Competing Supramolecular Structures: Dielectric and Rheological Spectroscopy on Glycerol/Propanol Mixtures

Basic Information

• Paper ID: 2509.15341
• Title: Competing Supramolecular Structures: Dielectric and Rheological Spectroscopy on Glycerol/Propanol Mixtures
• Author: Jan Philipp Gabriel (Roskilde University & German Aerospace Center)
• Classification: cond-mat.soft (Soft Condensed Matter Physics)
• Publication Date: arXiv v2, September 23, 2025
• Paper Link: https://arxiv.org/abs/2509.15341

Abstract

This study investigates the dynamic behavior of competing supramolecular structures in glycerol/propanol mixtures using dielectric and rheological spectroscopy. Glycerol possesses two additional hydroxyl groups compared to propanol, resulting in significant differences in melting point (ΔTm = 143K) and glass transition temperature (ΔTg = 92K). Two distinct calorimetric glass transitions are observed at molar concentration χgly = 0.3, while the shear modulus G∞ undergoes a transition between χgly = 0.5-0.7. The study demonstrates that dielectric spectroscopy monitors the evolution of supramolecular chain and network structures, with mechanical properties strongly dependent on the hydrogen-bonding network. Compared to water/glycerol mixtures, this chain/network mixture exhibits extremely pronounced dynamic heterogeneity.

Research Background and Motivation

Research Questions

This study aims to understand the dynamic behavior of competing supramolecular structures (chain-like versus network-like) in hydrogen-bonded liquid mixtures and their effects on macroscopic properties.

Significance

1. Biological System Relevance: The dynamic behavior of hydrogen-bonded liquids is crucial for biological system function and dynamic structure formation
2. Fundamental Scientific Value: Monohydric alcohols (propanol) and polyhydric alcohols (glycerol) form different supramolecular structures (chain-like vs. network-like); understanding their mixing dynamics has important theoretical implications
3. Materials Design: Controlling hydrogen-bonded structures through mixing offers new perspectives for materials design

Limitations of Existing Methods

1. Pure Component Studies: Previous work primarily focused on pure propanol or pure glycerol, lacking systematic investigation of structure competition in mixed systems
2. Single Technique Approach: The 1966 study by Kono et al. employed only limited-frequency-range dielectric and mechanical spectroscopy, failing to provide comprehensive characterization
3. Insufficient Theoretical Understanding: At that time, the correlation between hydrogen-bonded supramolecular structures and dielectric relaxation had not been established

Research Motivation

By combining three complementary techniques—dielectric spectroscopy, rheological spectroscopy, and calorimetry—this work systematically investigates a high-Tg-contrast mixture (ΔTg = 92K) to elucidate:

• The evolution of chain-like and network-like supramolecular structures
• The manifestation of dynamic heterogeneity
• The influence of hydrogen-bonding networks on mechanical properties

Core Contributions

1. First Systematic Characterization: Comprehensive characterization of glycerol/propanol mixture dynamics using broadband dielectric spectroscopy (10 mHz-1 MHz) and rheological spectroscopy (10 mHz-80 kHz)
2. Discovery of Percolation Transition: Observation of a sharp transition in shear modulus G∞ between χgly = 0.5-0.7, indicating a percolation transition of the hydrogen-bonding network
3. Dual Glass Transitions: Two independent glass transitions observed at χgly = 0.3, confirming extreme dynamic heterogeneity
4. Structure-Property Correlation: Establishment of correspondence between cross-correlation signals in dielectric spectra and supramolecular structures (chain/network)
5. Comparative Analysis: Comparison with water/glycerol (network/network) mixtures reveals unique dynamic characteristics of chain/network mixtures
6. Multi-Technique Validation: Consistent structural evolution picture provided by dielectric, mechanical, and calorimetric techniques

Methodology Details

Experimental Techniques

1. Sample Preparation

• Purity: Propanol 99.9% (Alfa Aesar), Glycerol 99.5% (Alfa Aesar)
• Mixing Method: Manual agitation; intermediate concentration samples heated overnight at 70°C to ensure homogeneity
• Operation: Mixing and loading in a glove box to minimize air contact
• Stability: No visible phase separation at room temperature over several months

