When Purple Perceived Only at Fixation: A Fixation and Distance-Dependent Color Illusion

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2509.11582
• Title: When Purple Perceived Only at Fixation: A Fixation and Distance-Dependent Color Illusion
• Author: Hinnerk Schulz-Hildebrandt (Wellman Center for Photomedicine, Massachusetts General Hospital, Harvard Medical School)
• Classification: physics.optics, q-bio.NC
• Publication Date: 2025 (arXiv preprint, version 4, October 13, 2025)
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2509.11582

Abstract

This paper describes a novel visual illusion phenomenon: purple structures at the fixation point are perceived as purple, while identical purple structures in the surrounding visual field appear bluish. As viewing distance increases, more purple structures recover their purple appearance.

Research Background and Motivation

Core Problem

This research identifies and explores a previously unreported color perception illusion involving differential perception of purple at different locations in the visual field.

Research Significance

1. Complexity of Color Perception: Color perception is not a direct consequence of electromagnetic radiation wavelengths, but rather an active construction process of the human visual system
2. Uniqueness of Purple: Purple, as a non-spectral color, does not exist at a single wavelength in the visible spectrum; it is a fragile perception produced through stimulation of L and S cone cells
3. Retinal Anatomical Influences: The distribution of different cone cells in the retina and the absorption characteristics of macular pigment affect color perception

Limitations of Existing Research

While previous studies have described color and brightness perception changes caused by S cone cell absence regions and wavelength-dependent absorption of macular pigment, this specific illusion capable of inducing hue shifts has not been widely recognized in the visual science community.

Core Contributions

1. Discovery of Novel Visual Illusion: First systematic description of fixation-dependent and distance-dependent color illusion in purple perception
2. Development of Three Demonstration Modes: Creation of three different illusion presentations: "Nine Purple Dots," "Color-Changing Dot Matrix," and "Vanishing Poetry"
3. Proposed Physiological Mechanism: Comprehensive theoretical explanation based on cone cell distribution, macular pigment absorption, and color contrast effects
4. Practical Verification: Implementation of the illusion effect on mobile devices, providing convenient tools for further research

Detailed Methods

Experimental Design

Three Illusion Patterns

1. "Nine Purple Dots" Illusion
   • Nine purple circles arranged in a square pattern
   • Each dot diameter: 150 pixels, spacing: 300 pixels
   • Color: Purple tone (red-blue mixture, no green component, Hex: #6600FF)
2. "Color-Changing Dot Matrix" Illusion
   • 18×20 purple circle array
   • Each dot diameter: 50 pixels, grid spacing: 25 pixels
   • Same purple tone configuration
3. "Vanishing Poetry" Illusion
   • Text of 94 words, Arial Bold font, 32pt size
   • Text in the same purple tone
   • Text content generated by large language model

Technical Parameters

• Background Color: Blue mixed tone (HEX: #495A9E)
• Display Device: iPhone 16 Pro OLED screen (2796×1290 pixels, 120Hz)
• Viewing Distance: Testing at various distances including 10cm, 30cm, 60cm

Observation Methods

• Fixation Point Testing: Fixed gaze on different purple elements, observing color perception changes in surrounding elements
• Distance Testing: Recording changes in the number of elements perceived as purple at different viewing distances
• Eye Movement Tracking: Rapid eye movement to observe real-time following effects of purple perception

Experimental Results

Main Findings

Fixation-Dependent Effects

• At 30cm viewing distance, only purple elements at the fixation point maintain purple perception
• Identical colored surrounding elements appear bluish, as if the red component is suppressed
• When eye movement is rapid, purple perception follows eye movement in real-time

Distance-Dependent Effects

• 10cm distance: Only very few dots appear partially purple
• 30cm distance: Approximately twice as many dots perceived as purple
• 60cm and beyond: Nearly all dots appear purple

"Vanishing Poetry" Effect

At 30cm comfortable reading distance, only fixated words appear purple while surrounding text appears bluish, creating the impression of text self-highlighting during reading.

