Two sequences of fully-nonlinear evolution equations and their symmetry properties

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2509.05535
• Title: Two sequences of fully-nonlinear evolution equations and their symmetry properties
• Authors: Marianna Euler, Norbert Euler
• Classification: nlin.SI (Exactly Solvable and Integrable Systems)
• Published Journal: Open Communications in Nonlinear Mathematical Physics, Vol.5 (2025) pp 81–89
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2509.05535

Abstract

This paper obtains the complete Lie point symmetry algebras for two sequences of odd-order evolution equations. These equations are fully nonlinear, meaning they are nonlinear in the highest-order derivatives. Two equations in the sequences were recently identified as symmetry integrable, namely a third-order equation and a fifth-order equation. The paper also discusses Lie-Bäcklund symmetries of the equation sequences and the corresponding symmetry integrability.

Research Background and Motivation

Problem Background

1. Fully-nonlinear evolution equations: Investigation of evolution equations that are nonlinear in the highest-order derivatives, which have significant importance in mathematical physics
2. Symmetry integrability: Search for evolution equations possessing infinitely many local Lie-Bäcklund symmetries, which is an important indicator of integrability
3. Generalization of known results: Construction of more general sequences based on two known symmetry integrable equations $u_t = u_{3x}^{-1/2}$ and $u_t = u_{5x}^{-2/3}$

Research Motivation

• The authors' previous discovery of two fully-nonlinear symmetry integrable evolution equations motivated investigation of more general sequences
• Desire to understand the symmetry structure and integrability patterns of such equations
• Provision of theoretical foundation for classification of nonlinear evolution equations

Core Contributions

1. Proposal of two sequences of fully-nonlinear evolution equations:
   • Sequence 1: $u_t = (u_{(2k+1)x})^{-k/(k+1)}$, $k = 1,2,3,...$
   • Sequence 2: $u_t = (u_{(2k+1)x})^{-n_k}$, $n_k \neq k/(k+1)$
2. Complete determination of Lie point symmetry algebras:
   • Sequence 1 possesses symmetry algebra of dimension $2k+6$
   • Sequence 2 possesses symmetry algebra of dimension $2k+5$
3. Conjecture of necessary conditions for symmetry integrability: Establishment of necessary conditions for symmetry integrability of evolution equations of different orders
4. Analysis of sequence symmetry integrability: Determination of which equations may possess symmetry integrability

Detailed Methodology

Problem Formulation

Investigation of Lie point symmetries and Lie-Bäcklund symmetries of odd-order fully-nonlinear evolution equations of the form $u_t = (u_{(2k+1)x})^{-n_k}$.

Lie Point Symmetry Analysis Method

Invariance Conditions

For an evolution equation $E := u_t - F(x,t,u,u_x,u_{xx},...,u_{nx}) = 0$, the Lie point symmetry generator is: $Z = \xi^1(x,t,u)\frac{\partial}{\partial x} + \xi^2(x,t,u)\frac{\partial}{\partial t} + \eta(x,t,u)\frac{\partial}{\partial u}$

The invariance condition is: $L_E[u]Q\Big|_{E=0} = 0$

where $Q = \eta - \xi^1 u_x - \xi^2 u_t$ is the invariant surface.

Sequence Classification

Through application of invariance conditions, the equation sequences naturally divide into two classes:

Case 1: Special sequence with $n_k = k/(k+1)$

• Lie symmetry algebra dimension: $2k+6$
• Symmetry generators include an additional generator $Z_5 = x^2\frac{\partial}{\partial x} + 2kxu\frac{\partial}{\partial u}$

Case 2: General sequence with $n_k \neq k/(k+1)$

• Lie symmetry algebra dimension: $2k+5$
• Lacks the aforementioned additional generator

Symmetry Integrability Analysis

Necessary Conditions Conjecture

The authors propose necessary conditions for symmetry integrability of evolution equations of different orders:

1. Second-order equations: $2\frac{\partial F}{\partial u_{xx}}\frac{\partial^3 F}{\partial u_{xx}^3} - 3(\frac{\partial^2 F}{\partial u_{xx}^2})^2 = 0$
2. Third-order equations: $9(\frac{\partial F}{\partial u_{3x}})^2\frac{\partial^4 F}{\partial u_{3x}^4} - 45\frac{\partial F}{\partial u_{3x}}\frac{\partial^2 F}{\partial u_{3x}^2}\frac{\partial^3 F}{\partial u_{3x}^3} + 40(\frac{\partial^2 F}{\partial u_{3x}^2})^3 = 0$
3. Odd-order $n \geq 5$: $(2k+3)\frac{\partial F}{\partial u_{(2k+3)x}}\frac{\partial^3 F}{\partial u_{(2k+3)x}^3} - (3k+5)(\frac{\partial^2 F}{\partial u_{(2k+3)x}^2})^2 = 0$