2. Shear Rheological Measurements

• Technique: Three-disc piezoelectric shear gauge
• Frequency Range: 10 mHz - 80 kHz (spanning over 6 orders of magnitude)
• Applicable Range: Rigid systems (1 MPa - 10 GPa)
• Advantages: Suitable for liquid measurements near the glass transition temperature

3. Dielectric Spectroscopy Measurements

• Setup: Parallel-plate capacitor placed in the same cryostat as mechanical measurements
• Advantages: Ensures that shear and dielectric data are measured under identical experimental conditions
• Frequency Range: Approximately 10 mHz - 1 MHz

4. Calorimetric Analysis

• Method: Custom-built differential scanning calorimetry
• Procedure:
  • Samples loaded into 0.5 ml glass vials in a glove box
  • Quenched in liquid nitrogen to 77K
  • Heating rate dT/dt monitored in a polystyrene foam insulation environment
• Principle: Based on the equation dT/dt = (1/R₀C)(T(t) - T₀), where R₀ is thermal resistance and C is heat capacity

Data Analysis Methods

1. Time-Temperature Superposition (TTS)

Frequency axis normalized to peak frequency νmax to obtain master curves for each concentration, verifying spectral shape consistency across different temperatures.

2. Vogel-Fulcher-Tammann (VFT) Fitting

Temperature dependence of relaxation time: $\tau_{VFT} = \tau_0 \exp\left(\frac{\Delta E}{T(t) - T_{VFT}}\right)$

3. Shear Compliance Analysis

Recoverable compliance estimated using derivative method: $J'_{der}(\omega) = -\frac{\pi}{2}\frac{dJ'(\omega)}{d\ln(\omega)} \approx \chi''_J(\omega)$

4. Glass Transition Temperature Definition

• Tg^ϵ, Tg^G, Tg^J: Temperature at which VFT fitting reaches 100s time constant
• Tg^cal: Onset temperature of calorimetric glass transition

Experimental Setup

Concentration Range

Nine molar concentrations investigated: χgly = 0, 0.05, 0.1, 0.2, 0.3, 0.5, 0.7, 0.9, 1.0

Temperature Range

• Propanol-rich: 110K - 170K
• Intermediate concentrations: 115K - 200K
• Glycerol-rich: 180K - 230K

Key Experimental Parameters

• Dielectric Spectroscopy: Covers Debye, α, and β relaxation processes
• Rheological Spectroscopy: Measures complex shear modulus G*(ω) = G'(ω) + iG''(ω)
• High-Frequency Modulus: G∞ extracted at 10 kHz as rigidity indicator

Reference Data

Historical data from Kono et al. (1966) at 10-130 MHz and 213K included for comparative validation

Experimental Results

Main Findings

1. Calorimetric Analysis (Figure 2)

• Pure Components: Propanol and glycerol each show single glass transition
• Key Finding: Two distinct glass transition steps appear at χgly = 0.3
• Tg Evolution:
  • Propanol-like Tg: Increases linearly from 98K (pure propanol)
  • Glycerol-like Tg: Decreases linearly from 190K (pure glycerol)
  • Parallel lines indicate independent dynamic behavior

2. Dielectric Spectral Evolution (Figures 3, 6)

Propanol-Rich Region (χgly = 0-0.3):

• Retains pronounced Debye peak (characteristic of hydrogen-bonded chain structure)
• Main peak broadens with increasing glycerol
• α and β relaxations similar to pure propanol

Critical Concentration (χgly = 0.5):

• Bimodal structure observed with time constants differing by ~10⁴
• Fast peak (~1s) consistent with glycerol-like dynamics
• Slow peak (~10⁵s) consistent with propanol-like dynamics

Glycerol-Rich Region (χgly = 0.7-1.0):

• Shows glycerol-like broadened cross-correlation peak
• Spectral shape gradually narrows, approaching pure glycerol

3. Rheological Spectral Characteristics (Figures 3, 6)

Time Constants:

• Mechanical peak frequencies 0.5-4 orders of magnitude faster than dielectric (concentration-dependent)
• Mechanical spectrum at χgly = 0.5 dominated by glycerol-like contribution

Spectral Shape Evolution:

• Extreme broadening near χgly = 0.5, suggesting two contributions but incomplete separation
• Spectral shape narrows in glycerol-rich region

