A Dynamical Approach to Studying the Lee-Yang Zeros for the Potts Model on the Cayley Tree

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2509.11505
• Title: A dynamical approach to studying the Lee-Yang zeros for the Potts Model on the Cayley Tree
• Authors: Diyath Pannipitiya, Roland Roeder
• Classification: math-ph cond-mat.stat-mech math.DS math.MP
• Publication Date: October 13, 2025 (arXiv v2)
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2509.11505

Abstract

This paper investigates the Lee-Yang zeros of the q-state Potts model on the binary Cayley tree. Let $Z_n(z,t)$ denote the partition function of the q-state Potts model on a rooted binary Cayley tree of depth n, where $z = e^{-h/T}$ and $t = e^{-J/T}$ represent the "magnetic field-like" and "temperature-like" variables, respectively. In the ferromagnetic case ($J > 0$ or $t \in (0,1)$), Lee-Yang zeros accumulate on the physical ray $(0,\infty)$ to at most one point; in the antiferromagnetic case ($J < 0$ or $t \in (1,\infty)$), zeros accumulate to at most two points. The paper provides explicit formulas for these accumulation points through an improved renormalization procedure and complex dynamical methods, particularly the active/passive dichotomy of marked points iteration.

Research Background and Motivation

Importance of the Problem

1. Historical Significance of the Lee-Yang Theorem: In 1952, Lee and Yang proved the celebrated Lee-Yang circle theorem, demonstrating that the zeros of the partition function of the Ising model lie on the unit circle, a result fundamental to understanding phase transitions.
2. Complexity of the Potts Model: For the Potts model with q≥3, Lee-Yang zeros no longer lie on the unit circle, making the research more challenging and interesting.
3. Specificity of the Cayley Tree: The recursive structure of the Cayley tree enables the application of renormalization methods, providing the possibility of exact solutions.

Limitations of Existing Research

1. Scarcity of Studies: Research on q-state Potts models with external magnetic fields is relatively limited, primarily due to their complexity.
2. Methodological Constraints: Previous studies have relied mainly on numerical methods and physical reasoning, lacking rigorous mathematical proofs.
3. Insufficient Theoretical Tools: A combination of statistical physics and complex dynamics methods is needed to address such problems.

Research Motivation

This paper aims to provide rigorous mathematical analysis of Lee-Yang zeros for the Potts model through the active/passive dichotomy from complex dynamics, combined with renormalization procedures.

Core Contributions

1. Established a complete theory of Lee-Yang zero accumulation in ferromagnetic and antiferromagnetic cases:
   • Ferromagnetic case: zeros accumulate to at most one point
   • Antiferromagnetic case: zeros accumulate to at most two points
2. Provided explicit formulas for accumulation points:
   • Critical point formula $Z_q(t)$ for the ferromagnetic case
   • Two-point formula $z_c^{\pm}(t,q)$ for the antiferromagnetic case
3. Introduced complex dynamical methods to statistical physics:
   • First application of the active/passive dichotomy to Lee-Yang zero research
   • Established connections between renormalization maps and families of rational functions
4. Determined critical temperatures:
   • $t_1(q) = \frac{1}{1+q}$ (Bethe-Peierls temperature)
   • $t_2(q) = \frac{q-2+\sqrt{q^2+32q-32}}{18(q-1)}$
   • $t_3(q) = \frac{3(3q-6+\sqrt{9q^2-32q+32})}{2(q-1)}$

Detailed Methodology

Problem Definition

Study the distribution of Lee-Yang zeros of the q-state Potts model on the binary Cayley tree, determining the accumulation behavior of zeros on the physical parameter region $(0,\infty)$ as the tree depth n approaches infinity.

Core Methodological Framework

1. Renormalization Procedure (Theorem D)

For q∈ℕ≥2, t∈ℝ, z,w∈ℂ, define the renormalization maps:

$R_{z,t,q}(w) := z\left[\frac{t+w+(q-2)tw}{1+(q-1)tw}\right]^2$

$\hat{R}_{z,t,q}(w) := z\left[\frac{t+w+(q-2)tw}{1+(q-1)tw}\right]^3$

Lee-Yang zeros are determined by:

• Rooted tree: $R_{z,t,q}^n(z) = \frac{1}{1-q}$
• Unrooted tree: $(\hat{R}_{z,t,q} \circ R_{z,t,q}^{(n-1)})(z) = \frac{1}{1-q}$

2. Active/Passive Dichotomy

Definition: A marked point $a(\lambda)$ at parameter $\lambda_0$ is:

• Passive: if the sequence $\{f_\lambda^n(a(\lambda))\}_{n=1}^{\infty}$ forms a normal family in some neighborhood of $\lambda_0$
• Active: otherwise

Key Lemma (Lemma 4): If $\lambda_0$ is an active parameter for the marked point $a(\lambda)$, then $\lambda_0 \in \{\lambda \in \Lambda : f_\lambda^m(a(\lambda)) = b(\lambda) \text{ for some } m \in \mathbb{N}\}$

3. Technical Innovations

Map Analysis:

• When $t \in (0,1)$, $R_{z,t,q}(w)$ is monotonically increasing on $[0,\infty)$
• When $t > 1$, $R_{z,t,q}^2(w)$ is monotonically increasing on $[0,\infty)$

Neutral Fixed Point Conditions: By solving the condition that $R_{z,t,q}(w)-w$ has multiple roots, the parameter relationships for neutral fixed point existence are obtained.

