Existence of Anisotropic Minkowski Content

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2508.08156
• Title: Existence of Anisotropic Minkowski Content
• Author: Filip Fryš (Mathematical Institute of Charles University)
• Classification: math.CA (Classical Analysis and ODEs)
• Publication Date: October 10, 2025 (arXiv v3)
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2508.08156

Abstract

This paper is devoted to investigating the existence of anisotropic Minkowski content and anisotropic outer Minkowski content. The main results demonstrate that the Minkowski content of the topological boundary of a finite perimeter set E equals the perimeter of E if and only if the anisotropic Minkowski content of the topological boundary of E equals half the sum of the anisotropic perimeter of E and the anisotropic perimeter of its complement. As a corollary, we find that the existence of anisotropic outer Minkowski content for a finite perimeter set and its complement ensures the existence of outer Minkowski content for the set and its complement.

Research Background and Motivation

Core Issues

1. Limitations of Classical Minkowski Content: Traditional Minkowski content based on Euclidean balls has limitations when dealing with geometric objects possessing directional characteristics.
2. Necessity of Anisotropic Generalization: Many geometric objects in practical applications exhibit direction-dependent properties, requiring the replacement of the unit ball with more general convex bodies to define Minkowski content.
3. Characterization of Existence Conditions: There is a need to establish necessary and sufficient conditions for the existence of anisotropic Minkowski content.

Research Significance

• In geometric measure theory, Minkowski content is an important tool for describing geometric properties of sets
• The anisotropic version better characterizes geometric structures with directional features
• Provides theoretical foundations for variational problems and free boundary problems

Deficiencies in Existing Research

• Work by CLL and others provides only one direction of implication, with flawed proofs for the reverse implication
• Lack of a unified theoretical framework for handling relationships between anisotropic Minkowski contents corresponding to different convex bodies

Core Contributions

1. Main Theorem: Establishes equivalence between the existence of classical Minkowski content and anisotropic Minkowski content (Theorem 4.1)
2. Technical Innovation: Provides complete proofs using the Besicovitch covering theorem and LV, Lemma 3.3
3. Theoretical Refinement: Corrects erroneous assertions regarding the reverse implication in CLL, Remark 3.5
4. Generalized Results: Proves that results extend to arbitrary sets F satisfying ∂*E ⊆ F ⊆ ∂E (Theorem 4.5)

Methodology Details

Core Definitions

Anisotropic Minkowski Content: For a convex body C ∈ C₀ⁿ, the C-anisotropic Minkowski content of a set S is defined as:

M_C(S; Ω) := lim_{ε→0⁺} (1/2ε)λₙ(((S ∩ Ω) ⊕ εC) ∩ Ω)

Anisotropic Outer Minkowski Content:

SM_C(E; Ω) := lim_{ε→0⁺} (1/ε)λₙ(((E ∩ Ω) ⊕ εC) ∩ (Ω \ E))

Anisotropic Perimeter:

Per_{h_C}(E; Ω) := ∫_{Ω∩∂*E} h_C(ν_E) dH^{n-1}

Main Technical Tools

1. Besicovitch Covering Theorem: Used for handling countable covering problems
2. Rectifiability in Geometric Measure Theory: Exploits the countable H^{n-1}-rectifiability of ∂*E
3. Properties of Support Functions: Utilizes Lipschitz continuity of support functions of convex bodies

Proof Strategy

The proof of Theorem 4.1 proceeds in two directions:

First Direction (straightforward): Utilizes lower bound estimates in Proposition 2.2

Second Direction (core):

1. Decomposes ∂*E ∩ Ω into a countable union of compact Lipschitz graphs
2. Applies Lemma 2.1 to each compact piece
3. Uses the Besicovitch covering theorem to control the contribution of remainder terms
4. Derives the desired inequality through the arbitrariness of ε

Theoretical Analysis

Key Lemmas

Lemma 2.1: If S is a compact set contained in a Lipschitz (n-1)-graph, then:

M_C(S; Ω) = (1/2)∫_S (h_C(ν_S) + h_C(-ν_S)) dH^{n-1}

Technical Difficulties

1. Remainder Control: Requires precise control of the contribution of ((∂E) \ ⋃ᵏₖ₌₁Sₖ) to the anisotropic Minkowski content
2. Covering Construction: Constructs effective ball coverings using the Besicovitch theorem
3. Uniform Estimates: Ensures that estimates hold for all sufficiently small ε