4. High-Frequency Shear Modulus G∞ (Figure 9)

Key Finding:

• G∞ drops sharply from ~4 GPa to ~2 GPa between χgly = 0.7-0.5
• Indicates percolation transition of hydrogen-bonding network
• Kono (1966) data suggests transition may occur between χgly = 0.5-0.3 (higher frequency measurement)

Physical Interpretation:

• High glycerol concentration: Fully percolated hydrogen-bonding network with high rigidity
• Below percolation threshold: Fragmented network with rigidity dropping to propanol level

5. Time Constant Analysis (Figures 4, 5, 8)

Dielectric Time Constants τϵ:

• Clearly separated into propanol-like and glycerol-like groups
• Transition occurs between χgly = 0.5-0.7
• After Tg normalization, both groups show excellent overlap (Figure 5)

Shear Modulus Time Constants τG:

• Follow similar grouping but transition to glycerol-like behavior earlier

Shear Compliance Time Constants τJ:

• Maximum difference from τϵ at χgly = 0.2 (>4 orders of magnitude)
• At high glycerol concentrations τJ ≈ τϵ (strong coupling)
• In pure propanol τJ lies between Debye and α relaxation

Ablation Studies

Time-Temperature Superposition Analysis (Figures 4b,c)

• Glycerol-Rich: Main peak perfectly follows TTS, indicating single dominant dynamics
• Propanol-Rich: Only main peak and low-frequency portion follow TTS; high-frequency deviations present
• Intermediate Concentrations: TTS fails, confirming coexistence of multiple dynamic processes

Compliance-Modulus Comparison (Figure 8)

Normalized compliance spectrum J'der(ω) identifies:

• Compliance peak slower than modulus peak but faster than dielectric Debye peak
• Possibly corresponds to hydrogen-bond opening/closing dynamics (intermediate between molecular reorientation and supramolecular reorganization)

Case Studies

Fixed-Temperature Slice (Figure 6)

Within narrow temperature window at 185K (170-190K):

• Dynamics span 8 orders of frequency magnitude
• At χgly = 0.5, two clearly separated contributions visible
• Demonstrates extreme dynamic heterogeneity

Low Glycerol Concentration Details (Figure 7, 116K)

• Dielectric spectrum maintains propanol characteristic Debye peak
• Mechanical spectrum more sensitive to glycerol addition
• β relaxation visible in both techniques but Debye and α difficult to separate

Experimental Observations

1. Dynamic Heterogeneity: Chain/network mixtures exhibit stronger heterogeneity than network/network (water/glycerol) mixtures
2. Percolation Phenomenon: G∞ transition indicates hydrogen-bonding network percolation near χgly ~ 0.6 (theoretical prediction for simple cubic lattice ~0.25 molar fraction)
3. Cross-Correlation Dominance: Dielectric relaxation strength exceeds pure self-correlation expectation at all concentrations; Kirkwood factor lies between propanol (~4.5) and glycerol (~2.5)
4. Structure-Dynamics Decoupling:
   • Dielectric Spectroscopy: Monitors supramolecular structure (chain/network) reorganization
   • Mechanical Spectroscopy: More sensitive to α relaxation and hydrogen-bond opening/closing
   • Calorimetry: Primarily reflects α relaxation
5. Comparison with Water/Glycerol: Water/glycerol mixtures do not show extreme broadening; glycerol's bimodal character diminishes with water addition

Related Work

Pure Component Studies

Propanol:

• Hansen et al. (1997): Dielectric + light scattering separate α relaxation
• Gabriel et al. (2017): Full spectral shape analysis confirms hydrogen-bonded chain structure
• Sillrén et al. (2013): X-ray scattering discovers "pre-peak" (evidence of chain structure)

Glycerol:

• Traditional View: Only α relaxation + high-frequency wing
• Gabriel et al. (2020): Similar to propanol—Debye + α + β three-process interpretation
• Hénot et al. (2023): Simulations confirm hydrogen-bonding network structure

Mixed System Studies

Monohydric Alcohol Mixtures:

• Bierwirth et al. (2018): Review of monohydric alcohol mixtures, discusses chain/ring opening/closing
• 2E1H/2E1Br (ΔTg=13K): Hydrogen-bonded/non-hydrogen-bonded mixture with weaker heterogeneity than this study

