Blowup relations and $q$-Painlevé VI

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2509.10938
• Title: Blowup relations and $q$-Painlevé VI
• Author: Artem Stoyan (University of Melbourne)
• Classification: math-ph hep-th math.MP nlin.SI
• Publication Date: October 10, 2025 (arXiv v2)
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2509.10938

Abstract

This paper proposes and investigates blowup relations satisfied by the partition function of five-dimensional $\mathcal{N}=1$ SU(2) gauge theory with four flavors in (quiver) supersymmetric Yang-Mills theory. By analyzing the action of the Weyl group on the set of blowup relations, the author connects the integer parameters of blowup relations to weights of the corresponding Lie algebra. The paper further explains how this Weyl group action arises from the Weyl group symmetry of the partition function. Finally, the author derives bilinear relations for the $q$-Painlevé VI tau function using these relations.

Research Background and Motivation

Problem Background

1. Importance of Blowup Relations: Blowup relations are effective tools for studying partition functions of supersymmetric gauge theories, originally proposed and proven by Nakajima and Yoshioka in the matter-free case. These relations can be used to extract the prepotential from partition functions.
2. Painlevé/Gauge Theory Correspondence: This research belongs to the broader framework of Painlevé/gauge theory correspondence or isomonodromic/CFT correspondence. This correspondence originated from the discovery of the Kiev formula, which expresses the Painlevé VI tau function as a series of $c=1$ Virasoro conformal blocks.
3. $q$-Painlevé VI Equation: As a $q$-deformation of the classical Painlevé VI equation, the $q$-Painlevé VI equation holds important significance in integrable systems and mathematical physics.

Research Motivation

1. Extending Existing Results: Extending the application of blowup relations from four dimensions to five dimensions, particularly in cases related to $q$-Painlevé VI.
2. Establishing New Correspondences: Establishing connections between five-dimensional gauge theory partition functions and $q$-Painlevé VI tau functions through blowup relations.
3. Weyl Group Symmetry: Systematically investigating the role of Weyl groups in blowup relations and connecting them to Lie algebra representation theory.

Core Contributions

1. Proposed Three Classes of Blowup Relations:
   • $A_1$ type relations (83 total)
   • $A_2$ type relations (580 total)
   • $A_3$ type relations and their Higgs-reduced versions
2. Established Weyl Group Actions: Proved the action of extended Weyl groups $\tilde{W}(D_5)$, $\tilde{W}(A_1 \times A_1 \times A_5)$, etc., on the corresponding sets of blowup relations.
3. Weight Identification: Identified the integer parameters of blowup relations as weights of the fundamental representations of the corresponding Lie algebras.
4. Derived Bilinear Relations: Through the $q_2 \to 1$ limit, derived eight bilinear relations for the $q$-Painlevé VI tau function from blowup relations.
5. Constructed Generating Functions: Established generating functions for canonical transformations related to $q$-Painlevé VI time evolution.

Methodology Details

Partition Function Construction

$A_1$ Case ($N_f = 4$)

The partition function decomposes into three factors: $F_4 = F^{\text{extra}}_4 \cdot F^{1-\text{loop}}_4 \cdot F^{\text{inst}}_4$

where:

• $F^{\text{extra}}_4$: Extra contributions related to the U(1) factor
• $F^{1-\text{loop}}_4$: One-loop exact perturbative part
• $F^{\text{inst}}_4$: Instanton part, computed via localization

$A_2$ Quiver Case

Similarly, there is a decomposition $F_5 = F^{\text{extra}}_5 \cdot F^{1-\text{loop}}_5 \cdot F^{\text{inst}}_5$, where the instanton part involves summation over pairs of Young diagrams.

Form of Blowup Relations

$A_1$ Blowup Relations

General form: $f(\theta, t|j, d) \times F^{\text{inst}}_4 = \sum_{n \in \mathbb{Z}+\nu} C_4[...] \times F^{\text{inst}}_4(...) \times F^{\text{inst}}_4(...)$

where $\nu = \frac{1}{2}(j_1 + j_2 + 1 \bmod 2)$ determines the parity of the summation.

$A_2$ Blowup Relations

More complex form involving two discrete parameters $(n_1, n_2)$ and additional instanton counting parameters.

Weyl Group Actions

Weyl Group Action in the $A_1$ Case

The action of the extended Weyl group $\tilde{W}(D_5)$ on parameters $(j_1, j_2, n, j_3, j_4, d)$ is given by generators:

• $s_1: (j_1, j_2, n, j_3, j_4, d) \mapsto (-j_1, j_2, n, j_3, j_4, d)$
• $s_2$: More complex linear transformations
• And so on

Orbit Decomposition

The 83 $A_1$ relations decompose under Weyl group orbits as: $83 = 40 + 32 + 10 + 1$, corresponding to fundamental representations of SO(10):

• 40-dimensional adjoint representation (root system $D_5$)
• 32-dimensional spinor representation
• 10-dimensional defining representation
• 1-dimensional trivial representation

Technical Innovations

1. Systematic Weyl Group Analysis: First systematic study of Weyl group symmetry of blowup relations, establishing connections with Lie algebra representation theory.
2. Higgs Reduction Technique: Implementing Higgs reduction by adjusting fundamental masses and Coulomb moduli parameters, corresponding to degenerate field insertions in CFT.
3. Limit Process: Skillfully utilizing the $q_2 \to 1$ limit to connect five-dimensional results with four-dimensional $q$-Painlevé theory.

Experimental Setup

Numerical Verification Methods

The author verifies the proposed blowup relations through "a series of numerical experiments," checking the validity of the relations order by order in the expansion of instanton counting parameters.