Main Results

Theorem 4.1 (Main Result)

Let E be a finite perimeter set in an open set Ω ⊆ Rⁿ, and C, C' ∈ C₀ⁿ. Then:

M_C(∂E; Ω) = (1/2)(Per_{h_C}(E; Ω) + Per_{h_C}(Ω \ E; Ω))

if and only if

M_{C'}(∂E; Ω) = (1/2)(Per_{h_{C'}}(E; Ω) + Per_{h_{C'}}(Ω \ E; Ω))

Corollary 4.3

For E ⊆ Ω with finite perimeter:

SM_C(E; Ω) = Per_{h_C}(E; Ω) and SM_C(Ω \ E; Ω) = Per_{h_C}(Ω \ E; Ω)

if and only if the corresponding C'-anisotropic versions also hold.

Proposition 4.6 (Refined Characterization)

Establishes bidirectional equivalence between anisotropic Minkowski content and anisotropic outer Minkowski content:

• Existence of M_C(∂*E; Ω) ⟺ Existence of SM_C(E¹; Ω) and SM_C(E⁰; Ω)

Technical Innovations

1. Improvements in Proof Methods

• Provides complete bidirectional proofs compared to CLL
• Corrects erroneous arguments in CLL, Remark 3.6

2. Unified Theoretical Framework

• Establishes equivalence relationships between anisotropic Minkowski contents corresponding to different convex bodies
• Proves that results are independent of the specific choice of convex body

3. Refined Technical Treatment

• Achieves precise control of remainder terms through the Besicovitch covering theorem
• Addresses rectifiability issues using deep results from geometric measure theory

Related Work

Classical Theory

• Federer Fe: Established Minkowski content theory for compact rectifiable sets
• Ambrosio-Fusco-Pallara AFP: Applications in BV function theory

Anisotropic Generalizations

• Lussardi-Villa LV: Provided fundamental results in the anisotropic case
• Chambolle-Lisini-Lussardi CLL: Studied anisotropic outer Minkowski content

Position of This Work

This paper refines theoretical deficiencies in CLL and provides a more complete theoretical picture.

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Equivalence Theorem: The existence of anisotropic Minkowski content is equivalent to the existence of classical Minkowski content
2. Independence Result: Existence conditions are independent of the specific choice of convex body
3. Complete Characterization: Provides necessary and sufficient conditions for the existence of anisotropic outer Minkowski content

Limitations

1. Existence of Counterexamples: There exist cases where anisotropic outer Minkowski content exists but does not exist for the complement
2. Technical Restrictions: Methods primarily apply to finite perimeter sets
3. Dimension Dependence: Constants in certain results depend on the space dimension

Future Directions

1. Generalization to more general measure spaces
2. Investigation of connections with variational problems
3. Exploration of applications in image processing and materials science

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Theoretical Completeness: Fills important theoretical gaps in the field
2. Technical Rigor: Proof methods are rigorous with refined technical treatment
3. Universality of Results: Establishes unified relationships between different convex bodies
4. Clarity of Presentation: Well-structured paper with accurate exposition

Weaknesses

1. Application Background: Lacks concrete application examples
2. Computational Aspects: Does not provide numerical computation methods
3. Generalizability: Conditions for certain generalizations are relatively restrictive

Impact

1. Theoretical Contribution: Provides important theoretical tools for geometric measure theory
2. Methodological Value: Proof techniques may be applicable to other related problems
3. Completeness: Perfects the theoretical system of anisotropic Minkowski content

Applicable Scenarios

• Regularization theory in variational problems
• Anisotropic diffusion in image processing
• Interface evolution problems in materials science
• Study of geometric flows

References

Main references include:

• AFP Ambrosio, Fusco, Pallara: Functions of bounded variation and free discontinuity problems
• CLL Chambolle, Lisini, Lussardi: A remark on the anisotropic outer Minkowski content
• LV Lussardi, Villa: A general formula for the anisotropic outer Minkowski content of a set
• Fe Federer: Geometric measure theory

This paper makes important theoretical contributions to the field of geometric measure theory, perfects the theory of anisotropic Minkowski content, and provides a solid mathematical foundation for related applications.