2025-11-20T10:07:15.221417

Generalized Sato-Tate and quadratic residues

Vladuts
We show that the Generalized Sato-Tate Conjecture permits to obtain rather precise information on the distribution of the consecutive quadratic residues modulo large primes.
academic

Generalized Sato-Tate and quadratic residues

Basic Information

  • Paper ID: 2509.07183
  • Title: Generalized Sato-Tate and quadratic residues
  • Author: Sergey Vlăduţ (Aix–Marseille Université, CNRS, I2M UMR 7373)
  • Classification: math.NT (Number Theory), math.AG (Algebraic Geometry)
  • Publication Date: October 16, 2025 (arXiv v2)
  • Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2509.07183

Abstract

This paper proves that the generalized Sato-Tate conjecture can provide fairly precise information about the distribution of consecutive quadratic residues modulo large primes. This work continues previous work KTVZ, resolving several open problems left therein concerning the distribution of consecutive quadratic residues.

Research Background and Motivation

Core Problem

The core problem studied in this paper concerns the distribution patterns of consecutive quadratic residues. Specifically, for an odd prime p, consider the sequence 1, 2, ..., p-1, replacing each number i with R (if i is a quadratic residue modulo p) or N (otherwise), yielding a string Wp. The research objective is to analyze the asymptotic behavior of np(t), the count of occurrences of t consecutive quadratic residues.

Problem Significance

  1. Number-Theoretic Foundation: The distribution of quadratic residues is a classical problem in number theory, intimately connected with the Legendre symbol, Jacobsthal sums, and related concepts
  2. Statistical Independence: The problem involves strong statistical independence assumptions that are completely inaccessible with current techniques
  3. Algebraic Geometry Connection: The problem is closely related to algebraic curves and abelian varieties over finite fields

Limitations of Existing Methods

  • For t ≤ 3, explicit formulas exist (classical results by Aldanov, Jacobsthal, etc.)
  • For t ≥ 4, there is no hope of obtaining similar explicit formulas
  • Reliance on strong statistical independence assumptions that currently cannot be proven

Research Motivation

The author's key observation is that these statistical independence assumptions can be derived from specific cases of the generalized Sato-Tate conjecture (GST), and certain known cases of GST can provide interesting upper and lower bounds for the corresponding arithmetic functions.

Core Contributions

  1. Theoretical Connection: Establishes a profound link between the distribution of consecutive quadratic residues and the generalized Sato-Tate conjecture
  2. Asymptotic Results: Under GST assumptions, obtains asymptotic results for the distribution of 4 and 5 consecutive quadratic residues
  3. Unconditional Bounds: Utilizing known cases of GST (products of two elliptic curves), establishes similar but weaker unconditional bounds
  4. Precise Estimates: Provides precise asymptotic distributions of np(t) - p/2^t, including support intervals and probability measures

Methodology in Detail

Task Definition

Given an odd prime p and positive integer t, define:

  • Wp: A string of length p-1, with the i-th position being R (if i is a quadratic residue modulo p) or N
  • np(t): The number of substrings consisting of t consecutive R's in Wp

Research objective: Analyze the asymptotic distribution of δp(t) = (np(t) - p/2^t)/√p

Core Mathematical Framework

1. Fundamental Formula

Using the Legendre symbol, one can express:

np(t) = 2^(-t) ∑(j=1 to p-t-1) ∏(i=1 to t) (1 + (i+j-1)/p)

2. Algebraic Geometric Formulation

Introduce a family of hyperelliptic curves CT: y² = fT(x), where:

  • fT(X) = ∏((i+1)∈T) (X + i)
  • NT = ∑(j∈Fp) (fT(j)/p) is related to the Frobenius trace of the curve CT

3. Abelian Variety Construction

The key abelian variety is:

A(t) = ∏(T⊂[1,...,t]) JT

where JT = Jac(CT) is the Jacobian of the curve CT, with dimension gt = 2^(t-2)(t-3) + 1.

Application of the Generalized Sato-Tate Conjecture

GST Statement

For a g-dimensional abelian variety A over Q, GST asserts:

  1. There exists a closed algebraic subgroup STA ⊂ Sp2g(C)
  2. The family of Frobenius elements {Fp, p ∉ SA} is equidistributed with respect to the Haar measure μA on STA

Key Observation

Although ST(A) ⊂ ∏T ST(JT), this inclusion is strict (for t ≥ 3), so one cannot directly derive the asymptotic behavior of δp(t) from GST. However, for small values of t, refined analysis is possible.

Experimental Setup

Theoretical Analysis Framework

This paper is primarily theoretical work, not involving numerical experiments in the traditional sense, but rather employing rigorous mathematical analysis:

Data Structure

  • Elliptic curve families: E0, E1, E2, E3, E4, etc., with different j-invariants and complex multiplication properties
  • Prime classification: Classified by p ≡ 1,3 (mod 4) and p ≡ 1,3,5,7 (mod 8)

Analysis Tools

  • Frobenius traces ai(p) of elliptic curves
  • Convolution of probability measures: ν1 (CM case) and ν2 (non-CM case)
  • Statistical independence analysis

Experimental Results

Main Results

Case t = 4 (Theorem 4.1)

