A Generalization of Diophantine Tuples

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2508.18550
• Title: A Generalization of Diophantine Tuples
• Author: Zijie Gu
• Classification: math.NT (Number Theory)
• Publication Date: October 12, 2025 (arXiv v4)
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2508.18550v4

Abstract

This paper investigates a generalized version of Diophantine tuples over finite fields. By applying the Shparlinski method, power-saving results for the count of such tuples are obtained.

Research Background and Motivation

Problem Background

1. Classical Diophantine Tuple Problem: Originating from Diophantus of Alexandria, this studies sets of numbers with specific properties, where the product of any two distinct elements plus one is a perfect square
2. Simplification over Finite Fields: Compared to the rational number field, the finite field Fq provides a simpler research environment for such problems
3. Complexity of Counting Problems: Although determining Nm(q) (the count of m-tuples in finite fields) appears straightforward, when m=4 it involves non-trivial modular forms

Research Motivation

1. Theoretical Significance: The existing asymptotic formula Nm(q) = qm/(m!2^(m choose 2)) + o(qm) can be improved
2. Methodological Innovation: Shparlinski (2023) improved the error term from O(qm-1/2) to O(qm-1), exceeding the expected results from the Lang-Weil estimate
3. Generalization Value: Extending classical Diophantine tuples to more general forms expands the theoretical framework

Core Contributions

1. Generalized the definition of Diophantine tuples: Introduced the concept of d-f-Diophantine m-tuples, where f is an admissible polynomial
2. Obtained precise asymptotic formulas: Provided exact estimates with error terms for the count of d-f-Diophantine m-tuples
3. Improved error terms: Through the Shparlinski method, the error term is improved by a factor of q^(1/2) compared to direct application of the Weil estimate
4. Provided a complete theoretical framework: Established transformation methods from Diophantine tuples to character sums

Methodology Details

Task Definition

Definition 1.3 (Admissible Polynomial): A polynomial f ∈ Fqx is called admissible if:

• f is non-constant and not a perfect square in Fqx
• For the decomposition f(x) = x^r h(x) with h(0) ≠ 0, the polynomial h(x) is not a perfect square in Fqx

Definition 1.4 (d-f-Diophantine m-tuple): For an odd prime power q and an admissible polynomial f, a d-f-Diophantine m-tuple is a set {a1, a2, ..., am} ⊂ Fq such that for any d distinct elements ai1, ai2, ..., aid, the element f(ai1ai2···aid) is a square in Fq.

Core Theorem

Theorem 1.5: The count N_f^(m choose d)(q) of d-f-Diophantine m-tuples satisfies:

N_f^(m choose d)(q) = qm/(m! 2^(m choose d)) + { O(qm-1/2), if deg(f) ≥ 2, O(qm-1), if deg(f) = 1 }

Technical Methods

1. Character Sum Transformation

Utilizing the quadratic character χ to transform the counting problem into character sums:

• For a ∈ Fq, the equation x² = a has χ(a) + 1 solutions
• Converting Diophantine tuple conditions into solution counting for polynomial systems

2. Application of Weil Estimate

Theorem 2.2 (Weil Estimate): For a multiplicative character χ of order e and a polynomial f, if there exists no g such that f = g^e, then: |∑_{x∈Fq} χ(f(x))| ≤ (d-1)q^(1/2)

3. Key Techniques of the Shparlinski Method

Processing products of multiple characters through variable separation techniques:

• When |ε| = 1, directly apply the Weil estimate
• When |ε| > 1, utilize dimension theory from algebraic geometry

Experimental Setup

Theoretical Verification Framework

This work is primarily theoretical, verified through:

1. Asymptotic Behavior Analysis: Verifying the leading coefficient as q → ∞
2. Error Term Estimation: Obtaining optimal error bounds through refined character sum analysis
3. Boundary Case Verification: Analyzing different cases for deg(f) = 1 and deg(f) ≥ 2

Technical Tools

• Weil character sum bounds
• Dimension theorems in algebraic geometry
• Zariski closure theory for constructible sets

Technical Innovations

1. Variable Separation Technique

For the case |ε| > 1, through clever variable substitution: (a1, ..., am) ↦ (a1/b^(d-1), a2b, ..., amb)

achieving separation of different character terms.

2. Application of Algebraic Geometry Methods

Theorems 4.6-4.7: Utilizing dimension theory of algebraic varieties, proving that the cardinality of parameter sets satisfying specific conditions is O(q^(t-1)).

3. Perfect Square Detection

Theorem 4.8: Proving that for an admissible polynomial f, f(x^k) is never a perfect square, which is crucial to the method's success.

Main Results

Precision of Asymptotic Formulas

Compared to the o(qm) error term of Dujella-Kazalicki and the naive Lang-Weil estimate's O(qm-1/2), this paper achieves:

• For deg(f) ≥ 2: O(qm-1/2)
• For deg(f) = 1: O(qm-1)

Method Limitations

Remark 4.9: This method cannot be generalized to more general symmetric polynomial conditions f(ai1, ai2, ..., aid), because the product form ∏aik is necessary for variable separation.

Related Work

Historical Development

1. Diophantus: Earliest example {1/16, 33/16, 17/4, 105/16}
2. Dujella's Series of Works: Established fundamental theory of Diophantine tuples over finite fields
3. Shparlinski (2023): First achieved O(qm-1) error term improvement

Parallel Research

• Kim-Yip-Yoo 7: Studied more general f-Diophantine sets using Slavov's techniques
• When deg(f) ≥ 2, the results of this paper are special cases of their Theorem 1.7

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Successfully generalized the Shparlinski method to d-f-Diophantine tuples
2. Obtained error term estimates of the same quality as the classical case
3. Established a complete theoretical framework from definitions to proofs

Limitations

1. Method Restrictions: Applicable only to product-form conditions
2. Constant Issues: Implicit constants in error terms are not sufficiently explicit
3. Generalization Difficulties: Difficult to extend to more general symmetric polynomials

Future Directions

The paper proposes two open problems:

1. Can the Shparlinski method be improved or adapted to more general symmetric polynomials?
2. Can the implicit constants in error terms be computed more precisely?

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Theoretical Depth: Cleverly combines number theory, algebraic geometry, and character sum theory
2. Methodological Innovation: Successfully generalizes Shparlinski's variable separation technique
3. Result Precision: Achieves optimal error term estimates
4. Clear Exposition: Rigorous logic and complete proofs

Weaknesses

1. Limited Scope of Application: Method applicability is restricted by strict product-form constraints
2. Computational Complexity: Calculation of implicit constants remains difficult
3. Practical Utility: Primarily theoretical results with limited practical applications

Impact

1. Theoretical Contribution: Provides new generalization directions for Diophantine tuple theory
2. Method Value: Successful application of Shparlinski technique demonstrates its potential
3. Subsequent Research: Provides technical foundation for related problem investigations

Applicable Scenarios

• Combinatorial number theory problems over finite fields
• Related research on character sum estimation
• Applications of algebraic geometry methods in number theory

References

This paper cites important literature in the field, including:

• Dujella's foundational work on Diophantine tuples
• Shparlinski's character sum methods
• Iwaniec-Kowalski's analytic number theory textbook
• Mumford's algebraic geometry foundations

Overall Assessment: This is a high-quality theoretical number theory paper that successfully generalizes important technical methods and obtains meaningful theoretical results. Although somewhat limited in scope of application, it makes substantial contributions to the development of related fields.