High-Tg-Contrast Mixtures:

• MTHF/OMMA (ΔTg=249K): Photon correlation spectroscopy observes two glass transitions
• PMMA/Picolin (ΔTg=227K): Light scattering, dielectric, MD, NMR multi-technique confirm separated dynamics

Historical Work:

• Kono et al. (1966): First study of propanol/glycerol but limited frequency range (50Hz-600kHz dielectric, 10-130MHz mechanical); lacked hydrogen-bonding structure theoretical framework

Novel Contributions of This Work

1. Technical Advantages: Wider frequency range (starting from 10 mHz), simultaneous measurement of dielectric and mechanical on same device
2. Theoretical Framework: Interpretation based on modern hydrogen-bonding supramolecular structure theory
3. Systematicity: Three-technique validation covering full concentration range
4. New Discoveries: Percolation transition, extreme heterogeneity, structure-dynamics correlation

Conclusions and Discussion

Main Conclusions

1. Supramolecular Structure Evolution:
   • χgly < 0.5: Propanol hydrogen-bonded chains dominate; dielectric shows Debye peak
   • χgly ~ 0.5-0.7: Percolation transition region; chains and networks coexist
   • χgly > 0.7: Glycerol hydrogen-bonding network percolates; mechanical rigidity increases significantly
2. Dynamic Separation:
   • Dielectric, mechanical, and calorimetric all observe independent propanol-like and glycerol-like Tg
   • Two calorimetric glass transitions at χgly = 0.3
   • Dielectric bimodal peak at χgly = 0.5 (time scale difference of 10⁴)
3. Measurement Technique Sensitivity Differences:
   • Dielectric Spectroscopy: Primarily probes hydrogen-bonded supramolecular structures (cross-correlations), Debye and network relaxation
   • Shear Compliance: Possibly corresponds to hydrogen-bond opening/closing dynamics (intermediate time scale)
   • Shear Modulus: More sensitive to α relaxation and fast processes
   • Calorimetry: Primarily reflects α relaxation (molecular reorientation)
4. Physical Picture:
   • Propanol can move relatively freely within hydrogen-bonded chains (molecular reorientation, hydrogen-bond opening/closing, chain reorganization separation)
   • Glycerol network processes strongly coupled
   • Network percolation causes mechanical property transition

Limitations

1. Missing X-ray Structural Information: The paper mentions unpublished X-ray experiments with Dorthe Posselt showing low-temperature structural changes, but data not included in this work
2. Low-Frequency Limitations: Dielectric spectrum obscured by conductivity, preventing observation of certain slow relaxation processes
3. Terminal Flow: Only pure glycerol approaches terminal flow; mixtures do not reach it, limiting compliance analysis precision
4. Temperature-Concentration Window: Due to large ΔTg, difficult to cover complete dynamics for all concentrations within single temperature window
5. Phase Separation Questions: Although no visible layering under visible light, X-rays reveal nanoscale structural changes requiring further investigation
6. Theoretical Modeling: Lack of quantitative percolation theory model; simple cubic lattice estimate too crude

Future Directions

1. X-ray Scattering: Systematic study of "pre-peak" evolution to characterize chain/network structure transition
2. Light Scattering Supplement: Separate self- and cross-correlations to precisely determine α relaxation
3. NMR Investigation: As demonstrated in 1-butanol studies, NMR can probe hydrogen-bond opening/closing dynamics
4. Theoretical Modeling: Develop percolation theory considering chain and network competition
5. Other Mixtures: Investigate water/propanol and other chain/network systems with different Tg contrasts
6. Electric Field Effects: Study strong field effects on chain and ring structures

In-Depth Evaluation

Strengths

1. Excellent Experimental Design:
   • Three complementary techniques (dielectric, rheological, calorimetric) measured under identical conditions
   • Wide frequency range (10 mHz - 80 kHz rheological, 10 mHz - 1 MHz dielectric)
   • Systematic concentration coverage (9 concentration points)
2. High Data Quality:
   • Fine temperature stepping (2-5K intervals)
   • Good data reproducibility (small relative errors)
   • Supplementary materials provide all raw spectra
3. Thorough Analysis:
   • Multiple representation methods (modulus, compliance, viscosity, normalized master curves)
   • VFT fitting extracts temperature dependence
   • Tg normalization reveals universal behavior
4. Clear Physical Picture:
   • Intuitive chain-like vs. network-like structure diagrams
   • Reasonable percolation transition concept
   • Comparison with water/glycerol highlights distinctive features
5. Comprehensive Literature Review:
   • Spans from historical (1929 Debye) to recent (2025) work
   • Compares relevant systems (monohydric alcohol mixtures, high-Tg-contrast mixtures)