Parameter Settings

• Using Omega background parameters $q_1 = \exp(\epsilon_1)$, $q_2 = \exp(\epsilon_2)$
• Fundamental masses parametrized as $e^{m_i} = q_1^{\theta_i}$
• Instanton counting parameters $t$, $y$, etc.

Special Limits

• $q_2 \to 1$ limit for connecting to $q$-Painlevé VI
• $t \to 0$ limit yielding $q$-hypergeometric functions
• $y \to \infty$ limit reducing $A_2$ relations to $A_1$ relations

Experimental Results

Main Results

$A_1$ Relations Verification

Successfully identified 83 blowup relations forming complete orbit structures under the extended Weyl group $\tilde{W}(D_5)$.

$A_2$ Relations Verification

Discovered 580 $A_2$ blowup relations with orbit cardinality under $\tilde{W}(A_1 \times A_1 \times A_5)$ given by: $580 = 4 + 8 + 12 + 20 + 2 \times 48 + 80 + 3 \times 120$

Character Decomposition

The character of $A_2$ relations can be decomposed as a product of $\text{sl}_2 \oplus \text{sl}_2 \oplus \text{sl}_6$ representations.

Derivation of Bilinear Relations

Through the $q_2 \to 1$ limit, successfully derived eight bilinear relations for $q$-Painlevé VI from blowup relations, for example:

• $\tau_1\tau_2 - q^{-\theta_t}\tau_3\tau_4 + (1-tq^{\theta_t})q^{-\theta_t}\tau_7\tau_8 = 0$
• $\tau_1\tau_2 - \tau_3\tau_4 + (1-tq^{\theta_1})q^{-\theta_t}\tau_7\tau_8 = 0$

Construction of $q$-Painlevé VI Solutions

Obtained $q$-Painlevé VI solutions in tau function representation: $y = tq^{\theta_1-1}\frac{\tau_3\tau_4}{\tau_1\tau_2}$

Related Work

Development of Blowup Relations

• Nakajima-Yoshioka: Originally proposed in the four-dimensional matter-free case
• Applications in Painlevé/gauge theory correspondence
• Connections with conformal field theory

Research on $q$-Painlevé Equations

• CFT methods by Jimbo, Nagoya, Sakai, and others
• Studies on quantized $q$-Painlevé VI
• Connections with integrable systems

Weyl Group Symmetry

• Enhanced symmetries in five-dimensional gauge theory
• Fiber-base duality
• Symmetries in topological string theory

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Systematically Established Connection Between Five-Dimensional Gauge Theory and $q$-Painlevé VI: Through blowup relations and limit processes, established profound connections between two seemingly different domains.
2. Central Role of Weyl Group Symmetry: Demonstrated that Weyl group symmetry not only exists in partition functions but is also embodied in the structure of blowup relations.
3. Geometric Realization of Representation Theory: Realized the abstract structures of Lie algebra representation theory in concrete physical systems.

Limitations

1. Limitations of Numerical Verification: Blowup relations are primarily verified through numerical experiments, lacking rigorous mathematical proofs.
2. Restrictions to Special Cases: Primarily focused on SU(2) gauge groups and specific matter content; generalization to more general cases requires further research.
3. Computational Complexity: Calculations of higher-order instanton contributions become extremely complex.

Future Directions

1. Affine Weyl Group Actions: Investigate how finite Weyl groups give rise to affine Weyl group actions on tau functions.
2. Quantization: Extend results to bilinear relations for quantized $q$-Painlevé VI.
3. More General Gauge Groups: Extend to more general gauge groups such as SU(N).
4. Rigorous Proofs: Provide rigorous mathematical proofs for the proposed blowup relations.

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Theoretical Depth: Organically combines multiple fields including gauge theory, integrable systems, representation theory, and conformal field theory, demonstrating profound mathematical physics insights.
2. Systematicity: Provides systematic classification and investigation of blowup relations, with particularly complete analysis of Weyl group symmetry.
3. Computational Techniques: Demonstrates sophisticated computational techniques in handling complex partition functions and limit processes.
4. Novelty: Establishes for the first time direct connections between five-dimensional gauge theory and $q$-Painlevé VI, opening new research directions.

Weaknesses

1. Missing Proofs: Main results are based on numerical verification, lacking rigorous mathematical proofs, which somewhat limits the reliability of the results.
2. Generalizability: Results are primarily limited to specific gauge groups and matter content; the path to generalization to more general cases is unclear.
3. Physical Interpretation: The physical meaning of certain mathematical structures requires further clarification.

Impact

1. Academic Value: Provides new five-dimensional perspectives for Painlevé/gauge theory correspondence, potentially advancing further development in this field.
2. Methodological Contribution: Provides new methods and tools for studying partition functions of higher-dimensional gauge theories.
3. Cross-disciplinary Impact: Connects multiple branches of mathematical physics, potentially inspiring related research.

Applicable Scenarios

1. Theoretical Physics Research: Particularly in the study of supersymmetric gauge theories and integrable systems.
2. Mathematical Research: Potential applications in Lie algebra representation theory, special functions theory, and algebraic geometry.
3. Computational Physics: Provides new theoretical frameworks for related numerical computations.

References

The paper cites 37 important references covering:

• Original blowup relation work by Nakajima-Yoshioka
• Modern research on Painlevé equations
• Five-dimensional gauge theory and AGT correspondence
• Topological string theory and vertex algebras
• $q$-special functions and integrable systems

These references reflect the author's deep understanding of relevant fields and solid theoretical foundation.