Influencing Factors

• Display Device Characteristics: Effect is most pronounced on high-contrast, wide-gamut devices
• Color Temperature Influence: Effect weakens when display color temperature leans toward warm tones
• Individual Differences: Different observers may experience varying perception intensities

Theoretical Mechanism Analysis

Physiological Basis

Cone Cell Distribution Characteristics

• S Cone Scarcity: Comprise only 8-12% of retinal cone cells
• Foveal Absence: S cone cells are almost completely absent at the absolute center of the fovea
• Dense L/M Cones: L and M cone cell density is extremely high in the foveal region

Macular Pigment Effects

• Strong Short-Wavelength Absorption: Macular pigment exhibits strong absorption in the short-wavelength region of the visible spectrum
• Highest Central Density: Macular pigment density is highest at the foveal center, gradually decreasing peripherally
• Blue Light Filtering Effect: Affects the intensity of blue light signals received by S cone cells

Integrated Mechanism Hypothesis

This illusion is considered to result from the combined action of three factors:

1. Classical Color Contrast Effect: Explains the bluish appearance of surrounding structures
2. Non-Spectral Nature of Purple: Fragility of purple as a non-spectral color produced only through L and S signal integration
3. Retinal Anatomical Factors: Biological basis of cone cell distribution and macular pigment's blue light absorption

Related Work

Historical Research Background

• Maxwell's Spot Illusion: Recently introduced by Kitaoka, showing reduced brightness of blue dots in central vision
• Color Perception Mechanisms: Research by Solomon and Lennie on color vision mechanisms
• Purple Perception Research: Research by Connors and Siegel on differential color sensitivity in purple regions

Uniqueness of This Research

While related research on S cone cell absence regions and macular pigment effects exists, this specific illusion capable of inducing hue shifts in observers has not been widely recognized and described in the visual science community.

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Novel Illusion Confirmed: Successfully described and verified a new color perception illusion phenomenon
2. Dual Dependency: Confirmed that purple perception exhibits both fixation-dependent and distance-dependent characteristics
3. Physiological Basis: Provided theoretical explanation based on retinal anatomy and color perception mechanisms

Limitations

1. Lack of Quantitative Measurement: Absence of rigorous psychophysical experiments and statistical analysis
2. Unexplored Individual Differences: Lack of systematic investigation of perception differences among individuals
3. Insufficient Mechanism Verification: Proposed theoretical mechanisms lack experimental verification
4. Device Dependency: Effect is significantly influenced by display device characteristics

Future Research Directions

1. Quantitative Psychophysical Research: Conduct rigorous threshold measurements and statistical analysis
2. Eye-Tracking Experiments: Use professional eye-tracking equipment to verify fixation-dependent effects
3. Individual Difference Research: Explore effects of age, gender, and other factors on illusion intensity
4. Neuroimaging Research: Use fMRI and other techniques to explore brain activity patterns

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Novelty of Phenomenon: Discovery of a visual illusion previously undescribed in systematic literature
2. Strong Practicality: Provides simple and easy-to-implement demonstration methods for reproduction and verification
3. Solid Theoretical Foundation: Reasonable explanations based on known retinal anatomy and color perception theory
4. Diverse Demonstrations: Three different illusion presentations enhance phenomenon credibility

Weaknesses

1. Rudimentary Experimental Design: Lacks rigorous control experiments and quantitative measurements
2. Insufficient Sample Size: Primarily based on author's personal observations, lacking large-sample verification
3. Speculative Mechanism: Proposed physiological mechanisms lack direct experimental evidence
4. Technology Dependency: Effect is limited by display device constraints, potentially affecting generalizability

Impact

1. Academic Value: Provides new phenomena and research directions for color perception studies
2. Application Potential: May have applications in display technology, visual design, and related fields
3. Educational Significance: Provides intuitive case studies for understanding visual system complexity

Applicable Scenarios

1. Visual Science Research: As a new tool for studying color perception mechanisms
2. Teaching Demonstrations: For visual science and psychology education
3. Display Technology Development: Reference for display device color calibration
4. Artistic Design: Utilization of this illusion effect in visual art creation

References

The paper cites 10 important references covering key areas including color vision mechanisms, cone cell distribution, and macular pigment characteristics, providing a solid foundation for theoretical explanation. Particularly noteworthy is Kitaoka's recent research on Maxwell's spot illusion, which provides important theoretical reference for this work.

Overall Assessment: This is an interesting paper describing a novel visual phenomenon. While it has some limitations in experimental rigor, the discovered phenomenon possesses significant scientific value and application potential. Further rigorous psychophysical experiments and mechanism research are recommended.