Weaknesses

1. Indirect Structural Information:
   • Structure primarily inferred from dynamics
   • Lacks direct structural characterization (X-ray data unpublished)
   • Quantitative percolation threshold analysis insufficient
2. Weak Theoretical Support:
   • Lacks microscopic model explaining time constant differences
   • Simple cubic lattice percolation estimate oversimplified
   • Kirkwood factor discussed only qualitatively
3. Some Conclusions Speculative:
   • Compliance corresponding to hydrogen-bond opening/closing mainly by analogy
   • Nanoscale phase separation properties unclear
   • Unresolved debate on α relaxation and hydroxyl group participation
4. Insufficient Discussion of Experimental Limitations:
   • Absolute G∞ error ~1 GPa but impact on conclusions not discussed
   • Quantitative assessment of conductivity masking effect missing
   • Systematic study of cooling rate effects on Tg absent
5. Reproducibility:
   • Custom calorimetry apparatus details insufficient
   • Sample mixing "overnight" timing imprecise
   • Filling error effects on mechanical measurements not quantified

Impact

Contributions to the Field:

1. First systematic demonstration of extreme dynamic heterogeneity in chain/network hydrogen-bonded mixtures
2. Provides model system for understanding biologically relevant mixtures (e.g., cytoplasm)
3. Demonstrates necessity of multi-technique approach for complex systems

Practical Value:

1. Guides materials design for hydrogen-bonded liquid mixtures
2. Provides concentration window for controlling mechanical properties (percolation transition)
3. Offers strategies for glass transition engineering

Theoretical Significance:

1. Challenges conventional single-Tg paradigm
2. Deepens understanding of self- and cross-correlation separation
3. Connects molecular-scale structure to macroscopic mechanical properties

Reproducibility:

• Commercial instruments (piezoelectric shear gauge) but requires expertise
• Simple sample preparation
• Clear data analysis methods
• Complete supplementary data

Applicable Scenarios

1. Basic Research:
   • Hydrogen-bonded liquid dynamics
   • Glass transition theory
   • Percolation phenomena
2. Materials Science:
   • Tunable mechanical property hydrogen-bonded materials
   • Glassy material design
   • Antifreeze formulations
3. Biophysics:
   • Cytoplasm model (multi-component hydrogen-bonded mixtures)
   • Cryoprotectants
   • Protein hydration layers
4. Methodology:
   • Multi-technique approach exemplar
   • Research strategy for high-Tg-contrast mixtures
   • Dynamic heterogeneity characterization

Not Applicable To:

• Studies requiring atomic-scale structural information (requires supplementary scattering experiments)
• Rapid screening (time-consuming measurements)
• High-temperature liquids (method targets glass transition region)

Key References

1. Böhmer et al., Phys. Rep. 545, 125 (2014): Comprehensive review of hydrogen-bonded liquid dynamics
2. Gabriel et al., Phys Chem Chem Phys 22, 11644 (2020): Debye + α + β interpretation for glycerol
3. Gainaru et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 105 (2010): Cross-correlation theory for monohydric alcohol Debye process
4. Bierwirth et al., J. Chem. Phys. 148 (2018): Review of monohydric alcohol mixtures
5. Kono et al., J. Chem. Phys. 45, 1790 (1966): Historical study of propanol/glycerol mixtures

Overall Assessment: This is a high-quality experimental physics paper that reveals the complex dynamics of chain/network hydrogen-bonded mixtures through carefully designed multi-technique experiments. The main contributions lie in systematically characterizing extreme dynamic heterogeneity and hydrogen-bonding network percolation transitions. Although lacking direct structural evidence, the dynamic analysis is thorough and convincing. It holds important reference value for soft condensed matter physics and hydrogen-bonded liquid research. Supplementary X-ray scattering data recommended to complete the structure-dynamics picture.