iterated totient values

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Complete Iteration Theory: Established a complete theoretical framework for totient function iterations
2. Special Status of Fermat Primes: Revealed the unique position of Fermat primes in iterative summation
3. Elegant Mathematical Relationships: Discovered perfect summation properties for 3ᵏ
4. New Research Direction: Pioneered the field of iterative summation research

Limitation Analysis

1. Restricted Scope of Applicability: Main results concentrate on Fermat primes; cases for other primes remain incompletely resolved
2. Computational Complexity: Iterative computation for large numbers remains complex
3. Open Problems: The finiteness problem of Fermat primes affects the completeness of the theory

Future Research Directions

1. Extension to General Primes: Investigate iterative summation properties for non-Fermat primes
2. Composite Number Cases: Explore iterative summation formulas for general composite numbers
3. Asymptotic Analysis: Study asymptotic behavior in cases of large numbers
4. Algorithm Optimization: Develop efficient algorithms for iterative summation computation

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Significant Theoretical Contribution: First systematic study of iterative totient summation, filling a research gap
2. Methodological Innovation: Cleverly combines classical number-theoretic methods (induction, multiplicativity, etc.) to solve new problems
3. Elegant Results: Particularly the perfect summation formula for 3ᵏ, exemplifying mathematical beauty
4. Rigorous Proofs: All theorems have complete mathematical proofs with clear logic
5. Complete Historical Perspective: Well-organized treatment of the historical development of related research

Weaknesses

1. Limited Applied Value: Primarily pure mathematical theory with limited practical applications
2. Narrow Coverage of Results: Main results are confined to Fermat primes; general cases remain unresolved
3. No Discussion of Computational Efficiency: Does not address computational complexity for large numbers
4. Dependence on Open Problems: Completeness of results depends on unresolved problems related to Fermat primes

Impact Assessment

1. Academic Value: Provides new perspectives and tools for number theory research
2. Inspirational Significance: May inspire research on iterations of other arithmetic functions
3. Educational Value: Excellent number theory teaching material, demonstrating multiple proof techniques
4. Reproducibility: All results can be verified through mathematical computation

Applicable Scenarios

1. Pure Mathematics Research: Number theory and arithmetic function theory research
2. Mathematics Education: Teaching cases for advanced number theory courses
3. Algorithm Research: May provide theoretical foundations for certain number-theoretic algorithms
4. Cryptography Theory: Applications of the totient function in cryptography may benefit

Technical Details Supplement

Key Proof Techniques

1. Application of the Chinese Remainder Theorem: Cleverly uses CRT to establish bijective relationships proving multiplicativity
2. Hierarchical Use of Induction: Sophisticated design at different levels (base cases, inductive steps)
3. Closed Forms of Geometric Series: Obtains elegant closed expressions through the "snowball" method

Comprehensive Use of Mathematical Tools

The paper successfully integrates:

• Elementary number theory (primes, coprimality, congruences)
• Arithmetic function theory (multiplicative functions)
• Combinatorics (counting principles)
• Algebraic techniques (induction, geometric series)

This integration exemplifies the characteristics and appeal of number theory research.

Overall Evaluation: This is a high-quality pure mathematics theory paper that makes pioneering contributions to the new field of iterative totient summation. While its practical applied value is limited, its theoretical value and mathematical elegance make it a valuable contribution to number theory research. The paper's rigor and innovation are commendable and establish a solid foundation for subsequent research.