  1. p ≡ 3 (mod 4): δp(4) is equidistributed with respect to the measure μ3 = ν2 on -2,2
  2. p ≡ 1 (mod 4): Under the GST(E0×E1×E4) assumption, δp(4) is equidistributed with respect to the measure μ1 = λcm * μ * ν2 on -10,10

Where:

ν2 = √(4-x²)dx/(2π)  (non-CM elliptic curves)
λcm = δ0/4 + dx/(2π√(16-x²))  (CM-related)

Case t = 5 (Theorem 4.3)

Depending on the residue of p modulo 8, different bounds are obtained:

  • p ≡ 7 (mod 8): |δ(p)| ≤ 7/32
  • p ≡ 5 (mod 8): |δ(p)| ≤ 13/32
  • p ≡ 3 (mod 8): |δ(p)| ≤ 11/32
  • p ≡ 1 (mod 8): |δ(p)| ≤ 17/32

Unconditional Results

Based on Known GST Results

Utilizing Johansson's GST result for products of two elliptic curves:

Proposition 5.2 (t=4): For any ε > 0, there exist primes p1, p'1 ≡ 1 (mod 4) such that:

np1(4) ≥ p1/16 + (3/8 - ε)√p1
np'1(4) ≤ p'1/16 - (3/8 - ε)√p'1

Proposition 5.3 (t=5): Similarly, bounds are obtained for various residue classes modulo 8, with coefficients around 1/16.

Statistical Independence

Proves that the sequences {a0(p)}, {a1(p)}, {a4(p)} (Frobenius traces corresponding to different elliptic curves) are pairwise statistically independent, which is key to obtaining strong bounds.

Related Work

Classical Results

  1. Aldanov (1896): The case t=2, np(2) = (p-5)/4 or (p-3)/4
  2. Jacobsthal (1906): The case t=3, involving the Legendre symbol and Gauss periods
  3. Conrad: Modern treatment of general formulas

Modern Developments

  1. KTVZ: The work directly continued by this paper, establishing connections with algebraic curves
  2. HSBT: Proof of the Sato-Tate conjecture for elliptic curves
  3. Jo: Proof of GST for products of two elliptic curves

Technical Tools

  1. Weil-Deligne Theory: Construction of Frobenius elements
  2. ℓ-adic Representation Theory: Description of Galois actions
  3. Equidistribution Theory: Weak* convergence and Haar measures

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

  1. The generalized Sato-Tate conjecture provides a powerful analytical tool for studying the distribution of consecutive quadratic residues
  2. For t=4,5, under appropriate GST assumptions, precise asymptotic distributions can be obtained
  3. Even with currently known GST cases, meaningful unconditional bounds can be derived

Limitations

  1. Dimension Growth: For large t, the dimension of the required abelian variety grows rapidly (gt = 2^(t-2)(t-3)+1), making GST assumptions increasingly difficult to verify
  2. Technical Constraints: Current GST proof techniques are primarily limited to low-dimensional cases
  3. Explicit Formulas: For t ≥ 4, no explicit formulas exist analogous to those for small t

Future Directions

  1. GST Extension: Develop GST proof techniques for higher-dimensional abelian varieties
  2. Other Patterns: Study more general quadratic residue patterns, not limited to consecutive cases
  3. Computational Aspects: Develop methods for effectively computing Frobenius traces of relevant elliptic curves

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

  1. Theoretical Depth: Establishes connections between seemingly unrelated number-theoretic problems and deep algebraic geometry theory
  2. Methodological Innovation: Applies GST to concrete arithmetic problems, demonstrating the practical value of the conjecture
  3. Precision of Results: Not only provides asymptotic behavior but determines precise probability distributions
  4. Technical Rigor: Mathematical derivations are rigorous with careful attention to technical details

Weaknesses

  1. Dependence on Assumptions: Main results rely on unproven GST, though these cases are reasonable
  2. Computational Complexity: Practical computation of relevant quantities requires handling multiple elliptic curves, with high technical demands
  3. Scope Limitations: Current methods primarily apply to small values of t

Impact

  1. Theoretical Contribution: Provides new application domains for GST, potentially inspiring further research
  2. Methodological: Demonstrates how to apply modern algebraic geometry tools to classical number theory problems
  3. Extensibility: Methods may apply to other types of arithmetic statistical problems

Applicable Scenarios

  1. Number Theory Research: Provides new perspectives for studying quadratic residues and related arithmetic functions
  2. Algebraic Geometry: Provides concrete test cases for GST research
  3. Algorithmic Applications: May have promising applications in cryptography and random number generation

References

Core References

  1. KTVZ: V. Kiritchenko, M. Tsfasman, S. Vlăduţ, I. Zakharevich, "Quadratic residue patterns, algebraic curves and a K3 surface"
  2. HSBT: M. Harris, N. Shepherd-Barron, and R. Taylor, "A family of Calabi-Yau varieties and potential automorphy"
  3. Jo: Ch. Johansson, "On the Sato-Tate conjecture for non-generic Abelian surfaces"

Classical References

  1. J: E. Jacobsthal, "Anwendungen einer Formel aus der Theorie der quadratischen Reste" (1906)
  2. A: N.S. Aladov, "Sur la distribution des résidus quadratiques" (1896)

This paper demonstrates the profound application of modern algebraic geometry theory to classical number theory problems. While the main results depend on conjectures, it provides important insights into understanding the deep structure of quadratic residue distributions.