Main Results

Ferromagnetic Case (Theorem A)

For $t \in [0,1]$, Lee-Yang zeros accumulate on $(0,\infty)$ if and only if $t \in [0,t_2(q)]$, with accumulation point:

$z_c(t,q) = \begin{cases} 1 & \text{if } 0 \leq t \leq t_1(q) \\ Z_q(t) & \text{if } t_1(q) < t \leq t_2(q) \end{cases}$

where $Z_q(t) = \frac{(-27(q-1)^2t^4+18(q^2-3q+2)t^3+(q^2+14q-14)t^2+2(q-2)t+1) - \sqrt{(t-1)((q-1)t+1)(9(q-1)t^2-(q-2)t-1)^3}}{8t((q-2)t+1)^3}$

Antiferromagnetic Case (Theorem B, q≥3)

For $t > 1$, Lee-Yang zeros accumulate on $(0,\infty)$ if and only if $t \geq t_3(q)$, with accumulation points $z_c^{\pm}(t,q)$:

$z_c^{\pm}(t,q) = \frac{(-3-6(-2+q)t-3(2+(-2+q)q)t^2-6(-2+q)(-1+q)t^3+(-1+q)^2t^4) \pm \sqrt{(-1+t)^3(1-t+qt)^3(-9+18t-9qt-t^2+qt^2)}}{8t(1-2t+qt)^3}$

Ising Model Special Case (Theorem C, q=2)

When $q=2$, in the antiferromagnetic case, in addition to $z_c^{\pm}(t,2)$, there is an additional accumulation point $z=1$.

Experimental Verification

Numerical Computation

The paper verifies theoretical results through computing Lee-Yang zeros of small-depth Cayley trees:

• Figure 2 displays the zero distribution for the Ising model (q=2), verifying the Lee-Yang circle theorem
• Figure 3 displays the zero distribution for the 3-state Potts model, showing that zeros no longer lie on the unit circle

Active Locus Visualization

Using Arnaud Chéritat's computer software to plot active loci:

• Figures 7-8 display active loci at different temperatures in the ferromagnetic case
• Figures 9-10 display active loci in the antiferromagnetic case

Critical Temperature Verification

Numerical computation verifies critical temperature formulas:

• $t_2(3) \approx 0.265$
• $t_3(3) = 3$ (Ising model)

Related Work

Historical Development

1. Original Lee-Yang Work (1952): Established foundational theory for the Ising model
2. Müller-Hartmann and Zittartz (1974-1977): First applied renormalization methods on the Cayley tree
3. Barata et al. (1997-2001): Further developed theory on the Cayley tree

Modern Development

1. Complex Dynamics Methods: Work by McMullen, Lyubich, and others provides theoretical foundations for this paper
2. Hierarchical Lattice Research: Work by Bleher, Lyubich, Roeder, and others on the Diamond hierarchical lattice
3. Computational Methods: Numerical research by Kim-Creswich (1998)

Innovation of This Paper

Compared to existing work, this paper is the first to systematically apply the active/passive dichotomy from complex dynamics to the study of Lee-Yang zeros for the Potts model.

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Complete characterization of Lee-Yang zero accumulation behavior: Provides complete classification in ferromagnetic and antiferromagnetic cases
2. Established new connections between complex dynamics and statistical physics: The active/passive dichotomy provides new tools for studying phase transitions
3. Provided exact mathematical formulas: All accumulation points have explicit expressions

Limitations

1. Limited to Cayley Trees: Results cannot be directly generalized to other graph structures
2. External Field Constraints: Only considers specific forms of external magnetic fields
3. Range of q: Main results require q≥2 to be natural numbers

Future Directions

1. Generalization to Other Graphs: Study Lee-Yang zeros on other hierarchical structures
2. More General Magnetic Fields: Consider more complex external field configurations
3. Precise Description of Phase Transitions: Utilize the distribution of Lee-Yang zeros to study exact properties of phase transitions

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Theoretical Rigor: All results have rigorous mathematical proofs, avoiding purely numerical or physical arguments
2. Methodological Innovation: First systematic introduction of complex dynamics to Lee-Yang zero research
3. Result Completeness: Provides complete classification for ferromagnetic and antiferromagnetic cases
4. Computational Operability: All accumulation points have explicit formulas, facilitating numerical verification

Weaknesses

1. Limited Applicability: Results apply only to binary Cayley trees, with limited generalizability
2. Insufficient Physical Interpretation: While mathematical results are precise, explanations of phase transition mechanisms are relatively limited
3. Computational Complexity: Some formulas (such as $Z_q(t)$) are quite complex and may require numerical computation in practical applications

Impact

1. Academic Value: Opens new directions for interdisciplinary research between statistical physics and complex dynamics
2. Methodological Contribution: The application of active/passive dichotomy in statistical physics has exemplary significance
3. Theoretical Completeness: Fills important gaps in the theory of Lee-Yang zeros for the Potts model

Applicable Scenarios

1. Theoretical Physics Research: Provides precise mathematical tools for studying phase transitions and critical phenomena
2. Complex Dynamics Applications: Demonstrates the power of complex dynamics methods in physical problems
3. Numerical Verification: Explicit formulas enable numerical verification and further research

References

The paper cites 44 important references, mainly including:

1. Original Lee-Yang Papers: 44 T. D. Lee and C. N. Yang (1952) - Laid the theoretical foundation
2. Renormalization Methods: 36 Müller-Hartmann and Zittartz (1974) - Provided technical framework
3. Complex Dynamics Theory: 31 M. Yu. Lyubich (1983) - Provided key lemmas
4. Related Applications: 14 Chio, He, Ji, and Roeder (2019) - Related work on Ising model

Overall Assessment: This is a high-quality theoretical paper at the intersection of statistical physics and complex dynamics, solving an important physical problem through rigorous mathematical analysis. Although its applicability is relatively limited, its methodological contributions and theoretical completeness make it an important advance in the field.