Experimental Setup

Computational Methods

• Symbolic computation systems employed for Lie symmetry analysis
• Calculation of Lie-Bäcklund symmetries up to order 19 (limited by computer memory)
• Verification of satisfaction of necessary conditions

Verification Strategy

• Verification of necessary conditions for known symmetry integrable equations
• Examination of whether equations in sequences satisfy corresponding necessary conditions
• Attempted construction of concrete Lie-Bäcklund symmetry generators

Experimental Results

Main Results

Symmetry Integrability of Sequence 1

• Confirmed symmetry integrable:
  • Third-order equation: $u_t = u_{3x}^{-1/2}$ (possesses fifth-order Lie-Bäcklund symmetry)
  • Fifth-order equation: $u_t = u_{5x}^{-2/3}$ (possesses eleventh-order Lie-Bäcklund symmetry)
• Theoretical prediction: All equations in the sequence satisfy necessary conditions for symmetry integrability
• Computational limitation: Seventh-order and higher-order equations show no Lie-Bäcklund symmetries within the order-19 range

Symmetry Integrability of Sequence 2

• Third-order equations: Satisfy necessary conditions only when $n_1 \in \{-1, 1/2, 2\}$
• Unique relevant case: $u_t = u_{3x}^{-2}$ (known to be symmetry integrable)
• Higher-order equations: None satisfy necessary conditions

Important Findings

Corollary 1

Sequence 2 contains only one symmetry integrable equation: $u_t = u_{3x}^{-2}$

Corollary 2

Any fifth-order or higher symmetry integrable fully-nonlinear evolution equation must have the form: $u_t = f_1(u_{(2k+3)x} + f_2)^{\frac{k+1}{k+2}} + f_3$

where $f_j$ are functions depending on lower-order derivatives.

Related Work

Historical Background

• Long history of application of Lie symmetry theory to differential equations
• Concept of symmetry integrability provides important tools for studying nonlinear evolution equations
• Authors' previous work established necessary conditions for symmetry integrability of second and third-order equations

Contributions of This Paper

• Extension of necessary conditions to arbitrary odd-order equations
• Systematic investigation of symmetry structure of fully-nonlinear equation sequences
• Provision of theoretical framework for classification of high-order nonlinear evolution equations

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Symmetry classification: The two sequences possess Lie point symmetry algebras of different dimensions, with the difference being an additional symmetry generator
2. Integrability patterns:
   • All equations in Sequence 1 are theoretically potentially symmetry integrable
   • Only one known symmetry integrable equation exists in Sequence 2
3. Role of necessary conditions: Provides effective tools for screening potentially symmetry integrable equations

Limitations

1. Computational constraints: Memory limitations prevent verification of Lie-Bäcklund symmetries beyond order 19
2. Sufficiency of necessary conditions: Satisfaction of necessary conditions does not guarantee that an equation is symmetry integrable
3. Construction methods: Lack of systematic methods for constructing new symmetry integrable equations

Future Directions

1. Higher-order symmetries: Development of more efficient algorithms for computing higher-order Lie-Bäcklund symmetries
2. Sufficient conditions: Search for sufficient conditions for symmetry integrability
3. Sequence generalization: Investigation of other types of nonlinear evolution equation sequences
4. Application exploration: Application of results to concrete physical problems

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Theoretical depth: Systematic investigation of symmetry structure of fully-nonlinear evolution equations
2. Methodological innovation: Proposal of necessary conditions conjecture for symmetry integrability of high-order equations
3. Completeness of results: Complete determination of Lie point symmetry algebras for both sequences
4. Practical value: Provision of theoretical guidance for finding new integrable equations

Weaknesses

1. Incomplete verification: Some results based only on necessary conditions analysis due to computational limitations
2. Conjectural nature: Core necessary conditions remain conjectures lacking rigorous proof
3. Limited applications: Primarily theoretical results with practical applicability yet to be explored

Impact

1. Theoretical contribution: Significant contribution to symmetry theory of nonlinear evolution equations
2. Methodological value: Provided analytical framework applicable to other equation sequences
3. Inspirational significance: Important clues for subsequent research on fully-nonlinear integrable systems

Applicable Scenarios

• Research on integrable systems in mathematical physics
• Classification problems of nonlinear evolution equations
• Application of symmetry methods to differential equations
• Application of computer algebra systems in symmetry analysis

References

The paper cites important previous work by the authors in this field, including:

• Research on second-order fully-nonlinear equations
• Establishment of symmetry integrability conditions for third-order equations
• Discovery of specific symmetry integrable equations

These works provide a solid foundation for the research in this paper, demonstrating continuity and systematicity of the investigation.